Đánh đấm trùm trường các kiểu, mình không thích cách truyện diễn ra, thực sự là mình không thích cái kiểu nhóm bạn của Haruka, tâm lý của mấy việc mà mấy nhân vật này làm đơn giản chỉ là bốc đồng tuổi trẻ.
Mình thích nhân vật Haruka vì dễ thương, và Haruka trông giống một nhân vật trong bộ manga khác mà mình thích.
Mình cũng không quá thích mối quan hệ giữa Haruka và Narumi, đó là tình thầy trò - thay đổi những điều xấu và mang tới những sự thay đổi tốt đẹp, nhưng mình vẫn thấy có gì đó không hợp với mình (mình cũng không mong đợi tình yêu gì giữa hai nhân vật). Tâm lý của thầy Narumi làm mình thấy mơ hồ thiệt á. Được cái là truyện dễ thương và hước.
[review written for the french website Manga Sanctuary]
How to write a healthy relationship from the « teacher-student » trope ? Don't flee so soon, if the challenge looks impossible, it's not for Nayuta Nago. First, during all the story, Narumi acts the only reasonable way towards a student's flirting with him : keeping his distances, even if Shirakawa ruses to get closer. Second, both are legal and if it isn't enough, there's no relationship at all until Shirakawa is done with school. Finally... it's fiction, and if the idea makes you that incomfortable, there are plenty other BL more suited for you. You'd miss a great story, but not everyone has the same tastes after all.
You probably got it, it's a veeeeryyyy SLOW slow-burn romance. Narumi takes ages to realise his feelings. Shirakawa is a bit faster, but it's still funny to see him gradually understand if he likes spending time with his teacher, it's not for admiring his fighting skills. Indeeed, there are a few fights, greatly drawn and dynamic. It's not what we're here for, but it's well-done. As are some nonsensical situations. Maybe you won't laugh, but I guarantee you'll smile. Wildely. Shirakawa's bright mood and carefree attitude are contagious. It's not a feel-good book, but almost. Light, sweet, with just enough uncertainties to fear a little for them.
I spoker earlier about how good the fights visually are, but emotions, too, are well-rendered. Shirakawa is super-expressive, while Narumi... a lot less. It's obviously on purpose and matches the character's traits. The artstyle is gorgeous and precise. Though, there could have been more backgrounds, but their absence in not that noticeable.
If you're looking for stories with sex and darker themes, this in not the book you want. But if, on the opposite, you want a contemporary sometimes a bit silly with and endearing and determined protagonist, go for it, you won't regret it !
J’ai adoré 😭, enfin une histoire prof/étudiant où je ne trouve rien à redire ! L’histoire était si cute et les dessins étaient sublimes.
Premièrement, parlons de Shirakawa qui était pour moi un protagoniste avec une personnalité tellement unique ! Au premier abord (quand j'ai vu la couverture), je pensais que ce serait un délinquant lambda au sang chaud. Mais en faîte c'était quelqu'un de super cute, qui agit selon ce qu'il ressent sur le moment et qui est tombé in love de Narumi.
Ensuite, pour parler de Narumi, déjà il était magnifique ! (Je pense que sa beauté était d'autant plus accentuée qu'on le voyait sous le prisme de Shirakawa). Ce que j'ai beaucoup aimé par rapport à lui c'est qu'il a quand même mis des barrières et qu'il a repoussé Shirakawa autant qu'il pouvait. (Et ça ne devait certainement pas être facile parce qu'il était beaucoup trop cute !)
Concernant leur relation, j'étais très contente de découvrir un Shirakawa dans la retenue dès l'instant où Narumi lui dit que le consentement a son importance et qu'il ne doit rien entreprendre vis-à-vis de lui qui ne soit pas consentis. De plus, l'évolution de leur relation se fait naturellement et reste plus ou moins platonique jusqu'à ce qu'il ne soit plus son élève et même un an de plus. Et à la fin j'étais juste beaucoup trop heureuse pour eux. Et c'est certainement une histoire que je relirai !
D'un point de vu général, par rapport aux histoires prof/élèves, c'est un genre que j'apprécie beaucoup. La plupart des gens voient ça d'un mauvais œil à cause de la différence d'âge et de la supériorité d'une des deux personnes. Mais pour moi, si ce n'est pas malsain et qu'il y a de vraies sentiments (et qu'ils attendent la majorité de la personne mineure) alors je ne vois pas le problème. Et cette histoire ci était un très bel exemple du genre extrêmement bien exécutée
Bref, « Le rossignol rêve aussi de printemps » est un Boy’s Love dynamique et entraînant. Le coup de crayon de la mangaka est parfaitement maîtrisé, notamment dans les scènes de bagarre et de sexe où le faciès de nos héros est expressif. J’ai adoré Narumi et Shirakawa, le premier pour sa classe constante et la discipline qu’il essaye d’instaurer autant chez lui que chez son élève. Le deuxième, pour son dévouement et les multiples émotions par lequel il passe tout au long du mangas. Il rigole peut-être à tout bout de champs mais il a les pieds sur terre et a conscience de ses capacités. A eux deux, ils forment un très bon duo où l’ascendance passe de l’un à l’autre en fonction des circonstances. J’ai passé un bon moment et je lirai probablement les œuvres futures de la mangaka.
Tbh, I love the art. I love mean looking character design. But the story itself is kinda weak. And student teacher relationships give me the ick. It's the power dynamic. Nothing sexual happens until the student graduates....but it still crosses lines for me. But I love the art so much. This is when I know I have problems...when something is visually my style, I tend to overlook problems with the story.
Ok this was just really cute, I kinda just wanted to see what else this author has made and this cover really caught my attention. I really liked how it was the student pursuing, and that he does back off when a boundary is set. Best of all the fact that the real romance only starts serious after he graduates, and eve than they wait a year!
Art màu rõ gu, nội dung thì bình thường, thêm đám bạn dở hơi. Điểm cộng là uke vẫn tỉnh táo, biết rõ thân phận của mình khó xử ntn. Nhưng nói chung đọc vẫn hơi hụt hẫng so vs cái art bìa, hic 🙄
Haruka couldn't care less about being the top fighter of his school, but his friends sure do. When he reaches the top, his friends push him to fight the legendary undefeated top fighter, Narumi, who just so happens to be Haruka's new classic literature teacher. Haruka reluctantly challenges Narumi to a fight after his friends threaten to make him eat alone, but Narumi refuses, of course, because a teacher can't fight his student. However after seeing a video of Narumi fighting, something sparks in Haruka and he becomes way more persistent in his pursuits to fight Narumi, but maybe his feelings are more than just wanting to fight?
This was so cute! I thoroughly enjoyed it . Nago Nayuta's works tend to be very hit or miss for me, but this one was definitely a hit. I want more tbh. This is a student/teacher romance, so if you're not into that probably skip. However, I think the way it was handled was pretty good. They don't actually get together until after Haruka graduates. The relationship itself made me kind of overlook a lot. Also Haruka is just so cute?? All the cute chibi faces!! I love. I loved Narumi's more serious personality as well and there were a few moments that made me laugh. This was overall a fun and cute read and I enjoyed it.