The story opens with Barribel MacDonald, a girl of nineteen, almost a prisoner in her grandmother's house. She has been kept in ignorance of her parents, whom she has never seen. She knows that her father is dead. The attic of the old house has always been a place of alluring mystery from which she has been carefully excluded and when one day she slips in, she learns the truth. That night, after being sent to her room as a punishment, she rolls what little treasures she has into a bundle and sets out for London.
It is the story of her adventures which the Williamsons tell in "The Heather Moon." The charm of the Scottish countryside runs through all the pages and there is a very interesting love story which unfolds under the skilful touch of these two popular writers.
Ah, this one gobbled me up and didn't let me go until the end! It is headed straight for my favorites shelf. If the Williamsons hadn't been favorite authors before this book, they certainly would be now. I stayed up until midnight to finish, and I hadn't the heart to resent the 6am alarm this morning because I enjoyed it so much.
Barrie is a young girl of eighteen whose grandmother has kept her extremely sheltered, even from most neighbors. At last she gains entrance to the locked garret and finds all sorts of odd things, resulting in her finding out that her mother is still alive and working as an actress. She quietly resolves to leave the house and go to her mother, and does so that very night. She is attempting to gain a ticket to go to London when she gains the attention of a passing gentleman, Ian Somerled, a painter who has made his own fortune.
Somerled takes her under his wing and into his motor-car, bringing her to a lady friend of his to stay in safety until they find out where her mother actually is. Turns out the lady is about to begin a play in Ediburgh, but is on holiday at the moment; so there is a week that Barrie must wait to go to her mother. It is spent in a motor-car touring through southern Scotland, especially the Border country so famous in literature. Even so, this section of the book is shorter than many of the other Williamson travelogue fiction I've enjoyed in the past.
There are many references to history and to literature in the things they see. There are descriptions of fabled castles, identification of the real that inspired the fictitious scenes, and thoughts about the authors that wrote of them. Authors mentioned include Burns, Carlyle, Scott, and S.R. Crockett—the latter a pleasant surprise, for he is mostly forgotten today, but is one of my favorite authors. Indeed, I'd actually pulled out my copy of "The Raiders" the night before I began reading this book, so it was fascinating to read the story of its scenery in a book that was just ahead of it in my immediate To-Read stack! Of course I am reading it next.
The book builds to a nail-biting climax for Barrie, and just saves itself for a good ending at the absolute last moment. You won't be able to put it down!
Pleasant enough fare from the Williamsons, but I still prefer Set in Silver, as well as a couple of their others. The girl in this one is a bit too disingenuous... eight different men fall in love with her (I kid you not), most of them propose in succession during a single afternoon, and she's still quite unaware of her perfect beauty and irresistible charm! She also falls into the "trap" of immediately believing the sob story that her jealous rival feeds her towards the end. I get a little frustrated with people being dense for no other reason than to make the book last longer. Also, EIGHT MEN?!!!??? Give me a break. These kind of statistics do not make me feel like the heroine needs my sympathetic interest. She'll be fine. Perhaps this is catty of me. :P
Also, unfortunately her hero never quite feels fleshed out, he's a bit distant.
But because I'm fond of the Williamsons' awesome genre of 1900s road trip romances, and this one had its good moments, I'm still giving it three stars.
Read Set in Silver first if you've never read these authors!!!!!
Two major flaws- This book was full of a LOT of descriptions of places and historical facts. About halfway through I started just skimming the huge chunks of flowery text. And, the main character is SO naive and obtuse. It’s like the song “She don’t know she’s beautiful” come to life. I have a hard time believing that this book was written by a woman, as unrealistic as Barry is. I am giving it two stars because I did really care about how the story turned out, and I enjoyed how she told it from different characters’ perspectives.
I devoured this book as a teen in one reading. It is full of beautiful description of Scotland and literary references tied to specific Scottish locations. The travelogue-story was fascinating though unrealistic. Like, hilariously absurd.
Content-wise clean. Some literary and educational value (if you're interested in Scotland). I would not recommend for immature readers though, because of the adult dynamics. For example, the 18 year old heroine makes a runaway escape from her grandmother- possibly justifiably, but her rebellious attitude is put in a positive or exciting light.