What do you think?
Rate this book
The Redemption of Lydia Wickham: A Pride and Prejudice Sequel/Variation
I may not be the most book-learned girl in the country, but I would like to think that I am wiser than I was, and much less silly.
Lydia Wickham used to think herself rather clever, having caught a handsome man and being the first to marry of her sisters. Soon, however, she finds herself trapped in a marriage to a man who is not what she thought him to be. Her pride keeps her from revealing her plight to her sisters and family, suffering in silence for years.
Unexpectedly, Lydia is freed from her marriage and begins life away from her misery in Newcastle. The changes in her are apparent to most, but there are those that resist seeing her for who she is and not who she was. As Lydia seeks to reconcile the girl she was with the woman she has become, she reunites with her loved ones and makes many friends along the way. But will Lydia get what she always wanted? Will she have what her sisters have, that which she craves desperately? Will Lydia Wickham find love of her own?
The Redemption of Lydia Wickham is a full length novel centered on the idea that even a foolish 16 year old girl can grow up and become wiser.
Warning: this book contains brief, non-graphic mentions of spousal abuse and assault
Lydia Wickham used to think herself rather clever, having caught a handsome man and being the first to marry of her sisters. Soon, however, she finds herself trapped in a marriage to a man who is not what she thought him to be. Her pride keeps her from revealing her plight to her sisters and family, suffering in silence for years.
Unexpectedly, Lydia is freed from her marriage and begins life away from her misery in Newcastle. The changes in her are apparent to most, but there are those that resist seeing her for who she is and not who she was. As Lydia seeks to reconcile the girl she was with the woman she has become, she reunites with her loved ones and makes many friends along the way. But will Lydia get what she always wanted? Will she have what her sisters have, that which she craves desperately? Will Lydia Wickham find love of her own?
The Redemption of Lydia Wickham is a full length novel centered on the idea that even a foolish 16 year old girl can grow up and become wiser.
Warning: this book contains brief, non-graphic mentions of spousal abuse and assault
- GenresRegency
220 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 1, 2022
42 people are currently reading
69 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
May 17, 2025
… the willingness to accept responsibility for one's own life — is the source from which self-respect springs. ~ Joan Didion
Take just a moment to study the girl on the cover of this book. Does that look like one of the silliest girls in the country? The cover leads the way to this story of Lydia Wickham, who has a long hard row to hoe on her way to maturity.
The story begins with newlywed Lydia and George Wickham traveling to Newcastle. Lydia chats endlessly about the townhouse where they will live. Her first indication that George is not exactly telling her the entire truth is their arrival at a two-room shack. Lydia Wickham has no servants, no money, and no kindness from her husband.
Put on your big girl panties and deal with it. ~ Author Unknown
Trigger Warning: Lydia suffers abuses of deprivation as well as physical assaults.
Eventually, Wickham allows Lydia a stipend to purchase food. She has no new gowns or even new trims to re-make an old garment. In a time when women had no rights, and spousal rape or spousal abuse was not considered a crime, Lydia must grow up in a hurry.
The relationship I found the most surprising was between Mr. Bennet and his “silly” daughter Lydia. If you are a fan of an “unfeeling Papa Bennet” this book is for you.
Overall, the book is named “The Redemption of Lydia Wickham” and a better life awaits Lydia if she can accept it.
Sign over the gates of hell: "Doesn't mean you're a bad person." ~ Robert Brault
Take just a moment to study the girl on the cover of this book. Does that look like one of the silliest girls in the country? The cover leads the way to this story of Lydia Wickham, who has a long hard row to hoe on her way to maturity.
The story begins with newlywed Lydia and George Wickham traveling to Newcastle. Lydia chats endlessly about the townhouse where they will live. Her first indication that George is not exactly telling her the entire truth is their arrival at a two-room shack. Lydia Wickham has no servants, no money, and no kindness from her husband.
Put on your big girl panties and deal with it. ~ Author Unknown
Trigger Warning: Lydia suffers abuses of deprivation as well as physical assaults.
Eventually, Wickham allows Lydia a stipend to purchase food. She has no new gowns or even new trims to re-make an old garment. In a time when women had no rights, and spousal rape or spousal abuse was not considered a crime, Lydia must grow up in a hurry.
The relationship I found the most surprising was between Mr. Bennet and his “silly” daughter Lydia. If you are a fan of an “unfeeling Papa Bennet” this book is for you.
Overall, the book is named “The Redemption of Lydia Wickham” and a better life awaits Lydia if she can accept it.
Sign over the gates of hell: "Doesn't mean you're a bad person." ~ Robert Brault
September 4, 2022
Review also posted on my blog
https://myjaffobsession.blogspot.com/...
Lydia Bennet had thought herself rather clever to elope with George Wickham. He was handsome, charming and looked dashing in his regimentals!
Unfortunately, Lydia Wickham finds that her husband is selfish, vicious and cruel.
She can’t bring herself to admit the truth to her family, so writes with tales of balls, parties and new gowns.
She is forced by circumstances to grow up quickly, just to survive.
After four years, fate frees her from Wickham.
She is reconciled with most of her family, who are horrified with how she has suffered.
Her sisters and brothers-in-law are deeply impressed with the poised young woman she has become. If only her father did not declare her still one of the silliest girls in England.
What Lydia truly yearns for is a man who will love and respect her. Perhaps, she may be lucky!
I usually shy away from books about Lydia, as she is a truly annoying character.
However, this book is excellent. The account of Lydia’s life with Wickham made me weep, she is so lost.
The mature Lydia is lovely and you desperately want a happy ending for her.
I highly recommend this book.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
https://myjaffobsession.blogspot.com/...
Lydia Bennet had thought herself rather clever to elope with George Wickham. He was handsome, charming and looked dashing in his regimentals!
Unfortunately, Lydia Wickham finds that her husband is selfish, vicious and cruel.
She can’t bring herself to admit the truth to her family, so writes with tales of balls, parties and new gowns.
She is forced by circumstances to grow up quickly, just to survive.
After four years, fate frees her from Wickham.
She is reconciled with most of her family, who are horrified with how she has suffered.
Her sisters and brothers-in-law are deeply impressed with the poised young woman she has become. If only her father did not declare her still one of the silliest girls in England.
What Lydia truly yearns for is a man who will love and respect her. Perhaps, she may be lucky!
I usually shy away from books about Lydia, as she is a truly annoying character.
However, this book is excellent. The account of Lydia’s life with Wickham made me weep, she is so lost.
The mature Lydia is lovely and you desperately want a happy ending for her.
I highly recommend this book.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
July 6, 2023
I loved this heartbreaking, poignant and redemptive story about Lydia Wickham! I enjoy it when our beloved characters go through adversity and rise like a phoenix from the ashes. This is very much the case for Lydia Wickham.
“My actions of this past August begin to seem foolish in the extreme…Perhaps I am one of the silliest girls in all of England.” (quote from the book)
Lydia Wickham feels she has the jump on all her sisters! How exciting to be singled out by Mr. Wickham and eloping! How exciting to be headed to Newcastle and their own townhouse! Just think of all the balls and dancing she will be attending with the handsomest officer! And then he brings her to a tiny run-down cottage with no servants…
“I grow concerned. Wickham is changing. Or perhaps, he is not what I believed him to be.” (quote from the book)
We, the reader, know what Wickham truly is. In this story, he is more vindictive and controlling. If he can’t have what he wants, then Lydia can’t either. I was ready to do great harm to him. But then Fate steps in. This was all in the Prologue as journal entries. Yes, Lydia records her first four years in a journal given to her by her Aunt Gardiner. At the time, she was dismissive of it but not after her life took a turn for the worse.
“How is it that we failed you? We, your family should have protected you.” (quote from the book)
I was not just engaged in this story but completely riveted. I laughed, I cried, and my heart broke, as I cheered Lydia on. Mr. Wickham was not the only one I wanted to do harm to…Mr. Bennet was a close second. But then…well I won’t give anything away. I found this to be an emotive and evocative journey for Lydia and cannot recommend it highly enough! Brava Ms. Stratton! I look forward to your next novel!
“I find that looking back over the course of one’s journey teaches us many things about who we are. Though I regret many of the decisions made in my journey, I would not trade the lessons learned and the knowledge gained for a simpler or easier path.” (quote from the book)
August 24, 2022
I received an ARC from booksprout and promised a review.
I’m happy to be able to almost wholeheartedly recommend this book; the abuse that is mentioned is the only reason I can’t. It may be upsetting to some readers. I did think it was handled well. It was an accurate picture of the plight of women in the Regency period.
I loved seeing Lydia mature and grow as a person. She learned her own worth and how to trust again.
I liked the love interest for Lydia. I enjoyed seeing all the characters from Pride and Prejudice.
I think a little too much time was spent with the villain. I didn’t care what happened to her.
I’m happy to be able to almost wholeheartedly recommend this book; the abuse that is mentioned is the only reason I can’t. It may be upsetting to some readers. I did think it was handled well. It was an accurate picture of the plight of women in the Regency period.
I loved seeing Lydia mature and grow as a person. She learned her own worth and how to trust again.
I liked the love interest for Lydia. I enjoyed seeing all the characters from Pride and Prejudice.
I think a little too much time was spent with the villain. I didn’t care what happened to her.
September 1, 2022
The opening journal entries grabbed me from the first page
Lydia Wickham nee Bennet, rarely anyone's favorite Bennet sister (certainly not mine and the reason I almost passed on reading this story). I highly recommend NOT passing on it.
Lydia has married Wickham and is on the threshold of all her delusions melting away into the barren wasteland that becomes her life. Insult to injury, her own behavior isolates her from female society, which in her self-absorption she expected to rule as a fashionable married lady.
Alone, with eyes brutally opened she must acquire many new skills to get through what has become a living nightmare, or she won't survive. A neighbor shows her kindness and compassion, with Lydia learning most of these skills from her.
Wickham uses his coldness, violence and dominion over her to keep her submissive and silent in her correspondence, she doesn't (can't!) say a thing to her family aside from lies of frivolity.
This and worse goes on till about the halfway point when 2 major pivotal occurrences bring huge changes to this matured and seasoned Lydia. She is reunited with her sisters one by one and figures out a way to find her true self in a new society and situation.
When Elizabeth gets in her head to match-make, well, the second half of the story develops. A summer house party is planned and we meet former and new characters - romance blooms at Pemberley.
The segues to introduce us to a couple of the new characters were sharp and didn't flow well. Maybe if we had been introduced to them as Part 2, it might have read more cohesively, IMO. I also was not a fan of the flatness of a couple of the new characters.
A sticking point was Mr. Bennet's obstinance concerning Lydia, but he too had to learn the hard way how wrong he had been, for most of his adult life!
I was very impressed with the writing, I found it enjoyable to read, despite some of the difficult content. A clean story, with some angst due to a few scenes of violence, resolved not too far from the beginning.
The opening journal entries were very poignant, it was almost a letdown when Chapter 1 started out so prosaically.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Lydia Wickham nee Bennet, rarely anyone's favorite Bennet sister (certainly not mine and the reason I almost passed on reading this story). I highly recommend NOT passing on it.
Lydia has married Wickham and is on the threshold of all her delusions melting away into the barren wasteland that becomes her life. Insult to injury, her own behavior isolates her from female society, which in her self-absorption she expected to rule as a fashionable married lady.
Alone, with eyes brutally opened she must acquire many new skills to get through what has become a living nightmare, or she won't survive. A neighbor shows her kindness and compassion, with Lydia learning most of these skills from her.
Wickham uses his coldness, violence and dominion over her to keep her submissive and silent in her correspondence, she doesn't (can't!) say a thing to her family aside from lies of frivolity.
This and worse goes on till about the halfway point when 2 major pivotal occurrences bring huge changes to this matured and seasoned Lydia. She is reunited with her sisters one by one and figures out a way to find her true self in a new society and situation.
When Elizabeth gets in her head to match-make, well, the second half of the story develops. A summer house party is planned and we meet former and new characters - romance blooms at Pemberley.
The segues to introduce us to a couple of the new characters were sharp and didn't flow well. Maybe if we had been introduced to them as Part 2, it might have read more cohesively, IMO. I also was not a fan of the flatness of a couple of the new characters.
A sticking point was Mr. Bennet's obstinance concerning Lydia, but he too had to learn the hard way how wrong he had been, for most of his adult life!
I was very impressed with the writing, I found it enjoyable to read, despite some of the difficult content. A clean story, with some angst due to a few scenes of violence, resolved not too far from the beginning.
The opening journal entries were very poignant, it was almost a letdown when Chapter 1 started out so prosaically.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
February 20, 2025
Can the spoiled, youngest Bennet daughter learn from the biggest mistake of her life and become something more? I've been making my way through MJ Stratton's backlist and kept hesitating over this one. I wasn't sure I wanted to read Lydia's story, but I took the gamble and glad I did.
Lydia Bennet Wickham goes through a refiner's fire once she is Wickham's wife. Her time with Wickham is told in epistolary format and this was a brilliant choice. For, Lydia is alone now save the gift of a diary from her aunt and her fiendish husband. The shine on her love and happiness tarnished not long after arriving in Newcastle. At first, they are popular among the wives and other officers for their beauty and vivacity as a couple. Then, suddenly they are cut from society and Wickham's habits of vice are no longer hidden from her when she is destitute, abused, and forced to watch a parade of mistresses go through her tiny poor neighborhood home.
Lydia hits bottom, but doesn't give up. She is humbled and teachable which helps her make a crucial friend and start to crawl out of the pit. Meanwhile, under the direction of her despised husband, all her letters to family are a tissue of lies about popularity, fashionable clothes and parties. Not that Lydia would have them know the truth so they could crow over stupid, gullible Lydia.
After the years in Newcastle when something big happens to change her life, the format goes back to narrative and includes Lydia, but others from her family and a few intriguing characters who will have their part in her life. I was really rooting for this Lydia who showed quiet strength and grit when she had to and had hope since the title, after all, references redemption for Lydia.
I thought the contrasts in scenes really accentuated by the writing format were brilliant. I thought the pace of Lydia's growth and details showing it happening and then later the growth and development of the romance element were pitch perfect. There are great reunion moments with family and showed a good sequel for all the extended Bennet family. But, yes, Lydia was the shining light of it all.
If you, like me hesitate because this is Lydia's story, you can trust Stratton to write a redemption story of determination and hope worth reading.
Lydia Bennet Wickham goes through a refiner's fire once she is Wickham's wife. Her time with Wickham is told in epistolary format and this was a brilliant choice. For, Lydia is alone now save the gift of a diary from her aunt and her fiendish husband. The shine on her love and happiness tarnished not long after arriving in Newcastle. At first, they are popular among the wives and other officers for their beauty and vivacity as a couple. Then, suddenly they are cut from society and Wickham's habits of vice are no longer hidden from her when she is destitute, abused, and forced to watch a parade of mistresses go through her tiny poor neighborhood home.
Lydia hits bottom, but doesn't give up. She is humbled and teachable which helps her make a crucial friend and start to crawl out of the pit. Meanwhile, under the direction of her despised husband, all her letters to family are a tissue of lies about popularity, fashionable clothes and parties. Not that Lydia would have them know the truth so they could crow over stupid, gullible Lydia.
After the years in Newcastle when something big happens to change her life, the format goes back to narrative and includes Lydia, but others from her family and a few intriguing characters who will have their part in her life. I was really rooting for this Lydia who showed quiet strength and grit when she had to and had hope since the title, after all, references redemption for Lydia.
I thought the contrasts in scenes really accentuated by the writing format were brilliant. I thought the pace of Lydia's growth and details showing it happening and then later the growth and development of the romance element were pitch perfect. There are great reunion moments with family and showed a good sequel for all the extended Bennet family. But, yes, Lydia was the shining light of it all.
If you, like me hesitate because this is Lydia's story, you can trust Stratton to write a redemption story of determination and hope worth reading.
October 3, 2022
I am an avid reader of all P & P varitions. To a lesser extent the sequels that follow as they are at times missing the fire, suspense and ODC.
This one,is the best sequel I have read by far. Though heart-breaking, the events that happened to Lydia molded her into a character that one should not only admire but emulate. I love also the bond of family that was embedded and of course ODC's role in the story. Though a small portion, Lizzy's "expressions" gave the comedy that made the story even more enticing.(The few things I wish added were what happened to GD, the Colonel and Mr. Carlson).
I think this book should be read not only by JA fans, but those looking for inspiration and growth. Highly recommend this story to everyone.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This one,is the best sequel I have read by far. Though heart-breaking, the events that happened to Lydia molded her into a character that one should not only admire but emulate. I love also the bond of family that was embedded and of course ODC's role in the story. Though a small portion, Lizzy's "expressions" gave the comedy that made the story even more enticing.(The few things I wish added were what happened to GD, the Colonel and Mr. Carlson).
I think this book should be read not only by JA fans, but those looking for inspiration and growth. Highly recommend this story to everyone.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
April 2, 2024
A Happy Ending for Lydia
An excellent story outlining Lydia Bennet’s life post elopement with Wickham starts out with words from her own journal, revealing the dark truth about her situation in Newcastle. Trying to mislead and cover up her reality, Mr. Bennet and Elizabeth know something seems off, causing the Darcys to investigate, eventually leading to Lydia discovering a secret Wickham kept from her, and renewing fractured relationships with her family. As she is about to achieve her happy ending, an angst-filled situation threatens to spoil it. This definitely a well-written page turner.
MJ Stratton has become a favourite author. I highly recommend this and all her books.
An excellent story outlining Lydia Bennet’s life post elopement with Wickham starts out with words from her own journal, revealing the dark truth about her situation in Newcastle. Trying to mislead and cover up her reality, Mr. Bennet and Elizabeth know something seems off, causing the Darcys to investigate, eventually leading to Lydia discovering a secret Wickham kept from her, and renewing fractured relationships with her family. As she is about to achieve her happy ending, an angst-filled situation threatens to spoil it. This definitely a well-written page turner.
MJ Stratton has become a favourite author. I highly recommend this and all her books.
September 10, 2022
Yeah for Lydia!
Wonderful detail of the misery in the Wickham marriage. Matches what other variations also illustrate. A very lovely second chance for HEA. Well done!
Wonderful detail of the misery in the Wickham marriage. Matches what other variations also illustrate. A very lovely second chance for HEA. Well done!
September 23, 2023
Poignant
Darkly poignant and yet also a beautiful redemption for Lydia Wickham. Yes she was a spoiled child who ruined their family with her elopement but she was only partly to blame. Her parents should have a major share of blame for failing to raise their daughters properly and supervise them in company. A good story and a lovely ending.
Darkly poignant and yet also a beautiful redemption for Lydia Wickham. Yes she was a spoiled child who ruined their family with her elopement but she was only partly to blame. Her parents should have a major share of blame for failing to raise their daughters properly and supervise them in company. A good story and a lovely ending.
August 24, 2022
First off, a few things to know about me… I have been reading JAFF and P&P Variations for over 20 years, I am not sure how many I have read as I lost count about 4 years ago (it was around 1500 then, and I have been reading an average of 200 +/- per year since then), and I want to mention that I almost never cry when I read a book. I also have an unfortunate tendency to not review books unless they are either excellent or horrendous. However... I have recently committed to working on changing that behavior… and with that... I have willingly committed to writing an honest review for this book in exchange for receiving an ARC via booksprout.
On to my review…
I enjoyed this book very much.
The book is approx 60,000 words, and I finished it in about 3-ish hours, over 2 sittings—only because I had an appointment and had to stop for a couple of hours. I was anxious to return to the story. The story is well done, well thought out, and is compelling. The story picks up from the time of Lydia’s elopement, and the outcomes for the different characters in the original P&P are all the same. I found the author’s versions of the characters to be true / inline to their original JA counterparts. Something to note… speech patterns and phrasings lean towards more modern diction vs regency, and while that does not bother me, I mention it as I know it may be a bother to some readers. I also found the book to be well edited, there were no obvious problems in the flow of the story, and no glaring mistakes in spelling, grammar, or punctuation. It was pleasure to read for that alone!
I will try to avoid spoilers, but beware from this point on, some spoilery info might creep in.
The book starts out in Journal form—Lydia’s perspective of her elopement and marriage “in real time” as it were. The journal entries show not just WHAT happened in the Wickhams’ marriage, but also hints at the evolution of the growth and maturity of Lydia, as well as how her love for Wickham dissipates, and ultimately her realization of just how rotten the person she married is. There is description of abuse… physical, mental, emotional, financial… but it was as kindly done a possible considering, and I found it was not overly graphic/descriptive. While there is some explanation... we are expected to fill in a lot of those details on our own. When Lydia asks her journal “What did I do? What did I do to make him so angry?” … my heart just broke for her, and I cried.
Once Wickham’s regiment is sent to the continent, the story then moves into narrative. And this is where we learn more of the details of Lydia’s story, the changes in her life, how and why she has had to change, and of how she has been forced to grow up quickly. The various Darcy, Bingley, & Bennet relations become involved in her story at this point, and we see how they variously relate to and respond to the changed Lydia. And through these familiar characters and their relationships, as well as some new characters and their various relationships, we see just how much Lydia has grown. I like that she has finally learned some discernment. (I also quite liked the new characters, they were flushed out and they had well developed back stories as well as in the current story.)
This book really is about Lydia’s journey in the years / aftermath of her elopement. The story is very relationship focused… not just on Lydia / Wickham, but Lydia and her various family, all of the various characters amongst themselves, as well as between Lydia and the new characters. There is some angst, and there is some description (more than once) of abuse(s) and some inappropriate behaviors (but not in overt graphic detail... it was description/discussion of events and how they shaped, and why they shaped, the characters into how they now appeared.) All in all… I really liked how much Lydia changed, and how she changed. She did not have an easy road but she did not buckle and she rose to the challenge. And she learns to forgive.
I thought this was a really fine story. I struggle to find anything to truly criticize. Would I recommend this? Yes. There are some cautions for those who may be sensitive to abuse/assault, etc, especially spousal abuse. And for those who want the regency styling for speech/writing/formatting, this may not be the best fit … this book is more plainly spoken and more modern leaning in its presentation. And for those who want all Elizabeth & Darcy all the time, this is not one those stories, even though E&D have a pretty large part to play. Anyone who wants a nice/sweet but realistic relationship-based growth story with mid-angst, a bit of intrigue and plotting, some cry-inducing moments, and a developing love story… this is for you.
(And in case you were wondering… yes, Lydia does have an HEA).
On to my review…
I enjoyed this book very much.
The book is approx 60,000 words, and I finished it in about 3-ish hours, over 2 sittings—only because I had an appointment and had to stop for a couple of hours. I was anxious to return to the story. The story is well done, well thought out, and is compelling. The story picks up from the time of Lydia’s elopement, and the outcomes for the different characters in the original P&P are all the same. I found the author’s versions of the characters to be true / inline to their original JA counterparts. Something to note… speech patterns and phrasings lean towards more modern diction vs regency, and while that does not bother me, I mention it as I know it may be a bother to some readers. I also found the book to be well edited, there were no obvious problems in the flow of the story, and no glaring mistakes in spelling, grammar, or punctuation. It was pleasure to read for that alone!
I will try to avoid spoilers, but beware from this point on, some spoilery info might creep in.
The book starts out in Journal form—Lydia’s perspective of her elopement and marriage “in real time” as it were. The journal entries show not just WHAT happened in the Wickhams’ marriage, but also hints at the evolution of the growth and maturity of Lydia, as well as how her love for Wickham dissipates, and ultimately her realization of just how rotten the person she married is. There is description of abuse… physical, mental, emotional, financial… but it was as kindly done a possible considering, and I found it was not overly graphic/descriptive. While there is some explanation... we are expected to fill in a lot of those details on our own. When Lydia asks her journal “What did I do? What did I do to make him so angry?” … my heart just broke for her, and I cried.
Once Wickham’s regiment is sent to the continent, the story then moves into narrative. And this is where we learn more of the details of Lydia’s story, the changes in her life, how and why she has had to change, and of how she has been forced to grow up quickly. The various Darcy, Bingley, & Bennet relations become involved in her story at this point, and we see how they variously relate to and respond to the changed Lydia. And through these familiar characters and their relationships, as well as some new characters and their various relationships, we see just how much Lydia has grown. I like that she has finally learned some discernment. (I also quite liked the new characters, they were flushed out and they had well developed back stories as well as in the current story.)
This book really is about Lydia’s journey in the years / aftermath of her elopement. The story is very relationship focused… not just on Lydia / Wickham, but Lydia and her various family, all of the various characters amongst themselves, as well as between Lydia and the new characters. There is some angst, and there is some description (more than once) of abuse(s) and some inappropriate behaviors (but not in overt graphic detail... it was description/discussion of events and how they shaped, and why they shaped, the characters into how they now appeared.) All in all… I really liked how much Lydia changed, and how she changed. She did not have an easy road but she did not buckle and she rose to the challenge. And she learns to forgive.
I thought this was a really fine story. I struggle to find anything to truly criticize. Would I recommend this? Yes. There are some cautions for those who may be sensitive to abuse/assault, etc, especially spousal abuse. And for those who want the regency styling for speech/writing/formatting, this may not be the best fit … this book is more plainly spoken and more modern leaning in its presentation. And for those who want all Elizabeth & Darcy all the time, this is not one those stories, even though E&D have a pretty large part to play. Anyone who wants a nice/sweet but realistic relationship-based growth story with mid-angst, a bit of intrigue and plotting, some cry-inducing moments, and a developing love story… this is for you.
(And in case you were wondering… yes, Lydia does have an HEA).
May 6, 2023
3.5.
A perfectly sweet little story but not much substance too it. Nevertheless an interesting angle and good to see a positive version of Lydia (not however my favorite, that goes to the Lydia that fends off Wickham in the carriage, bites him and gives him blood poisoning!).
A perfectly sweet little story but not much substance too it. Nevertheless an interesting angle and good to see a positive version of Lydia (not however my favorite, that goes to the Lydia that fends off Wickham in the carriage, bites him and gives him blood poisoning!).
August 15, 2024
Poignant novel. The physical and emotional pain inflicted on a childish, ignorant adolescent is heartbreaking, sickening really. I'm glad I stuck with it though. Transformation, inspiration, reflection, growth...all these words come to mind. The dialogue between Lydia and Mr. Bennet...brilliant!
September 17, 2022
Okay, but contrived
Lydia Wickham goes through the school of hard knocks in her marriage to George Wickham, learning quickly that she made a huge mistake, and that she should have listened to her older sisters when they tried to improve her behavior and her education. She is forced to grow up in a hurry, and learn how to cook, clean, and economize. She is mentally and physically abused by her husband, but she's too embarrassed to tell anyone in her family. After a few years, Wickham's regiment is sent to fight in the war, and he's killed. A pregnant Lydia is now free of her terrible husband, but it isn't until Darcy and Elizabeth come to Newcastle to check on Lydia, that anyone learns of her ordeals. The Darcys take her to live at Pemberly, and inform her that she has a fortune that her husband never told her about.
This is an interesting tale, and a disturbing one at times, but the style of writing is somewhat matter-of-fact, and documentary like. Even the scenes of abuse in the beginning are told about without much emotion. Elizabeth Darcy, in a disappointing move, acts way too much like her mother in her efforts to get Lydia married again in, what feels like, way too much of a hurry. Shortly after Lydia has her baby, and is still coming to grips with her tumultuous life, Elizabeth decides to have a house party clearly designed to throw Lydia in the path of some eligible bachelors. WTH!! Give the poor girl some time!
There are several characters that do some very stupid and contrived things, including Caroline Bingley, Mr Bennett, the Hamilton brothers (both), and this Lady Felicity. Although their idiotic actions further the plot, I just had to roll my eyes at the silliness of it. Also, the man who was to become Lydia's new love interest was presented in such an obvious way that it killed all of the surprise and potential romance of it. It was glaringly obvious who Lydia had to end up with before they were even introduced. A little more subtlety would have been nice.
The book is well written and well edited. It's not great literature, but I recommend it.
Lydia Wickham goes through the school of hard knocks in her marriage to George Wickham, learning quickly that she made a huge mistake, and that she should have listened to her older sisters when they tried to improve her behavior and her education. She is forced to grow up in a hurry, and learn how to cook, clean, and economize. She is mentally and physically abused by her husband, but she's too embarrassed to tell anyone in her family. After a few years, Wickham's regiment is sent to fight in the war, and he's killed. A pregnant Lydia is now free of her terrible husband, but it isn't until Darcy and Elizabeth come to Newcastle to check on Lydia, that anyone learns of her ordeals. The Darcys take her to live at Pemberly, and inform her that she has a fortune that her husband never told her about.
This is an interesting tale, and a disturbing one at times, but the style of writing is somewhat matter-of-fact, and documentary like. Even the scenes of abuse in the beginning are told about without much emotion. Elizabeth Darcy, in a disappointing move, acts way too much like her mother in her efforts to get Lydia married again in, what feels like, way too much of a hurry. Shortly after Lydia has her baby, and is still coming to grips with her tumultuous life, Elizabeth decides to have a house party clearly designed to throw Lydia in the path of some eligible bachelors. WTH!! Give the poor girl some time!
There are several characters that do some very stupid and contrived things, including Caroline Bingley, Mr Bennett, the Hamilton brothers (both), and this Lady Felicity. Although their idiotic actions further the plot, I just had to roll my eyes at the silliness of it. Also, the man who was to become Lydia's new love interest was presented in such an obvious way that it killed all of the surprise and potential romance of it. It was glaringly obvious who Lydia had to end up with before they were even introduced. A little more subtlety would have been nice.
The book is well written and well edited. It's not great literature, but I recommend it.
September 3, 2022
This book opens up with some snippets from Lydia Wickham's diary. She was a naive flighty child but the reality of her marriage forces her to grow up. It turns out that sweet-talking George is a broke, abusive, unfaithful and controlling husband, as well as short-lived. He leaves his widow with financial problems and a child. The Darcys invite her to live at Pemberley where she meets the rest of her family again. Her father is a judgemental ass but Lydia's thoughtful Christmas gift gets him to see what a jerk he had been. There is a man who might be interested in loving Lydia but he is mired in Other Woman drama.
I liked the first half of the story more than the second. Lydia's hardships and emotional growth was described in a way that made her a sympathetic character. In the second half I was kind of disappointed in everyone who surrounds her. She deserved a champion but nobody had told her what financial assets she had, nobody was able or willing to protect her from people who obviously meant to distress her, and her secondary love interest's first instinct at the first sight of a problem is a knee jerk reaction based on jealous rage and distrust. I wanted better for her. But I am told that she got very happy with the jealous guy so I am going to have to take the author's word for it.
In addition to Lydia, the author is able to redeem some minor characters.
Steam level: kissing.
CW: domestic violence and sexual assault.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I liked the first half of the story more than the second. Lydia's hardships and emotional growth was described in a way that made her a sympathetic character. In the second half I was kind of disappointed in everyone who surrounds her. She deserved a champion but nobody had told her what financial assets she had, nobody was able or willing to protect her from people who obviously meant to distress her, and her secondary love interest's first instinct at the first sight of a problem is a knee jerk reaction based on jealous rage and distrust. I wanted better for her. But I am told that she got very happy with the jealous guy so I am going to have to take the author's word for it.
In addition to Lydia, the author is able to redeem some minor characters.
Steam level: kissing.
CW: domestic violence and sexual assault.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Read
March 15, 2024DNF
I wanted to like a story where Lydia triumphs but this was hard going. It is very unemotional and cold, whether in terrible or happy moments, telling rather than showing. For a character like Lydia this style doesn’t work at all and rather than making her seem mature, it feels like an entirely different person. There is no real indication of what happened really impacting Lydia emotionally, but her behaviour is entirely the opposite of her canon self. I have read other abusive Wickham stories that show Lydia reacting as herself and I prefer that style - this, in my opinion, might as well be an original story and not a JAFF.
Even stand alone, the storyline is painfully contrived, everything happening just at the most convenient moment in the most convenient way for the plot regardless of how realistic it is. It is difficult to suspend disbelief for any length of time.
I found the wording very Americanised, though that is a personal thing - it wouldn’t be so jarring if the story and characterisation was more accurate or drew one in. The writing is also quite repetitive: eg, Lydia’s diaries are first and then most of that information is repeated again in the story chapters; we are reminded of various things multiple times, far too many for such a short story; and the same phrases and sentiments are reused often, with the tone of teaching a lesson (and an obvious one at that). Did not finish.
I wanted to like a story where Lydia triumphs but this was hard going. It is very unemotional and cold, whether in terrible or happy moments, telling rather than showing. For a character like Lydia this style doesn’t work at all and rather than making her seem mature, it feels like an entirely different person. There is no real indication of what happened really impacting Lydia emotionally, but her behaviour is entirely the opposite of her canon self. I have read other abusive Wickham stories that show Lydia reacting as herself and I prefer that style - this, in my opinion, might as well be an original story and not a JAFF.
Even stand alone, the storyline is painfully contrived, everything happening just at the most convenient moment in the most convenient way for the plot regardless of how realistic it is. It is difficult to suspend disbelief for any length of time.
I found the wording very Americanised, though that is a personal thing - it wouldn’t be so jarring if the story and characterisation was more accurate or drew one in. The writing is also quite repetitive: eg, Lydia’s diaries are first and then most of that information is repeated again in the story chapters; we are reminded of various things multiple times, far too many for such a short story; and the same phrases and sentiments are reused often, with the tone of teaching a lesson (and an obvious one at that). Did not finish.
September 8, 2022
LOVED IT!!!!!!
I received an ARC in exchange for my honest review. That said, I pre-ordered my kindle copy because this is one I will most definitely re-read.
I love redemptive stories. I particularly enjoy redemptive JAFF that features characters who were irredeemable in canon. Lydia Wickham nee Bennet is one such person.
I am not going to summarize this story - because it is definitely worth the read and I am not good at summary reviews.
Some parts of this tale are told by Lydia’s journal entries - and as such we are able to truly be a part of her maturation process. I was both saddened and angered by what Lydia went through prior to Wickham’s (deserved) death.
I found the pacing to be very good - it never got too bogged down in overtelling. Though some might say this was a low angst book, I think there is an element of angst underlying Lydia’s journey. Learning to open up her heart, to trust again, to allow healing… to give up the facade that all is well to her family. Even grieving the loss of one’s idealized expectations.
This is one of my all-time favorite secondary character PP variations!
I loved it.
I received an ARC in exchange for my honest review. That said, I pre-ordered my kindle copy because this is one I will most definitely re-read.
I love redemptive stories. I particularly enjoy redemptive JAFF that features characters who were irredeemable in canon. Lydia Wickham nee Bennet is one such person.
I am not going to summarize this story - because it is definitely worth the read and I am not good at summary reviews.
Some parts of this tale are told by Lydia’s journal entries - and as such we are able to truly be a part of her maturation process. I was both saddened and angered by what Lydia went through prior to Wickham’s (deserved) death.
I found the pacing to be very good - it never got too bogged down in overtelling. Though some might say this was a low angst book, I think there is an element of angst underlying Lydia’s journey. Learning to open up her heart, to trust again, to allow healing… to give up the facade that all is well to her family. Even grieving the loss of one’s idealized expectations.
This is one of my all-time favorite secondary character PP variations!
I loved it.
June 20, 2024
A very well rendered story
Lydia’s evolution from spoiled, headstrong child to a mature, loving woman is entirely believable, due to Stratton’s effective use of journaling to reveal Lydia’s experience and thought processes, and to the choices Lydia, herself, makes. Within her spirit were the seeds of the Bennet women, her sisters. In their light, her determination to make the best to things, her willingness to accept neighbourly help, and to learn the skills she once deemed beneath her is entirely convincing. Her energy and passion are turned towards survival skills that begin her transformation. Her sisters play supporting roles, though Lizzy’s actions are key plot turning points.
Generally, the writing is good. A few grammatical clangers, but the language I learnt is changing. “Bored of” still makes my ears bleed but it is used by more and more authors, instead of the grammatically correct “bored with/by”. Yet, the need for subject and verb to agree in number is still the default use. So “bride clothes” should have had a plural verb.
Lydia’s evolution from spoiled, headstrong child to a mature, loving woman is entirely believable, due to Stratton’s effective use of journaling to reveal Lydia’s experience and thought processes, and to the choices Lydia, herself, makes. Within her spirit were the seeds of the Bennet women, her sisters. In their light, her determination to make the best to things, her willingness to accept neighbourly help, and to learn the skills she once deemed beneath her is entirely convincing. Her energy and passion are turned towards survival skills that begin her transformation. Her sisters play supporting roles, though Lizzy’s actions are key plot turning points.
Generally, the writing is good. A few grammatical clangers, but the language I learnt is changing. “Bored of” still makes my ears bleed but it is used by more and more authors, instead of the grammatically correct “bored with/by”. Yet, the need for subject and verb to agree in number is still the default use. So “bride clothes” should have had a plural verb.
August 29, 2022
I really enjoyed this book. I read a lot of Jane Austen Fan Fiction and enjoy stories where Lydia has a happy ending. It's not easy to think of a 15-year-old girl at the mercy of a much older, selfish man who doesn't;t care who he hurts in order to get what he wants. Jane Austen doesn't redeeming Lydia, but this story is different. I was gripped right from the start, the author knows how to tap into emotions and I loved Lydia right from the start. I was heartbroken as Lydia realises what kind of a man her husband is and how she can't escape. I also was heartbroken when she decides how to respond to her family. I wasn't so keen on the second half of the book, it veered off with too many new characters, but that's my own personal choice, it still reads well and was gripping. Anyone who like JAFF will surely enjoy this. Thanks for the opportunity to read this book in advance.
September 17, 2022
4.5 Stars
For anyone who ever wondered how things turned out for Lydia after marrying Wickham, this story can fill that void. At least this is how I now choose to view it.
I honestly never planned on reading a story dedicated to Lydia- she and Mrs. Bennet are my least favorite characters. However, this story grabbed my attention and I found myself rooting for Lydia's happiness.
-Darcy and Elizabeth were part of the supporting cast, but useful.
-The Hamilton storyline was a plus.
-Love how the Bennet family embraced Lydia (not all at the same time.)
For anyone who ever wondered how things turned out for Lydia after marrying Wickham, this story can fill that void. At least this is how I now choose to view it.
I honestly never planned on reading a story dedicated to Lydia- she and Mrs. Bennet are my least favorite characters. However, this story grabbed my attention and I found myself rooting for Lydia's happiness.
-Darcy and Elizabeth were part of the supporting cast, but useful.
-The Hamilton storyline was a plus.
-Love how the Bennet family embraced Lydia (not all at the same time.)
September 5, 2022
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I loved the continuing saga of the youngest Bennet sister. Her husband's treatment of her was deplorable, and it was hard to read about the abuse. However, seeing her triumph through those trials to become a confident, strong woman was refreshing and great ending for this wayward child.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 19, 2022
loved this Lydia
I am usually not a Lydia fan. She is usually one of my least favorite characters because of her grading and amateur personality. However the author did an amazing job by allowing her to grow and become someone different. She brought Lydia to life in a way that seemed reasonable and even maybe possible. I loved the romance and the story at all of it coming together. I look forward to more once by this author
I am usually not a Lydia fan. She is usually one of my least favorite characters because of her grading and amateur personality. However the author did an amazing job by allowing her to grow and become someone different. She brought Lydia to life in a way that seemed reasonable and even maybe possible. I loved the romance and the story at all of it coming together. I look forward to more once by this author
September 26, 2022
Quite a surprise
Lydia Bennnet as someone to admire! Who's thunk it? It's true. The tale begins with her marriage to Wickham and their trip North. Bliss turn to bane quickly enough.
Lydia was never simple in The head, she simply hadn't learned to care. The hard life taught her to bear down and make the most of her plight
Well written and edited with very believable dialog. Her story is one of learning and making something out of little. Well done.
Recommended
Lydia Bennnet as someone to admire! Who's thunk it? It's true. The tale begins with her marriage to Wickham and their trip North. Bliss turn to bane quickly enough.
Lydia was never simple in The head, she simply hadn't learned to care. The hard life taught her to bear down and make the most of her plight
Well written and edited with very believable dialog. Her story is one of learning and making something out of little. Well done.
Recommended
June 27, 2024
Excellent!
Sadly, Lydia Wickham couldn't possibly imagine what her life would be with George Wickham. She endures hunger, shame and abuse. The gift of a journal from Aunt Gardiner helps her write of her true life in Newcastle, not the letters she sends to her family. Given limited funds an absent often husband. Lydia grows responsible and industrious and strong. Wickham leaves a widow. Which frankly is a blessing!
Sadly, Lydia Wickham couldn't possibly imagine what her life would be with George Wickham. She endures hunger, shame and abuse. The gift of a journal from Aunt Gardiner helps her write of her true life in Newcastle, not the letters she sends to her family. Given limited funds an absent often husband. Lydia grows responsible and industrious and strong. Wickham leaves a widow. Which frankly is a blessing!
March 3, 2023
This was such a good read! I always wish Lydia’s story was more finished, and I love MJs version of events. Everyone deserves a chance at redemption, and Lydia redeems herself before she is redeemed by love. This was a wonderful story of overcoming your trials and becoming the best and strongest version of yourself. I feel so much more closure of Lydia’s story. Great job? MJ!
September 6, 2022
Lydia Bennett's marriage to George Wickham unveils an uncomfortable truth ... that perhaps she's one of the silliest girls in all of England after all. I wasn't a fan of Lydia Bennett, but found myself rooting for her in The Redemption of Lydia Wickham. I highly recommend this book.
November 3, 2022
So Good!!!
I love books about the changes Lydia goes through.
I think this the third book I have read about her and I enjoyed
all of them but this one made me tear up a little for the happiness she found.
I love books about the changes Lydia goes through.
I think this the third book I have read about her and I enjoyed
all of them but this one made me tear up a little for the happiness she found.
November 10, 2022
Good Read.
Lovely, and well written, this book delivers on its title. Lydia grows from selfish and clueless child to mature and sensitive adult embodied of courage and perseverance.
Lovely, and well written, this book delivers on its title. Lydia grows from selfish and clueless child to mature and sensitive adult embodied of courage and perseverance.
September 14, 2023
Lydia, really?
This is the best characterization of Lydia I’ve read to date in JAFF (and I’ve read a lot). It’s hard to come up with a new storyline that readers will enjoy; this one hits the mark.
This is the best characterization of Lydia I’ve read to date in JAFF (and I’ve read a lot). It’s hard to come up with a new storyline that readers will enjoy; this one hits the mark.
March 29, 2024
Great Read
I really enjoyed this book and how the story was written about Lydia. For me it tells we are all capable of redemption. It was refreshing to read about another Bennett sister other than Elizabeth.
I really enjoyed this book and how the story was written about Lydia. For me it tells we are all capable of redemption. It was refreshing to read about another Bennett sister other than Elizabeth.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews