What do you think?
Rate this book
A Case for the Book of Mormon
“The Book of Mormon,” Tad R. Callister unequivocally states, “is God’s crowning witness of the divinity of Jesus Christ, the prophetic calling of Joseph Smith, and the absolute truth of this Church. It is all it claims to be. It is the word of God.” But over the years, many critics have claimed otherwise. In this logical examination of many of the critics’ claims, the author offers a compelling defense of the Book of Mormon. In addition, he outlines six further evidences of its divine authenticity and its ability to influence our lives for good. Ultimately, the author helps readers clearly understand how they can learn for themselves—not only intellectually, but spiritually—that the Book of Mormon is true.
262 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2019
275 people are currently reading
1328 people want to read
About the author
Tad R. Callister
11 books130 followersTad R. Callister is an emeritus General Authority Seventy and was the 21st Sunday School General President of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. He served in the Presidency of the Seventy from 2011 until 2014 when he was called as Sunday School General President. Brother Callister received a BS in accounting from Brigham Young University, a JD from the University of California-Los Angeles, and an MS in tax law from New York University Law School. He spent most of his professional career practicing tax law. He is the author of the best-selling books The Infinite Atonement, A Case for the Book of Mormon, The Inevitable Apostasy, and The Blueprint of Christ's Church. He and his wife, Kathryn Louise Saporiti, are the parents of six children.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 300 reviews
April 3, 2019
If you enjoyed other books by Elder Callister, then you will like this one also. Provides an intelligent brief overview of what the critics have said about the Book of Mormon while providing credible counterpoints. Makes you think. (Just when I think I have the Book of Mormon figured out, along comes more stuff to ponder. There’s just too much to this scriptural work to dismiss it as unimportant in my opinion. The Book of Mormon might just be the most criticized book by those who have admittedly never even read it!)
February 20, 2019
I got to listen to an advanced copy of the book on CD, read by the author.
Fantastic book! Some of the points made in the book will be familiar if you have read his previous book, "The Blueprint of Christ's Church." But these points are fleshed out in greater detail in this volume.
The first part of the book plays "defense" against some common criticisms of the Book of Mormon and its origins. Callister tackles these criticisms head on, exploiting the fallacy of the theories put forth to try to explain away the book. He also openly acknowledges that he doesn't have an answer for every complaint put forth, but uses past evidences to suggest that just because we don't have an answer now, doesn't mean we won't have an answer later. For example, the Book of Mormon was mocked for its mention of barley, cement, and other things thought to not exist in pre-Columbian America. But discoveries have since proven that these things did in fact exist. Time will surely reveal the truth of other things as well.
In the next part of the book, Callister switches to "offense," declaring that the burden of proof does not have to fall on believers of the Book of Mormon. While critics may nitpick to try to find fault, Callister points out an overwhelming amount of truth in the book that everybody needs to face and grapple with. There is no way that an obscure farm boy could have created such beautiful Gospel teachings that were hidden from religious scholars and experts for over a thousand years.
But when it all comes down to it, the questions and answers put forth pale to the testimony of the Holy Ghost. God desires to bear His personal witness through His Spirit of the truth of the Book of Mormon. The points made by the author are helpful in confirming testimony, but the author acknowledges that these things do not create the testimony. Only the witness of the Holy Ghost can do that.
Fantastic book! Some of the points made in the book will be familiar if you have read his previous book, "The Blueprint of Christ's Church." But these points are fleshed out in greater detail in this volume.
The first part of the book plays "defense" against some common criticisms of the Book of Mormon and its origins. Callister tackles these criticisms head on, exploiting the fallacy of the theories put forth to try to explain away the book. He also openly acknowledges that he doesn't have an answer for every complaint put forth, but uses past evidences to suggest that just because we don't have an answer now, doesn't mean we won't have an answer later. For example, the Book of Mormon was mocked for its mention of barley, cement, and other things thought to not exist in pre-Columbian America. But discoveries have since proven that these things did in fact exist. Time will surely reveal the truth of other things as well.
In the next part of the book, Callister switches to "offense," declaring that the burden of proof does not have to fall on believers of the Book of Mormon. While critics may nitpick to try to find fault, Callister points out an overwhelming amount of truth in the book that everybody needs to face and grapple with. There is no way that an obscure farm boy could have created such beautiful Gospel teachings that were hidden from religious scholars and experts for over a thousand years.
But when it all comes down to it, the questions and answers put forth pale to the testimony of the Holy Ghost. God desires to bear His personal witness through His Spirit of the truth of the Book of Mormon. The points made by the author are helpful in confirming testimony, but the author acknowledges that these things do not create the testimony. Only the witness of the Holy Ghost can do that.
August 10, 2019
First, the good. Callister’s treatment of the witnesses to the Book of Mormon is very good and very thorough. He brings to light sources from each witness, many which are not widely known, especially the later Whitmer interviews. The footnotes and cited material in the witness section of the book is truly first-rate, and this research is a welcome contribution to the discussion.
I wish I could be as flattering about the remainder of the book. I felt I was wading through a series of false dichotomies, sloppy conclusions, and rhetorical swiss cheese.
Most of my issues stem from the fact that Callister fails to acknowledge two essential, non-controversial facts about the Book of Mormon: (1) it is not an ancient document, and (2) it is a man-made product.
And yes, those two facts are not controversial, even from a believing perspective because (1) the Book of Mormon claims to be a translation of an ancient document, not an ancient document itself, and (2) the Book of Mormon claims to be written by Nephi, Jacob, Mormon, Moroni, and others, and translated by Joseph Smith, all of whom were men, and none of whom were God.
This may seem like legalistic hairsplitting, but these facts are crucial to understand, and make questions like “is the Book of Mormon divine, or man-made?” completely inappropriate false dichotomies. Worse is the opening question: “is the Book of Mormon from God or the Devil,” another false dichotomy that the least bit of creative thought would obliterate.
Furthermore, the discussion about anachronisms and King James language is completely stillborn without a grounding discussion of the implications of a 19th-century translation into English, however, it was done. We can assess the accuracy of any given Bible translation by comparing it to source manuscripts. But given that the ancient source for the Book of Mormon is not available for examination, there is no reasonable way to assess the degree to which the English rendering reflects the wording, language, or terminology of the original. Thus when “ticking clocks” (anachronisms) appear in the English translation, we have no way of seeing if the anachronism was “really” there, or if that was simply an artifact or byproduct of a modern translation. Failing to acknowledge this crucial point renders entire sections of this book obsolete.
Callister’s arguments refuting dated authorship theories like the Spaulding and View of the Hebrews is decently solid, but when he gets into theological territory, he seems completely out of his depth. The becoming-like-Christ percentile question he asked his Christian friend seems very inappropriate and doctrinally off-base, and the fact that he still believes that mode-of-baptism is still an urgent doctrinal issue for a 21st-century truth seeker is revealing, to say nothing of the fact that the Book of Mormon, while it does explicitly mention immersion, does not seem nearly as concerned about making sure everyone knows about it as Callister does.
The demand that critics offer the whole truth without selectively choosing what to present seemed incredibly incongruous to his free pass given to milk-before-meat teaching, where the whole truth may have been intended to be disclosed eventually, but intentionally withheld initially. The reality that Callister seems to allude to is one in which milk-before-meat transitions into not meat, but just an endless supply of milk.
There’s so much more to gripe about, but ultimately, the Book of Mormon deserves a much better case than Callister gives it here. Time and time again I cringed at his bad logic and the naive, unexamined assumptions that undergird the majority of this book.
I have serious concerns about Calilster’s qualifications as a lawyer, given the inexcusable carelessness of reasoning and argument in this supposedly definitive apologetic work on the Book of Mormon.
But thanks for the new collection of sources about the witnesses, those were actually really helpful!
I wish I could be as flattering about the remainder of the book. I felt I was wading through a series of false dichotomies, sloppy conclusions, and rhetorical swiss cheese.
Most of my issues stem from the fact that Callister fails to acknowledge two essential, non-controversial facts about the Book of Mormon: (1) it is not an ancient document, and (2) it is a man-made product.
And yes, those two facts are not controversial, even from a believing perspective because (1) the Book of Mormon claims to be a translation of an ancient document, not an ancient document itself, and (2) the Book of Mormon claims to be written by Nephi, Jacob, Mormon, Moroni, and others, and translated by Joseph Smith, all of whom were men, and none of whom were God.
This may seem like legalistic hairsplitting, but these facts are crucial to understand, and make questions like “is the Book of Mormon divine, or man-made?” completely inappropriate false dichotomies. Worse is the opening question: “is the Book of Mormon from God or the Devil,” another false dichotomy that the least bit of creative thought would obliterate.
Furthermore, the discussion about anachronisms and King James language is completely stillborn without a grounding discussion of the implications of a 19th-century translation into English, however, it was done. We can assess the accuracy of any given Bible translation by comparing it to source manuscripts. But given that the ancient source for the Book of Mormon is not available for examination, there is no reasonable way to assess the degree to which the English rendering reflects the wording, language, or terminology of the original. Thus when “ticking clocks” (anachronisms) appear in the English translation, we have no way of seeing if the anachronism was “really” there, or if that was simply an artifact or byproduct of a modern translation. Failing to acknowledge this crucial point renders entire sections of this book obsolete.
Callister’s arguments refuting dated authorship theories like the Spaulding and View of the Hebrews is decently solid, but when he gets into theological territory, he seems completely out of his depth. The becoming-like-Christ percentile question he asked his Christian friend seems very inappropriate and doctrinally off-base, and the fact that he still believes that mode-of-baptism is still an urgent doctrinal issue for a 21st-century truth seeker is revealing, to say nothing of the fact that the Book of Mormon, while it does explicitly mention immersion, does not seem nearly as concerned about making sure everyone knows about it as Callister does.
The demand that critics offer the whole truth without selectively choosing what to present seemed incredibly incongruous to his free pass given to milk-before-meat teaching, where the whole truth may have been intended to be disclosed eventually, but intentionally withheld initially. The reality that Callister seems to allude to is one in which milk-before-meat transitions into not meat, but just an endless supply of milk.
There’s so much more to gripe about, but ultimately, the Book of Mormon deserves a much better case than Callister gives it here. Time and time again I cringed at his bad logic and the naive, unexamined assumptions that undergird the majority of this book.
I have serious concerns about Calilster’s qualifications as a lawyer, given the inexcusable carelessness of reasoning and argument in this supposedly definitive apologetic work on the Book of Mormon.
But thanks for the new collection of sources about the witnesses, those were actually really helpful!
March 31, 2021
This book expands on a memorable General Conference talk Brother Callister gave in October of 2017. I appreciate the way in which he highlights just how much of a miracle the Book of Mormon truly is. It's here. It's the tangible evidence of the Restoration. You have to account for it somehow. Too often it seems we, as people of faith, find ourselves taking a defensive posture. With this book, Brother Callister goes on the offense, and rightfully so.
"This book focuses on a case for the Book of Mormon, but in one sense the Book of Mormon does not need a case presented on its behalf. It is its own best witness -- its own best evidence. It is the unmitigated word of God from beginning to end; it teaches the doctrine of Christ in its purity; it bears witness of the Savior with precision and power; and it invites the Spirit in unrestrained proportions. Every aspect of the Book of Mormon bears witness of its divine origin because, in fact, it is divinely inspired."
"This book focuses on a case for the Book of Mormon, but in one sense the Book of Mormon does not need a case presented on its behalf. It is its own best witness -- its own best evidence. It is the unmitigated word of God from beginning to end; it teaches the doctrine of Christ in its purity; it bears witness of the Savior with precision and power; and it invites the Spirit in unrestrained proportions. Every aspect of the Book of Mormon bears witness of its divine origin because, in fact, it is divinely inspired."
November 24, 2019
Interesting and fascinating
January 29, 2020
Oh, man. Absolutely incredible.
Tad R. Callister had been a favorite author of mine since I read "The Infinite Atonement" almost 20 years ago and it became an instant favorite, landing itself a spot on my bookcase forever. So, I was looking forward to this book, but I had no idea how much I would love it.
Well-researched and well-written, "A Case for the Book of Mormon" makes the unapologetic case for the truthfulness of the Book of Mormon. Or maybe, more accurately, it makes the case for the impossibility of the Book of Mormon being a falsity or fabrication .
Note that this book is not the place where you will (or even should) gain your testimony of the truthfulness of the Book of Mormon—that will (and always should) be by sincerely studying it and then following the promise extended in Moroni 10:3–5 to ask of God yourself. However, "The Case for the Book of Mormon" may be the place that piques your interest in finding out for yourself. Alternatively, it may be the place that sets the record straight for you regarding the attacks on the Book of Mormon—as the world combats your faith in the Book of Mormon and the prophetic calling of Joseph Smith— by revealing those attacks as the half-truths, misinformation, strawman fallacies and/or radical stretches of reason that they are.
As an aside, Tad's brother, Douglas L. Callister (also a General Authority Emeritus), was Area Authority over my mission and visited our mission several times. I am still changed from the stories, testimony, and the vision he shared but it was the power, authority and Spirit by which he spoke that I will never forget. His testimony radiated from him—a rock-solid spiritual knowledge of the Gospel and the Church, firmly anchored in the Rock Himself, our Savior Jesus Christ.
Even through the pages of a printed book or the recorded tracks of an audiobook, Tad R. Callister radiates the same firm foundation of testimony as his brother, Douglas. In fact, I actually recommend listening to this as an audiobook. Hearing the author's voice, inflection, and delivery takes the content to a new level.
This book, too, has earned itself a "spot on my bookcase" forever.
Tad R. Callister had been a favorite author of mine since I read "The Infinite Atonement" almost 20 years ago and it became an instant favorite, landing itself a spot on my bookcase forever. So, I was looking forward to this book, but I had no idea how much I would love it.
Well-researched and well-written, "A Case for the Book of Mormon" makes the unapologetic case for the truthfulness of the Book of Mormon. Or maybe, more accurately, it makes the case for the impossibility of the Book of Mormon being a falsity or fabrication .
Note that this book is not the place where you will (or even should) gain your testimony of the truthfulness of the Book of Mormon—that will (and always should) be by sincerely studying it and then following the promise extended in Moroni 10:3–5 to ask of God yourself. However, "The Case for the Book of Mormon" may be the place that piques your interest in finding out for yourself. Alternatively, it may be the place that sets the record straight for you regarding the attacks on the Book of Mormon—as the world combats your faith in the Book of Mormon and the prophetic calling of Joseph Smith— by revealing those attacks as the half-truths, misinformation, strawman fallacies and/or radical stretches of reason that they are.
As an aside, Tad's brother, Douglas L. Callister (also a General Authority Emeritus), was Area Authority over my mission and visited our mission several times. I am still changed from the stories, testimony, and the vision he shared but it was the power, authority and Spirit by which he spoke that I will never forget. His testimony radiated from him—a rock-solid spiritual knowledge of the Gospel and the Church, firmly anchored in the Rock Himself, our Savior Jesus Christ.
Even through the pages of a printed book or the recorded tracks of an audiobook, Tad R. Callister radiates the same firm foundation of testimony as his brother, Douglas. In fact, I actually recommend listening to this as an audiobook. Hearing the author's voice, inflection, and delivery takes the content to a new level.
This book, too, has earned itself a "spot on my bookcase" forever.
July 26, 2020
I recommend this book to anyone and everyone, whether a member of The Church or Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints or not. Fantastic, straight forward, testimony building. I borrowed a digital copy but will be purchasing a hard copy to have on hand and want my 11-year-old son, and eventually all my children to read it. I love how the author explains how science and archeologic evidences should not be what we build a testimony upon, but should not be discounted as a means that can strengthen our testimonies. This book went through several critics’ arguments against the Book of Mormon and shows just how unbelievable and unlikely these theories are. I love the second half of the book that covers gaining a firm testimony through the Spirit and the importance of doing so.
March 30, 2019
Very thorough and well-written. You can tell he is a lawyer by how sound his logic is. I love how he says that the Book of Mormon doesn’t need to have a logical explanation, but it doesn’t hurt to have it (he says it better so read the book!)
August 4, 2019
This is an outstanding book! Extremely well researched, logical and well thought out, intelligently written and yet it's easily understood and very engaging. Highly recommended.
August 6, 2019
4.5
The first third of the book is all information I have read elsewhere presented in more depth and in many instances more convincingly.
Where this book shines follows in the next sections where Callister concentrates on spiritual matters and the spirit glows through his writing.
The first third of the book is all information I have read elsewhere presented in more depth and in many instances more convincingly.
Where this book shines follows in the next sections where Callister concentrates on spiritual matters and the spirit glows through his writing.
May 3, 2020
Powerful witness of the Book of Mormon with historical facts and logic of the truthfulness of this magnificent book of scripture. I wish everyone who doubts the authenticity of the Bookof Mormon would read Callister's book AND read The Book of Mormon.
March 21, 2019
It's soooo good! I know people will still find a way, but even after reading just half of this I couldn't see how anyone could believe that Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon and that it is not of Divine origin! Callister lays it out in classic style, thoroughly and comprehensively, every major critical argument against the Book of Mormon and then shows how their argument actually shows support for the fact that it must be of Divine origin. He then goes on the offense and displays a thorough review of the astounding doctrinal and literary clarity that the Book of Mormon has, once again showing the impossible explanation that Joseph Smith wrote it just cannot be true. He then spend the rest of the book highlighting just how much good the Book of Mormon contributes to christianity and to the personal lives of those who sincerely study it. Amazing book. Instant classic.
January 6, 2021
Tad Callister is a lawyer, and I think it is important to keep that in mind as you read this book. He is not a historian or a theologian who will carefully present both sides. His goal is to present the data in a way that will persuade the reader to agree with him. While I do side with him, I don't think this book will be helpful to an outsider or critic, who may feel that he unfairly represented their positions. It is a broad overview of many issues, and it will appeal to someone who wants an elevator pitch they can give to explain the evidence for the Book of Mormon.
Callister begins and ends by stating that the Book of Mormon must be divinely authentic or a man-made fraud. The purpose and message of the book do not allow it to be the work of the devil, nor does the historical record support it being a "pious" fraud. He then gives an overview of some critical arguments against the Book of Mormon. First, in discussing authorship, he shows that it does not make sense for someone like Oliver Cowdery or Sidney Rigdon to have written the Book, nor does it match any of the supposed sources like View of the Hebrews of Spaulding's manuscript. As I said, I don't know if these are just straw men, but in my research it does seem that critics have yet to come up with a coherent narrative to explain the origin of the Book of Mormon that matches historical sources.
He then goes through past accusations of anachronisms that have been proven to be accurate (large cities, metal plates, cement, barley, Alma as a male name, and the frequency of "And it came to pass"). He uses these examples to argue that we should not be concerned about other items, like elephants, horses, chariots, silk, and steel, because they will likely be found. He quotes Kerry Hull to show readers that archaeologists have only unearthed a small percentage of the Americas, and there is no evidence to claim that it is enough for a "representative sample."
Callister discusses the 11 witnesses to the plates and Book of Mormon, who never denied it, even when their reputations and lives depended on it. He acknowledges that this is a summary of research by Richard L. Anderson, which I think I should read to get more depth. I also wish he had discussed some of the other witnesses, like Mary Whitmer, who were initially skeptical.
Callister directs much of his argument at Christians. He points out that there are plenty of things in the Bible which have no archaeological evidence, yet Christians have no problem believing those. He mentions those who say that becoming like Christ is blasphemous, but he asks the question, if we can become like Christ to a degree, say 5 percent, why not 100 percent, as the scriptures command? He also addresses the idea that the Book of Mormon is "Trinitarian," which is a claim that can only be made by isolating verses that discuss God's oneness without acknowledging the verses that highlight different roles for the Father and Son. Again, I'm not sure if Callister accurately represents the Christian view of the Trinity, but that's a difficult topic to understand for anyone.
He goes on to make the positive case for the Book of Mormon, with ancient evidences like chiasmus. He discusses the groundbreaking doctrine taught in the book, like the Plan of Salvation & Fortunate Fall, the correct mode of baptism, ongoing revelation outside the Bible, and the Atonement. I do believe that Joseph Smith taught some radical theology, but I would be curious to know how this compared to other American Protestants--if these were completely unique, or just rare. I'd need a lot more context than the quotes provided in this book to come to a conclusion.
He mentions some verses in the Bible that prophesy of the Book of Mormon. John 10:16, Ezekiel 37:17, Revelation 14:6, and Isaiah 29 are fairly well known in our Church. I didn't realize that Genesis 49:22 and Deuteronomy 33:13 mention the descendants of the tribe of Joseph having a promised land, and seem to imply that they should be as blessed as Judah. There is also a short section of iconic quotes from the Book of Mormon that are memorable and powerful. The implication of all this is that Joseph Smith would have to be a genius to come up with a Book that so eloquently matches the Bible while also standing on its own as a holy text.
Here is where I think the argument becomes subjective. Believers elevate the Book of Mormon to a masterpiece that a single farm-boy could never have written. Skeptics, on the other hand, see it as a copy of the Bible with obvious flaws that make it unremarkable. Because this is such a subjective judgment, I think each person has to weigh for themselves which side makes more sense.
Callister does concede that the Book of Mormon cannot be proven true scientifically or logically. These evidences may support your faith, but you have to gain a testimony through prayer and a witness of the Holy Spirit. He spends multiple chapters explaining this process. I agree with this process. Belief in the Book of Mormon is a personal choice, but it is one that should be made after reading the Book itself and thoughtfully evaluating its fruits.
Callister begins and ends by stating that the Book of Mormon must be divinely authentic or a man-made fraud. The purpose and message of the book do not allow it to be the work of the devil, nor does the historical record support it being a "pious" fraud. He then gives an overview of some critical arguments against the Book of Mormon. First, in discussing authorship, he shows that it does not make sense for someone like Oliver Cowdery or Sidney Rigdon to have written the Book, nor does it match any of the supposed sources like View of the Hebrews of Spaulding's manuscript. As I said, I don't know if these are just straw men, but in my research it does seem that critics have yet to come up with a coherent narrative to explain the origin of the Book of Mormon that matches historical sources.
He then goes through past accusations of anachronisms that have been proven to be accurate (large cities, metal plates, cement, barley, Alma as a male name, and the frequency of "And it came to pass"). He uses these examples to argue that we should not be concerned about other items, like elephants, horses, chariots, silk, and steel, because they will likely be found. He quotes Kerry Hull to show readers that archaeologists have only unearthed a small percentage of the Americas, and there is no evidence to claim that it is enough for a "representative sample."
Callister discusses the 11 witnesses to the plates and Book of Mormon, who never denied it, even when their reputations and lives depended on it. He acknowledges that this is a summary of research by Richard L. Anderson, which I think I should read to get more depth. I also wish he had discussed some of the other witnesses, like Mary Whitmer, who were initially skeptical.
Callister directs much of his argument at Christians. He points out that there are plenty of things in the Bible which have no archaeological evidence, yet Christians have no problem believing those. He mentions those who say that becoming like Christ is blasphemous, but he asks the question, if we can become like Christ to a degree, say 5 percent, why not 100 percent, as the scriptures command? He also addresses the idea that the Book of Mormon is "Trinitarian," which is a claim that can only be made by isolating verses that discuss God's oneness without acknowledging the verses that highlight different roles for the Father and Son. Again, I'm not sure if Callister accurately represents the Christian view of the Trinity, but that's a difficult topic to understand for anyone.
He goes on to make the positive case for the Book of Mormon, with ancient evidences like chiasmus. He discusses the groundbreaking doctrine taught in the book, like the Plan of Salvation & Fortunate Fall, the correct mode of baptism, ongoing revelation outside the Bible, and the Atonement. I do believe that Joseph Smith taught some radical theology, but I would be curious to know how this compared to other American Protestants--if these were completely unique, or just rare. I'd need a lot more context than the quotes provided in this book to come to a conclusion.
He mentions some verses in the Bible that prophesy of the Book of Mormon. John 10:16, Ezekiel 37:17, Revelation 14:6, and Isaiah 29 are fairly well known in our Church. I didn't realize that Genesis 49:22 and Deuteronomy 33:13 mention the descendants of the tribe of Joseph having a promised land, and seem to imply that they should be as blessed as Judah. There is also a short section of iconic quotes from the Book of Mormon that are memorable and powerful. The implication of all this is that Joseph Smith would have to be a genius to come up with a Book that so eloquently matches the Bible while also standing on its own as a holy text.
Here is where I think the argument becomes subjective. Believers elevate the Book of Mormon to a masterpiece that a single farm-boy could never have written. Skeptics, on the other hand, see it as a copy of the Bible with obvious flaws that make it unremarkable. Because this is such a subjective judgment, I think each person has to weigh for themselves which side makes more sense.
Callister does concede that the Book of Mormon cannot be proven true scientifically or logically. These evidences may support your faith, but you have to gain a testimony through prayer and a witness of the Holy Spirit. He spends multiple chapters explaining this process. I agree with this process. Belief in the Book of Mormon is a personal choice, but it is one that should be made after reading the Book itself and thoughtfully evaluating its fruits.
December 31, 2021
"The Book of Mormon is one of God’s most priceless gifts to us. It is both sword and
shield—it sends the word of God into battle to fight for the hearts of the just, and it serves as an arch defender of the truth."
This took way longer to read than it should have. I'll be honest...I got bored and then I'd fall asleep. The first half was super interesting, but then it got too wordy. It also could be that I'm already convinced of its truthfulness so some of it got redundant.
Despite all that it's a great read with lots of really good insight.
There's a lot of actual, physical proof that it was translated not written by Joseph Smith but, and it's a huge but, faith and a witness of its truthfulness through the Spirit is absolutely necessary. Which is very difficult for some people. I really like this quote from the book; "Once we have a foundational testimony of the Book of Mormon, as confirmed by the Spirit, then any question or challenge we confront in life, however difficult it may seem, can be approached with faith, not doubt."
So much of what the critics argue about the Book of Mormon is based on half truths. "Presenting a partial truth as the whole
truth in order to win an argument is nothing less than an untruth." I love that!
Another favorite quote; "recognizing and receiving spiritual truth is not a function of one’s IQ; rather it is a function of one’s faith and humility and willingness to live God’s
commandments." Boom!
shield—it sends the word of God into battle to fight for the hearts of the just, and it serves as an arch defender of the truth."
This took way longer to read than it should have. I'll be honest...I got bored and then I'd fall asleep. The first half was super interesting, but then it got too wordy. It also could be that I'm already convinced of its truthfulness so some of it got redundant.
Despite all that it's a great read with lots of really good insight.
There's a lot of actual, physical proof that it was translated not written by Joseph Smith but, and it's a huge but, faith and a witness of its truthfulness through the Spirit is absolutely necessary. Which is very difficult for some people. I really like this quote from the book; "Once we have a foundational testimony of the Book of Mormon, as confirmed by the Spirit, then any question or challenge we confront in life, however difficult it may seem, can be approached with faith, not doubt."
So much of what the critics argue about the Book of Mormon is based on half truths. "Presenting a partial truth as the whole
truth in order to win an argument is nothing less than an untruth." I love that!
Another favorite quote; "recognizing and receiving spiritual truth is not a function of one’s IQ; rather it is a function of one’s faith and humility and willingness to live God’s
commandments." Boom!
February 15, 2024
This is a great reminder of the power of the Book of Mormon and how it is its own witness of the truth. While some try to discount its authenticity and power, we can know for ourselves that it is the word of God. The Spirit testifies of truth. There are other evidences of its truth, but the Spirit is the most powerful. I know for myself that the Book of Mormon is true. It is the word of God. Here are some other great quotes about the Book of Mormon:
"The Book of Mormon is a book for all seasons. It is for all men and all women of all nations and races. If we are lonely or discouraged, its words can soothe our 'wounded souls.' If we feel the stain of sin or guilt, it can lead us to the Savior's cleansing powers. If our testimonies are waving, it can shore them up. If we have been incorrectly influenced by the philosophies of men, it can restore the truth. And if we desire to become more like Christ, it can be our spiritual catalyst. Whatever our circumstance or need, it can provide us with a remedy of superior healing power. It is God's divine gift to every soul who wants to return to Him and become more like Him (p. 3)."
"'The outrageous daring of its title page is the very thing that should whet the appetite of a real scholar: here is a book that is asking for a fight, so to speak' (Hugh Nibley, p. 4)."
"The Book of Mormon is either a divine work or a fraud (p. 5)."
"A fraud does not produce a fine moral treatise (p. 6)."
"The Book of Mormon is God's crowning witness of Jesus Christ... The testimony of this book, as confirmed by the Spirit, is the single most powerful and compelling witness we have of the divinity of Jesus Christ (p. 8)."
"'Each of us must accommodate the mixture of reason and revelation in our lives. The gospel not only permits but requires it' (Boyd K. Packer, p. 9)."
"Reason does not necessarily bring about conviction, but a lack of it creates a climate for doubt, while the presence of it creates a climate for belief (p. 9)."
"'The Book of Mormon is tough; it thrives on investigation; you may kick it around like a football, as many have done; and I promise you it will wear you out long before you ever make a dent in it' (Hugh Nibley, p. 9)."
"Once we have a foundational testimony of the Book of Mormon, as confirmed by the Spirit, then any question or challenge we confront in life... can be approached with faith, not doubt (p. 15)."
"This effort to disprove the Book of Mormon is no easy task--in fact, it is impossible, because the Book of Mormon is true (p. 16)."
"This assertion that someone who was ignorant and uneducated could write such a work as the Book of Mormon seemed so preposterous to other contemporary critics that they readily dismissed it and instead presented alternative theories for the books' origin (p. 17)."
"The similarities between the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Book of Mormon demonstrate that two records or books on the same subject can have parallels, even numerous parallels, without any trace whatsoever of plagiarism or influence upon one another (p. 24)."
"'Joseph Smith... could neither write nor dictate a coherent and well-worded letter, let alone dictate a book like the Book of Mormon' (Emma Smith, p. 28)."
"'My belief is that the Book of Mormon is of divine authenticity--I have not the slightest doubt of it' (Emma Smith, p. 30)."
"Josphe Smith's explanation of the coming forth of the Book of Mormon remains the only viable option (p. 31)."
"Professor Hugh Nibley challenged some of his students to write a book comparable to the Book of Mormon (p. 35)."
"The Book of Mormon is matchless--it is a work of God and therefore cannot be duplicated by man (p. 36)."
"Science and linguistics and other evidentiary sources have and will continue to vindicate the Book of Mormon as the word of God (p. 42)."
"'O Lord, what will the world say?'... 'Fear not, I will cause the earth to testify of the truth of these things' ([the Lord's response to Joseph Smith according to Charles A. Callis via LeGrand Richards], p. 42)."
"'Don't lose faith in what you know because of what you don't know!' (John Lund, p. 51)"
"Time and science are great allies of the Book of Mormon, and no doubt the earth will continue to reveal its treasures and produce further witnesses of the book's divine authenticity (p. 55)."
"'The absence of archaeological evidence is not evidence of absence' (Edwin Yamauchi, p. 57)."
"'There should be no cause for unbelief among the children of men' (Helaman 14:28, p. 57)."
"On occasion, the Lord gives us physical and intellectual signs to help us believe on Him--not as a replacement of the Spirit but as a supplement to it (p. 62)."
"'If there are faults they are the mistakes of men; wherefore, condemn not the things of God, that ye may be found spotless at the judgment-seat of Christ' (Title page of the Book of Mormon, p. 64)."
"God, who is perfect in every way, works with imperfect men to accomplish His work (p. 65)."
"The Spirit is the ultimate evidence (p. 66)."
"While I disagree with the Church's critics on most points, I recognize that among them are good, intelligent people (p. 86)."
"The doctrinal truths taught in the Book of Mormon are an overwhelming evidence of its divine authenticity (p. 92)."
"While the Bible acts as one witness of Jesus Christ and His doctrine, the Book of Mormon acts as another (p. 93)."
"The Book of Mormon clarifies what is confusing in much of the Christian world (p. 104)."
"It makes it clear that one must have priesthood authority to baptize, because God is a God of order (p. 105)."
"The Book of Mormon restored the truth that miracles continue in our day based on the faith of the people, just as they occurred in Christ's original Church (p. 109)."
"Divine language has a divine eloquence, simple but powerful, that appeals not only to the intellect but also to the heart... So it is with the Book of Mormon--it mobilizes the language of the Spirit and sends it into battle against Satan, against sin, against pride, against the false philosophies of men, against ignorance, against every enemy and obstacle that prevents us from returning to God and becoming more like Him. Its divine language leaves an indelible impression upon the mind while also causing a stirring of the soul (p. 123)."
"The testimonies of these eleven witnesses, in addition to Joseph Smith's testimony, are a powerful evidence of the truth of the Book of Mormon (p. 133)."
"'We recognize that our forebears were human. They doubtless made mistakes... But the mistakes were minor, when compared with the marvelous work which they accomplished. To highlight the mistakes and gloss over the greater good is to draw a caricature... There was only one perfect man who ever walked the earth. The Lord has used imperfect people in the process of building his perfect society' (Gordon B. Hinckley, p. 134)."
"In spite of these personal differences, none of these witnesses ever denied his testimony of the Book of Mormon--an incredible evidence of its truthfulness (p. 138)."
"With passion and consistency--never wavering--David Whitmer reaffirmed his testimony again and again and again (p. 147)."
"While all of the Three Witnesses were excommunicated from the Church and had personal differences with the Prophet Joseph Smith, the overwhelming evidence confirms they never denied their testimonies, contrary to any secondhand or hearsay statements presented by critics (p. 150)."
"'They were willing to die rather than deny the divine origin and the eternal truthfulness of the Book of Mormon' (p. 157)."
"'How can I deny what I know to be true' (p. 158)."
"One of the prime purposes of the Book of Mormon, as announced on its title page, is 'to the convincing of the Jew and Gentile that Jesus is the Christ, the Eternal God, manifesting himself unto all nations' (p. 165)."
"'Mormonism is obsessed with Christ, and everything that it teaches is meant to awaken, encourage, and expand faith in him. I came to this conclusion when I read through the Book of Mormon for the first time' (Stephen H. Webb, p. 166)."
"'Why not speak of the atonement of Christ, and attain to a perfect knowledge of him' (Jacob 4:12, p. 167)."
"The Book of Mormon helps us understand the expansiveness of Christ's cleansing powers by giving us specific examples of the depth to which one may sink and still be saved (p. 170)."
"One of the glorious insights into the Atonement of Jesus Christ, as taught in the Book of Mormon, is that the Savior can not only cleanse us but also perfect us (p. 176)."
"Nowhere is the Savior's Atonement taught more powerfully, more concisely, and more expansively than in the Book of Mormon. It restores much that has been lost or mystified on this most sublime of all gospel truths (p. 181)."
"The Book of Mormon also bears witness of Jesus Christ through its references to His multiple titles (p. 181)."
"Perhaps there is no greater demonstration of Christ's love and compassion in all scripture (excepting His Atonement) than that recorded in 3 Nephi 17 (p. 182)."
"Not only does the Book of Mormon teach us about Christ, it brings us to Christ (p. 183)."
"I believe that individuals who honestly read the Book of Mormon can learn by the Spirit 'that Jesus is the Christ, the Eternal God, manifesting himself unto all nations' (p. 184)."
"Ezekiel prophesied that the stick of Judah (meaning the record of the Jews, known as the Bible) and the stick of Joseph (meaning the record of Joseph's descendants, known as the Book of Mormon) shall be joined into one stick or book (p. 190)."
"The Book of Mormon was prophesied of in the Bible, not by name, but by events and descriptions (p. 192)."
"God has given us sufficient evidences not to replace our faith but to support our faith (p. 197)."
"Reliance on the Spirit will produce a testimony built on rock (p. 198)."
"In truth, the Book of Mormon does not need to be defended by outside sources; it is its own best witness. Its genius lies in the inherent converting power found within the text itself (p. 199)."
"Knowledge is an intellectual understanding of truth, while faith is a principle of action--it motivates us to live what we believe (p. 201)."
"Of all the witnesses to the Book of Mormon, there is none more certain or sure than that of the Spirit (p. 202)."
"The Book of Mormon... is not on trial. It is we who are on trial to see if we will read it with a sincere heart and real intent to discover and live its truths (p. 205)."
"Why is it critical for each of us to gain a testimony of the Book of Mormon?... The time will come when each of us will be faced with an intellectual question we cannot answer or a crisis that tries our faith to the very core (p. 206)."
"I am not an archaeologist or scientist, but I have felt the impressions of the Spirit of which Moroni testified, and when I read the Book of Mormon, I am so moved. Such has been my personal experience, and such is my testimony that this book is God-given, that it is of divine origin, that it is the word of God (p. 210)."
"The whisperings and impressions of the Spirit are all around us, but they will be drowned out and smothered by the noise of the secular world if we do not train our spiritual ears to hear them and our hearts to feel them (p. 213)."
"The voice of God thrives in a quiet, reverent setting (p. 215)."
"If you feel peace as you read the Book of Mormon, that is a witness from God to you, by the Spirit, that it is true. That peace may come as you read of the reality of the Resurrection, the goodness of God and His tender mercies, the certainty of complete forgiveness for those who repent, the power of the Savior to comfort, or our glorious divine destiny, but peace will come to the humble seeker of truth. It is a witness of the presence of the Spirit (p. 217)."
"If while reading the Book of Mormon you have a desire to be a better person, then that is your personal witness from the Spirit that what you are reading is from God (p. 218)."
"Another divine witness comes in the form of increased enlightenment and understanding (p. 219)."
"The Book of Mormon is not only the keystone of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, but it can also become the keystone of our testimonies (p. 229)."
"To suggest that Joseph Smith possessed the skills necessary to write this monumental work in a single draft in approximately sixty-five working days is simply counter to the realities of life (p. 232)."
"With regard to the Book of Mormon, each of us stands at a crossroads. One road leads to the conclusion that the Book of Mormon is man-made and thus a fraud. The other leads to the conclusion that the Book of Mormon is of divine origin and thus the word of God (p. 234)."
"'There is a power in the Book of Mormon which will begin to flow into your lives the moment you begin a serious study of the book. You will find greater power to resist temptation. You will find the power to avoid deception. You will find the power to stay on the strait and narrow path' (Ezra Taft Benson, p. 235)."
"'I feel certain that if, in our homes parents will read from the Book of Mormon prayerfully and regularly, both by themselves and with their children... the spirit of reverence will increase, mutual respect and consideration for each other will grow. The spirit of contention will depart... Righteousness will increase' (Marion G. Romney, p. 236)."
"'The Book of Mormon teaches how to resolve the problems and challenges that we face today that were foreseen by the Lord' (Richard G. Scott, p. 236)."
"'I promise you that if you will prayerfully read the Book of Mormon, regardless of how many times you previously have read it, there will come into your hearts an added measure of the Spirit of the Lord. There will come a strengthened resolution to walk in obedience to his commandments, and there will come a stronger testimony of the living reality of the Son of God' (Gordon B. Hinckley, p. 236)."
"The Book or Mormon is one of God's most priceless gifts to us. It is both sword and shield--it sends the word of God into battle to fight for the hearts of the just (p. 237)."
"It is its own best witness--its own best evidence. It is the unmitigated word of God from beginning to end; it teaches the doctrine of Christ in purity; it bears witness of the Savior with precision and power; and it invites the Spirit in unrestrained proportions. Every aspect of the Book of Mormon bears witness of its divine origin (p. 237)."
"I bear my solemn witness that the Book of Mormon was translated by the gift and power of God. It is God's crowning witness of the divinity of Jesus Christ, the prophetic calling of Joseph Smith... It is all it claims to be. It is the word of God. May it become the keystone of our testimonies (p. 237)."
"The Book of Mormon is a book for all seasons. It is for all men and all women of all nations and races. If we are lonely or discouraged, its words can soothe our 'wounded souls.' If we feel the stain of sin or guilt, it can lead us to the Savior's cleansing powers. If our testimonies are waving, it can shore them up. If we have been incorrectly influenced by the philosophies of men, it can restore the truth. And if we desire to become more like Christ, it can be our spiritual catalyst. Whatever our circumstance or need, it can provide us with a remedy of superior healing power. It is God's divine gift to every soul who wants to return to Him and become more like Him (p. 3)."
"'The outrageous daring of its title page is the very thing that should whet the appetite of a real scholar: here is a book that is asking for a fight, so to speak' (Hugh Nibley, p. 4)."
"The Book of Mormon is either a divine work or a fraud (p. 5)."
"A fraud does not produce a fine moral treatise (p. 6)."
"The Book of Mormon is God's crowning witness of Jesus Christ... The testimony of this book, as confirmed by the Spirit, is the single most powerful and compelling witness we have of the divinity of Jesus Christ (p. 8)."
"'Each of us must accommodate the mixture of reason and revelation in our lives. The gospel not only permits but requires it' (Boyd K. Packer, p. 9)."
"Reason does not necessarily bring about conviction, but a lack of it creates a climate for doubt, while the presence of it creates a climate for belief (p. 9)."
"'The Book of Mormon is tough; it thrives on investigation; you may kick it around like a football, as many have done; and I promise you it will wear you out long before you ever make a dent in it' (Hugh Nibley, p. 9)."
"Once we have a foundational testimony of the Book of Mormon, as confirmed by the Spirit, then any question or challenge we confront in life... can be approached with faith, not doubt (p. 15)."
"This effort to disprove the Book of Mormon is no easy task--in fact, it is impossible, because the Book of Mormon is true (p. 16)."
"This assertion that someone who was ignorant and uneducated could write such a work as the Book of Mormon seemed so preposterous to other contemporary critics that they readily dismissed it and instead presented alternative theories for the books' origin (p. 17)."
"The similarities between the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Book of Mormon demonstrate that two records or books on the same subject can have parallels, even numerous parallels, without any trace whatsoever of plagiarism or influence upon one another (p. 24)."
"'Joseph Smith... could neither write nor dictate a coherent and well-worded letter, let alone dictate a book like the Book of Mormon' (Emma Smith, p. 28)."
"'My belief is that the Book of Mormon is of divine authenticity--I have not the slightest doubt of it' (Emma Smith, p. 30)."
"Josphe Smith's explanation of the coming forth of the Book of Mormon remains the only viable option (p. 31)."
"Professor Hugh Nibley challenged some of his students to write a book comparable to the Book of Mormon (p. 35)."
"The Book of Mormon is matchless--it is a work of God and therefore cannot be duplicated by man (p. 36)."
"Science and linguistics and other evidentiary sources have and will continue to vindicate the Book of Mormon as the word of God (p. 42)."
"'O Lord, what will the world say?'... 'Fear not, I will cause the earth to testify of the truth of these things' ([the Lord's response to Joseph Smith according to Charles A. Callis via LeGrand Richards], p. 42)."
"'Don't lose faith in what you know because of what you don't know!' (John Lund, p. 51)"
"Time and science are great allies of the Book of Mormon, and no doubt the earth will continue to reveal its treasures and produce further witnesses of the book's divine authenticity (p. 55)."
"'The absence of archaeological evidence is not evidence of absence' (Edwin Yamauchi, p. 57)."
"'There should be no cause for unbelief among the children of men' (Helaman 14:28, p. 57)."
"On occasion, the Lord gives us physical and intellectual signs to help us believe on Him--not as a replacement of the Spirit but as a supplement to it (p. 62)."
"'If there are faults they are the mistakes of men; wherefore, condemn not the things of God, that ye may be found spotless at the judgment-seat of Christ' (Title page of the Book of Mormon, p. 64)."
"God, who is perfect in every way, works with imperfect men to accomplish His work (p. 65)."
"The Spirit is the ultimate evidence (p. 66)."
"While I disagree with the Church's critics on most points, I recognize that among them are good, intelligent people (p. 86)."
"The doctrinal truths taught in the Book of Mormon are an overwhelming evidence of its divine authenticity (p. 92)."
"While the Bible acts as one witness of Jesus Christ and His doctrine, the Book of Mormon acts as another (p. 93)."
"The Book of Mormon clarifies what is confusing in much of the Christian world (p. 104)."
"It makes it clear that one must have priesthood authority to baptize, because God is a God of order (p. 105)."
"The Book of Mormon restored the truth that miracles continue in our day based on the faith of the people, just as they occurred in Christ's original Church (p. 109)."
"Divine language has a divine eloquence, simple but powerful, that appeals not only to the intellect but also to the heart... So it is with the Book of Mormon--it mobilizes the language of the Spirit and sends it into battle against Satan, against sin, against pride, against the false philosophies of men, against ignorance, against every enemy and obstacle that prevents us from returning to God and becoming more like Him. Its divine language leaves an indelible impression upon the mind while also causing a stirring of the soul (p. 123)."
"The testimonies of these eleven witnesses, in addition to Joseph Smith's testimony, are a powerful evidence of the truth of the Book of Mormon (p. 133)."
"'We recognize that our forebears were human. They doubtless made mistakes... But the mistakes were minor, when compared with the marvelous work which they accomplished. To highlight the mistakes and gloss over the greater good is to draw a caricature... There was only one perfect man who ever walked the earth. The Lord has used imperfect people in the process of building his perfect society' (Gordon B. Hinckley, p. 134)."
"In spite of these personal differences, none of these witnesses ever denied his testimony of the Book of Mormon--an incredible evidence of its truthfulness (p. 138)."
"With passion and consistency--never wavering--David Whitmer reaffirmed his testimony again and again and again (p. 147)."
"While all of the Three Witnesses were excommunicated from the Church and had personal differences with the Prophet Joseph Smith, the overwhelming evidence confirms they never denied their testimonies, contrary to any secondhand or hearsay statements presented by critics (p. 150)."
"'They were willing to die rather than deny the divine origin and the eternal truthfulness of the Book of Mormon' (p. 157)."
"'How can I deny what I know to be true' (p. 158)."
"One of the prime purposes of the Book of Mormon, as announced on its title page, is 'to the convincing of the Jew and Gentile that Jesus is the Christ, the Eternal God, manifesting himself unto all nations' (p. 165)."
"'Mormonism is obsessed with Christ, and everything that it teaches is meant to awaken, encourage, and expand faith in him. I came to this conclusion when I read through the Book of Mormon for the first time' (Stephen H. Webb, p. 166)."
"'Why not speak of the atonement of Christ, and attain to a perfect knowledge of him' (Jacob 4:12, p. 167)."
"The Book of Mormon helps us understand the expansiveness of Christ's cleansing powers by giving us specific examples of the depth to which one may sink and still be saved (p. 170)."
"One of the glorious insights into the Atonement of Jesus Christ, as taught in the Book of Mormon, is that the Savior can not only cleanse us but also perfect us (p. 176)."
"Nowhere is the Savior's Atonement taught more powerfully, more concisely, and more expansively than in the Book of Mormon. It restores much that has been lost or mystified on this most sublime of all gospel truths (p. 181)."
"The Book of Mormon also bears witness of Jesus Christ through its references to His multiple titles (p. 181)."
"Perhaps there is no greater demonstration of Christ's love and compassion in all scripture (excepting His Atonement) than that recorded in 3 Nephi 17 (p. 182)."
"Not only does the Book of Mormon teach us about Christ, it brings us to Christ (p. 183)."
"I believe that individuals who honestly read the Book of Mormon can learn by the Spirit 'that Jesus is the Christ, the Eternal God, manifesting himself unto all nations' (p. 184)."
"Ezekiel prophesied that the stick of Judah (meaning the record of the Jews, known as the Bible) and the stick of Joseph (meaning the record of Joseph's descendants, known as the Book of Mormon) shall be joined into one stick or book (p. 190)."
"The Book of Mormon was prophesied of in the Bible, not by name, but by events and descriptions (p. 192)."
"God has given us sufficient evidences not to replace our faith but to support our faith (p. 197)."
"Reliance on the Spirit will produce a testimony built on rock (p. 198)."
"In truth, the Book of Mormon does not need to be defended by outside sources; it is its own best witness. Its genius lies in the inherent converting power found within the text itself (p. 199)."
"Knowledge is an intellectual understanding of truth, while faith is a principle of action--it motivates us to live what we believe (p. 201)."
"Of all the witnesses to the Book of Mormon, there is none more certain or sure than that of the Spirit (p. 202)."
"The Book of Mormon... is not on trial. It is we who are on trial to see if we will read it with a sincere heart and real intent to discover and live its truths (p. 205)."
"Why is it critical for each of us to gain a testimony of the Book of Mormon?... The time will come when each of us will be faced with an intellectual question we cannot answer or a crisis that tries our faith to the very core (p. 206)."
"I am not an archaeologist or scientist, but I have felt the impressions of the Spirit of which Moroni testified, and when I read the Book of Mormon, I am so moved. Such has been my personal experience, and such is my testimony that this book is God-given, that it is of divine origin, that it is the word of God (p. 210)."
"The whisperings and impressions of the Spirit are all around us, but they will be drowned out and smothered by the noise of the secular world if we do not train our spiritual ears to hear them and our hearts to feel them (p. 213)."
"The voice of God thrives in a quiet, reverent setting (p. 215)."
"If you feel peace as you read the Book of Mormon, that is a witness from God to you, by the Spirit, that it is true. That peace may come as you read of the reality of the Resurrection, the goodness of God and His tender mercies, the certainty of complete forgiveness for those who repent, the power of the Savior to comfort, or our glorious divine destiny, but peace will come to the humble seeker of truth. It is a witness of the presence of the Spirit (p. 217)."
"If while reading the Book of Mormon you have a desire to be a better person, then that is your personal witness from the Spirit that what you are reading is from God (p. 218)."
"Another divine witness comes in the form of increased enlightenment and understanding (p. 219)."
"The Book of Mormon is not only the keystone of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, but it can also become the keystone of our testimonies (p. 229)."
"To suggest that Joseph Smith possessed the skills necessary to write this monumental work in a single draft in approximately sixty-five working days is simply counter to the realities of life (p. 232)."
"With regard to the Book of Mormon, each of us stands at a crossroads. One road leads to the conclusion that the Book of Mormon is man-made and thus a fraud. The other leads to the conclusion that the Book of Mormon is of divine origin and thus the word of God (p. 234)."
"'There is a power in the Book of Mormon which will begin to flow into your lives the moment you begin a serious study of the book. You will find greater power to resist temptation. You will find the power to avoid deception. You will find the power to stay on the strait and narrow path' (Ezra Taft Benson, p. 235)."
"'I feel certain that if, in our homes parents will read from the Book of Mormon prayerfully and regularly, both by themselves and with their children... the spirit of reverence will increase, mutual respect and consideration for each other will grow. The spirit of contention will depart... Righteousness will increase' (Marion G. Romney, p. 236)."
"'The Book of Mormon teaches how to resolve the problems and challenges that we face today that were foreseen by the Lord' (Richard G. Scott, p. 236)."
"'I promise you that if you will prayerfully read the Book of Mormon, regardless of how many times you previously have read it, there will come into your hearts an added measure of the Spirit of the Lord. There will come a strengthened resolution to walk in obedience to his commandments, and there will come a stronger testimony of the living reality of the Son of God' (Gordon B. Hinckley, p. 236)."
"The Book or Mormon is one of God's most priceless gifts to us. It is both sword and shield--it sends the word of God into battle to fight for the hearts of the just (p. 237)."
"It is its own best witness--its own best evidence. It is the unmitigated word of God from beginning to end; it teaches the doctrine of Christ in purity; it bears witness of the Savior with precision and power; and it invites the Spirit in unrestrained proportions. Every aspect of the Book of Mormon bears witness of its divine origin (p. 237)."
"I bear my solemn witness that the Book of Mormon was translated by the gift and power of God. It is God's crowning witness of the divinity of Jesus Christ, the prophetic calling of Joseph Smith... It is all it claims to be. It is the word of God. May it become the keystone of our testimonies (p. 237)."
August 12, 2019
Tad Callister was one of my favorite General Authorities of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. And his book The Infinite Atonement is one of my all-time favorite church doctrine books. Callister's a lawyer, and if you look at his work, they can sometimes feel like well-thought court cases. That's especially the case with A Case for the Book of Mormon.
This book feels born from a talk Callister gave in the October 2017 General Conference titled "God's Compelling Witness: The Book of Mormon." It was an address that stood out to me that year for its simplicity and directness that borders on humor. That talk elicited a few laughs, and there were a few comments in this book that made me laugh out loud, too.
This is scriptural pugilism. And being sympathetic to the author's case, it's fun to watch. He spends the first half of his book answering common questions and accusations made by deterrents of The Book of Mormon. In the second half he transitions from defense to offense and begins posing questions he feels the critics either overlook or conveniently ignore.
At times I tried to imagine myself hearing Callister's case as a non-believer. I don't think any book, sermon, or mountain of facts could sway a determined critic. But I think an open-minded non-believer could find some interest in Callister's comments. If nothing else, it would give some interesting historical context. Of course, in a book like this, there's going to be heavy doses of confirmation bias by any reader. But I think Callister's legal presentation does an excellent job of keeping facts impartial.
While any practicing member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints will enjoy this book, I think it's best suited for members of the Church who either struggle with their faith. I've seen scores of friends and family lose faith when facts and history they'd never been exposed to chip away at a spiritual foundation based in whitewashed stories never explored beyond a primary class setting. It's unfortunate, but I'm sympathetic to it. But there's value and virtue in doubting our doubts. And Callister's book offers some excellent reasons to do that. I also think it's an excellent book for those just beginning their journey of testimony. Callister presents facts and historical accounts not commonly referenced that should give credence to any honest seeker. This book in itself won't convince anyone one way or another. And Callister admits it's not designed to. But it might help.
This book feels born from a talk Callister gave in the October 2017 General Conference titled "God's Compelling Witness: The Book of Mormon." It was an address that stood out to me that year for its simplicity and directness that borders on humor. That talk elicited a few laughs, and there were a few comments in this book that made me laugh out loud, too.
This is scriptural pugilism. And being sympathetic to the author's case, it's fun to watch. He spends the first half of his book answering common questions and accusations made by deterrents of The Book of Mormon. In the second half he transitions from defense to offense and begins posing questions he feels the critics either overlook or conveniently ignore.
At times I tried to imagine myself hearing Callister's case as a non-believer. I don't think any book, sermon, or mountain of facts could sway a determined critic. But I think an open-minded non-believer could find some interest in Callister's comments. If nothing else, it would give some interesting historical context. Of course, in a book like this, there's going to be heavy doses of confirmation bias by any reader. But I think Callister's legal presentation does an excellent job of keeping facts impartial.
While any practicing member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints will enjoy this book, I think it's best suited for members of the Church who either struggle with their faith. I've seen scores of friends and family lose faith when facts and history they'd never been exposed to chip away at a spiritual foundation based in whitewashed stories never explored beyond a primary class setting. It's unfortunate, but I'm sympathetic to it. But there's value and virtue in doubting our doubts. And Callister's book offers some excellent reasons to do that. I also think it's an excellent book for those just beginning their journey of testimony. Callister presents facts and historical accounts not commonly referenced that should give credence to any honest seeker. This book in itself won't convince anyone one way or another. And Callister admits it's not designed to. But it might help.
June 27, 2019
A beautiful and well-written support and testimony of the Book of Mormon.
April 25, 2021
I read the majority of this book with my children as part of morning devotionals to discuss concerns that exist about the origin of the Book of Mormon, to further explore doctrinal points, and to introduce points of view about the Book of Mormon that might be new to them. I particularly appreciated the personal historical accounts of the individual witnesses. There were extensive footnotes with documentation to scriptures and other references that I enjoyed studying. I respect each individual’s spiritual journey, but I ask one thing. Please don’t have an opinion about it’s validity without reading it in its entirety with an open, prayerful mind. Please don’t be a critic if you have never read it with sincerity and openness. Each time I read it, it continues to be a second witness to me, in hand with the Bible, of the divinity of Jesus Christ and his role as the Son of God. I don’t want to live my life without it as a guiding source in my life. For those who leave it behind after having read it sincerely, God knows our hearts, and I know if we have been true to our desire to seek him, he will be merciful and understanding of our journey for he knows all. 💗
January 23, 2020
Phenomenal logical approach to the validity of The Book of Mormon. Elder Callister does not shy away from critics claims against the Book of Mormon but tackles them right on. This is a must read for all. I love how Elder Callister ends the book by declaring that despite the logical, scientific, and agricultural evidences supporting The Book of Mormon the books greatest witness is the book itself. This witness available to all who will read and study its’ pages. I add my witness that I know that The Book of Mormon is a divine work of God.
August 22, 2019
This is such a great book. It is well-researched, logically explained, and faith promoting. I love the way Callister can enlighten and inspire both the mind and heart. The scripture "seek wisdom by learning and also by faith" comes to mind when I think about both this book and Callister as an author. He shares his research and testimony in an eloquent way. I left feeling so grateful for the gift of the Book of Mormon and a desire to make it a bigger part of my life.
April 22, 2019
I'm a fan of how Tad Callister compiles and presents information. He is clear yet he recognizes the emotional element of an argument. One of my favorites points is the difference between spiritual and intellectual truth. I feel truly blessed to have read "The Infinite Atonement" and this book. They are enlightening and presented in a way that really resonated with me.
July 22, 2019
I really enjoyed this one. Callister very appropriately presents his case like a lawyer: clear, concise, and researched. The real gold mine is the footnotes, though. I've become a bit of a footnote snob in the last few years and he presents some of the best footnotes I've ever seen.
November 22, 2019
*SPOILER ALERT*
It made it clear that there is archeology for the Book of Mormon all of which was discovered after the Book of Mormon's publication. I already knew about most of the archeology that this book mentioned before reading it. Also liked it how he mentioned that in many instances what the Book of Mormon teaches not only used to lack evidence but contradicted the current evidence but then new archeological discoveries ended up supporting the Book of Mormon. I realize that Tad R. Callister is not going to cover everything from the discipline of Book of Mormon archeology or else this book would've been over 1,000 pages but I still wish he would've done more.
I also like how he threw down the anti-LDS arguments about Joseph Smith supposedly getting this information from his local library. Duh, most of the Hebrew, and ancient american knowledge in the BOok of Mormon was not confirmed by evidence until after the Book of Mormon was published so that knowledge would not have been in any of the books in the libraries that Joseph Smith would've had access to.
I'm also glad that he addressed why it's ridiculous for people to think that DNA disproves the Book of Mormon. The very 1st time I heard someone claim that DNA disproves the Book of Mormon, I could tell that it was a crappy argument because it's common knowledge that science doesn't know everything, and continues to make new discoveries so just because the DNA test results that anti-LDS was alluding to don't show middle eastern genes doesn't mean that native americans don't have middle eastern ancestry. (Also, there are some DNA test results from non-LDS sources that now confirm that native americans do indeed have middle eastern DNA in addition to their asianic DNA which just proves how brainwashed the anti-LDS really are, and then they have the nerve to claim that we're brainwashed).
The account of the 3 witnesses, and 11 witnesses was great because once again it exposed those filthy anti-LDS for the frauds they are, and proved even further that the Book of Mormon is true.
Wish he would've gone more in-depth on the Bible prophecies about the Book of Mormon coming forth.
It made it clear that there is archeology for the Book of Mormon all of which was discovered after the Book of Mormon's publication. I already knew about most of the archeology that this book mentioned before reading it. Also liked it how he mentioned that in many instances what the Book of Mormon teaches not only used to lack evidence but contradicted the current evidence but then new archeological discoveries ended up supporting the Book of Mormon. I realize that Tad R. Callister is not going to cover everything from the discipline of Book of Mormon archeology or else this book would've been over 1,000 pages but I still wish he would've done more.
I also like how he threw down the anti-LDS arguments about Joseph Smith supposedly getting this information from his local library. Duh, most of the Hebrew, and ancient american knowledge in the BOok of Mormon was not confirmed by evidence until after the Book of Mormon was published so that knowledge would not have been in any of the books in the libraries that Joseph Smith would've had access to.
I'm also glad that he addressed why it's ridiculous for people to think that DNA disproves the Book of Mormon. The very 1st time I heard someone claim that DNA disproves the Book of Mormon, I could tell that it was a crappy argument because it's common knowledge that science doesn't know everything, and continues to make new discoveries so just because the DNA test results that anti-LDS was alluding to don't show middle eastern genes doesn't mean that native americans don't have middle eastern ancestry. (Also, there are some DNA test results from non-LDS sources that now confirm that native americans do indeed have middle eastern DNA in addition to their asianic DNA which just proves how brainwashed the anti-LDS really are, and then they have the nerve to claim that we're brainwashed).
The account of the 3 witnesses, and 11 witnesses was great because once again it exposed those filthy anti-LDS for the frauds they are, and proved even further that the Book of Mormon is true.
Wish he would've gone more in-depth on the Bible prophecies about the Book of Mormon coming forth.
October 14, 2022
From the book:
Austin Farrer, an Anglican theologian, gave us this important insight: “Though argument does not create conviction, lack of it destroys belief. What seems to be proved may not be embraced; but what no one shows the ability to defend is quickly abandoned. Rational argument does not create belief, but it maintains a climate in which belief may flourish.” In other words, reason does not necessarily bring about conviction, but a lack of it creates a climate for doubt, while the presence of it creates a climate for belief.
And although not from this book, the following quote by Elder Callister in his book, Teaching With Power, packs a nice rational punch using some similar logic laid out in greater detail in this book:
Do you think that Joseph Smith, at age 23, with a limited education, who could not write a coherent letter as attested to by his wife, wrote the entire book of Mormon without any notes in a single dictation draft in approximately 65 days? That he invented the multitude of inspiring stories in that book? That he authored the incredible doctrine found within its pages, much of which was contrary to the religious teachings of his day? That he created the legion of thought-provoking statements that hang on peoples’ walls and refrigerator doors? Or that he was such a lucky guesser, that archaeology keeps proving him right after the critics have derided his claims as false?
Or alternatively, do you believe he translated that book by the gift and power of God? If the latter, then Joseph was a prophet and the church is absolutely true, and for the time being we can live with a few unanswered questions.
Austin Farrer, an Anglican theologian, gave us this important insight: “Though argument does not create conviction, lack of it destroys belief. What seems to be proved may not be embraced; but what no one shows the ability to defend is quickly abandoned. Rational argument does not create belief, but it maintains a climate in which belief may flourish.” In other words, reason does not necessarily bring about conviction, but a lack of it creates a climate for doubt, while the presence of it creates a climate for belief.
And although not from this book, the following quote by Elder Callister in his book, Teaching With Power, packs a nice rational punch using some similar logic laid out in greater detail in this book:
Do you think that Joseph Smith, at age 23, with a limited education, who could not write a coherent letter as attested to by his wife, wrote the entire book of Mormon without any notes in a single dictation draft in approximately 65 days? That he invented the multitude of inspiring stories in that book? That he authored the incredible doctrine found within its pages, much of which was contrary to the religious teachings of his day? That he created the legion of thought-provoking statements that hang on peoples’ walls and refrigerator doors? Or that he was such a lucky guesser, that archaeology keeps proving him right after the critics have derided his claims as false?
Or alternatively, do you believe he translated that book by the gift and power of God? If the latter, then Joseph was a prophet and the church is absolutely true, and for the time being we can live with a few unanswered questions.
May 23, 2019
Written by the author of my favorite book, The Infinite Atonement, Tad Callister does an outstanding job of defending, teaching and testifying of the truthfulness of the Book of Mormon. So much to love about this book. While I’m talking it over with my husband, I’m getting goosebumps.
Even though I’ve been a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day saints my entire life, there were many new details I’ve learned. Many subjects were covered verifying the validity of The Book of Mormon, its origin, and miraculous translation: Archaeological evidences discovered since its original release showing the existence of massive amounts of people living where there wasn’t thought before, showing the use of cement in an era believed to not have the knowledge, evidence of people actually writing on metal pages during the same time frame where it was believed ancient writings only occurred on papyrus,etc. In my experience, many people who fight against the Book of Mormon with the most vigor are the ones who haven’t read it themselves.
With each theory of its origin/ translation debunked, the Book of a Mormon stands as the most investigated and criticized book of all time, and yet it still stands. It’s stands as the cornerstone of my faith and for millions of others. The Book of Mormon is true and you only need to read and pray about it to find out for yourself.
Even though I’ve been a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day saints my entire life, there were many new details I’ve learned. Many subjects were covered verifying the validity of The Book of Mormon, its origin, and miraculous translation: Archaeological evidences discovered since its original release showing the existence of massive amounts of people living where there wasn’t thought before, showing the use of cement in an era believed to not have the knowledge, evidence of people actually writing on metal pages during the same time frame where it was believed ancient writings only occurred on papyrus,etc. In my experience, many people who fight against the Book of Mormon with the most vigor are the ones who haven’t read it themselves.
With each theory of its origin/ translation debunked, the Book of a Mormon stands as the most investigated and criticized book of all time, and yet it still stands. It’s stands as the cornerstone of my faith and for millions of others. The Book of Mormon is true and you only need to read and pray about it to find out for yourself.
January 4, 2020
Received as a gift. As indicated by the title the premise of the book is that there is a strong case that the Book of Mormon is exactly what it says it is. For nearly 200 years critics have been trying to explain away the Book of Mormon but have never been able to provide an honestly compelling explanation for how it came to be. This book discusses some of the most common arguments that have been proffered by critics, as well as a long series of evidences and questions that are not explained by any of these arguments.
I am not one that needs convincing that Joseph Smith could not have written the Book of Mormon - I have been convinced both spiritually and intellectually for a long time - but I really enjoyed and appreciated several insights provided in this book. For example, Callister asks the question: where did Joseph get all the profound doctrines found in the Book of Mormon? Many of them were contrary to or added clarification to prevailing beliefs of his day. Also: if the Book is a fraud, then how and why has it helped so many people want to be better and more Christlike (myself included)?
I would recommend A Case for the Book of Mormon to any of my friends, whether already convinced or not.
I am not one that needs convincing that Joseph Smith could not have written the Book of Mormon - I have been convinced both spiritually and intellectually for a long time - but I really enjoyed and appreciated several insights provided in this book. For example, Callister asks the question: where did Joseph get all the profound doctrines found in the Book of Mormon? Many of them were contrary to or added clarification to prevailing beliefs of his day. Also: if the Book is a fraud, then how and why has it helped so many people want to be better and more Christlike (myself included)?
I would recommend A Case for the Book of Mormon to any of my friends, whether already convinced or not.
July 25, 2019
I really appreciated how Callister examined many of the arguments made against Joseph Smith, specifically those related to his translation of the Book of Mormon. He pointed out flaws in the arguments, arguments that lacked evidence, and his conclusions in relation to these arguments. In addition, he detailed some of the archaeological and other findings that support the Book of Mormon (such as finding cement in the Americas and finding that they did grow barley during the Book of Mormon era in the Americas) while also admitting that there are some things that have not been proven yet and pointing out that relatively little archaeological excavation has happened thus far in the Americas. In addition to these more rational and systematic proofs, Callister also goes into spiritual witnesses and the power of the Holy Ghost to bear testimony that the Book of Mormon is true. This is well worth reading and considering.
Finally, I appreciate his footnotes so that you could easily do additional reading if desired and so you can see his sources.
Finally, I appreciate his footnotes so that you could easily do additional reading if desired and so you can see his sources.
January 14, 2024
This was a books whose purpose was to, "lay out in a concise way a compelling case for the Book of Mormon as a work of God, and thus inspire one to read it, embrace its doctrine, and become a witness of its divine authority." As such, I felt like it did an excellent job. Each part took on different elements the "case for the Book of Mormon." It tackled critics' arguments against and responses to those arguments, shared additional evidences of the Book of Mormon, and then shared how one might decide and find out for one's self.
In the end, what a believes about the Book of Mormon will come down to 1)whether they've actually read the book itself and 2)whether they're willing to ask God if what they've read is true. There is power in the Book of Mormon, a power which brings honest seekers closer to Christ, and a power which I have felt for myself. I appreciate what Mr. Callister has done in his book to lay things out in such a way to help others find out for themselves as well.
In the end, what a believes about the Book of Mormon will come down to 1)whether they've actually read the book itself and 2)whether they're willing to ask God if what they've read is true. There is power in the Book of Mormon, a power which brings honest seekers closer to Christ, and a power which I have felt for myself. I appreciate what Mr. Callister has done in his book to lay things out in such a way to help others find out for themselves as well.
February 18, 2020
At last.
A book tackling the criticisms of the Book of Mormon head on without flinching. Callister refuses to mince words in discussing the grievances brought against the Book of Mormon since its genesis. He provides answers and rebuttals to each quibble, especially the whimsical idea that Joseph Smith wrote the book in ninety days. Callister shows how time and science are great allies of the Book of Mormon and how the vastness of the doctrine cannot be easily dismissed. He expresses the importance of gaining a testimony of the Book of Mormon through spiritual means but adds that “on occasion, the Lord gives us physical or intellectual signs to help us believe on Him—not as a replacement of the Spirit but as a supplement to it.”
This book is a supplement to the Spirit of the Book of Mormon.
A book tackling the criticisms of the Book of Mormon head on without flinching. Callister refuses to mince words in discussing the grievances brought against the Book of Mormon since its genesis. He provides answers and rebuttals to each quibble, especially the whimsical idea that Joseph Smith wrote the book in ninety days. Callister shows how time and science are great allies of the Book of Mormon and how the vastness of the doctrine cannot be easily dismissed. He expresses the importance of gaining a testimony of the Book of Mormon through spiritual means but adds that “on occasion, the Lord gives us physical or intellectual signs to help us believe on Him—not as a replacement of the Spirit but as a supplement to it.”
This book is a supplement to the Spirit of the Book of Mormon.
March 28, 2019
What a book. Anyone who really wants to know about The Book of Mormon should read this book. From investigators to seasoned members. This is so well written and copiously researched and always seem to enlighten.
This is Tad R Callister's 4th book and when you take all for into account, The Infinite Atonement, The Inevitable Apostasy, The Blueprint of Christ's Church and now A Case for the Book of Mormon, reading all four is a perfect primer on the restored gospel of Jesus Christ and a new member would do well to read all 4 as soon as possible once they join the Church.
This is a landmark work in the Church.
This is Tad R Callister's 4th book and when you take all for into account, The Infinite Atonement, The Inevitable Apostasy, The Blueprint of Christ's Church and now A Case for the Book of Mormon, reading all four is a perfect primer on the restored gospel of Jesus Christ and a new member would do well to read all 4 as soon as possible once they join the Church.
This is a landmark work in the Church.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 300 reviews