There is no doubting that the Washington DC area has for many years been a stronghold of high school basketball, with a greater metropolitan area covering the District, northern Virginia and southern Maryland. It may be, it seems from the outside, that this is in part an effect of the absence of other forms of elite and of professional sport from the region, but it seems also to be an effect of a powerful local culture emphasising the importance of basketball and an attachment to high schools in an area with what may well be a highly transient population around the importance of Federal Government institutions. Whatever the reason, basketball is a potent force in a range of local high school leagues built around public schools, a network of Catholic and other independent schools and until the early 1960s a powerful set of Black schools.
Not surprisingly, such a powerful force that could attract over 10,000 people to an inter-league final, would have its dominant figures – mainly coaches, and its heroic stories of individual players, of teams and of coaches, its tragedies, and its chroniclers. John McNamara is one such chronicler, formerly a local sports reporter for many years until he was killed in a shooter attack on his newspaper office adding a layer of tragedy to the existence of the book. This book is very much a chronicle, built around the last 5 decades of the 20th century the emphasis is on stories of post war rivalry, power and development, of the shifting forces of power and influence across the areas component regions and between leagues.
McNamara highlights dominant teams and individuals – it’s intriguing how some schools maintain their dominance over so much of the period, given that the players have, for the most part, careers of no more than three years. Yet the same schools keep turning up in the finals: the turnover of players in the 50 year scope is huge. Equally interesting is the intermittent appearance of other schools as powerful forces for a few years, sometimes a decade or more apart, linked to a cluster of players or the effects of a specific coach and more often than not a serendipitous confluence of both. This is a ‘data rich’ book demonstrating an astounding depth of knowledge about a place where the significance may be seen in the sheer number of NBA and NCAA players of note (so much of note that even I recognised many of the names).
This ‘data richness’ however comes at the expense of an overarching narrative meaning that although this is not a nostalgic narrative it is a commemorative one, marking major events, highlighting key individuals and celebrating great moments it stumbles. It does not have the contextual framing that I’d hope to see in a social history of the era, making this very much a history of a set of sporting events, rivalries, matches, framed by the institutions – schools, leagues and localities – that give them meaning. I suspect if I was a long term DC resident, I’d have read this differently.