For one-semester, freshman-level courses in Composition.Both student- and instructor-friendly, this text/reader offers an abundance of interesting and appealing essay examples, easily implemented classroom suggestions, and varied homework and writing assignments.
Sometimes I just want to read a good essay, and The Prentice Hall Reader contains a lot of good essays. I got about halfway through and the categories became uninteresting (an essay on the lethal ingredients of toothpaste circa 1985? 1990?). The presumed readers of this book are students, so it's about teaching folks how to write, and I didn't read all the accompanying material.
I just lost interest when the essays became clever but nothing to admire; I'm sure there are other good essays further along, and, after all, the purpose here is to teach students to write; an essay about toothpaste might actually be more helpful for students who might need to write papers for their geology class.
So even though I only read half of it I figure I can take credit for reading it all. (Actually, I read less than 1/4 of it, since I mostly skipped the didactic portions and stuck to the essays themselves.