This novel is tricky to review because of fear of revealing spoilers. So many things happen in this novel that I can’t discuss, so bear with me. I initially loved Libby, but as I watched her grow and mature throughout the novel I came to realize how immature she was in the beginning. For a woman in her early 30’s, she was traveling around and enjoying Positano for the summer without much responsibility.
I liked Luca at first and then fell in love with him. He was sexy, charming, sweet, loving, and so on. Did I love him the entire novel? No, I didn’t, but I didn’t hate him either.
Angus and Jules flip-flopped for me. I hated him initially and loved her. Then that all changed. Regardless, I felt that most characters were well-developed and not overly simple or overly complex. Libby’s sister Helen aggravated me to no end. She broke up with a guy, returned to her typical state of depression, moved to another country, continued to be depressed, came home. What was at the center of all this depression? her desire to have a man and a baby. Helen just seemed very shallow and uninteresting to me as she was completely unable to find any happiness without a man.
There are so many subplots and underlying themes to this novel, but to me, it mostly embodies love, trust, taking risks, and moving on from disappointment and hurt. Libby went through a lot of things in this novel, some that were devastating. However, she picked herself up and created a new life that gave her happiness. Like her sister, I felt that she was a little too man-dependent, although she frequently reminded herself not to be. But I’ve tried to look at it in more of a romantic, soulmates way, rather than her needing a man to be happy.
It Was Always You is my second time reading Georgie Capron and I admit that I am addicted to her stories and her writing. This novel did not turn out at all as I thought it would, but I adored the story, especially all of the surprises and twists. With her descriptions of Italy, prepare to have severe wanderlust after reading this one. Lover’s of women’s fiction and romance, this should go on your TBR!
*Thanks to NetGalley and Aria for providing this ARC in exchange for my honest review!
PRE-ORDER IT WAS ALWAYS YOU ON AMAZON!