This was just okay. I love sapphic YA books, and have read a lot this year, but I think this was a case of me not being the right audience for this book. I normally read contemporary YA, because it lets me reminisce or pulls at my heartstrings because it can be very emotional. While many things change over the years, there are lots of young adult experiences that stay the same so even as adults we can still relate. However, in this case I felt like this book was really geared to someone much younger than I, and that it dealt with too many things I could not relate too. This book at times seemed a little too stereotypical Gen Y, like all kids care about are posting thirst traps and being TikTok famous. The story was very readable and didn’t drag, but it was not a book for me.
To the right audience this could be a very different experience so I will use this review to only mention what the biggest issues were for me. Things didn’t start off well with this being third person but only one POV. The more I read books written like this the more I dislike this set-up. And even more unfortunate is that I did not like the one main character who’s one POV we are in. “Billie in the sheets”, I felt like I was reading about a 16 year-old-boy and not an 18 year-old girl. She was super immature and was girl-crazy to a point that kept making me roll my eyes. I could not connect with her at all, and I didn’t get what her redeeming qualities were. She’s tough and cute so I guess that’s why she gets a pass most of the time for being an asshole. Well that doesn’t work on me and while I wanted to root for her character growth, it seemed too little, too late.
The biggest bright spot of the book for me was theater girl Lois. Her character was very likeable, thank goodness, but I thought the book could have used more time with her. There were too many distractions and time spent on other characters like June, Erin, and Crystal who didn’t add anything to the story for me. I did yell at the book “Lois, you deserve better!” multiple times, but at least I was able to root for her.
TLDR: This book was not for me and I mean that in the way that I think I’m not the right audience. Normally I love YA, but I think this was geared to someone younger who could connect to things that I just could not. I had big issues with the main character Billie, but thankfully Lois saved the book. Since this book wasn’t for me, I would suggest checking out other reviews because someone could have a completely different reading experience than I had.
An ARC was given to me for a review.