This is a beautiful, richly illustrated book with lots of great information on Loades' modern approach to cottage gardens. That said, it wasn't a perfect fit for me. I love cottage gardens and it's a style I use in my own gardens. There were things I liked about this book and some areas that fell short for me. Goodreads says 3 stars represents "liked it," which is where I fall.
The goods -- Gorgeous photos are used throughout. The author talks about container gardens, small gardens and other variations. He gives lots of tips and a nice history of cottage gardens. The section on 50 must-have plants was nice with photos and profiles. He focuses on the garden in the off seasons too, like winter. He modernizes the idea in a way that will speak to many.
The not so good -- Most of the gardens featured seemed like massive, full time jobs to tend. The aesthetic didn't really strike me as cottage garden anymore, with lots of succulents and nontraditional plants. He tends to recommend having many different modern perennials so you always have flowers, but the end result felt overwhelming to me as a gardener. My garden is a small part of a really busy life as a homesteading, work at home, homeschooling mother of five with large vegetable gardens and quite a lot of household tasks and projects that take up my time. There are also no garden zones given for the recommended plants, which left me not knowing if any of the plants would survive my zone 4 Minnesota garden other than the ones I already grow. The gardens all looked rather well manicured and were mostly just modern hybrid flowers, even though he points out that original cottage gardens were working gardens with a wonderful mix of veggies, herbs, roses and flowers. Also, I just missed the look of the cottage gardens I love -- hollyhocks, shrub roses, elderflowers, etc. with that old fashioned charm.
I'm sure this will be a well loved book by many gardeners. It wasn't very helpful for me, but it will be especially helpful for British gardeners and those with the time and money to create this kind of beautiful garden.
I read a temporary digital ARC of this book for the purpose of review.