This review is for both books in the Decades series. Let me start by saying that I enjoyed reading these books. The writing was good and the story was entertaining. Pacini managed to make his characters seem like different people, which is important when you write multiple POV stories. He also gets an A for diversity - characters are of multiple ethnicities (Caucasian, Ethiopian, African-American, mixed race, and Latinx) and religions (LDS, Judaism, Islam), and ability (one character is confined to a wheelchair, another shows symptoms of sociopathy, and several show signs of PTSD) and these characters all have unique viewpoints. I was truly entertained by the series. If that’s all you’re looking for, this may be a book for you.
Nevertheless, I could not justify giving this book more than two stars. Why? Because it was set in the real world, made to seem as if it were a realistic apocalyptic dystopian novel, but was so completely and utterly outside the realm of possibility as to be laughable - only it’s suggestions weren’t funny.
First off, by now you know that America is in civil war. No one in their right mind would have dropped a nuke on their own country just to start a civil war. Nuclear fallout has decades of impact. Why would you want to control a country that you’ve essentially made useless? And shipping all the 14-18 year olds out of country is also idiotic if you want to have a civil war - those are all the people who will be soldiers in the next few years. They’re too young and stupid to be good colonialists (which, granted, the book does show).
And by the way, did the author really think countries in the Middle East were just going to sit there and be part of new America? Countries have these things called Allies. America has something called Enemies. Politics is precariously balanced on the edge of a knife. No one is going to be happy if we start grabbing land - that’s a huge shift in power. Other big players will get involved.
What really got me was the part where one of the characters said that if America wasn’t free, then nobody was free. Are you freaking kidding me? America is 17th on Cato’s Human Freedom Index, 10th on the World Index of Moral Freedom, 25th on the Democracy Index, and a depressing 48th on the Press Freedom Index. America is hardly the paragon of freedom the author makes it out to be.
Then there’s the atrocities committed by the American soldiers. Certain crimes, like rape, are about power. Others, like cannibalism, are about survival (except in the case of the occasional depraved individual). When Fetty freed the teens at the camp, it’s clear that MPREs were still available to the soldiers. Cannibalism is abhorrent to humans; that the soldiers were participating in the practice before they were in danger of starving reads like torture porn. (Also, soldiers with guns could go steal sheep and crops... just saying).
I could go on, but I think by now you get my point. Although I initially enjoyed the book, the Americentrism and poor research just left a bad taste in my mouth. If you don’t care about that stuff, then this will be a good read for you. Otherwise, take heed.