I received this book through Goodreads First Reads, and I am grateful for the opportunity to read and review this book.
I have mixed feelings about this book, feeling intrigued and curious yet also a little confused and underwhelmed. The setting feels like a vibrant and fascinating world that stands out from other fantasy worlds, with the way the book presents unique facets like the soul energy, fake skin, and badges actually making me sort of see this as a fantasy take on the usually sci-fi cyberpunk mechanics.
The trouble I run into when reading the book is that while some of the elements are explained clearly, other things are left unexplained. Part of the appeal of an isekai character is that it gives narrative the opportunity to clarify things that are commonplace to people in that world but strange for readers. But with most characters keeping Harry in the dark on things for various reasons, or just assuming he knows things, we're left fumbling in the dark. Worse than that is the prologue - which, while still good, is entirely from the perspective of character from that world, meaning we get thrown a lot of various jargon that we can't easily decipher.
And I kind of feel that Harry's semi-amnesia also hinders the flow a little; if it's part of a larger plot that will become evident in later books, that's reasonable, but on the other hand, it limits the culture clash aspects that are really fun to explore in isekai stories like this. A lot of the time, Harry sort of questions local customs and technology, but since he lacks enough memories to frame a solid contrast in his mind, he then just sort of goes along with it and doesn't question it further. The world feels very distinctive from other fantasy worlds, and I liked the moments of culture clash we did encounter, so I kind of wish we could have seen more of that.
I think including a glossary of some kind would have alleviated the stress of confusion from readers. The map at the front page was very nice, but I would have liked some sort of appendix or two at the end. I know that we're advised to view the world lore glossaries on the website listed - and I strongly recommend checking them out; they're really cool - but this could pose an accessibility issue for people with limited access to the internet. Plus, the note about the website warns about spoilers, since the full lore on the site is updated with each new book; it would have been better to have a separate glossary from Harry's perspective in each book, with the information changing book-by-book as he learns more in successive books, so readers have a source for reference without risking spoilers from future novels.
Going back to the positive side, the colored illustrations throughout the book are great. They're not spectacular, but they're colorful and capture the scenes and setting well in a way that highlights the distinct flavor of this world. They make me think of the illustrations you can find in Japanese light novels, and I appreciate the art to further immerse us into the story.
However, I do think that the front cover, combined with the relatively vague summary on the back, proved rather misleading. The cover shows a scene from the prologue, with one of the two featured characters in the picture not actually having an active role past the prologue. Because of that, before reading the book I assumed that the isekai'ed main character was one of the two men on the cover, and that it would be a same-sex marriage between the two men. Instead, we appear to be moving toward a relationship between Harry and women such as the maid Eiri. I'm fine with either direction, but this shows how the choice of cover can drastically mislead readers.
In any case, while this book isn't perfect, it has created a unique world that draws me in. I want to learn more about this intrigue-filled world that Harry has gotten himself into, and I hope to read the following books in the near future. Thank you for creating this amazing world, and the stories to let us journey through it!