4.5 stars. I’ve been rereading (well, actually re-listening to) this series with my sister, and this is the first place in the series where the book was new, not just to her, but to us both. We both loved this; however, it was nothing like we expected.
This is part one of two of Father Tim’s backstory and it honestly felt like a (believable) soap opera in places. We go back to the WWII period, in the Deep South of Mississippi. Injustice abounds. So so many surprising events occur - sometimes many hard hitting events all in one paragraph! We had a deadline for the Libby audiobook, and had to read this pretty fast. It was very dramatic, with a lot to process. Not just from the halfway point, but pretty much all the way through.
The Mitford series, from which this one was born, is a much gentler read. This mini series, delving into Father Tim’s childhood, and even prior to his birth at times, is hard-hitting, with many gasping moments. There were more tears than laughter, but as much as I prefer the latter to the former, this was well worth the read.
You should also know that there are hints of present day Mitford characters’ stories here and there. Not so many that you’d be lost if you skipped this book entirely, but enough that you probably wouldn’t want to miss this one if you were a true Mitford lover.
The audio narrator, Scott Sowers, was also different than John McDonogh, who does the rest of the Mitford series. He wasn’t as good as McDonogh, because that would be a very high bar, but his voice for Peggy was worth the price of admission. It was pitch perfect.
I’ve read this series many times, but always got stuck when I got to this one, so it was good to finally push through. If you go into it aware that the mood and tone is completely different from the wider Mitford series, with a lot of drama and not much comic relief, then my guess is you’ll enjoy this book, in both audio and print.