What a beautiful, gorgeous book! I loved everything about it, and I especially loved reading it with my daughter. Even the little extra touches the author and illustrator put in the text, like printing the challenging words in pink, and listing them in the glossary. My daughter and I loved the characteristics index, reading through and choosing our favorite on each page.
I loved the way the author (Carrie) and illustrator (Kamdon) had each girl compared to an animal and drew them accordingly. The way the fonts and text would change to highlight aspects of the story was a fun touch, making it easier for my daughter to read aloud when it was her turn.
And Carrie’s writing! It is absolutely gorgeous and even poetic! Several times I stopped to ‘ooh’ and ‘ah’ over a sentence, glad my daughter was getting this exposure to such beautiful examples of figurative language.
Just a small smattering of examples:
“She wasn’t sure, but if the feeling was a color, it would be a dark grey, like a weighty shadow.”
“Yes. They all—including her teacher—had suitably subdued, tastefully colored hair. Dark navy blues, rich henna browns, deep plum reds, and even a shimmery golden, over there by the chalkboard. Not one of them had bright and brash, YELLING-IN-ALL-CAPS hair, like hers.”
“In Rosalie, Poppy had found a kind of friendship that soothed, and filled the gaps in her heart that had been torn by betrayal and mistrust. It was a friendship that softly shaded her life in lovely hues of grace and joy.”
“A perfect, complete brokenness distinguished her—not the kind that hindered the spirit, but rather the opposite. It was the kind of ground-leveling humility where one’s spirit could start from scratch.”
This was just such a gorgeous, inspired book. I would’ve enjoyed it had I read it for myself, but it was truly the perfect story to read with my daughter.