What do you think?
Rate this book


368 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2007
Art books featuring artworks and artifacts from the non-Western world are always an interesting experience. On the one hand, I love the beautiful color photographs of objects--just the opportunity to gaze at the intricacies and patterns of carving, weaving, painting. But on the other hand, it's an odd feeling, looking at these drastically out-of-context objects, floating against their sterile light-gray backgrounds, so far from where they originally came from. The privilege of looking at them now, collected in the Metropolitan and now in this book, comes because Europeans traveled and bought or traded for the objects years ago. And I know from living in Papua New Guinea that some people in the places of origin feel that the objects should come back home. It's a complicated issue, to be sure.
In spite of the complexities, however, I did enjoy Eric Kjellgren's tour of the Metropolitan Oceania collection. I saw a lot of items that I've never seen before, as well as some objects that are very much like art I've seen "in-context" in my work throughout PNG. Sprinkled throughout the book are historical pictures of similar items in their original contexts; I would've appreciated even more such photos, which tended to fire up my imagination of different places and different times. Another element I wanted more of was maps. The book includes only two very general maps at the beginning--inadequate for book's content. I would've liked each regional section to begin with more detailed maps, pointing out the places that are mentioned in that section.These are relatively minor criticisms, though. The book is beautiful, and I enjoyed my read-through. What endures as the most significant thing about the book is how thorough a collection the Metropolitan has. They have representative examples of an amazing number of major Oceanic traditions.