(Zero spoiler review) 3.25/5
Well, that was certainly a fall from grace of sorts. After the ball bustingly good opening salvo that was the oversized omnibus volume one, things go a little bit off the rails here. Losing sight of a great many things that made volume one so special. First off, the art. Darick Robertson is The Boys, just as much as Ennis is. The fact that his art encompassed almost the entire first volume, yet ew get precious little of it here goes a long way towards why this was a much less enjoyable read. I believe there were three, if not four alternative artists on this collection, so we got little in the way of consistency when it came to replacements either. None of them could hold a candle to Robertson, with their far more cartoonish style losing much in the way of storytelling ability. Robertson is a pro when it comes to subtlety and nuance in his artwork, having the characters tell the story as much as Ennis' words. All others failed to varying degrees at this. With character models fluctuating wildly, and quality in general resembling the yoyo of a kid after a gallon of red cordial. Russ Braun being the only one who came close to imitating Robertson' style. Why we couldn't have him do all the issues Robertson couldn't, I'll never know. But then again, why we couldn't just have Robertson... His issues were by the far the best collected here, and I refuse to believe it was simply cause Ennis brought his A game to those ones alone.
Story wise, we get an awful lot of wheel spinning here. The opening volume was tight, well plotted, well paced, and quite intriguing. Here, whilst certain plot threads are continued, its lost much of the allure, much of the appeal these storylines had initially. Mostly because the stories surrounding these ongoing threads aren't as interesting, and the better elements are tainted by association.
The 'edgy' elements here, much as I dislike that term, don't feel as organic as they did originally, and as a result, it comes across as trying just a little bit too hard. But then again, I really was quite dejected looking at the significant downgrade in art, so I imagine that did affect my enjoyment of thee stories maybe a tad more than they should. But the final arc, the Hughie spin off was a very bland and boring finish to an up and down collection. It might just have sneaked a higher 3, and thus four stars, but this last arc really was twice as long and twice as boring as it should have been.
Don't see myself rereading much of anything contained here, sadly. Hopefully volume three ups its game for a stronger finish, and we actually get a decent amount of Robertson art to go with it. I'm not holding my breath, though. 3.25/5
OmniBen.