The Adventure of the Empty House The Adventure of the Norwood Builder The Adventure of the Six Napoleons The Adventure of the Three Students
When Sherlock Holmes met his demise in The Adventure of the Final Problem, published in 1893, the distress of the unsuspecting reading public was profound. For years fans showed no signs of letting Sherlock Homes lie down and die. Eventually, Doyle saw fit to continue his Holmes' canon and wrote a series of 13 short stories The Return of Sherlock Holmes published in 1905. The series begins, inevitably, with the shock re-appearance of the master detective in The Adventure of the Empty House. This, plus 3 others are included in Naxos AudioBooks' first volume of Doyle's continuation of the famous bloodhound of a genius, read by master storyteller David Timson. Though he has been away, it seems that Holmes has lost none of his remarkable qualities.
I loved this audioversion of Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories. The stories were interesting quick reads and the narrator did an excellent job of capturing Holmes's character and personality. The violins were a bit much at times, but did add a little something to the story at points. I really enjoyed this and will move quickly to volume 2 (as quickly as overdrive's hold list will allow).
I had thought I had completed the Holmes Canon, but discovered just over a week ago that I had overlooked "The Return." Now, I am listening to the stories as they become available through my local library.
This first batch are quite good, filling in a gap for me. In the many movies and television shows, Moriarty and Inspector Lestrade are regulars, and here they are mentioned in nearly every story. Without "The Return," they would not be nearly as prominent in the canon, and therefore not such regulars in all the pastiches and adaptations that have followed.
The Adventure of the Empty House: If I'd read this story to myself, I wouldn't have felt much besides annoyance at Holmes for treating Watson the way he does, but David Timson emotes their reunion in a most touching manner.
(But actually what I want now is a Colonel Moran/Holmes story, written by someone who has sensible thoughts about the British Empire.)
The Adventure of the Norwood Builder: I kept comparing this one unfavorably to Dorothy L. Sayer's "In the Teeth of the Evidence."
The Adventure of the Six Napoleons: I like the crime, but I find that cleverly deluding the criminal into believing that s/he is undetected by allowing reports to enter the newspaper which draw on the public's eagerness to believe that a mentally ill person is likely to commit violent acts, just about as repulsive and unethical a behavior in a supposedly admirable detective as the same scheme which draws upon racist public opinions.
The Adventure of the Three Students: This is the one where everyone is racist about the Indian student except for Sherlock Holmes, which is kind of surprising! I did think it was a nice change to have a mystery about academic cheating, though.