*I received a free advanced copy from the publisher via #netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
This is a beautiful book with a ton of information on how to art journal your story. I’m a beginner in this art form, so I appreciate this book’s informative parts. She introduced me to unique supplies, clever techniques that I never considered before. The author really knows her stuff.
However, as is most common among artists, the author puts too much spirituality in her approach to art. As a Christian, I believe that creating art is an expression of humans’ being made in the image of God, just as Genesis 1:27 says. I also believe the fact that we can appreciate beauty in whatever form (a breathtaking sunset, a gorgeous painting, a heartwarming story, etc) is a testament to our reflection of God, our Creator. So, I agree with the author that there is a spiritual aspect to doing art.
She, however, takes it to another level. First of all, the point of the book is using mixed media to tell one’s story (through family history, old pictures, etc). But, from the beginning, she emphasizes that truthfulness is not important. She encourages the reader, “Your story can even be imaginary and what you want it to be” and “It is also OK on this creative journey to rewrite any part of your story through your art.”
If what you’re trying to convey about you is not true, then it isn’t YOUR story anymore. If I say that I’m related to Abraham Lincoln, which is not true, and make an art journal that says so, then it isn’t my story anymore. It’s just an art journal about a fictional story.
She encourages rituals (meditations, speaking out loud key words, etc) before doing art, which I found weird. Maybe this is what makes me a hobby artist and not a “real” one. The author seems to take art too seriously when it’s meant to be a fun endeavor.
The section on Mark Making was confusing to me. If the point of the chapter is to find what makes your art yours by the distinct marks you make, then what is the point of the mark making suggestions in this section? By doing her suggestions, then it is no longer your own mark, but a mere imitation of another artist’s.
Overall, the book has many things to teach anyone who is new to mixed media. I like these parts very much. But I am not a fan of and found uninspiring the author’s too serious approach to art, her messy style and the busy randomness of her artwork.
————————
On a similar note (though not really part of my review), after reading this book, I realized mixed media is the art form for our post-modern age. Beauty is treated too subjectively that a haphazardly put together collection of photos, notes, ephemera, paint, etc. are passed as art. Of course, I don’t dispute there is a subjective aspect in how we perceive beauty, but it should not be completely that. As an amateur artist, I am saddened by the reality that we all are expected to accept and appreciate any form of art, without much regard to objective beauty.