The blurbs led me to believe I'd love this book: "passionate, daring book reminiscent of Orwell's Animal Farm" and "brilliant satire, propelled by a furious comic inventiveness somewhere between Carl Hiaasen and John Kennedy Toole" and "crucially sophisticated and timely rewriting of the nature of allegory...this is going to be a famous book". In fact this book is not well known. Bradfield's subject is so fun, so great, but it doesn't reach its goal. There are too many gaps; the reader cannot suspend disbelief.
Charlie the Crow loves to talk. He's seen the world, "overcrowded cities, polluted oceans, animal killing fields, corrupted body politics," and now he wants a place to hang out for a while, selecting the London Zoo, where the animals are in a bit of a stupor (Why, exactly, are they so complacent? Because, like Noah's arc, they are not part of a community of their own kind? Were they ever?). Charlie challenges them to think about their dreams. Naturally, there is an uprising; leaders like Charlie and Scaramangus the wildebeest (Mr. Big) are born.
In parallel, there are animal worlds where animals behave like humans - they have jobs and suburbs and participate in a capitalist society - and some are not happy about it, longing for adventure and freedom and less civilization. This is where my confusion begins - the penguins, for example, have not been acculturated by humans - they don't know from humans. Are we meant to believe the trappings of civilization are the same regardless of their genesis? That a civilization created by penguins has the same pitfalls as that created by humans? Our biologists tell us, in fact, that animal societies are very different than human ones.
Humans decide they need to "save" the animals from themselves, esp after the London Zoo incident. They want the animals to play by the rules of human society (pay taxes, have jobs, live in apartments, etc) - and this by default means that most animals will be lower class citizens, lacking education, opposable thumbs, etc. Charlie believes in the domino effect, which was used during the Cold War to describe how communism might spread. The humans fly into Antarctica with military aircraft and enforce human rules, in fact taking over the society that already existed b/c the penguins' society was already human-like. Like dominos, other animal societies fall into the same traps. The animals know, or come to know, that this isn't what they want, but because they were only recently awakened, they only know what they don't want, not what they want. The animals are split into a couple of factions, one behind Charlie and another behind Mr. Big. They are splintered and disorganized.
This book challenges the food chain where humans are on top and animals fall below. Animals are third class citizens; they are overlooked, oppressed, and without voice (not dissimilar to the strata of human societies or races with one key difference - humans are already at the top, and we don't eat each other!!) Humans think of animals as part of nature; the animals see humans as animals themselves - and all animals have things in common. At the book's end, animals have become part of the capitalist hamster wheel - factories are converted to make products for both humans and animals, which increases their profit margin. An uneasy truce has been reached, but it is no real solution. The final message is: please try to get along; live and let live.