[Spoiler free]
“Dearest,” simply renamed “Jacqui” in my language, was recommended to me by a bookshop seller as I was looking for something original and quite dark. I bought it, I started it. So buckle up, cause this review will be as contradictory as this book is.
First of all, this is classified as horror. I do not agree. In my opinion, this is a hundred percent a drama with some horrific elements. The majority of the book sends off very melancholic vibes, and the main character strikes you as incredibly miserable. So if you’re expected to be scared by gory scenes, search elsewhere.
I was expecting a fast-paced, kind of unhinged thriller with gore elements, and it took me a while to overcome my disappointment when I realized that this book actually is a constant ramble about women and society as a whole. The last 50 pages hold some gruesome details lost in between details upon details about Egyptian religion, and if you are sensitive to corpse disposal, maybe don’t pick up this book because it was sort of disgusting.
At the end of the day, this book is much more of a sociological and philosophical thesis by a misogynist yet pretty respectful man. His character was incredibly confusing, because at first I found him fascinating, then he revolted me, then I felt sincere sympathy for him. Being in his head truly was fascinating and I highly recommend this very bizarre experiment at one condition:
Put your own beliefs aside. If you are someone who is easily triggered by either inappropriate scenes/comments or not so acceptable thinking about women, don’t even try picking this book up. If you are able to step out of your own shoes and just study the world being completely neutral, you might be as fascinated as I was with this book.
With that being said, I did struggle a bit during the mid section of this book -it became my post nap read. It is not that it is boring, it is just that the tone is always the same, it is really introspective and there is little to no action. This book solely relies on thinking and a very sad and sometimes shocking atmosphere, and this did not help me stay focused for a long period of time. I will admit it, it was a little too dull at times.
I would recommend this book to those who like very experimental, philosophical writing with a hint of horror. If you like a typical style of writing, you will despise this. If, however, you are into original concepts, you might like this.
3,5 stars rounded up to 3.