Re-read on 8th Jun/25
No, this re-read didn't convince me. I'm sticking with my 2.75⭐ rating.
I still dislike Harlow. I just can't see him as the right pick for Benito. And what a shame, because Benito is really a fantastic character and I like him a lot.
I can't see him with Harlow, though. I also can't see him in this dynamic either. Benito needed a softer guy and a love story much more profound than what he got.
Harlow just doesn't gel with this family, I don't see it. He's too eccentric and he should've had his own book in a completely new series, that was my first thought. He's the discarded son of the Yakuza mob family, he still has people from his family being loyal to him, he's got so much shit to take care of, by himself he's a really interesting character, so he definitely should've gotten his own book, not be put together with Benito.
Maybe I'll just skim over Paolo's book to refresh my memory because I've read it last year and then I'm off to End It All, which is why I've started re-reading this series in the first place.
____________________________________
Original review on 6th Jul/23
I can't give this book more than 2.75 - 3⭐, because it absolutely didn't deliver.
I couldn't wait to read Benito's book and considering he's the boss, I'd expect for that image of him being a held-back, always in control, dangerous guy to continue, but it didn't.
Not only that, even though this book is stated as an enemies-to-lovers book, for me it's really wasn't. They were too annoying together. Benito should've gotten someone else.
🟡 Enemies-to-lovers
🟢 Age gap - 28/38
🟠 Bisexual/gay
🟣 Both possessive and jealous
🔵 Arranged marriage
🟢 They get a kid
🌶️ Good smut, a lot of sex scenes; oral, penetrative, lingerie; t/b
This book started out very promising with Benito, the boss of the Vitale family, getting married to Harlow, the son of the Yakuza boss.
Harlow's had a pretty terrible life and has devoted everything to the family business, he's quick and lethal, likes to cut and murder people and is a mild basket case. He's femme, so he looks tall, slender, has long hair, likes to dress in women's underwear and dresses and he's pushed into an arranged marriage with Benito instead of his sister.
It's just an arrangement, but he's not taking it lightly.
Benito feels robbed, because even though he has to do this for the family, he wanted to have a wife and kids, so throughout the book he has trouble accepting his sexuality, even though he's actually already been with a man in the past and was also in love with him.
The enemies-to-lovers was happening until they started living together, which was right after the wedding. Pretty soon both characters lost their edge and were just having sex all the damn time. Yes, the sex was good, but it happened way too soon in the story and therefore it wasn't a big deal. There was no build-up, no long-term tension, just straight up sex right away and not only that, a lot of it was happening off-page.
I didn't appreciate how Harlow wasn't accepted into the brothers' circle. Everyone was distant and noone talked to him. And that trend continued almost until the end. I really thought Harlow was going to have a bigger role in this book in terms of the family business too. He's from a mob family himself and he knows the business, he's very useful, so I had no idea why Benito didn't involve him in anything.
The development of their love story was disappointing. Benito seemed like a strong guy, always in control, I loved his character in previous books and Harlow was supposed to be this beautiful wounded young man who's secretly yearning for his husband. I just couldn't feel that dynamic. Benito was seeking tenderness and they have exactly one or two moments of it, it wasn't special, so I think the moments where their relationship could really develop, were instead used for this crazy, toxic dynamic between them that didn't work for me. Their inner emotions were not being talked about enough. They had depth, but there wasn't much written about it.
I found the jealousy and the possessiveness hot, but what I absolutely didn't like is the fact that they were literally hitting each other all the time. Even when they loved each other, they were punching each other's brains out and I get it, it's a crazy family and they're both nuts, but I always saw Benito differently; he's a tough, merciless guy, but completely soft, gentle and loving on the inside, so Harlow wasn't the best option for him. I didn't like their dynamic, I wanted Benito to have someone else and a different love story.
Don't even get me started on all the Italian and japanese in this book. So much of it! Benito was saying things to Harlow in Italian and Harlow had no idea what was being said, Benito didn't elaborate and it was getting on my nerves. I get it once or twice, but so many times??
I have mixed feelings about the whole story and I only liked Benito and Harlow in the beginning with that restaurant kiss that was promising big things and later in the 31st chapter, that part where they both go out with sweats and hoodies on and sit on the hood of the car, watching the waves together. Those to me were the only real moments between them.
So at the end of the day I've read almost 500 pages for Benito and Harlow to not get their wedding as they should, no honeymoon, the big issue with Harlow's owner wasn't resolved and we get very little page time with the brothers. Clearly, I'm disappointed. I should probably give it a lower rating, but I really like these brothers and their boyfriends.
I hope Gianpaolo's story is better.