**going to be on my best-books-of-2018 list**
Please, please, please experience this through the audiobook. Even if you don't normally like audiobooks, listening to Annie share the story in her own voice is an incredibly moving, absorbing experience. She's a popular podcaster with a unique voice (which I personally love) that is just as vulnerable and open as her words are. Listening to this book was like getting to walk by someone’s side through their journey.
And that's where a lot of criticisms of this book I've seen come from, from the fact that Annie's story is an ongoing journey: People don't like the emotional ups and downs and the fact that it's kind of unfinished. I can understand why that wouldn't appeal to everyone—maybe I didn't mind because I feel like I am the same phase right now, an emotionally intense time of continually having to trust God despite nothing looking like I expected. Not everyone is there. I get that.
The biggest criticisms I disagree with are that the book feels unfinished, it is not tied with a pretty bow, and there isn't one clear, shining lesson or answer to her struggles. In my opinion, those things are not problems. In fact, I think we need more books that have those things in them. I have read many stories of people going through hard times, and they are all written once they have come through to the other side—either the author has finally gotten what they desired or they have discerned and reconciled themselves to the clear lesson/truth God wanted to impart. But so rarely do people write from in the midst of that struggle, before the season of mourning has passed and before they are completely settled in God’s will.
It is so encouraging to read about how people can look back and see all the good that came from their suffering. But it is perhaps even more powerful and encouraging to read about the suffering and the struggle itself, how you get glimpses of what good thing is at work but it is still hard and you still do not like it.
Annie is honest, and I love, I just love seeing her work through her relationship with God. I love seeing what another person's walk with God looks like, how it's different for everybody and yet how, fundamentally, it is the same because the One we are in a relationship with is the same. That's the whole point of the book— to remember God. To keep turning your gaze to him even when you're angry with him and disappointed with him and maybe just tired of him.
Also, I understand people’s annoyance with her seemingly overdramatic response to not being on the List and even just her disappointment in being single. Obviously, there are far, far worse lots in life. Maybe I'm unable to view this objectively because her struggles feel so similar to mine (your life not turning out at all how you expected), but I think, so what if her disappointments are vain and petty compared to the life-and-death situations of others? They are the disappointments God has given her, and so they are the ones she is working through and writing about. It's not her fault that she doesn't struggle with, say, poverty or cancer. Again, I know it's easy to say that when you're not struggling with those more serious issues and it's true that she, and I, really have nothing to complain about in the grand scheme of things. But that doesn't prevent us from wanting to complain. And just because our problems are small does not invalidate them or prevent us from being able to glorify God through them.
Anyway. This book made me cry. It pushed me to God. I left it feeling a little confused, like, what was the point of this book? But I think that is the point. That you don't often know what the point of all your experiences are and that you aren't supposed to. You are just supposed to keep turning to God.
Maybe that doesn't sound very encouraging. Maybe that makes you feel bitter and annoyed. I think it would've made me feel that way even a few months ago. If so, I encourage you to read it (*chants* the audiobook, the audiobook) because she shows you her own bitterness and brokenness and invites you into her own questions and somehow, that's better than some theological answer.