What do you think?
Rate this book


127 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 2, 2019
Edit: The author informed me a week after this review that they have pared back the italics. I haven't reread the book to confirm that, but it is quite possible that my biggest complaint about this book has subsequently been fixed. I'm leaving my review here as is since it reflects the book as I read it in, but know that my last paragraph and overall rating may no longer reflect the current state of the book.
I have very mixed feelings about this one; there is a lot of potential here that is marred by one persistent issue. The summary blurb actually gives you a pretty good idea of the direction the plot takes, so I won't rehash that. I will note that each of the characters mentioned by name is a PoV character, though two of them have more chapters than the third.
The good: Steele clearly has some talent as a writer. His descriptions of places are quite good at conveying the atmosphere and appearance of the location; when a character enters a forest or tavern you get a sense of what it looks like, smells like, and how the overall ambiance makes it feel like to be there. Some of the characters feel fairly close together in terms of personality, which isn't exactly great, but others feel quite unique; given enough time (this book is quite short) they could all develop unique voices. The dialogue is solid, and at times we get some pretty witty banter. The world is fairly interesting, if a bit generic, and we get tantalizing hints at events and mysteries that will (presumably) be explored in future books. Technical issues with the writing are minor, just a few typos in the form of unneeded commas or missing apostrophes.
The slightly bad: as previously mentioned this book is short, basically a novella in length. It is titled "Part One" and it truly does feel like it is just the first part of larger novel. Things do happen of course, but there just isn't enough time for events to really build up steam before the book ends. I likely would complain about this if I had bought this as the first book of a series or as a standalone, but given that this book is free it's more like this is a long free sample of the complete story. This seems relatively fair to me, though your opinion may differ.
The bad: I'm going to open this with a quote from Paul Robinson's essay "The Philosophy of Punctuation:"
Italics rarely fail to insult the reader's intelligence. More often than not they tell us to emphasize a word or phrase that we would emphasize automatically in any natural reading of the sentence.Steele either does not share this opinion, or he believes that all of his readers are idiots. Every sentence that ends in an exclamation point is italicized. All curses and swear words are italicized. Other words are italicized to make sure you absolutely understand what the speaking character is emphasizing. I believe that almost every single conversation had at least one italicized word, and most had multiple words or entire sentences. I never would have thought that I could be angered by perfectly legible typography, but the excessive amount of italics throughout the dialogue managed to distract me from what was happening and being said. If frequent use of italics as emphasis doesn't bother you then this is likely a non-issue, but for me it proved to be enough of an irritation to ruin my enjoyment of the story.