I had been longing to read Broda Barnes’s book “Hypothyroidism: The Unsuspected Illness” for so long. But here it is in my hands now. I have finally managed to read it. And I have to say it is a memorable book.
It came out in 1976 after Dr. Barnes had been treating patients for several decades - and taking thyroid hormone himself. In his book he has gathered his knowledge and experience and presented it in a way that is quite easy to understand. The book was obviously intended for thyroid patients, but also, I think, for other doctors who might have been skeptical of his methods. I do hope more doctors read it and decide to at least put Dr. Barnes’s teachings to the test in their own patients. The world certainly needs more doctors like him. And thyroid patients need his approach.
Here is a list of some of his merits:
- he diagnosed his patients by having them take their basal temperature – a test that was both readily available, non-invasive, cheap and could be performed at home by the patients themselves. Besides, it showed how their metabolism was working – something that blood tests quite often fail to do. He also took into account the patients’ symptoms – something that most doctors don’t do nowadays and it’s really a shame, because they basically miss most cases of hypothyroidism, while the patients continue to suffer needlessly;
- he prescribed combined thyroid therapy, i.e. both T4 and T3. To most of his patients he prescribed desiccated thyroid – this is not the treatment of choice nowadays;
- he was aware of the numerous conditions that thyroid disease could manifest as – all kinds of menstrual disturbances, susceptibility to infections, migraines, skin disorders, arthritis, hypertension, heart attacks, the complications of diabetes, emphysema and lung cancer. Most of them are never associated with thyroid disease nowadays and are treated in various different ways, with other medications and/or surgery, when thyroid therapy in the right form and dosage could easily do the trick in many cases.
I think Dr. Barnes’s book should be read together with Dr. Mark Starr’s, the two definitely complement each other. Dr. Starr based his on Dr. Barnes’s teachings. Both books are extremely valuable.