Gianno Caldwell makes some really good points about being a Republican vs being a Democrat. Again, I am of the belief that everything should be about ideas and not parties but if ever there was a person who defended being a Republican when he could so easily be a Democrat, it is Caldwell.
I read this book, surprisingly, because President Trump tweeted about it and recommended it. You see, I'm still trying to learn about the differences and political parties and such.
In this book, I particularly liked the progression of his antagonist, Democratic Richard Fowler, and how their fiery debate on a FoxNews panel went viral and they used that to go speak in schools together (and I love how Caldwell later noted that he and Fowler are now friends)
Caldwell's book was well thought out and nicely presented. It was storytelling interspersed with facts to keep the reader engrossed. Some of the content was harsh and absurdly subjective but as far as convincing people to see things more his way, I think that it would be somewhat more successful, if the right people read it. I gave it only four stars because of some of the saturated Republican and God praising that I felt did not add to his story.
Another reason I felt it only was worth four stars was his use of shocking his readers with explicit details. Shock factor may work for some of his audience but I think it's time to go beyond the shock factor: yes, our world is fucked up. Stop telling us how fucked up it is and tell us more about how to fix it.
I'm sad to say that Caldwell's book was the first I'd heard of The First Step Act. I have since started reading up about it and the First Step Act and it's criminal justice reform as well as its bipartisanship support.
On the other side of the coin, I was impressed when Caldwell was upset about the way President Trump handled the tragedy in of Charlottesville, Virginia where "massive gathering of neo-Nazis, neo-Confederates, southern nationalists, and alt-right militias from across the country."
"But now the president of the United States had just given a group whose sole purpose and history have been based on hate and the elimination of blacks and Jews moral equivalence with the genuine counterprotesters. My grandfather was born and raised in Helena, Arkansas, where the KKK sought to kill him and other family members. You can imagine this issue was very personal to me. In Chicago, the day before Trump’s press conference, my grandfather and I had had a long conversation about Charlottesville, and his words to me were fresh in my mind.
"So, yeah, I was hurt. Angry. Frustrated. Sad."
Yes, I was too. I cried. I knew, I knew 100% heart and soul that President Obama would have handled it beautifully.
"But as I reflected on what the president could have done or said differently, I also remembered what it felt like in the weeks following 9/11. When, for a few glorious weeks, we were all united as Americans. For a brief time, it didn’t seem to matter if you were black, white, or brown. We were all brothers and sisters because we were Americans. We shared certain values, a certain past, a certain goal.
"We haven’t really seen that since.
"Charlottesville, I knew, had the same potential to unite us.
"But Trump’s response derailed that opportunity. America didn’t need a stock statement. The country was pleading for a serious discussion about race, about our fundamental need to completely stamp out the Klan and neo-Nazis. I couldn’t help but think of the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing and the Charleston church shooting. Emmett Till and Jimmie Lee Jackson. Black Codes and the Southern Manifesto.
"Trump, I felt, had betrayed black America.
"And Jewish America. And American decency."
Caldwell was on a talk show the following day. He threw away his planned points of discussion and spoke from his heart.
"The words just came out: “I come today with a very heavy heart. Last night, I couldn’t sleep at all because President Trump, our president, has literally betrayed the conscience of our country…the very moral fabric in which we’ve made progress when it comes to race relations in America….He’s failed us.”"
Caldwell is beyond the parties, if only there were no parties, he would get a lot more support. I have to believe that maybe, just maybe, his ideas and ideals would gain the support of millennials and GenZers.
"Only when people feel comfortable discussing race or gender or creed or socioeconomic status honestly will true change occur. When Americans can freely talk to one another, and listen, and allow for those uncomfortable moments that happen in a free society. Such communication does not come from the position that what came before me must be wrong; that what my opponent is proposing must be wrong; that only my team’s words are correct and all others are racist, sexist, micro-aggressive, threatening…"
"Our future is of our own making.
And I know that it will be extraordinary."
Mister Gianno Caldwell, if you ever run for president, no matter what party, you have my vote.