Although there are some interesting stories in here, some of them rarely reprinted, I would hardly consider this to be the best 19th century horror fiction. My main issue is the overrepresentation of non-supernatural horror, which I find to be much less interesting (and in many cases, especially here, boring) than supernatural horror. In addition to that, many of these stories are not the best that the authors have done; for example Crawford is represented by The Dead Smile, rather than The Upper Berth. I would also represent Wells with The Red Room and Bierce with The Damned Thing, instead of the chosen stories by them. Finally, several of the best writers from the era are not in the book, most egregiously M. R. James. On its own, it's a perfectly serviceable anthology of 19th century horror, but the stories hardly constitute the best the period has to offer.