What do you think?
Rate this book
Short Circuit: A Novel
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
October 3, 2023
A delightful little adventure book!
Having been a huge Johnny 5 fan for as long as I can remember, I adore the film and was so excited for this.
Although I did enjoy it, it was very different to what I expected. It wasn't particularly well written and most of the characters were completely different to how I know them. Stephanie came across as a bit dim and very aggressive (unlike Stephanie in the film who was more loving but fiesty) and Number 5 just seemed to lack any sort of personality. He was written as a completely different character - personality and physically. I understand the concept of a novelization, and I'm glad I read it, but I think I'll stay with the films from that era from now on!
Having been a huge Johnny 5 fan for as long as I can remember, I adore the film and was so excited for this.
Although I did enjoy it, it was very different to what I expected. It wasn't particularly well written and most of the characters were completely different to how I know them. Stephanie came across as a bit dim and very aggressive (unlike Stephanie in the film who was more loving but fiesty) and Number 5 just seemed to lack any sort of personality. He was written as a completely different character - personality and physically. I understand the concept of a novelization, and I'm glad I read it, but I think I'll stay with the films from that era from now on!
February 4, 2025
Sorry, I’m not going to be unbiased on this one. Short Circuit is my favorite movie. When I found out there was a novelization of it, combining my two favorite things–books and Short Circuit–I hit the ceiling. I’m sorry, it’s going to have to really try to be horrible to get me to dislike it. Like it’s going to have to have some scene where Number 5 says something anti-semitic.
I really do like novelizations of movies, even if I don’t read them anymore. Yeah, they can be cash tie-ins, but you get to see all the tiny little details you might miss in a 1/2 second shot. Yeah, the emotional impact is lessened but the immersion is increased. Plus novelizations usually include elements from the shooting script, which means deleted scenes (before we had DVDs for that).
For example, the construction of the robot is a little different. Instead of a grasshopper body, it’s stockier like a barrel, with three arms and an antenna. Instead of equalizer lights, it has a grill for its voice. And the faux-Indian guy Ben is called “Chigger”. No idea where that came from. Overall, it’s a fun and fast read, but ironically, the movie is better. It fixes all the problems involving pacing, humor, and likability.
I really do like novelizations of movies, even if I don’t read them anymore. Yeah, they can be cash tie-ins, but you get to see all the tiny little details you might miss in a 1/2 second shot. Yeah, the emotional impact is lessened but the immersion is increased. Plus novelizations usually include elements from the shooting script, which means deleted scenes (before we had DVDs for that).
For example, the construction of the robot is a little different. Instead of a grasshopper body, it’s stockier like a barrel, with three arms and an antenna. Instead of equalizer lights, it has a grill for its voice. And the faux-Indian guy Ben is called “Chigger”. No idea where that came from. Overall, it’s a fun and fast read, but ironically, the movie is better. It fixes all the problems involving pacing, humor, and likability.
July 12, 2013
This book brings back memories, it packs an adventurous read. There were extra parts throughout the story that is missing from the film, but that is to be expected. I would recommend!
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews