What do you think?
Rate this book
True Crime Stories You Won't Believe: Book Two
In this book, I present tales of true crime and bizarre applications of justice (or injustice, as the case may be). They include:
The real story behind “Arsenic and Old Lace” and why the reality isn’t as lighthearted as Hollywood made it out to be.
A case in which a dream helped solve a gruesome murder. Or did it?
When a staunch Irish sea captain murdered almost his entire crew on the high seas and what happened afterward.
Did an Ouija board drive an Alabama mother and daughter to commit murder?
The story of Jane Toppan and what drove her to kill so many of her patients.
The story of Blanche Monnier, whose family locked her away for decades to keep her from marrying the wrong man.
Was the Devil responsible for the murder of Alan Bono?
The true story of the Vampire of Le Muy and his bizarre need to steal corpses.
The story of Bridget Cleary, whose husband killed her in the belief that she had been replaced by fairies.
And this is just a sampling of the stories you will find
The real story behind “Arsenic and Old Lace” and why the reality isn’t as lighthearted as Hollywood made it out to be.
A case in which a dream helped solve a gruesome murder. Or did it?
When a staunch Irish sea captain murdered almost his entire crew on the high seas and what happened afterward.
Did an Ouija board drive an Alabama mother and daughter to commit murder?
The story of Jane Toppan and what drove her to kill so many of her patients.
The story of Blanche Monnier, whose family locked her away for decades to keep her from marrying the wrong man.
Was the Devil responsible for the murder of Alan Bono?
The true story of the Vampire of Le Muy and his bizarre need to steal corpses.
The story of Bridget Cleary, whose husband killed her in the belief that she had been replaced by fairies.
And this is just a sampling of the stories you will find
- GenresTrue CrimeNonfiction
230 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 20, 2022
25 people are currently reading
2919 people want to read
About the author
Romeo Vitelli
14 books37 followersI am a psychologist in private practice in Toronto. My latest book, True Crime Stories You Won't Believe, Volume Three has just been released.
Interests: true crime, law, websurfing, archaeology, travelling and a whole list of other things i can't recall at the moment., gay/lesbian/bisexal/transgender issues, political arguments
Interests: true crime, law, websurfing, archaeology, travelling and a whole list of other things i can't recall at the moment., gay/lesbian/bisexal/transgender issues, political arguments
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews
July 12, 2024
I find true crime very intriguing and these crimes were really something else! Truly, nothing in fiction matches reality!
I thought the cases were presented in just the right way and it was an interesting read.I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I thought the cases were presented in just the right way and it was an interesting read.I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
October 26, 2022
I won this book from Goodreads and I loved it.. I am a true crime freak and this book I learned so much about crime in earlier times. I had not heard of many of these stories. So interesting how times have changed and how punishments have changed. You could kill a man if he is trying to have an affair with your wife. Crazy
February 4, 2026
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I’ve previously read, and reviewed, the first volume in this series and loved it. I’m happy to report that this second installment was just as interesting, thoroughly researched, and well-written as the first one. Vitelli acknowledges the racism and other harmful bias held by society and law enforcement, pointing out how those biases may have (and probably did) influence the case in question. What I like most about his books, is that he provides plenty of historical context for when, and where, the murder was committed.
My only complaint is that the stories are not organized in any discernible manner. I think it’d be interesting if the cases were presented in chronological order, perhaps dividing them into sections by century. However, the lack of organization doesn’t make the reading experience unpleasant, only a little confusing at times. I look forward to the subsequent volumes in this series and hopefully, there’ll be several of them.
I’ve previously read, and reviewed, the first volume in this series and loved it. I’m happy to report that this second installment was just as interesting, thoroughly researched, and well-written as the first one. Vitelli acknowledges the racism and other harmful bias held by society and law enforcement, pointing out how those biases may have (and probably did) influence the case in question. What I like most about his books, is that he provides plenty of historical context for when, and where, the murder was committed.
My only complaint is that the stories are not organized in any discernible manner. I think it’d be interesting if the cases were presented in chronological order, perhaps dividing them into sections by century. However, the lack of organization doesn’t make the reading experience unpleasant, only a little confusing at times. I look forward to the subsequent volumes in this series and hopefully, there’ll be several of them.
October 17, 2022
I read books 1 & 2 in quick succession, and they are virtually the same book. So, if you enjoyed the first one then you will very likely enjoy the second. They are both written in the exact same style - factual based and straight to the point. As is the case with a lot of true crime, the attention is on the perpetrators, not the victims.
I would say that the first book probably has more "famous" cases that the average person will be familiar with. This second book (mainly) focuses on cases from at least 100+ years ago - most of which were unknown to me.
*I received an advance review e-copy for free from BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I would say that the first book probably has more "famous" cases that the average person will be familiar with. This second book (mainly) focuses on cases from at least 100+ years ago - most of which were unknown to me.
*I received an advance review e-copy for free from BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
October 1, 2024
**Book Review: True Crime Stories You Won’t Believe Volume 2**
In "True Crime Stories You Won’t Believe Volume 2," the author takes readers on an electrifying journey through some of the most shocking and bizarre criminal cases in history. This collection effectively showcases the darker side of human nature, presenting real-life stories that challenge the imagination and leave you questioning the very fabric of morality.
From the outset, the book grabs attention with its gripping narratives and vivid descriptions. Each story is meticulously researched, offering readers an in-depth look at the events leading up to the crimes, the investigation, and the often-unfathomable motives of those involved. The author’s storytelling prowess brings each account to life, making it feel like you are right there alongside the investigators, piecing together the clues.
One of the standout stories involves a seemingly ordinary person whose life takes a horrific turn, revealing layers of deception and hidden darkness. The author skillfully builds suspense, wrapping the reader in a web of intrigue. Additionally, the inclusion of lesser-known cases broadens the scope of true crime literature, presenting tales that might have slipped under the radar but are equally haunting and thought-provoking.
The writing style is engaging and accessible, making it suitable for both true crime aficionados and newcomers alike. Each chapter flows smoothly, allowing readers to easily digest the information without feeling overwhelmed. The book also includes photographs and illustrations, adding a visual element that enhances the storytelling.
However, it’s important to approach these stories with sensitivity, as they revolve around real victims and often tragic circumstances. The author navigates this aspect respectfully, focusing on the facts while maintaining the humanity of those affected.
Overall, "True Crime Stories You Won’t Believe Volume 2" is an enthralling read that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or simply curious, this collection is sure to captivate and provoke deep reflection about the complexities of crime and the human psyche. Prepare to be amazed and horrified by the chilling realities within these pages.
In "True Crime Stories You Won’t Believe Volume 2," the author takes readers on an electrifying journey through some of the most shocking and bizarre criminal cases in history. This collection effectively showcases the darker side of human nature, presenting real-life stories that challenge the imagination and leave you questioning the very fabric of morality.
From the outset, the book grabs attention with its gripping narratives and vivid descriptions. Each story is meticulously researched, offering readers an in-depth look at the events leading up to the crimes, the investigation, and the often-unfathomable motives of those involved. The author’s storytelling prowess brings each account to life, making it feel like you are right there alongside the investigators, piecing together the clues.
One of the standout stories involves a seemingly ordinary person whose life takes a horrific turn, revealing layers of deception and hidden darkness. The author skillfully builds suspense, wrapping the reader in a web of intrigue. Additionally, the inclusion of lesser-known cases broadens the scope of true crime literature, presenting tales that might have slipped under the radar but are equally haunting and thought-provoking.
The writing style is engaging and accessible, making it suitable for both true crime aficionados and newcomers alike. Each chapter flows smoothly, allowing readers to easily digest the information without feeling overwhelmed. The book also includes photographs and illustrations, adding a visual element that enhances the storytelling.
However, it’s important to approach these stories with sensitivity, as they revolve around real victims and often tragic circumstances. The author navigates this aspect respectfully, focusing on the facts while maintaining the humanity of those affected.
Overall, "True Crime Stories You Won’t Believe Volume 2" is an enthralling read that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or simply curious, this collection is sure to captivate and provoke deep reflection about the complexities of crime and the human psyche. Prepare to be amazed and horrified by the chilling realities within these pages.
January 26, 2026
Romeo Vitelli curates a compelling collection of true crime stories that explore not only acts of violence, but the deeply unsettling social, psychological, and cultural forces behind them. These are not sensationalized retellings meant to shock for shock’s sake. Instead, Vitelli approaches each case with curiosity and restraint, allowing the inherent absurdity and horror of the facts to speak for themselves.
What makes this collection stand out is its range. From the grim reality behind Arsenic and Old Lace to murders allegedly influenced by dreams, Ouija boards, superstition, and mass delusion, the book constantly challenges the reader’s assumptions about motive and responsibility. Several cases, such as the murders of Bridget Cleary and Blanche Monnier’s decades-long imprisonment, are especially haunting, revealing how belief systems, family dynamics, and societal norms can enable prolonged cruelty.
Vitelli also excels at placing crimes within their historical and cultural contexts. Stories like the Irish sea captain who murdered his crew, the so-called Vampire of Le Muy, and Jane Toppan’s chilling medical crimes are enriched by thoughtful background details that help explain, not excuse, how such events unfolded.
The writing is clear, accessible, and engaging, making complex cases easy to follow without oversimplifying them. Each chapter feels self-contained, yet together they form a broader meditation on justice, injustice, and the disturbing unpredictability of human behaviour.
What makes this collection stand out is its range. From the grim reality behind Arsenic and Old Lace to murders allegedly influenced by dreams, Ouija boards, superstition, and mass delusion, the book constantly challenges the reader’s assumptions about motive and responsibility. Several cases, such as the murders of Bridget Cleary and Blanche Monnier’s decades-long imprisonment, are especially haunting, revealing how belief systems, family dynamics, and societal norms can enable prolonged cruelty.
Vitelli also excels at placing crimes within their historical and cultural contexts. Stories like the Irish sea captain who murdered his crew, the so-called Vampire of Le Muy, and Jane Toppan’s chilling medical crimes are enriched by thoughtful background details that help explain, not excuse, how such events unfolded.
The writing is clear, accessible, and engaging, making complex cases easy to follow without oversimplifying them. Each chapter feels self-contained, yet together they form a broader meditation on justice, injustice, and the disturbing unpredictability of human behaviour.
December 29, 2025
This book is a fascinating collection of real crime stories that feel stranger than fiction. True Crime Stories You Won’t Believe explores cases where justice, belief, fear, and human behaviour collide in unsettling ways.
Romeo Vitelli covers a wide range of true events, including the real and much darker story behind Arsenic and Old Lace, a case where a dream may have helped solve a brutal murder, and the shocking story of an Irish sea captain who killed most of his crew. Other chapters explore crimes tied to belief systems, such as whether an Ouija board influenced a mother and daughter to murder, and whether the Devil was blamed for the killing of Alan Bono.
Some of the most disturbing stories include Jane Toppan, a nurse who murdered her patients, Blanche Monnier, who was locked away by her own family for decades, and the chilling case of Bridget Cleary, whose husband believed she had been replaced by fairies.
The writing is clear and easy to follow, even when the subject matter is disturbing. Each story is presented thoughtfully, allowing readers to understand not just what happened, but why people believed and acted the way they did.
This is a strong read for anyone interested in true crime, history, and the darker corners of human belief.
Romeo Vitelli covers a wide range of true events, including the real and much darker story behind Arsenic and Old Lace, a case where a dream may have helped solve a brutal murder, and the shocking story of an Irish sea captain who killed most of his crew. Other chapters explore crimes tied to belief systems, such as whether an Ouija board influenced a mother and daughter to murder, and whether the Devil was blamed for the killing of Alan Bono.
Some of the most disturbing stories include Jane Toppan, a nurse who murdered her patients, Blanche Monnier, who was locked away by her own family for decades, and the chilling case of Bridget Cleary, whose husband believed she had been replaced by fairies.
The writing is clear and easy to follow, even when the subject matter is disturbing. Each story is presented thoughtfully, allowing readers to understand not just what happened, but why people believed and acted the way they did.
This is a strong read for anyone interested in true crime, history, and the darker corners of human belief.
April 29, 2023
Interesting book on Little known crimes.
Romeo Vitelli has done an excellent job researching this book for any true crime fan as he has so many different stories. This was a great a collection of short true crime stories that gives you the right amount of information. This book contains a collection of 32 short true crime stories dating back to the late 1800’s. Some of the story’s I was remarkably familiar with and others I had never heard or read about. I found each story to be interesting and this book kept my full attention. Plus, I googled some to learn more I recommend this book to other true crime fans.
I received an advance review copy for free from BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Romeo Vitelli has done an excellent job researching this book for any true crime fan as he has so many different stories. This was a great a collection of short true crime stories that gives you the right amount of information. This book contains a collection of 32 short true crime stories dating back to the late 1800’s. Some of the story’s I was remarkably familiar with and others I had never heard or read about. I found each story to be interesting and this book kept my full attention. Plus, I googled some to learn more I recommend this book to other true crime fans.
I received an advance review copy for free from BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 5, 2024
I love true crime and was excited to read this. The stories are fine - only a couple of them were interesting enough to warrant the title. Most were average. The majority of them were from the 1700 and 1800s and it feels like the author was making assumptions that can't be supported 200 years later.
The main reason for my rating is the quality of the book. If you can even call it a book. I feel like this is a first draft and it far from ready for publication. My kindle copy even still includes footnotes from editors. Not with clarification for the reader, but asking for clarification from the author. Like he sent the text to editors (two different ones!), they commented, then he just published it without looking at it again...
The main reason for my rating is the quality of the book. If you can even call it a book. I feel like this is a first draft and it far from ready for publication. My kindle copy even still includes footnotes from editors. Not with clarification for the reader, but asking for clarification from the author. Like he sent the text to editors (two different ones!), they commented, then he just published it without looking at it again...
March 6, 2023
From a girl who shot her daddy and claimed the Ouija board made her do it to a woman who charge people a penny and claimed her eggs were condoned by God to many other crazy crime stories. This was such a great idea for a book series and I get so excited when a new one comes out. Although I was very excited to get this one now but I’ve read it I have to wait for the next one so to the powers that be please hurry up! I received this book from book sirens but I am leaving this review voluntarily please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.
November 2, 2022
Just as good as the previous book, this true crime collection is an easy read with some well known stories, but several that were completely unfamiliar to even the most avid reader. I didn't notice any particular order of the summaries, so that may help in the future with additional books in this series, but overall it didn't cause any issues as far as readability. Maybe some photos in future collections would enhance the stories too.
BookSirens Review Copy
BookSirens Review Copy
November 15, 2022
Well, I don't know what to believe at this point. Any true-crime fan will love this book!
I don't want to put the author's thoughts, explanations, or "spoilers" in here, though I'm not sure if spoilers are real in a true-crime book because the facts are out there and each person can come up with their own opinions on the subject, HOWEVER, I appreciate the depth of this, the details not usually talked about, and the "wrap up" of each.
I don't want to put the author's thoughts, explanations, or "spoilers" in here, though I'm not sure if spoilers are real in a true-crime book because the facts are out there and each person can come up with their own opinions on the subject, HOWEVER, I appreciate the depth of this, the details not usually talked about, and the "wrap up" of each.
July 1, 2023
So before this book, I read and reviewed the first book in the series. I really enjoyed the first book so I wanted to read this one. I thought this was a great book of true crime stories. They seemed to be well researched as well as well written. The author provides a lot of detail to help the readers understand the stories. I really enjoyed this book and hope for another in the future.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 16, 2024
The content itself was good, but there were more mistakes than I would expect for a published work. There were some places were it looked like a sentence or two might be missing and you had to piece it together with context clues. I would read it again, because I do enjoy true crime, but it was a slower read due to the mistakes.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 23, 2022
Interesting stories any true crime fan would love to read.
This collection of stories is an easy read, well researched and is overall a compelling collection that's guaranteed to keep you up, flipping through pages.
Thank you to the author and BookSirens as I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review
This collection of stories is an easy read, well researched and is overall a compelling collection that's guaranteed to keep you up, flipping through pages.
Thank you to the author and BookSirens as I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review
March 12, 2023
I love true crime, so reading about some crimes I never knew about got me very intrigued. I was able to read this one rather quickly and not because it is an easy read but because each of the stories were very different. Plus I love that there were different crimes from all different times and locations. I look forward to reading more books like this.
March 25, 2023
Not your run-of-the-mill crime stories
There are some strange cases covered in this volume. I hope the author continues to share stories we won't believe.
These bizarre stories vary in time and place and some of them So have read about. It is nothing short of ludicrous what some so-called members of the human race are capable (and willing) to do. I confess I Googled a time or two to satisfy my curiosity.
28
There are some strange cases covered in this volume. I hope the author continues to share stories we won't believe.
These bizarre stories vary in time and place and some of them So have read about. It is nothing short of ludicrous what some so-called members of the human race are capable (and willing) to do. I confess I Googled a time or two to satisfy my curiosity.
28
August 27, 2023
I won this book on Goodreads and really enjoyed it! Lots of great stories on historical crimes of which I was not familiar. Times have changed with punishments, but evil always exists. Highly recommend if you enjoy true crime!
February 28, 2023
True crime
This book had some great information, with lots of murder stories from people I have never heard of before. It covered different dates and different parts of the world.
This book had some great information, with lots of murder stories from people I have never heard of before. It covered different dates and different parts of the world.
June 20, 2023
I love true crime this is an very great read for everyone who love true crime a very well written page turner
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 30, 2023
Won this in Goodreads giveaway and I love it. Super happy to have won a copy. Essential for any true crime fan. Goes in depth and had many details I hadn't previously come across in these cases. It flows well and is hard to put down. I hope they continue this series and I'll definitely be going back to find book one after this. Great airport/travel read though because you can finish a piece without feeling torn from the story.
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews