What do you think?
Rate this book
Pourquoi les Juifs ?
" Soixante-quinze ans après la Shoah, qui décima un peuple plusieurs fois millénaire dont je me réclame, après qu'on a juré d'une voix presque unanime "Plus jamais ça', ce "ça' envahit à nouveau nos trottoirs. En particulier dans l'Europe de l'Ouest, dont la France, patrie des droits de l'homme. Pourquoi toujours les juifs ? "
Cet essai d'une sobriété percutante passe en revue tous les faux procès faits aux juifs – religieux ou non – au cours des périodes troublées de l'Histoire. Seront-ils encore les boucs émissaires d'une société sans rêves ni prophètes qui, après avoir mis en danger la Terre, ne parvient toujours pas à se libérer de la peur ?
- GenresHistory
120 pages, Paperback
Published January 16, 2020
6 people are currently reading
66 people want to read
About the author
Marek Halter
81 books180 followersMarek Halter was born in Poland in 1936. During World War II, he and his parents narrowly escaped from the Warsaw ghetto. After a time in Russia and Uzbekistan, they emigrated to France in 1950. There Halter studied pantomime with Marcel Marceau and embarked on a career as a painter that led to several international exhibitions. In 1967, he founded the International Committee for a Negotiated Peace Agreement in the Near East and played a crucial role in the organization of the first official meetings between Palestinians and Israelis.
In the 1970s, Marek Halter turned to writing. He first published The Madman and the Kings, which was awarded the Prix Aujourd’hui in 1976. He is also the author of several internationally acclaimed, bestselling historical novels, including The Messiah, The Mysteries of Jerusalem, The Book of Abraham, which won the Prix du Livre Inter, and Sarah, the first of the Canaan trilogy, and Lilah, the concluding one.
In the 1970s, Marek Halter turned to writing. He first published The Madman and the Kings, which was awarded the Prix Aujourd’hui in 1976. He is also the author of several internationally acclaimed, bestselling historical novels, including The Messiah, The Mysteries of Jerusalem, The Book of Abraham, which won the Prix du Livre Inter, and Sarah, the first of the Canaan trilogy, and Lilah, the concluding one.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
January 17, 2021
For more reviews and bookish posts visit: https://www.ManOfLaBook.com
Why the Jews?: The Need to Scapegoat by Marek Halter (translated by Grace McQuillan) is a collection of short essays examining the titled question. Mr. Halter is a French citizen born in Poland, he is the founder of the International Committee for a Negotiated Peace Agreement in the Near East and played a crucial role in the organization of the first official meetings between Palestinians and Israelis.
This book is short, but thought provoking. The question of “why the Jews?” has been asked for centuries without a good answer other than racism, probably because there isn’t one. As is tradition in the Jewish religion the book asks a lot of poignant, hard hitting questions but gives very few answers.
Why the Jews?: The Need to Scapegoat by Marek Halter, might not have many answers, but it does make you think.
Anti-Semitism is on the rise, again, in Europe and the United States (not a surprise for many, including the author I’m sure), and in these essays Mr. Halter tries to deconstruct several preconceived prejudices about the Jews and all the perceived evils they are responsible for. Many of these notions, of course, do not pass the “laugh test” for any person with a drop of critical thinking skills. Throughout his lifelong journey, the author recounts of meetings he had with many famous thinkers including David Ben Gurion and Jean-Paul Sartre, who both had some insight, but – again – no answers.
Mr. Halter tries to understand and investigate where the hatred towards Jews comes from. He goes back very far to do so, even trying to get an explanation by examining the behavior of Moses and the Ten Commandments, an interesting exercise, but a futile one. I, for one, think that trying to explain hatred and anti-Semitism by delving into, or blaming, religious texts is, frankly, a bit lazy. For generations the haters used religious nonsense to justify their pre-existing, or learned, notions. Deep down, however, even they knew its ridiculous drivel, at best, speaking only to weak minded losers trying to blame their own incompetence and bad decisions on others.
I appreciated the tone of the book, more investigative than preachy, which servers it well. Great job by translator Grace McQuillan who managed to keep the tone throughout on this difficult subject . I thought the author’s conclusion was on point, and probably the best one could hope for.
Ironically it comes from Pope John Paull II: “Do not be afraid!”
Why the Jews?: The Need to Scapegoat by Marek Halter (translated by Grace McQuillan) is a collection of short essays examining the titled question. Mr. Halter is a French citizen born in Poland, he is the founder of the International Committee for a Negotiated Peace Agreement in the Near East and played a crucial role in the organization of the first official meetings between Palestinians and Israelis.
This book is short, but thought provoking. The question of “why the Jews?” has been asked for centuries without a good answer other than racism, probably because there isn’t one. As is tradition in the Jewish religion the book asks a lot of poignant, hard hitting questions but gives very few answers.
Why the Jews?: The Need to Scapegoat by Marek Halter, might not have many answers, but it does make you think.
Anti-Semitism is on the rise, again, in Europe and the United States (not a surprise for many, including the author I’m sure), and in these essays Mr. Halter tries to deconstruct several preconceived prejudices about the Jews and all the perceived evils they are responsible for. Many of these notions, of course, do not pass the “laugh test” for any person with a drop of critical thinking skills. Throughout his lifelong journey, the author recounts of meetings he had with many famous thinkers including David Ben Gurion and Jean-Paul Sartre, who both had some insight, but – again – no answers.
Mr. Halter tries to understand and investigate where the hatred towards Jews comes from. He goes back very far to do so, even trying to get an explanation by examining the behavior of Moses and the Ten Commandments, an interesting exercise, but a futile one. I, for one, think that trying to explain hatred and anti-Semitism by delving into, or blaming, religious texts is, frankly, a bit lazy. For generations the haters used religious nonsense to justify their pre-existing, or learned, notions. Deep down, however, even they knew its ridiculous drivel, at best, speaking only to weak minded losers trying to blame their own incompetence and bad decisions on others.
I appreciated the tone of the book, more investigative than preachy, which servers it well. Great job by translator Grace McQuillan who managed to keep the tone throughout on this difficult subject . I thought the author’s conclusion was on point, and probably the best one could hope for.
Ironically it comes from Pope John Paull II: “Do not be afraid!”
February 16, 2021
ARC received in exchange for a review.
An interesting book which packs a lot of ideas into its short page count. I'm not sure I can agree with where Halter ultimately lands in his attempt to answer the question posed in the title; it seems to rely a little too heavily on the general public understanding more about Judaism and Jewishness than I think the majority of us actually do (Halter places a lot of emphasis on the story of Moses and the Ten Commandments) but I think it's a question which is really ultimately unanswerable anyway, so the fact that I don't necessarily agree with the conclusion isn't altogether surprising; I'm not sure there's any conclusion any of us can realistically agree on entirely.
Although I expected a more direct attempt to engage with the question of the book's title, a good third of the book turned out to be a historicising of the writing of the Ten Commandments rather than grappling with the question at hand. Halter clearly has an impressive breadth of ideas and influences, evidenced by the numerous philosophers and theorists he quotes from (Durkheim works particularly well here with his theory of scapegoating) and I feel like perhaps this book would have worked better if Halter had the space to go off on the tangents he evidently enjoys, and which are often ideologically fruitful. In a short work like this, it sometimes felt more as though the tangents evaded the central thesis.
As I say, it was an interesting book, but not necessarily one I feel gave me as much insight as I expected.
An interesting book which packs a lot of ideas into its short page count. I'm not sure I can agree with where Halter ultimately lands in his attempt to answer the question posed in the title; it seems to rely a little too heavily on the general public understanding more about Judaism and Jewishness than I think the majority of us actually do (Halter places a lot of emphasis on the story of Moses and the Ten Commandments) but I think it's a question which is really ultimately unanswerable anyway, so the fact that I don't necessarily agree with the conclusion isn't altogether surprising; I'm not sure there's any conclusion any of us can realistically agree on entirely.
Although I expected a more direct attempt to engage with the question of the book's title, a good third of the book turned out to be a historicising of the writing of the Ten Commandments rather than grappling with the question at hand. Halter clearly has an impressive breadth of ideas and influences, evidenced by the numerous philosophers and theorists he quotes from (Durkheim works particularly well here with his theory of scapegoating) and I feel like perhaps this book would have worked better if Halter had the space to go off on the tangents he evidently enjoys, and which are often ideologically fruitful. In a short work like this, it sometimes felt more as though the tangents evaded the central thesis.
As I say, it was an interesting book, but not necessarily one I feel gave me as much insight as I expected.
March 28, 2021
This book is thought provoking. To read it around the time of Passover when there have been so many outbreaks of anti-semitism in recent years both from the far right and the far left, is timely. Many of the witnesses to the Holocaust are gone. For a brief time, in my childhood, not long after WW II, the shock and horror of what was perpetrated silenced many voices, although anti-semitism was pernicious but less obvious. Hatred of Jews is different from racism. Whereas racism is hatred against people who look and act differently to you, the Jews around the world do not look too dissimilar and for many, they have integrated and assimilated into the cultures of the countries in which they live.
The book examines why Jews have suffered from pervasive hatred throughout history. Why have they, time and again, been the handy scapegoats for whatever is perceived wrong with society. It is well documented and considered and while nothing can truly explain why so often in history, attempts have been made to eradicate a people whose identity nevertheless has survived for thousand upon thousands of years.
I have sincere doubt that anything in this book will dissuade a hater from hating. Nor will it eliminate the lies and the vitriol. What it will do, to those whose minds are open, is provide food for thought.. It seeks answers where there are none and continues to ask the question- why the Jews.
Five purrs and two paws up.
The book examines why Jews have suffered from pervasive hatred throughout history. Why have they, time and again, been the handy scapegoats for whatever is perceived wrong with society. It is well documented and considered and while nothing can truly explain why so often in history, attempts have been made to eradicate a people whose identity nevertheless has survived for thousand upon thousands of years.
I have sincere doubt that anything in this book will dissuade a hater from hating. Nor will it eliminate the lies and the vitriol. What it will do, to those whose minds are open, is provide food for thought.. It seeks answers where there are none and continues to ask the question- why the Jews.
Five purrs and two paws up.
January 5, 2021
I've read a lot of books in the past year about Judaism and the struggles the Jewish people have been through since recorded history. What made this one unique, in my opinion, is that it is filled with memories and events of the author's life as well as some generally good information on antisemitism and the problems that it is still creating for society at large, and for the Jewish people specifically.
The author does not shy away from the truth, that this is still happening, that Jews are still targets and that now Israel gives some people another reason to make judgements against Jewish peope. With all of the upheaval over equality that society has faced in the last year, I think it is important that we continue to publish and support books with clear mesages against hatred. That is what this book does, and does it well.
My only critical comment of this work, is that I felt there was so much more that could have and should have been said. It was too short, although there was no wasted space and no extra words just for lengthening the manuscript, and that was nice, it could have covered more ground comfortably.
Still, if you have a moment or two, and you want to spend it reading, please consider this book. It may surprise you.
This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher, provided by Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
The author does not shy away from the truth, that this is still happening, that Jews are still targets and that now Israel gives some people another reason to make judgements against Jewish peope. With all of the upheaval over equality that society has faced in the last year, I think it is important that we continue to publish and support books with clear mesages against hatred. That is what this book does, and does it well.
My only critical comment of this work, is that I felt there was so much more that could have and should have been said. It was too short, although there was no wasted space and no extra words just for lengthening the manuscript, and that was nice, it could have covered more ground comfortably.
Still, if you have a moment or two, and you want to spend it reading, please consider this book. It may surprise you.
This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher, provided by Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
December 7, 2020
This of course is the 4000 year-old question. Based on Halter's book it has to do with people's perception of the "Jew" as the other, the easily defined as not one of "us". Usually accused of not being part of the "homeland" and most likely just passing through to somewhere else ever if that means staying for three or four generations.
His biggest question is related to understanding that the religion and the people are bounded by a promise by the Lord as being a chosen people and ruled by the Ten Commandments, which are seen as above all other laws. Probably the biggest problem has always been the belief by non-jews that the idea that 'chosen' means 'better' than others. Few Jews believe this way, most believe that they are just like any other ethnic or religious group like the Mormons/LDS, but the denial of the divinity of Jesus is a BIG sticking point.
My belief is that until we me another species of extraterrestrials, when it becomes us vs them, little is going to change.
His biggest question is related to understanding that the religion and the people are bounded by a promise by the Lord as being a chosen people and ruled by the Ten Commandments, which are seen as above all other laws. Probably the biggest problem has always been the belief by non-jews that the idea that 'chosen' means 'better' than others. Few Jews believe this way, most believe that they are just like any other ethnic or religious group like the Mormons/LDS, but the denial of the divinity of Jesus is a BIG sticking point.
My belief is that until we me another species of extraterrestrials, when it becomes us vs them, little is going to change.
January 7, 2021
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and all opinions are my own. thanks to NG and the publisher for this opportunity.
I found this book interested since the title is an age old question and one I truly didn't understand. I'm not sure i understand it a whole lot better after reading this and not sure i can subscribe to the author's rationale. however it is an interesting read, made more so due to the author's inclusion of his own experiences with anti-semitism. I think i might have been looking for more in the world's history...but this was thought provoking. The fact that anti-Jewish sentiment is still occurring 75 years after WW II and the "never again" sentiment is very interesting. More so as people from the era are growing older and disappearing.
I found this book interested since the title is an age old question and one I truly didn't understand. I'm not sure i understand it a whole lot better after reading this and not sure i can subscribe to the author's rationale. however it is an interesting read, made more so due to the author's inclusion of his own experiences with anti-semitism. I think i might have been looking for more in the world's history...but this was thought provoking. The fact that anti-Jewish sentiment is still occurring 75 years after WW II and the "never again" sentiment is very interesting. More so as people from the era are growing older and disappearing.
December 5, 2020
This is a short and thought-provoking book. What separates this work from some of the other recent (and worthy) books on anti-Semitism is that it is filled with Halter’s personal story and reminiscences. It is a quick and important read. It certainly makes the reader think!
Want to read
March 30, 2021Note: I accessed a digital review copy of this book through Edelweiss.
Read
August 6, 2020Marek Halter se pose la question de savoir d'où vient la haine à l'égard des juifs, manifestée à tant de reprises dans l'histoire. Il remonte très loin dans l'histoire de l'humanité, allant chercher des explications jusque dans les comportements de Moïse.
Mais, il ne dégage aucune réponse.
Un titre prometteur - Un contenu brouillon - Le livre lu, nous n'en savons pas davantage sur le Pourquoi les Juifs…?
Mais, il ne dégage aucune réponse.
Un titre prometteur - Un contenu brouillon - Le livre lu, nous n'en savons pas davantage sur le Pourquoi les Juifs…?
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews