What do you think?
Rate this book


191 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 2, 2020
The Bad: It's very obvious that Jethani is a preacher from the Evangelical tradition; in this book he is often guilty of talking about cultural context, or peculiarities of language, without any citation of where he got this information, even in the notes... in fact there's no bibliography to speak of at all. This works fine in the pulpit, so long as you can back up your claims if asked, but in a book I demand better.
The Ugly: So here is the big problem for me, Jethani skirts very close to actually making a point of doctrine, or taking a stand on praxis, or calling his reader to self examination and reform many times... but never actually does.
He manages to leave room for almost any Christian to pick up this book and find a way to read it that either offends or endorses their own personal understanding of Christian faith practice as it relates to the passages addressed.
Sure, maybe he calls out mega-churches and populist preachers... but in the next breath he endorses following teachers with magnetic and influential personalities, the very qualities that make the modern mega-church leader so popular.
He skirts close to endorsing purity culture, but also half-heartedly acknowledges some of the flaws inherent in that idea of holiness.
This is the inherent flaw in the benefit I mentioned earlier, that the book could provide a starting point for further discussion or meditation, this book lends itself to manipulation and it would be better if the author took a firmer stance on one or two of the issues raised.
Overall I don't hate it, but I also wont be recommending it.