Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

My Boyfriend #1

Claiming My Boyfriend's Best Friend

Rate this book
Kenny dated Franky in college, so he knows exactly how good he is in bed.

But Franky’s off limits because he’s best friends with Kenny’s boyfriend.

That is, until one night when Franky invites himself over to Kenny’s apartment. The two end up on the couch, making up for lost time with desperate touches. Kenny feels pleasure spreading through his chest as Franky touches him. So far, their reunion is even better than he imagined, and he’s writhing under Franky’s passionate caresses.

But it’s then that Franky tells him he wants to bottom.

Kenny is a skinny twink without a lot of experience, but he’s ready to put his back into it. Soon Franky is shivering with pleasure, begging for more.

The only problem is that Kenny’s boyfriend is asleep in the next room. Will they get away with it?

This is a 5k word male/male erotica featuring: exes who are neighbors, a boyfriend asleep in the next room, a couch, a twink topping, and witty one-liners. It’s sexy with a side of comedy.

This story was previously published as “Claiming My Boyfriend’s Ex.” It has been edited to remove water and add steam.

26 pages, Kindle Edition

First published June 4, 2022

54 people are currently reading
109 people want to read

About the author

Cara Cumberland

4 books3 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
30 (15%)
4 stars
30 (15%)
3 stars
70 (35%)
2 stars
57 (28%)
1 star
12 (6%)
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews
Profile Image for Brooke.
872 reviews596 followers
January 17, 2025
[TBH, I completely forgot I read this and forgot about the review.]

⭐️ 2 stars ⭐️

“You can watch next time, if you want.”


A weird and a bit confusing — Kenny fucks his ex who is also his current boyfriend’s best friend, and his current boyfriend is into it? Did this turn into a throuple situation? I don’t know.
It was kinda hot, but not the best.

CW and tropes (spoilers):
- Boyfriend’s best friend
- Vers MCs?
- Cheating/cuckholding
Profile Image for Laura (lady_h_reads).
837 reviews349 followers
October 19, 2022
Short and Spicy

Really not much to this short than s3x and more s3x, but it is erotica, so that’s what you expect and this provided. As far as the actual scenes go, I have read smuttier depictions, but these are still pretty hot.
Profile Image for fishreads (back? from hiatus).
669 reviews20 followers
January 5, 2023
(1,5 stars) Short erotica story about cuckolding.

Kenny wants to bang Franky, his ex from ten years ago, who just happens to be Kenny's boyfriend's best friend and living in the apartment next door. Franky is all for the idea of banging Kenny and comes on to Kenny one night while Kenny's boyfriend is asleep drunk in their bedroom.

Neither Kenny nor Franky were particularly likable characters.

You cheated on me and I leaked your nudes on Facebook.

Don't be fooled by the following dialogue because neither of them look like they've changed at all.

"Would you ever let me paint you again?" Kenny asked from the kitchen.
"I don't see why not."
"How about, because last time let to a stupid love affair that alsmost got me kicked out of college."
"That was ten years ago, you've changed."
"You think so?"


Kenny is living in an apartment his parents are paying for, wearing designer clothes that his parents are probably also paying for. And Franky is working as "a model" but actually mooching of Kenny and his boyfriend. They've been exes for ten years which means they have to be in their late twenties or early thirties and they're still behaving as infantile as their childish names suggest.

I assumed this wasn't the author's goal but maybe I am wrong because if they wrote this story intending to portray the most annoying unlikable characters they've more succeeded at it. Because as far as erotica goes this story wasn't particularly erotic at all.

Also who the hell in their right mind would secretly lust after his cheating ex for over ten years. Only Kenny, that's who.

Themes: single POV, boyfriend's best friend (but actually main character's cheating ex), infidelity, cuckolding
Profile Image for Dan.
3,718 reviews650 followers
March 9, 2025
“Is it wrong that I’m turned on by cucking my boyfriend?”
“You wanna wake him up and ask him to watch?”



Set in Los Angeles, California.

Franky, Kenny’s ex-boyfriend, is a model. He also lives next door to Kenny, who is presently dating Magnus.

Magnus and Franky have become best bros…and spend way too much time on Instagram.

“I don’t think you’re over me.”

Franky wears grey sweatpants like a weapon. 💀

Turns out, their acrimonious breakup (back in art school) was ten years ago.

He usually deserved it; he was a menace in his twenties.

Kenny is a blonde 5’7” twink. He loves designer clothes. And has a passion for interior design.

Franky is a musclebound stud at 6’.

“Kenny, think about it. It could be good for us.”

Good detail. Thorough preparation. Anatomy and physiology are strong.

Some weirdness at the end with Magnus. He and Kenny don’t vibe as well as Franky and Kenny do.

Kenny’s concerns for the furniture, and for their clothing, while in the throes, are hilarious.

Bonus points for a unique take on the situation, as well as Kenny’s inner monologues. Deductions for inappropriate condom usage, as evidenced by the following books in this series.

Kinda weird, but also fun.


“I wish I’d been in there with you guys.”
“You can watch next time, if you want.”
Profile Image for LGO.
482 reviews
August 10, 2023
Aunque no me gustan las historias de infidelidad, debo admitir que esta historia erótica corta donde Kenny se enrolla con su exnovio Franky (que resulta ser su vecino y mejor amigo de su novio) mientras su novio duerme en la habitación de al lado tras una noche de borrachera me ha parecido muy caliente. Da lo que promete, es sexy. Se me ha hecho corta y me ha dejado con ganas de leer su continuación. Lo único que diría es que los dos nombres se me parecían tanto que a veces tenía que releer para ver quién era quién.

#M-M-romance
Profile Image for RomanceIsMyJam.
516 reviews
September 22, 2022
Well it was okay enough for me to want to see where this went in book 2. And I did and I left a review for it over there. This story is only 24 pages. It focuses on Kenny and his ex Franky. Book 2 is Franky and Magnus and a brief bit of Kenny.
The story needs to be long so there is more character development.
Profile Image for Monika .
2,349 reviews39 followers
Read
June 28, 2022

I'm not going to rate this because that was both confusing and bizarre. Just 24 pages and I was lost through pretty much all of it, which btw was really nothing but sex. There needed to be way more content than just sex and a clearer picture of who was who.
Profile Image for Maureen.
3,787 reviews39 followers
July 15, 2022
A hot short that ended suddenly, two in a row for me, but I quickly found out there's a part two, which I'm going to right now, hopefully it's as hot and sexy as this one as these three men get into it
Profile Image for Melissa.
1,959 reviews3 followers
July 2, 2023
Not sure what to think

Not real sure what to think of this very short sex book. I don't have enough words .. It was kind of hot but the lack of substance cannot be covered with banging.
17 reviews
September 11, 2023
Definitely leaves you wanting more

Oh it’s a mediocre book. It’s not bad but probably only worth $.99. It’s short and very little as far as character development.
Profile Image for Diane Schroeder.
177 reviews15 followers
January 2, 2025
What a h0t ride…

I can’t say that I’ve read very much MM but this was a sp1cy little number and that surprise ending?!? Wow.
1,588 reviews5 followers
June 29, 2022
😍😍😍😍

A good start to a good series!!!! Left it just right at the end!!! I can't wait for more!!! On to the next
Profile Image for anneke.
193 reviews7 followers
September 12, 2022
horrible isn't enough to describe how tragic this book was. i was confused, and wouldn't wish this book upon my enemies.
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.