Re No Reprieve - Susan Napier dips onto the psychic plane in this one with an h who is literally called 'Mouse" and an H who is, in the h's words "a citizen of Sleazeville" as he runs a notorious scandal-mongering, muck-raking newspaper.
This seems like it should be a very fun book, and to be fair the humor is great in this one. The H and h chemistry is very well done and both characters are very strong. But there is a very, very dark theme under all of this and it is one that I have a hard time doing an adequate spoilerization for because I am so morally outraged by the outcome. I will tolerate a lot in HPlandia, but this outcome I just couldn't come to terms with.
The book opens with the H storming into the quiet, introverted librarian h's home that she shares with her aunt. Her elderly aunt has a little side business of being a psychic and does tea readings and palmistry for various acquaintances. The h considers her aunt's eccentricities harmless fun and thinks it is good that her elderly aunt is getting a bit of spirit in her old age.
The h loves her aunt. When she and her twin sister were orphaned as children, her spinster aunt took them in and raised them with love and kindness. The h's parents were circus people and the h and her twin are genuinely psychic and used to do demonstrations as part of their parent's circus act. A fire swept through their caravan one night and the h and her sister were rescued but the parents did not survive.
The h, who finds it easier to pick on negative emotions as opposed to positive ones, gradually grew more and more introverted and reclusive. She is a librarian, but she doesn't watch tv, she doesn't read the news and she doesn't follow local events. She tries to distance herself from everyday life as much as possible because otherwise she gets overwhelmed with the miserable situations that happen to people and all that pain and sorrow and hurt is really wearing on her psyche.
The H on the other hand, is a born muckraker. However, part of his journalistic muckraking drive comes from having his daughter kidnapped when she was a toddler. The H and his daughter's mother had a brief fling, she got preggers and wasn't interested in motherhood so she left and the H kept his daughter and dearly loved her. A woman who had recently lost her own child took the H's daughter (this is revealed over the course of the story,) and she and her husband escaped from New Zealand to Australia.
The H has spent many tormented years trying to find his little girl, and as a journalist he is all too aware of the harsh realities of what happens to kidnapped children. He storms the h's home because the h's aunt has been charging the H's mother - who is just as tormented as the H by the loss of her grandchild- to do psychic readings on the premise that she can locate the little girl.
The aunt has no psychic abilities, but the h does and the h got a feeling that the little girl was safe when she saw a picture of the child in an old newspaper. The h did not really read the article, she just saw the headline and saw the picture and knew the girl was okay.
However the aunt seems to be determined to continue the charade with the H's mother, but she is using the h's skills in lieu of her lack. The h is against this, she really gets angry. But her aunt just keeps pushing things and eventually this leads to closer involvement with the H - even tho he is beyond skeptical and the h is very aware of how harsh and critical other's can be about her talent. The h is getting more and more impressions of the H's daughter and in the process she is getting closer and closer to the H. He likes her back and eventually they become lovers.
The H's mother then has a spell and ends in hospital and the h gets one of her feelings. The h finds the little girl on the children's ward of the hospital and tells the H. The h and H talk their way onto the children's ward and his daughter is there. But she thinks she was adopted, her 'mother' -really the lady who kidnapped her- lost her husband after they had been wandering around Australia for a bit.
They were in a remote mining region and the 'mother' was taken in by the little girl's adopted parents. The kidnapper soon realized that she preferred her freedom to having a child to care for and since the couple that took them in were desperate for a child, the kidnapper left the little girl with them. To their credit, they love the little girl and they took exceptional care of her and even the kidnapper did her best to make sure the girl was safe and loved.
The kidnapper eventually drowned in an accident and then the little girl got meningitis when her adoptive parents moved back to New Zealand, this led to the hospital stay and discovery by the h and H. The H visits every day and finally tells the adoptive parents that they have his child. Here is where I lose the plot and wind up smashing the book against the wall.
The adoptive parents knew there was something off about the whole situation, so they never formally or legally adopted the little girl. When the H explains that they have his child, the mother gets belligerent and demands that the H give up his daughter. This was all highly dramatic but I felt the woman should have been brained with a skillet.
Irregardless of how much they loved the little girl, they KNEW something was wrong and they did NOTHING about it. That in my world view completely disqualifies you from being a parent - period. You STOLE someone else's baby and then throw a fit when that parent, who has been through YEARS of torment and anguish, wants his child back. If you do that, you don't deserve sewer slurping status, let alone parenthood.
The little girl is six at this point, so the H caves, he allows the parasite slime swillers to adopt his child, as long as she knows he is her father and he can set up a trust fund for her. The h, having helped the H through what has easily been the most horrific experience of his life when he gives up all rights to his child, feels like her presence and her psychic abilities will only serve as a harsh reminder of all the H had to endure only to have it end in pain. She leaves the H and goes off on her own, alone and miserable because she really loves the H.
The h's twin sister, who is a very free spirit and roaming the world, calls the H and tells the H that the h is somewhere connected to Anthony Perkins in the north and that the h needs the H desperately. The H does some journalistic snooping and finds the h at the Bates motel - there were several sly Psycho references in there too, which was good cause light relief was definitely needed at that point.
The H and h finally talk about the major events and the H is just happy that his daughter is safe, has a family and that he can be in her life too. He loves the h, doesn't mind her psychic abilities because it reunited him with his daughter and he is marrying the h asap, before any other poaching male tries to find out that there is a lion under the h's mouse exterior.
We get a little epilogue where the H and h have their own child, the H retired from muckraking news and now writes novels, his first daughter is visiting while her parents are on holiday and the H is gradually learning to cope with fear of being separated from his daughter with the h, whose uncomfortable psychic visions have decreased in frequency. The h's aunt and the H's mum are very best friends and everyone is happy and together for the HEA.
This is an excellently written book. The interactions between the H and h are fantastic. I just couldn't handle the outcome for the H's daughter or the callous lack of empathy the adoptive sewer sludge had for a man who has his child ripped away from him through no fault of his own. This book made me deeply uneasy and that is really because of my own personal ethics and POV. So my tirade shouldn't discourage anyone from trying this one.
It is an unusual HP, the h and H are fabulous in their character growth and the story is very compelling. Give this one a try if the truly different kind of HPlandia outing appeals, I don't think anyone will be sorry if they do.