This is part of a series where it looks like they're all written by different authors, but the stories take place simultaneously and the characters all know each other. All the characters go back in time at the same time, but they're kind of parallel from there. I imagine that took some planning and that care was taken not to spoil or present a preferred order.
This is the second that I've tried and I bounced again, despite loving the frame story. Fairies sending people back to 1850 after completing an "immersion program" for Regency manners just has so much potential. I mean, you can play it mean (exploiting the wish-fulfillment) or nice (granting hearts' desires) and it works either way. Or at least, has the potential to work either way. Sadly, this one didn't work for me, either.
At least this author didn't have an idiot lady who couldn't stop preaching hard-core feminism while being a giant wuss herself. Kaitlyn is enjoying herself and simply loves being able to experience the stuff she has read about for so long. I liked that she's still bored with the constrained activities but she's still happy she's there. Good characterization and I liked her.
Cyrus, on the other hand, is an even bigger wimp than Jem was. Once it became clear that both leads secretly liked each other I lost all patience. Cyrus can't be bothered to act like he's interested in Kaitlyn even a little bit and I just can't even. What, you can't say "you look awesome in that dress"? You can't say "I love seeing you enjoy yourself"? No, he just follows her around with a disapproving demeanor even though he's all "I sure like seeing her enjoy herself" inside. This is so very stupid I wanted to reach into the novel and smack this dimwit for wasting everybody's time! Cyrus, you don't deserve her, you amazing limp noodle! Now step aside so someone with more brains than a wet tissue can take a shot at making her happy.
I mean, once I realized that she was kind of pining for him in secret, I lost respect for her, too. I mean, what the crap does she see in the idiot? He's a huge downer literally* all of the time.
So I stopped at 45% so that the pain would go away. I'm still going to try for the third one, but if that one blows it, I'm going to be very, very sad.
* Literally used in the original, some might say correct, sense of the term.