Rocking the Boat (1963) is Gore Vidal’s first essay collection, wherein he sets his erudite mind on varying topics related to politics, theater, and literature. It’s exciting to read essays from his earliest years, comparing their conclusions to his later essays. You can get a sense of how he evolved as an essayist, putting in more of his acerbic wit as he grows more comfortable with the format.
One example of this evolution is the book’s opening essay, “John F. Kennedy: A Translation for the English,” which presents a rather straightforward analysis of the then-newly inaugurated commander-in-chief. Vidal ran for congress in 1960 and was a friend to JFK, which makes the tone of this piece more conciliatory than his later remarks on the age we now refer to as “Camelot.” One striking phenomenon that Vidal points out is the growing ascendency of intellectuals in Kennedy’s orbit, a stark departure from the presidency of Dwight D. Eisenhower. Vidal’s take-away is that Kennedy seems to be a genuine break with the past and how it’s all for the better. The Bay of Pigs debacle, which happened months after this piece was published and Vidal comments on in the appendix to this volume, scuttled any of his optimism.
Many of the essays here are as timely as ever. “Closing the Civilization Gap” is a visceral reflection on the barbarism of police violence and the lengths to which society neglects to hold law enforcement accountable for its own crimes. “Love Love Love” comments on the growing trend in popular entertainment, in this case the theater, that abandons substantive emotional investigations in exchange for superficial sentimentality. He also writes passionately about the defense of civil liberties in two pieces focusing on the House Un-American Activities Committee and its retrograde investigations during the McCarthy era. My favorite essay is “Norman Mailer: The Angels are White,” an insightful meditation on the popular writer and the limitations of grasping for authenticity.
Rocking the Boat is a portrait of the essayist as a young man, still finding his voice and developing his talents as a commentator. It makes for fun, engaging, and always enlightening reading.