Carrie has loving parents, but she's always felt a little out of place. Yet when she's approached by a private investigator who tells her that she was adopted and her sister is looking for her, she's shattered. How could her parents have lied to her?
Mark is a PI, specialising in reuniting adopted kids with their birth families. When he encounters people like Carrie, who are so crushed by the whole situation, he sometimes wonders if he's doing the right thing. But as he helps Carrie and her long-lost sister Suzanne to meet and build a relationship, he comes to realise that his job may be messy and painful, but it's very necessary. And as he spends more time with Carrie, becoming her friend and confidant, the relationship that had such a difficult start begins to blossom into more.
When I first picked up this book on this read-round, I didn't like it. (I know I read it once, but didn't remember it, and it was in a bag that I never got round to donating.) About a third of the way through I started to warm to it, but it didn't really grab me the way a couple of Janice Kay Johnson's previous books have. Carrie is the complete opposite of me: she's messy, mercurial, passionate (some might say melodramatic), flighty, and has a totally different set of values to me. That made her hard for this reader to understand and empathise with. YMMV, of course. Mark seems like a nice man, but I didn't get to know him well enough to fall for him, though I liked his relationship with his son, and appreciated his kindness to Carrie and Suzanne.
The book is really less about the romance, and more about the family dynamics: between Carrie and Suzanne (and estranged brother Lucien / Gary, who only briefly appears and wants nothing to do with his sisters), between Carrie and her adoptive parents, and for a short time between Carrie and Suzanne and their aunt and uncle. It's Carrie's book, not Carrie and Mark's, and while that isn't necessarily a fault per se - many good books focus on one main character - it isn't what I look for in a romance. 3 stars.