What do you think?
Rate this book
I Have A Hunch
Summer holidays are for relaxing, spending time with friends and listening to great music. All things that Alice desperately wanted to do. Instead she was sent to London to work with her Uncle Humphrey, a world famous private detective. Things start to get interesting when they’re employed to investigate the mysterious murder of millionaire, Victor Tymm. Together they start to gather clues before they run out of time, and the killer can strike again.
- GenresMystery
260 pages, Kindle Edition
Published December 1, 2019
1 person is currently reading
17 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 49 reviews
May 6, 2020
this is called a homophone. it's what makes the english language so annoying to learn.
disclaimer: i noticed this was tagged middle grade only after i got the arc but before i started reading the book, which let me adjust my expectations accordingly.
thank you to book sirens and the publisher for an arc.
this was so good in such a nostalgic way. it really took me back to the mystery books i used to read growing up.
i enjoyed the characters, the plot (even though i found some of it quite obvious, i was still surprised by some twists and turns) and the humor (the puns!). i even enjoyed the unrealistic parts and how the child character was written in a way that kids want to see portrayed; like someone who was actually helpful, insightful and made a difference. someone who could see what the adults missed. it's cute. it's cannon.
i also found it super interesting that the whole book was about the events of one single day. i found it different and original.
the only real problem i had with this was that the author must choose: either bach is brilliant and would not miss some of the obvious clues the author deliberately made him miss so that alice could point out, or bach is not brilliant. i think that, instead of writing bach as someone who would dismiss or not see obvious clues or links, the author should have made it so that maybe only alice had access to that information (something she saw or heard and didn't think to mention, for example) and, therefore, bach could not have known about it, instead of just not seeing its relevance.
i was also a bit annoyed that alice seemed to arrive in london to work with her uncle for the whole summer without any luggage. it's just weird and i couldn't unsee it. it kept nagging me.
i really hope decoursey makes this into a series because i am here for detective bach's adventures, particularly the unsolvables. i need closure!
disclaimer: i noticed this was tagged middle grade only after i got the arc but before i started reading the book, which let me adjust my expectations accordingly.
thank you to book sirens and the publisher for an arc.
this was so good in such a nostalgic way. it really took me back to the mystery books i used to read growing up.
i enjoyed the characters, the plot (even though i found some of it quite obvious, i was still surprised by some twists and turns) and the humor (the puns!). i even enjoyed the unrealistic parts and how the child character was written in a way that kids want to see portrayed; like someone who was actually helpful, insightful and made a difference. someone who could see what the adults missed. it's cute. it's cannon.
i also found it super interesting that the whole book was about the events of one single day. i found it different and original.
the only real problem i had with this was that the author must choose: either bach is brilliant and would not miss some of the obvious clues the author deliberately made him miss so that alice could point out, or bach is not brilliant. i think that, instead of writing bach as someone who would dismiss or not see obvious clues or links, the author should have made it so that maybe only alice had access to that information (something she saw or heard and didn't think to mention, for example) and, therefore, bach could not have known about it, instead of just not seeing its relevance.
i was also a bit annoyed that alice seemed to arrive in london to work with her uncle for the whole summer without any luggage. it's just weird and i couldn't unsee it. it kept nagging me.
i really hope decoursey makes this into a series because i am here for detective bach's adventures, particularly the unsolvables. i need closure!
August 13, 2020
A wonderful face paced and gripping mystery book. the chronology of events and writing style is very amusing. it not only has thrill and suspense but some fun parts too. the writer has done a great job in connecting little things in it and keeping them important as well. would recommend to anyone looking for an engrossing yet light murder mystery. but best suited for teens. Thank you BookSirens for an advance review copy for free.
April 6, 2020
Review in a nutshell:
I Have A Hunch befits young ones interested in mystery and crime-solving. It's easy to understand while also maintaining enough suspense and excitement children and teens will appreciate.
Full review:
Rather than spending her summer with her friends attending concerts and summer fairs, 13-year old Alice was sent to work for her uncle instead, the great detective Humphrey Bach. What she expected to be a relaxing summer turned out to be a summer filled with teas, biscuits, and solving the mysterious death of one Victor Tymm. As they go deeper into the case, the duo worries if they'll be able to solve it in time or will the killer get them first?
I Have A Hunch, as I will keep reiterating, is a book best suited for kids and teens who are just recently dabbling into mystery and crime fiction. The narrative, the characters, and the story's progression really reminded me of grade school mystery books or even the riddles that, well, riddled the internet. There were quite a few puns throughout the book, which may be appreciated by parents or, again, by young ones. The highlight for me was the one element that kept coming out throughout the book, and what it means for the main characters, as well as the other characters that can potentially change the story's progress.
Personally, I would have enjoyed this book more if it were the decision-based kind where the book can have multiple endings depending on your choice. That would have made the book more immersive and at the same time, fully explored the plot and characters' potentials.
I Have A Hunch befits young ones interested in mystery and crime-solving. It's easy to understand while also maintaining enough suspense and excitement children and teens will appreciate.
Full review:
Rather than spending her summer with her friends attending concerts and summer fairs, 13-year old Alice was sent to work for her uncle instead, the great detective Humphrey Bach. What she expected to be a relaxing summer turned out to be a summer filled with teas, biscuits, and solving the mysterious death of one Victor Tymm. As they go deeper into the case, the duo worries if they'll be able to solve it in time or will the killer get them first?
I Have A Hunch, as I will keep reiterating, is a book best suited for kids and teens who are just recently dabbling into mystery and crime fiction. The narrative, the characters, and the story's progression really reminded me of grade school mystery books or even the riddles that, well, riddled the internet. There were quite a few puns throughout the book, which may be appreciated by parents or, again, by young ones. The highlight for me was the one element that kept coming out throughout the book, and what it means for the main characters, as well as the other characters that can potentially change the story's progress.
Personally, I would have enjoyed this book more if it were the decision-based kind where the book can have multiple endings depending on your choice. That would have made the book more immersive and at the same time, fully explored the plot and characters' potentials.
April 13, 2020
3,5/5 🌟
Alice is thirteen years old and, like any other girl her age, she wants to spend her summer to listen to music at great concerts and make her instagram more popular. But her mother decided she had to do paperwork at her uncle’s private detective’s office in London. But her summer could get more interesting when someone unexpected knocks at the office.
This book was really enjoyable. Alice is very curious and observant which makes her point of view all along the book interesting and doesn’t give the impression to be stuck in an immature head. All along the book there are references to Sherlock Holmes which I love ! Even the character of Humphrey, Alice’s uncle, is a modern Sherlock Holmes with his capacity but more gentle and a better instructor. He is really sweet and intelligent, he is without an hesitation my favorite character of the book. The plot is really mysterious and until the very end I wasn't able to guess who was responsible. The countdown of the chapter names are also really good, it creates a rhythm to the book and is a great wink to the rest of the story I think. Finally this book is adapted to younger children, like 13 to 15 years old, they will understand easily the story, but because the plot is well written it can be read by young adult too.
Thanks again to BookSirens for sending me this book for free in exchange of a review.
Alice is thirteen years old and, like any other girl her age, she wants to spend her summer to listen to music at great concerts and make her instagram more popular. But her mother decided she had to do paperwork at her uncle’s private detective’s office in London. But her summer could get more interesting when someone unexpected knocks at the office.
This book was really enjoyable. Alice is very curious and observant which makes her point of view all along the book interesting and doesn’t give the impression to be stuck in an immature head. All along the book there are references to Sherlock Holmes which I love ! Even the character of Humphrey, Alice’s uncle, is a modern Sherlock Holmes with his capacity but more gentle and a better instructor. He is really sweet and intelligent, he is without an hesitation my favorite character of the book. The plot is really mysterious and until the very end I wasn't able to guess who was responsible. The countdown of the chapter names are also really good, it creates a rhythm to the book and is a great wink to the rest of the story I think. Finally this book is adapted to younger children, like 13 to 15 years old, they will understand easily the story, but because the plot is well written it can be read by young adult too.
Thanks again to BookSirens for sending me this book for free in exchange of a review.
January 9, 2020
What an enjoyable read. This children's mystery story is fast paced and keeps you guessing throughout. I was left guessing "whodunnit" up to the reveal which is very nice. I would recommend this book.
May 2, 2020
https://clavie.co/2020/05/01/arc-book...
Firstly I would like to thank the author, Jeremy DeCoursey for sending me a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
I write my thoughts as I get them therefore this review will have my suspicions on the murder this plot is based on.
The main character Alice, 13 years old is sent to spend the summer with her uncle that works as a private investigator. Automatically I think this is a great opportunity to get into the mystery type genre without too many complications as the main character is young but not immature. Straight away she is told about a mystery with a symbol left at the crime scenes every time as that’s been a long-term one to solve.
A woman walks into the office on her first day as her uncle’s ‘apprentice’ and tells them about her late boss’s situation. When the police automatically rule it out as any sort of murder she turns to them to help and that they do. This is where the story becomes interesting and the plot thickens.
Clues are discovered and then replaced as a mystery person goes to get rid of them straight away which to me indicates it’s definitely someone in the household or at least has access to the household within the estate which means when the gardener suddenly appears it brings a red flag to me. Especially as me chatters on about the other neighbours in the estate.
For supposedly the best private detective investigator this character was written poorly as there are obvious clues that I figured out instantly and he’s supposed to be the best yet he’s as silly as his niece?
Just as I think I know who the murderer is the plot thickens as there could be a partner involved (with my theory) however I noticed all the small signs of the ‘what if’s’ to my theory however both Humphrey and Alice seem to mention the details and never actually get back to them – when writing I think those points should be addressed / looked into as the character did notice it instead of purposely not going over them if the guy is supposed to be the best at this kind of thing wouldn’t you agree?
This novel has me anxious to read more and to find out what happens next, if my theory is correct as it changes slightly with the new information I am given.
Also, I would like to point out I like how this seems to all take place in the space of one day and is split up into hours of the day.
It’s shown throughout it a decent attempt at humour towards the two main characters. By the end I was hooked as I was wondering was my theory correct and how it would pan out. I was correct. Some character flaws as with a lot of characters when I read novels but it still kept me hooked.
Firstly I would like to thank the author, Jeremy DeCoursey for sending me a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
I write my thoughts as I get them therefore this review will have my suspicions on the murder this plot is based on.
The main character Alice, 13 years old is sent to spend the summer with her uncle that works as a private investigator. Automatically I think this is a great opportunity to get into the mystery type genre without too many complications as the main character is young but not immature. Straight away she is told about a mystery with a symbol left at the crime scenes every time as that’s been a long-term one to solve.
A woman walks into the office on her first day as her uncle’s ‘apprentice’ and tells them about her late boss’s situation. When the police automatically rule it out as any sort of murder she turns to them to help and that they do. This is where the story becomes interesting and the plot thickens.
Clues are discovered and then replaced as a mystery person goes to get rid of them straight away which to me indicates it’s definitely someone in the household or at least has access to the household within the estate which means when the gardener suddenly appears it brings a red flag to me. Especially as me chatters on about the other neighbours in the estate.
For supposedly the best private detective investigator this character was written poorly as there are obvious clues that I figured out instantly and he’s supposed to be the best yet he’s as silly as his niece?
Just as I think I know who the murderer is the plot thickens as there could be a partner involved (with my theory) however I noticed all the small signs of the ‘what if’s’ to my theory however both Humphrey and Alice seem to mention the details and never actually get back to them – when writing I think those points should be addressed / looked into as the character did notice it instead of purposely not going over them if the guy is supposed to be the best at this kind of thing wouldn’t you agree?
This novel has me anxious to read more and to find out what happens next, if my theory is correct as it changes slightly with the new information I am given.
Also, I would like to point out I like how this seems to all take place in the space of one day and is split up into hours of the day.
It’s shown throughout it a decent attempt at humour towards the two main characters. By the end I was hooked as I was wondering was my theory correct and how it would pan out. I was correct. Some character flaws as with a lot of characters when I read novels but it still kept me hooked.
February 11, 2020
I have mixed feelings about this book. For about 75% of it, I wasn't sure if I was going to finish it or not. Personally, I am glad that I finished the book as it did improve in quality during the last 25% but I do not see myself seeking out this series long term. Everything from the characters to the puns seemed to get better in the far latter part of the book, but I would have rather it been a solid read throughout rather than it pulling through in the final lap. I will be interested in seeing if the writing of the next book follows the same path as its predecessor or if the writing will stay strong overall. Until then, I will patiently weight.
I received this book for free in return for an honest review, which I am giving voluntarily
I received this book for free in return for an honest review, which I am giving voluntarily
August 13, 2020
I want to thank Booksirens for the free published copy of I Have a Hunch in exchange for an honest review!
Rating ~ 3.5 / 5 stars
I had a lot of fun reading this mystery because of how interesting the clues were in the book. Humphrey back, the detective, deals with a disability but that hasn't stopped him from being one of London's best detectives. Alice, his niece, comes to spend the summer with him and instead of filling paperwork for him, she gets sucked into a open-murder case. It was really interesting to read how a 13-year old girl tried to solve a murder case when the clues didn't make sense but that goes to show that anyone, young or old, can have helpful insight. I did feel like that some parts in the story didn't make sense to me (as to why it was relevant to the plot) but I loved how I kept wanting more from the book.
Rating ~ 3.5 / 5 stars
I had a lot of fun reading this mystery because of how interesting the clues were in the book. Humphrey back, the detective, deals with a disability but that hasn't stopped him from being one of London's best detectives. Alice, his niece, comes to spend the summer with him and instead of filling paperwork for him, she gets sucked into a open-murder case. It was really interesting to read how a 13-year old girl tried to solve a murder case when the clues didn't make sense but that goes to show that anyone, young or old, can have helpful insight. I did feel like that some parts in the story didn't make sense to me (as to why it was relevant to the plot) but I loved how I kept wanting more from the book.
January 11, 2021
Fans of Sherlock and Enola Holmes would love this book. This book is targeted at middle age readers but I'm sure many cozy mystery readers would enjoy it too.
Alice was spending her summer holiday with her Uncle Humphrey. They got involved in a murder mystery and that was how their advanture started. There were many interesting characters and they came alive for me in the book.
The author was smart to use word play to make the book more fun to read. There were many metaphors that younger readers can learn.
I received an arc for free from Booksirens and I'm leaving this review voluntarily.
Alice was spending her summer holiday with her Uncle Humphrey. They got involved in a murder mystery and that was how their advanture started. There were many interesting characters and they came alive for me in the book.
The author was smart to use word play to make the book more fun to read. There were many metaphors that younger readers can learn.
I received an arc for free from Booksirens and I'm leaving this review voluntarily.
December 7, 2020
3.5 stars out of 5.
❝I have a hunch.❞
I must say the ending was really fun and the mystery ended up being more exciting than i expected.
Alice was a nice character and so was Humphrey, their dynamic exquisite.
A fun middle grade mystery book. Nothing too big and not too small. If you enjoy little mysteries, you will probably enjoy this one.
I would recommend.
[I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.]
❝I have a hunch.❞
I must say the ending was really fun and the mystery ended up being more exciting than i expected.
Alice was a nice character and so was Humphrey, their dynamic exquisite.
A fun middle grade mystery book. Nothing too big and not too small. If you enjoy little mysteries, you will probably enjoy this one.
I would recommend.
[I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.]
January 22, 2021
What a thrilling read!
This is exactly the type of mystery I enjoy. It’s almost like Agatha Christie mixed with a bit of humor.
The plot is great! It’s interesting and I for one did not have any clue who the murderer was until the very end. I also really like that the main character is a young girl and we see everything from her point of view. That makes the book more interesting I think.
All the characters are interesting too, but Humphrey has to be in a league on his own! He is super cool. For some reason I keep seeing Frank Hathaway from the TV program as Humphrey but that probably isn’t how he actually is.
All in all, this book is great and keep on your toes mystery and the way it is written is brilliant!
*ARC received from BookSirens
This is exactly the type of mystery I enjoy. It’s almost like Agatha Christie mixed with a bit of humor.
The plot is great! It’s interesting and I for one did not have any clue who the murderer was until the very end. I also really like that the main character is a young girl and we see everything from her point of view. That makes the book more interesting I think.
All the characters are interesting too, but Humphrey has to be in a league on his own! He is super cool. For some reason I keep seeing Frank Hathaway from the TV program as Humphrey but that probably isn’t how he actually is.
All in all, this book is great and keep on your toes mystery and the way it is written is brilliant!
*ARC received from BookSirens
August 19, 2020
I would like to thank BookSirens for my free copy of I Have a Hunch in exchange for a voluntary and honest review.
I really enjoyed this book. It is clearly aimed at a younger audience, probably 10-15 year olds, but I'm 23 and I still found it to be a really fun story. The plot moved at a reasonable pace. I especially liked that each chapter of the book constituted an hour of the day, as it meant there was always something happening. Every little detail was important.
There are a lot of puns in the book. A lot. I did not grow sick of them, and I don't think a younger audience would either. I laughed and groaned in jest with quite a few of them, especially when I realised the hilarity of Humphrey Bach's name.
I really hope there is a sequel, heck, I hope there's a whole series coming in the works, because I need that cliffhanger to be resolved.
I really enjoyed this book. It is clearly aimed at a younger audience, probably 10-15 year olds, but I'm 23 and I still found it to be a really fun story. The plot moved at a reasonable pace. I especially liked that each chapter of the book constituted an hour of the day, as it meant there was always something happening. Every little detail was important.
There are a lot of puns in the book. A lot. I did not grow sick of them, and I don't think a younger audience would either. I laughed and groaned in jest with quite a few of them, especially when I realised the hilarity of Humphrey Bach's name.
I really hope there is a sequel, heck, I hope there's a whole series coming in the works, because I need that cliffhanger to be resolved.
June 21, 2020
Alice comes to visit her Uncle Humphrey on her school vacation. Alice does not want to be there. Within the 1st hour her Uncle is hired to invesigate a murder. Ths story is a whodunit and does a very good job of not letting you know until the very end who is guilty. I usually figure out the murderer halfway through the book, but this story had me guessing until the conclusion. I was given a free copy of this book at my request and this is my honest review.
December 23, 2020
3.5 stars rounded up
I received a review copy for free from BookSirens (thanks!) and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I thought that the characters were engaging - Humphrey is a cool uncle and Alice mostly has a good head on her shoulders, though it did make me a bit sad that she was hung up with the number of likes on her social media (I know this is how things are now, but it shouldn't be). I should also mention that I love that Humphrey is not perfect and has such a positive mindset - that his hunch is what makes him, him; I felt that his "disability" was handled very well.
I really enjoyed the overall story too with enough potentially spicy back story hints to carry over into other instalments.
I received a review copy for free from BookSirens (thanks!) and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I thought that the characters were engaging - Humphrey is a cool uncle and Alice mostly has a good head on her shoulders, though it did make me a bit sad that she was hung up with the number of likes on her social media (I know this is how things are now, but it shouldn't be). I should also mention that I love that Humphrey is not perfect and has such a positive mindset - that his hunch is what makes him, him; I felt that his "disability" was handled very well.
I really enjoyed the overall story too with enough potentially spicy back story hints to carry over into other instalments.
May 8, 2020
I was given a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. I am leaving this review voluntarily. This is an ok story which is good for a YA audience. I, personally, found the awful puns for characters names annoying - but I've no doubt that a younger audience will find them appealing. Puns aside, this is a good read with well-written characters and a plot that moves at a steady pace. There is a strong element of fun throughout the book and, on the whole, it is an enjoyable read.
April 21, 2021
I Have a Hunch is a fun, cozy mystery. The investigator, Humphrey Bach, and his niece Alice are quite a pair. She proves herself smart and capable in her first case during her Internship with her uncle. The cast of characters are quirky and interesting. The story unfolds at a good pace with a few surprises sprinkled throughout. I look forward to reading further adventures of Humphrey and Alice!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
May 16, 2021
What a marvellous murder mystery that has a Christie-esq feel to it. I particularly like that the book caters to both adults and young adults. The story as with most good mysteries has red herrings as well as numerous hints, that I for one did not catch till the very end. Loved that the characters are unique, quirky, and full of life (except for the dead guy). Highly recommended!
Note: I received an advance review copy of this book for free. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Note: I received an advance review copy of this book for free. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 3, 2021
Oh, my! I love how the British write! A perfect way to spend a quite afternoon. Good clean fun! So well written! Brilliant!
Enjoyable! Humerous! Cute! Amusing! Different! Exciting! Wonderful! Gripping! Light-hearted! Engrossing! Thrills and suspense! Interesting, come to live characters. Sherlock Holmes written style, with clues and puns thrown in.
It kept me wanting more. Great job!
Wow! Great fun mystery. I hope there is more, volumn two!
Read and enjoy the story.
I received an ARC free from BookSirens and this is my voluntary honest review.
Enjoyable! Humerous! Cute! Amusing! Different! Exciting! Wonderful! Gripping! Light-hearted! Engrossing! Thrills and suspense! Interesting, come to live characters. Sherlock Holmes written style, with clues and puns thrown in.
It kept me wanting more. Great job!
Wow! Great fun mystery. I hope there is more, volumn two!
Read and enjoy the story.
I received an ARC free from BookSirens and this is my voluntary honest review.
February 25, 2020
i received a free e-book in exchange for an honest review. the book was an enjoyable read. it was smart to those who find it fun to play with words. it was an easy read & its characters easy to fall in love with. the danger was an additional treat, making it an even rewarding read.
April 29, 2020
A lighthearted fun adventure for young teens or tweens.
This is a quite charming, young teen mystery that sometimes occasionally becomes a little silly. (Which the author freely acknowledges)
Our heroine visits her eminently famous, private detective Uncle as a summer job. Her uncle then gets hired to solve a murder, and Alice, our protagonist, is swept along investigating the site, interviewing witnesses, all of whom seem suspicious. Eventually even running afoul of the murderer and having to try to apprehend the killer while not becoming the next victims! But all is brought to a happy conclusion. Running in the background is another more curious mystery, one that is not resolved in this book but appears to be setup to run throughout a series, of which this is the first book.
There are many classic Holmesian tropes in play here: Alice's uncle is the brilliant detective, Alice is a Watsonish every-person, albeit very young, who helps point out just the right things; there is even a grumpy police inspector not unlike Lestrade. All of this is handled usually nicely, but there are a few minor bumps. Happily there are some fresh takes: the brilliant detective lives alone until his niece arrives one summer, he has a love interest although he is still a little awkward about it, the great detective also has some friends who provide high tech assistance.
The author did well enough with creating characters. I found Alice to be quite annoying sometimes, as I'm sure I would find a thirteen year old. I did feel that at times Alice seemed to explain things about English life or London that a young English girl would not think about explaining to herself. She would just know them. I am guessing this is to make it a little easier for American readers. But I feel this is important to note since the story is being told in first person.
The pace moved quickly which I enjoyed. Even though some of the major clues were painfully obvious, the story still did surprise me a few times. It may do well for Young Adult. Although the most obvious things were the grammar errors it seemed quite a few people made.
What I think this book needs most is a good editor. I know a young teen would be obsessed with social media, but the constant references to Instagram in the early chapters was perhaps one time too many. There was an annoying trend in the early chapters to try to teach Alice and the reader some English grammar. As I entered the fourth chapter I wondered if this was going to be an "educational" story. But thankfully that did not continue. However having many clues and other related humor in the story all revolve around the same feature of grammar got a bit wearisome. There also seemed to be a few eBook formatting errors, which I have heard can be tricky.
I also got a little frustrated and lost some suspension of disbelief when this supposedly great detective breezes right past several clues, both in the main mystery and the background overarching mystery, which the author even goes to pains to highlight to the reader. That being said, the way Alice's uncle behaved once real and imminent danger arose felt very real and I thought was excellently handled.
Overall I enjoyed it, and I would have no problem recommending it to any of my friends young teens! Good clean fun, without anything to worry cautious parents. I'm actually looking forward to the next book!
This is a quite charming, young teen mystery that sometimes occasionally becomes a little silly. (Which the author freely acknowledges)
Our heroine visits her eminently famous, private detective Uncle as a summer job. Her uncle then gets hired to solve a murder, and Alice, our protagonist, is swept along investigating the site, interviewing witnesses, all of whom seem suspicious. Eventually even running afoul of the murderer and having to try to apprehend the killer while not becoming the next victims! But all is brought to a happy conclusion. Running in the background is another more curious mystery, one that is not resolved in this book but appears to be setup to run throughout a series, of which this is the first book.
There are many classic Holmesian tropes in play here: Alice's uncle is the brilliant detective, Alice is a Watsonish every-person, albeit very young, who helps point out just the right things; there is even a grumpy police inspector not unlike Lestrade. All of this is handled usually nicely, but there are a few minor bumps. Happily there are some fresh takes: the brilliant detective lives alone until his niece arrives one summer, he has a love interest although he is still a little awkward about it, the great detective also has some friends who provide high tech assistance.
The author did well enough with creating characters. I found Alice to be quite annoying sometimes, as I'm sure I would find a thirteen year old. I did feel that at times Alice seemed to explain things about English life or London that a young English girl would not think about explaining to herself. She would just know them. I am guessing this is to make it a little easier for American readers. But I feel this is important to note since the story is being told in first person.
The pace moved quickly which I enjoyed. Even though some of the major clues were painfully obvious, the story still did surprise me a few times. It may do well for Young Adult. Although the most obvious things were the grammar errors it seemed quite a few people made.
What I think this book needs most is a good editor. I know a young teen would be obsessed with social media, but the constant references to Instagram in the early chapters was perhaps one time too many. There was an annoying trend in the early chapters to try to teach Alice and the reader some English grammar. As I entered the fourth chapter I wondered if this was going to be an "educational" story. But thankfully that did not continue. However having many clues and other related humor in the story all revolve around the same feature of grammar got a bit wearisome. There also seemed to be a few eBook formatting errors, which I have heard can be tricky.
I also got a little frustrated and lost some suspension of disbelief when this supposedly great detective breezes right past several clues, both in the main mystery and the background overarching mystery, which the author even goes to pains to highlight to the reader. That being said, the way Alice's uncle behaved once real and imminent danger arose felt very real and I thought was excellently handled.
Overall I enjoyed it, and I would have no problem recommending it to any of my friends young teens! Good clean fun, without anything to worry cautious parents. I'm actually looking forward to the next book!
May 24, 2020
Thank you, Book Sirens, for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Alice is the niece of Humphrey Bach, a world-famous private detective. Humphrey’s managed to crack cases that the police couldn’t solve, and he’s like a modern-day Sherlock Holmes. When Alice comes to work for him during her summer holidays, she doesn’t know what to expect. When a potential client comes storming into the office to ask for help solving the murder of the millionaire, Victor Tymm, Alice gets to go on her first crime-solving adventure.
This book was a lot of fun to read because it was full of so much wordplay. Early on, Humphrey explains to Alice what a homophone is, and the book is full of homophones and wordplay. There’s a character who works at the library whose name is Dewey; the gardener Herbert wants to plant an herb garden; even Humphrey Bach is a play on words because Uncle Humphrey has Kyphosis, or a hunched back. I loved all of the wordplay, and I thought the way that it tied into the mystery was very clever.
I enjoyed the mystery aspect of this book, and it reminded me of a Hercule Poirot or Sherlock Holmes adventure. I liked the different characters that Humphrey and Alice meet on the estate, and I enjoyed the interview and clue finding process. I thought the mystery was full of exciting twists and turns, and even though I figured out who did it, I thought the buildup to the end was exciting.
I also liked that there was a larger, over-arching mystery going on in the background. There’s a string of connected cases that Humphrey hasn’t been able to solve, and they’re mentioned throughout the book. I liked that this left it open for there to be more books, which I will probably read.
It took me a little while to warm up to Alice, but once I did, I didn’t mind her. There were a few moments where I thought she was acting a bit immature, but then I remember that she’s thirteen and that normal thirteen-year-olds are sometimes immature. I liked Humphrey, and I liked how passionate he was about solving mysteries. I also liked that he didn’t let his Kyphosis get in the way of doing what he loved.
Overall, this was a fun book to read. I liked the mystery, and I thought the wordplay gave it a unique twist. It wasn’t my favourite mystery, but I’m curious enough to check out more Humphrey Bach mysteries.
Alice is the niece of Humphrey Bach, a world-famous private detective. Humphrey’s managed to crack cases that the police couldn’t solve, and he’s like a modern-day Sherlock Holmes. When Alice comes to work for him during her summer holidays, she doesn’t know what to expect. When a potential client comes storming into the office to ask for help solving the murder of the millionaire, Victor Tymm, Alice gets to go on her first crime-solving adventure.
This book was a lot of fun to read because it was full of so much wordplay. Early on, Humphrey explains to Alice what a homophone is, and the book is full of homophones and wordplay. There’s a character who works at the library whose name is Dewey; the gardener Herbert wants to plant an herb garden; even Humphrey Bach is a play on words because Uncle Humphrey has Kyphosis, or a hunched back. I loved all of the wordplay, and I thought the way that it tied into the mystery was very clever.
I enjoyed the mystery aspect of this book, and it reminded me of a Hercule Poirot or Sherlock Holmes adventure. I liked the different characters that Humphrey and Alice meet on the estate, and I enjoyed the interview and clue finding process. I thought the mystery was full of exciting twists and turns, and even though I figured out who did it, I thought the buildup to the end was exciting.
I also liked that there was a larger, over-arching mystery going on in the background. There’s a string of connected cases that Humphrey hasn’t been able to solve, and they’re mentioned throughout the book. I liked that this left it open for there to be more books, which I will probably read.
It took me a little while to warm up to Alice, but once I did, I didn’t mind her. There were a few moments where I thought she was acting a bit immature, but then I remember that she’s thirteen and that normal thirteen-year-olds are sometimes immature. I liked Humphrey, and I liked how passionate he was about solving mysteries. I also liked that he didn’t let his Kyphosis get in the way of doing what he loved.
Overall, this was a fun book to read. I liked the mystery, and I thought the wordplay gave it a unique twist. It wasn’t my favourite mystery, but I’m curious enough to check out more Humphrey Bach mysteries.
October 26, 2020
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
For adults who skim past this book, please do not let the ‘Middle Grade’ genre put you off. As an adult who is familiar with dark and complex writing styles and plots, I enjoyed this light-hearted detective adventure filled with wordplay. The novel has a clear and concise plot, with plentiful clues and wordplay and conversations that cleverly tie to the mystery.
DeCoursey did a great job writing in the perspective of a 13-year-old who wanted nothing more but to have something cool happen during her summer. The writing and language brought nostalgia and familiarity as the characters reminded me of Ronald Dahl’s trademark style of writing. I very much enjoyed the lessons DeCoursey teaches through his characters’ ordeals, in particular I loved the heartfelt moment between Alice and her Uncle, and the wisdom Uncle Bach bestows onto Alice. On the other hand, the writing was occasionally confusing, I did have to pause and reread to understand what the author meant and there were typos (3) I had spotted. This also be because the author had a habit of cutting the scene short and moving on to the next sequence, leaving me feeling incomplete between each chapter.
Nonetheless, I enjoyed the twists and turns the story brought, the novel had a satisfying ending, bidding the first mystery completed with a tantalizing promise for another exciting adventure. This wasn’t my favourite mystery book, but Bach and Alice did grow on me and I am curious to see more of their adventures. So, while I may not recommend this for young adults, I do recommend this for Middle Graders, students who have just started reading and those who love puns and Sherlock Holmes.
For adults who skim past this book, please do not let the ‘Middle Grade’ genre put you off. As an adult who is familiar with dark and complex writing styles and plots, I enjoyed this light-hearted detective adventure filled with wordplay. The novel has a clear and concise plot, with plentiful clues and wordplay and conversations that cleverly tie to the mystery.
DeCoursey did a great job writing in the perspective of a 13-year-old who wanted nothing more but to have something cool happen during her summer. The writing and language brought nostalgia and familiarity as the characters reminded me of Ronald Dahl’s trademark style of writing. I very much enjoyed the lessons DeCoursey teaches through his characters’ ordeals, in particular I loved the heartfelt moment between Alice and her Uncle, and the wisdom Uncle Bach bestows onto Alice. On the other hand, the writing was occasionally confusing, I did have to pause and reread to understand what the author meant and there were typos (3) I had spotted. This also be because the author had a habit of cutting the scene short and moving on to the next sequence, leaving me feeling incomplete between each chapter.
Nonetheless, I enjoyed the twists and turns the story brought, the novel had a satisfying ending, bidding the first mystery completed with a tantalizing promise for another exciting adventure. This wasn’t my favourite mystery book, but Bach and Alice did grow on me and I am curious to see more of their adventures. So, while I may not recommend this for young adults, I do recommend this for Middle Graders, students who have just started reading and those who love puns and Sherlock Holmes.
October 26, 2020
First of all, thank you BookSirens for this review copy!
This story is told from Alice’s perspective. She was sent to London on a summer holiday to work with her Uncle Humphrey or much more known as Humphrey Bach the world-famous private investigator. After she arrived, they are employed to solve the death of a millionaire, Victor Tymm. They went to the deceased’s estate and many things happened since then. The story is quite easy to follow because it is geared to middle-grade but it doesn’t mean older readers can’t enjoy it too. The chapters are also quite unique, they are served as a timeline.
In my opinion, the theme of this novel is revolving around homophone. Even the key to solving the mystery is a homophone. Alice is an interesting character, she’s like a normal 13 years old teenager, seeking validation, quite relatable in my opinion. She’s always curious even though quite impulsive sometimes. Her Uncle Humphrey is a sweetheart and a good mentor for Alice. What I like about this novel is both of them work together in solving this case, Alice picked up some important clues too alongside Humphrey. For the case, I can not guess the real murderer until the end, that’s how slow I am. Interesting story. I don’t know if this story is strong enough to become a series, but if there is another one, I’m interested to read it.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This story is told from Alice’s perspective. She was sent to London on a summer holiday to work with her Uncle Humphrey or much more known as Humphrey Bach the world-famous private investigator. After she arrived, they are employed to solve the death of a millionaire, Victor Tymm. They went to the deceased’s estate and many things happened since then. The story is quite easy to follow because it is geared to middle-grade but it doesn’t mean older readers can’t enjoy it too. The chapters are also quite unique, they are served as a timeline.
In my opinion, the theme of this novel is revolving around homophone. Even the key to solving the mystery is a homophone. Alice is an interesting character, she’s like a normal 13 years old teenager, seeking validation, quite relatable in my opinion. She’s always curious even though quite impulsive sometimes. Her Uncle Humphrey is a sweetheart and a good mentor for Alice. What I like about this novel is both of them work together in solving this case, Alice picked up some important clues too alongside Humphrey. For the case, I can not guess the real murderer until the end, that’s how slow I am. Interesting story. I don’t know if this story is strong enough to become a series, but if there is another one, I’m interested to read it.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 26, 2021
*Thank you Booksiren for letting me read this book!*
“I have a Hunch" is a mystery about 13 year old Alice who is sent to London to work with her Uncle Humphrey, a world famous private detective. Things start to get interesting when they're employed to investigate the mysterious murder of millionaire, Victor Tymm. Together they start to gather clues before they run out of time, and the killer can strike again.
What I did not know when I applied for this book is that it was for a younger audience. Late teen so to say. Well.... I am 34 years old and I loved it and I honestly think most adult Cozy Mystery readers will enjoy it as well. I was even in doubt if it was Late Teen/YA as there is a scene where the protagonist, Alice who is 13 years old, sees a dead body in the Morgue. So yeah Young Adult would be more fitting. But again, adults will also enjoy!
I loved the interacting between Alice and her uncle. He takes her along on a murder case, even though her mum though she would be doing paperwork. Alice at first is hesitant if she wants to do this, but eventually loves it. The mystery was great, I was thrown off by the many double meaning of words. It's a quick read, perfect for in between books and yeah I really liked it! If there is going to be a second book, I will certainly read that as well! I had too much fun!
“I have a Hunch" is a mystery about 13 year old Alice who is sent to London to work with her Uncle Humphrey, a world famous private detective. Things start to get interesting when they're employed to investigate the mysterious murder of millionaire, Victor Tymm. Together they start to gather clues before they run out of time, and the killer can strike again.
What I did not know when I applied for this book is that it was for a younger audience. Late teen so to say. Well.... I am 34 years old and I loved it and I honestly think most adult Cozy Mystery readers will enjoy it as well. I was even in doubt if it was Late Teen/YA as there is a scene where the protagonist, Alice who is 13 years old, sees a dead body in the Morgue. So yeah Young Adult would be more fitting. But again, adults will also enjoy!
I loved the interacting between Alice and her uncle. He takes her along on a murder case, even though her mum though she would be doing paperwork. Alice at first is hesitant if she wants to do this, but eventually loves it. The mystery was great, I was thrown off by the many double meaning of words. It's a quick read, perfect for in between books and yeah I really liked it! If there is going to be a second book, I will certainly read that as well! I had too much fun!
January 15, 2021
'I Have a Hunch' my Jeremy DeCoursey is a fun, engaging mystery novel aimed at the younger adult audience. With this in mind, I read the book with some younger members of my family.
They immediately identified, with 13 year old Alice, who is working with her uncle for the summer. Humphrey Bach in a private detective, similar to his hero, Sherlock Homes and Alice is supposed to be help Humphrey with his paperwork but his quickly drawn into the world of mystery and intrigue.
I found Alice to be somewhat naive at times, but I am reading as as adult, from a teenagers perspective, her confusion over language and and focus on social media interaction seem perfectly normal. Clearly, the author knows his reader base and has developed the characters well.
There are plenty of 'red herrings' and twists in the story, just as with a typical Sherlock Holmes novel. Alice and Humphrey's adventure takes place in one day so it is a quick read and the main mystery is soon resolved. However, there are several references to their family history which suggest that there could be more mysteries from this intrepid duo to come.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
They immediately identified, with 13 year old Alice, who is working with her uncle for the summer. Humphrey Bach in a private detective, similar to his hero, Sherlock Homes and Alice is supposed to be help Humphrey with his paperwork but his quickly drawn into the world of mystery and intrigue.
I found Alice to be somewhat naive at times, but I am reading as as adult, from a teenagers perspective, her confusion over language and and focus on social media interaction seem perfectly normal. Clearly, the author knows his reader base and has developed the characters well.
There are plenty of 'red herrings' and twists in the story, just as with a typical Sherlock Holmes novel. Alice and Humphrey's adventure takes place in one day so it is a quick read and the main mystery is soon resolved. However, there are several references to their family history which suggest that there could be more mysteries from this intrepid duo to come.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
February 20, 2021
3.5/5⭐️, but I rounded up to 4!
This was such an interesting book! I feel like I should go back and reread it because there are so many little things I most likely missed- like all of the puns!
Some of the story was incredibly difficult to read or even suspend my belief with. I understand that it’s geared towards younger readers, but Alice seemed much older than she was. Like possibly 15-16 years old instead of 13.
That being said, it was extremely enjoyable. Alice is observant and curious, and it made her point of view fun to read. The “who done it?” part of it was very well done as well. I really did not know who had committed the murder until the end when they revealed it, and even then I looked back to see if there were any hints.
The Sherlock Holmes side of this read was another enjoyable part. All of the word play and allusions to other book culture things made it fun. I was looking for double entendres and reading into things in every sentence!
I think middle to YA readers would enjoy this read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This was such an interesting book! I feel like I should go back and reread it because there are so many little things I most likely missed- like all of the puns!
Some of the story was incredibly difficult to read or even suspend my belief with. I understand that it’s geared towards younger readers, but Alice seemed much older than she was. Like possibly 15-16 years old instead of 13.
That being said, it was extremely enjoyable. Alice is observant and curious, and it made her point of view fun to read. The “who done it?” part of it was very well done as well. I really did not know who had committed the murder until the end when they revealed it, and even then I looked back to see if there were any hints.
The Sherlock Holmes side of this read was another enjoyable part. All of the word play and allusions to other book culture things made it fun. I was looking for double entendres and reading into things in every sentence!
I think middle to YA readers would enjoy this read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Read
May 24, 2020I Have A Hunch is a mystery novel that follows a detective and his teenage niece, who is visiting him for the summer. They explore, and try to solve, the murder of a billionaire Londoner. The novel has a clear and concise plot, laying down the facts (clues) when necessary. The story has a satisfying, and rather obscure, ending. I loved being able to follow these characters' thoughts as they worked through the mystery. On the other hand, sometimes the writing would be confusing. I would have to pause for several seconds to puzzle out what the author meant. Alongside that, often it seemed as if the author left thoughts unfinished. We would be reading about a specific event, or reading about a character's point of view, and then abruptly the storyline would shift. This left me with a somewhat scattered impression of the novel. Other than that, the mystery was intriguing. I was engaged and amused by the wordplay scattered throughout the story.
I received a free copy of this book, in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I received a free copy of this book, in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
June 11, 2020
This book was really good. It is aimed for middle schoolers so it is really easy to read.
Firstly, Alice is a great character, she worries about teenagers' things but is also clever, creative, and funny. I felt really connected with this character, although I am older than her! Another great thing is that the book is very fast-paced and not too boring. I think it is a perfect book for kids or teens who are starting to read, as well as a light book if you do not want anything too complicated.
I loved the references to Sherlock and how Alice was Holmes-like.
The plot was fast-paced and interesting. Although they were some details that were too obvious, I get that is aimed at younger readers and is intended to not being too complicated. Although it follows a murder investigation, the humor is present in the book, thing I enjoyed a lot.
Overall, is a good book to read, but is not incredible. As I mentioned before, it is aimed at high schoolers so it might be too simple for adults.
Firstly, Alice is a great character, she worries about teenagers' things but is also clever, creative, and funny. I felt really connected with this character, although I am older than her! Another great thing is that the book is very fast-paced and not too boring. I think it is a perfect book for kids or teens who are starting to read, as well as a light book if you do not want anything too complicated.
I loved the references to Sherlock and how Alice was Holmes-like.
The plot was fast-paced and interesting. Although they were some details that were too obvious, I get that is aimed at younger readers and is intended to not being too complicated. Although it follows a murder investigation, the humor is present in the book, thing I enjoyed a lot.
Overall, is a good book to read, but is not incredible. As I mentioned before, it is aimed at high schoolers so it might be too simple for adults.
September 1, 2020
While I Have a Hunch is written for middle graders, it is enjoyable for middle aged mystery lovers as well. Author Jeremy Decoursey liberally lards this book with wordplay and puns (e.g. an author named Paige Turner) that should appeal to young readers. As in most traditional British mysteries, the clues are all there for 13-year-old Alice and her detective uncle Humphrey Bach (and the reader) to discover and interpret. I appreciate the way that little lessons about disabilities, race, bullying, and ageism are subtly woven through the story. A number of minor mysteries are left unsolved, so I have a hunch this is the first of a series of books.
I hope the author finds a more scrupulous editor. The large number of missing apostrophes and typographical errors was quite annoying, and affected my rating.
BookSirens gave me an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I hope the author finds a more scrupulous editor. The large number of missing apostrophes and typographical errors was quite annoying, and affected my rating.
BookSirens gave me an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 24, 2020
Enjoyable murder mystery
The story is about Alice, a young 13 year old teenager who is sent to London to visit her uncle Humphrey who is a well-known detective. Just as she reaches his office, she is pulled into a murder mystery as his apprentice. Victor Tymm, one of the richest people in town is found murdered in his library. A member of the estate's staff, Miss Terry reports the crime to Mr. Humphrey.
The story's pace is its advantage, it is so fast that we don't get to wait around for too long. From chapter to chapter, a new twist engages you and you run with it. The quirky sense of humour enhances the author's descriptive language. You tend to suspect all of Victor Tymm's staff members, friends and associates.
From start to finish, this is an enjoyable who-dunnit and a perfect murder mystery for young adults.
The story is about Alice, a young 13 year old teenager who is sent to London to visit her uncle Humphrey who is a well-known detective. Just as she reaches his office, she is pulled into a murder mystery as his apprentice. Victor Tymm, one of the richest people in town is found murdered in his library. A member of the estate's staff, Miss Terry reports the crime to Mr. Humphrey.
The story's pace is its advantage, it is so fast that we don't get to wait around for too long. From chapter to chapter, a new twist engages you and you run with it. The quirky sense of humour enhances the author's descriptive language. You tend to suspect all of Victor Tymm's staff members, friends and associates.
From start to finish, this is an enjoyable who-dunnit and a perfect murder mystery for young adults.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 49 reviews