Aeschylus' Prometheus Bound and the Seven Against Thebes by Aeschylus: Aeschylus' Prometheus Bound and the Seven Against Thebes by Aeschylus

by Aeschylus .

Prometheus Bound and Seven Against Thebes Aeschylus Theodore Alois Buckley English

Genres: Classics, Plays, Drama, Mythology, Fiction, Ebooks

64 pages, Paperback

First published April 2, 1897

Reviews

[Joseph Carrabis · Rating 3 out of 5]

One of two Aeschylean works I read this month to learn how storycrafting has changed over the millennia. I read that Prometheus Bound and... was the first time Dialogue was intentionally and formally used, meaning it was the first time it appeared as characters talking to each other rather than a conversation between characters being narrated by the orator, and wanted to pick up any techniques I could find.
What appears immediately is the dialogue, while dialogue, is still being orated. There's little differentiation between characters' verbal styles and little to no attribution. I wondered if the orator used different voices or presented themselves to the audience from different angles, perhaps used their hands to indicate who was talking when.
In any case, interesting to see how it was done and recognize how it's changed.

[Tony · Rating 4 out of 5]

Bitchin'

[Leila · Rating 4 out of 5]

[Prometheus Bound]

I liked reading this one. Don’t know how it ended on my TBR, but when I decided to read from different eras this year, it showed up.
It was interesting finding out how it is one of the first plays - rather, a story where characters have dialogue-.

The Chorus of nymphs were (was?) the most loving character, I think. The problem for me was that I was hoping to get a bit more backstory; you are assumed to know who each of the characters is and how they are connected, it feels. Not to understand what is going on, rather, to comprehend all the ramifications (I’m thinking about Io’s story in particular).
Enjoyed it, also made me want to read a bit more about mythology again.

[Erin]

Well, I'm glad I didn't have to read this for a class. Dry and boring; I paid minimal attention. Was reminded throughout of that quote from Amadeus about the characters being so lofty they sound as if they [poop] marble. The prose in this translation was . . . turgid.

I thought it would be a fun way to get through my to-read pile by starting with the oldest titles and moving forward, but. I may give up that idea pretty quickly. Like now-ish.

[Genesis · Rating 3 out of 5]

The footnotes in this book were astonishingly boring, only giving translation explanations.

[Brandt · Rating 3 out of 5]

The three-star rating was mostly for Prometheus Bound [Chained]. Although there are important insights in the Seven Against Thebes,” the storyline lacked a connection for me.

In the introduction of Prometheus Chained, the translator makes a statement that is hard to improve on. This play is “The sublimest poem and simplest tragedy of antiquity”. To this, I would mostly agree; adding the predicate of Western in front of “antiquity”.

The fascination, for me, began with seeing Prometheus as only partially mortal, meaning above humankind; yet, still a part of it. This led me to consider the introduction where it is noted that:

“Prometheus being bound and left alone, bemoans his fate and relates to the chorus of nymphs the base ingratitude of Jove, who through his counsels having overwhelmed the aged Saturn beneath the murky abyss of Tartarus, now rewards his ally with indignities because he had compassion upon mortals.”

This led me to question the deep understanding of the Ancient Greeks of the division between right and wrong; good and bad. It seems superfluous. However, there is a great body of literature devoted to the idea of arête [translated usually as virtue] in Ancient Greece. This small statement casts some doubt on the genealogical roots of ethical considerations; if it is translated correctly.

Another interesting part of Prometheus Chained is the parallel to Socratic Wisdom. For example, Ocean says,

“I see Prometheus, and to thee, subtle as thou art, I wish to give the best counsel. Know Thyself…”

To be sure, this is one of the Delphic Maxims; notwithstanding, it is also a part of the Socratic grounding for ethical living. Moreover, Ocean reminds Prometheus that,

“…’[T]is of the highest advantage for one that is wise not to seem wise”.

Again, this is reminiscent of the Apology of Socrates.

From Seven against Thebes, I was only able to collect one important statement. This statement was mostly pertaining to a philosophical political position; nevertheless, it is an important aspect of looking at the state of the “State,” or the “Affairs of State”:

“…and the state at different times sanctions different maxims of justice.”

I understand that quote to be a truism of all States, past and present. This is a preliminary problem in any political exposition and if it is correct – at least I think – that the inquiry begins in the definition of Justice.

[Chris · Rating 2 out of 5]

If the translation is any indication, Aeschylus' Greek was painfully turgid yet, in substance, thin. Of the two plays included, Prometheus Bound was the more palatable and informative, in that it presents a fuller picture of the Promethean myth. Nonetheless it is entirely devoid of action and overladen with dialogue--and that without imparting the wisdom or providing the entertainment of many other ancient plays.

Seven Against Thebes's premise had potential which, again, was not realized. The "Chorus" was annoyingly shrill and the warriors wrangled words, not swords. The play coasted from set-up to denouement without so much as a climax to slow its passage.

I've come to prefer to see plays performed, or at least read them aloud with a group; most just don't seem to translate into an enjoyable solitary reading experience for me. However, I'm not sure even live treatment could redeem these two.

[Ajay]

Only read Prometheus Bound. Found the second title a little boring after a fee pages.

PB was decent but a bit short. Wouldn't mind reading a little more into the history behind Prometheus. Sounds like an interesting character!

[Holly]

read Prometheus Bound only, Great Books translation.

[Fluttershy · Rating 4 out of 5]

In this edition, read only Prometheus Bound. Read Seven Against Thebes in a different translation.