Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

New York Sullivans #4

Every Time We Fall In Love

Rate this book
Harry Sullivan has always put his family first, even when it meant losing Molly—his one true love. He’s never been able to forget her, even after fifteen years. Now that his siblings are all blissfully happy, Harry hopes it’s not too late for his own happily-ever-after. But then his doorbell rings…and one look at the teenage girl standing on his doorstep changes absolutely everything.

Molly never thought she’d see Harry Sullivan again, so she's beyond stunned when her fifteen-year-old daughter brings him back into her life. At eighteen, Harry was already strong, sexy, and honorable. And now that he's even more handsome, more brilliant, more loyal and caring? Molly can't stop herself from falling in love with him all over again. Especially when his kisses and the sizzling attraction between them are hotter than ever.

But with more at stake now than they ever thought possible, will they be able to move beyond the mistakes they both made in the past, and fall in love forever this time?

318 pages, Paperback

First published July 18, 2018

1354 people are currently reading
1234 people want to read

About the author

Bella Andre

167 books56.2k followers
Bella Andre is the New York Times, USA Today and Publishers Weekly bestselling author of “The Sullivans” and “The Morrisons” series.

Having sold more than 10 million books, Bella Andre’s novels have been #1 bestsellers around the world and have appeared on the New York Times and USA Today bestseller lists 84 times. She has been the #1 Ranked Author at Amazon (on a top 10 list that included Nora Roberts, JK Rowling, James Patterson and Steven King). Apple iBooks named her one of the "bestselling authors of all time." And Publishers Weekly named Oak Press (the publishing company she created to publish her own books) the Fastest-Growing Independent Publisher in the US. After signing a groundbreaking 7-figure print-only deal with Harlequin MIRA, Bella’s “The Sullivans” series is being released in paperback in the US, Canada, and Australia.

Known for “sensual, empowered stories enveloped in heady romance” (Publishers Weekly), her books have been Cosmopolitan Magazine “Red Hot Reads” twice and have been translated into ten languages. Winner of the Award of Excellence, The Washington Post called her “One of the top writers in America” and she has been featured by Entertainment Weekly, NPR, USA Today, Forbes, The Wall Street Journal, and TIME Magazine. A graduate of Stanford University, she has given keynote speeches at publishing conferences from Copenhagen to Berlin to San Francisco, including a standing-room-only keynote at Book Expo America in New York City.

Bella also writes the New York Times bestselling Four Weddings and a Fiasco series as Lucy Kevin. Her “sweet” contemporary romances also include the new Walker Island series written as Lucy Kevin.

If not behind her computer, you can find her reading her favorite authors, hiking, swimming or laughing. Married with two children, Bella splits her time between the Northern California wine country, a 100 year old log cabin in the Adirondacks, and a flat in London overlooking the Thames..

* * * * * * *

For digital/eBook, audiobook, foreign licensing, conference keynote and press inquiries, please contact Bella at bella@bellaandre.com

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,133 (50%)
4 stars
693 (31%)
3 stars
318 (14%)
2 stars
71 (3%)
1 star
18 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 220 reviews
Profile Image for Bella Andre.
Author 167 books56.2k followers
Read
May 15, 2018
I can't wait for you to read Harry Sullivan's love story, coming July 18, 2018! ❤️ Bella

Amazon Kindle US: http://bellaandre.com/ETWFIL_Kindle
Apple iBooks: http://bellaandre.com/ETWFIL_iBooks
Barnes & Noble Nook: http://bellaandre.com/ETWFIL_Nook
Kobo: http://bellaandre.com/ETWFIL_Kobo
Google: http://bellaandre.com/ETWFIL_GooglePlay
Amazon Kindle Australia: http://bellaandre.com/ETWFIL_AmazonAU
Amazon Kindle Canada: http://bellaandre.com/ETWFIL_AmazonCA
Amazon Kindle UK: http://bellaandre.com/ETWFIL_AmazonUK
Paperback (shipped from Amazon): http://bellaandre.com/ETWFIL_Paperback

Harry Sullivan has always put his family first, even when it meant losing Molly—his one true love. He’s never been able to forget her, even after fifteen years. Now that his siblings are all blissfully happy, Harry hopes it’s not too late for his own happily-ever-after. But then his doorbell rings…and one look at the teenage girl standing on his doorstep changes absolutely everything.

Molly never thought she’d see Harry Sullivan again, so she's beyond stunned when her fifteen-year-old daughter brings him back into her life. At eighteen, Harry was already strong, sexy, and honorable. And now that he's even more handsome, more brilliant, more loyal and caring? Molly can't stop herself from falling in love with him all over again. Especially when his kisses and the sizzling attraction between them are hotter than ever. 

But with more at stake now than they ever thought possible, will they be able to move beyond the mistakes they both made in the past, and fall in love forever this time?
Profile Image for Annie .
2,506 reviews940 followers
July 24, 2018


In the eighteenth book in the Sullivans series, Bella Andre finally gives Harry Sullivan his story. I was really looking forward to his story because he seems to be the most steady and most caring member of the family. He has such a big heart that I wondered who would be able to snatch his up. I’m happy to note that this story was both sweet and charming and a perfect addition to this series.

This book actually features a trope that I am not really a big fan of, so when I started the book, I was a little nervous because I wasn’t sure I was going to like it. It’s a secret baby trope that I feel like has been vastly overused in this genre. However, Andre doesn’t spend too much time on the angst and keeps the book moving forward nicely. Despite the awkwardness in the beginning, I found that the romance was able to progress well without lagging too much. I think it also helped that everyone was very accommodating and accepting of Harry’s fifteen-year-old daughter.

If I had to describe this book in one word, it would be sweet. There are plenty of heartwarming and touching moments in this book and dare I say it, it kind of makes me miss my family. Because of all the love that this book has, it will really make you feel good. And, I feel like this book definitely celebrates the Sullivans as a family and really plays up their solid relationship with one another.
Profile Image for Sharon Rudolph.
2,145 reviews
July 20, 2018
Great book

I really enjoyed this book! The best part was realizing that Boldt Castle is a real place!! I love reading books that have real places in them, it makes the book so much better! I have visited most of the places from the California and Seattle Sullivans, now I can look forward to New York and Maine!
Profile Image for Syndi.
3,750 reviews1,050 followers
October 13, 2018
I always like bella andre's book. Especially the sullivan series. I read the san fransisco sulivan
And now i read this new york sullivan. I found this book is again refreshing.
I especially love the relationship between william and harry. The father and son is really a nice touch to close this series.

This book is minimal angst and a lot of feel good love.

4 stars.
Profile Image for Simply Love Book Reviews.
7,046 reviews870 followers
August 8, 2018


Bella Andre has done it again. It amazes me how she can continue to write the Sullivans and come up with new and refreshing stories each and every time. She's a powerful writer with stories that will warm your soul and put a permanent smile on your face. Harry and Molly's story was beautiful, poignant and stole my breath away.

I would have never expected Harry to be as wonderful as he was. We knew that he was a loyal family man. Always there when they needed him no matter what he had to give up for them. Pushing Molly away was the hardest thing that he has ever done an he's done nothing but think about her, wonder where she is and how her life is going. When the unexpected happens to him, is he going to be able to depend on his family to be there for him? It's the Sullivan's, of course they will rally around him and do whatever they could to ease the transition from History Professor to ….

Molly was such a wonderful, loving person. No man could ever hold a light to Harry. When he pushed her away, her life changed. She knew he was honorable but was heart-broken that he wouldn't let her be there for him. Now, living her life, working in a place that she loves, she can't believe that he's back and bringing back all those old feelings. How does she deal with them? How does she stop herself from falling in love with him again?

My heart burst with Every Time We Fall In Love. I was totally engrossed in this story of love lost and then found again. And then the ending … OMG, I cried like a baby. Like I said, Bella Andre is amazing and I really can't find words to describe what her writing does to and for me. Enjoy this beautiful love story from one of this genre's leading authors.
Profile Image for Under the Covers Book Blog.
2,840 reviews1,344 followers
July 23, 2018



I received this book for free from Author in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.


In the eighteenth book in the Sullivans series, Bella Andre finally gives Harry Sullivan his story. I was really looking forward to his story because he seems to be the most steady and most caring member of the family. He has such a big heart that I wondered who would be able to snatch his up. I’m happy to note that this story was both sweet and charming and a perfect addition to this series.

This book actually features a trope that I am not really a big fan of, so when I started the book, I was a little nervous because I wasn’t sure I was going to like it. It’s a secret baby trope that I feel like has been vastly overused in this genre. However, Andre doesn’t spend too much time on the angst and keeps the book moving forward nicely. Despite the awkwardness in the beginning, I found that the romance was able to progress well without lagging too much. I think it also helped that everyone was very accommodating and accepting of Harry’s fifteen-year-old daughter.

If I had to describe this book in one word, it would be sweet. There are plenty of heartwarming and touching moments in this book and dare I say it, it kind of makes me miss my family. Because of all the love that this book has, it will really make you feel good. And, I feel like this book definitely celebrates the Sullivans as a family and really plays up their solid relationship with one another.

*ARC provided by author
Reviewed by Ann❤ ♡ Don't want to miss any of our posts? Subscribe to our blog by email! ♡ ❤
Profile Image for Blender.
447 reviews13 followers
July 18, 2018
Another winner! Harry Sullivan is just too good to be true... and that’s exactly what I like in a hero! Molly was such a good fit for him, loved the ending... William was perfect! #LoveAllSullivans

ARC provided in exchange for honest review.
Profile Image for Kandis Redman.
995 reviews3 followers
July 18, 2018
I love Bella Andre’s books, they are all so heart lifting. Harry has always put his family before himself or any one else. He loves Molly his childhood girlfriend but his father needs him. Fate has put Harry and Molly together, when a 15 year old girl shows up at his doorstep saying that he is her father. Is Harry a father, will he get another chance with Molly, or will three hearts be broken this time ?
Profile Image for Michelle.
266 reviews
July 27, 2018
Another great Sullivan's book. This time bringing Harry and Molly back together through their daughter Amelia. Good character development. Maybe a little far fetched that everything is perfect right off the bat, real life just doesn't work that way. But it worked for the story. The writing flows very well. Good story development. Overall a great read.
Profile Image for Laurie.
468 reviews12 followers
July 15, 2018
I'm such a sucker for 2nd chance romance!! Another hit for Bella Andre. Harry Sullivan has always put his family first even at the expense of his personal happiness. Not until his teenage daughter, Amelia, shows up on his doorstep does he begin to consider his life a priority. Amelia secretly does some searching at home and online to come to the conclusion that Harry is her dad. Without telling her mom Amelia treks by bus to Harry's home to confront him. Molly Connal met Harry in their favorite place, the library their freshman year of college. Harry is the ultimate sexy, swoony, eye-glass wearing, history-loving hottie who would do anything for his family including his new found daughter and first-love, Molly. Molly is strong, smart, beautiful, and puts her daughter first in every way. Molly struggles with her guilt of keeping Harry away from Amelia even though Harry and his family truly understand her reasons of the how and why. The characters are well developed and strong including Aldwin,, the wolfhound. He steals the show pretty much with his antics and loyalty most of all. I have read many Sullivan books now, either as an ARC or purchased myself and have loved them all. This is one of the ultimate "large" family series that I have come to love. It is an easy summer/anytime escape read. If you happen to like history then Harry and Molly will totally blow you away. They are history buffs too. Totally recommend "Everytime We Fall in Love". 5 stars*****
Profile Image for Bobbie.
1,208 reviews10 followers
July 17, 2018
Another book about the Sullivan series by Bella Andre is like your favorite old blanket. I always enjoy revisiting whatever branch of the family Ms. Andre writes. This was the William Sullivan family in New York City and Harry is the only one of the siblings who has not gotten his HEA. This is due to the fact that he has always taken care of the rest of the family. Because of this he gave up his true love, and the book starts with him finding out he has a 15 year old daughter. She is the daughter of his true love, and from there the story evolves. It was enjoyable with not a lot of angst. If you have read any of the Sullivan family books, this book is a must!
Profile Image for Cali Jewel.
5,249 reviews39 followers
July 18, 2018
A heartwarming, sexy, emotional and engaging second chance romance filled with love, mistakes and a passionate connection that never faded.....

Harry and Molly's story is very real, sweet, charming and very relatable. Completely enjoyed this story from the very beginning and could not put it down. Loved every emotional and heart pounding twist and turn in this romantic journey.
Profile Image for Emily.
1,692 reviews125 followers
July 19, 2018
"Every Time We Fall In Love" (The Sullivans Book 18) by Bella Andre is a wonderful read. I loved Harry and Molly's story. This is a fantastic addition to The Sullivans series, packed with romance, passion, close family, second chances, entertaining characters, twists and turns, happily-ever-afters, and more. I can't wait to see what happens next with this awesome family. Highly recommend to all fans of romance, family, and series.
Profile Image for Selina Durio.
2,524 reviews12 followers
July 20, 2018
Wonderful

Harrison was always the New York Sullivan that kept that branch of the family together after multiple tragedies. This was such a wonderful read about second chances and happily ever after. It was especially great to see William doing so well.
Profile Image for Barbara Lack.
1,651 reviews20 followers
July 14, 2018
I just loved Harry and Molly’s story. It was such a fantastic second chance romance. Even though it had a lot of passion it was still such a sweet romance. Amelia was such a sweet and funny character. I loved the history of Boldt Castle and look forward to one day visiting. I thoroughly enjoyed this book! I received an advance review copy in exchange for an honest review.
50 reviews1 follower
July 24, 2018
Wow! Another winner by Bella Andre. Each book in her Sullivans series just gets better and better and you just know that ‘Every Time We Fall In Love’ will be one of those books on your to be reread list.
In this book it was great to see Harry reunite with his list love Molly, as he has made many sacrifices for his family over the years, even at the expense of his own happiness. I loved reading Harry and Molly’s story and this one rounded off the New York Sullivan’s series beautifully. Now the wait is on for the Maine Sullivans and Cassie’s story
I was received an ARC for ‘Every Time We Fall In Love’ for my honest review.
Profile Image for Danielle.
203 reviews15 followers
July 19, 2018
(Received an ARC and voluntarily reviewing)

I absolutely loved this book. It's taken me a while to feel as connected to the New York Sullivans as much as I have to the others. This book fully cemented that connection. Since it's the last book in the New York Sullivan subseries, it brings everything from that branch of the family to a nice close and ties it up with a bow. The appearances by the rest of the family are somewhat minimal and don't disrupt the plot of the story, which I appreciated. I do hope that someday we can read a book about their father falling in love with someone, but I'm not sure if that will happen.

I loved Harry. I loved his devotion to his family, as well as his devotion to Molly and her daughter Amelia. I don't want to give any spoilers away, but let me just say that even though the main plot of this book has been done several times before, it was executed very well and with a different twist than normal. It's a very lighthearted story with very little major drama or suspense, but it's still very entertaining and I highly recommend it.
Profile Image for Jacqueline  Adams.
151 reviews1 follower
July 19, 2018
I received this as a ARC for my honest review. I read it in one setting. I loved it so much. Put it down only to go to the 🚻 LOL! Bella Andre this was a great,fun and enjoyable read. Harry and Molly's story made me feel happy. I'm a sucker for second chance romance💋💋💋
Profile Image for Maida.
Author 15 books463 followers
July 23, 2018
Exactly what I needed during my worst trip ever: a light no-stress, family-centric tale of love and forgiveness. This second-chance story between Harry and Molly is a light and easy read, but still has substance. There were a couple of things that stretched credulity a bit, but they didn't detract from my enjoyment of the story. You have a cute couple who've been devoted to each other in spite of their many years of separation. Add a perky daughter, an adorable dog, a repentant father, and supportive family and friends, and you have the ingredients for an entertaining read.

This quote encapsulates why I love this series so much.

"... the true gift of being a Sullivan had nothing at all to do with fortune and spotlights.
And everything to do with family."

Profile Image for Sara.
17 reviews11 followers
July 18, 2018
ARC review. Bella has written another great Sullivan story! Harry's story had me hooked from the first chapter and I had to know how things turned out for not only Harry and Molly, but also Amelia. I knew from reading other books by Bella, that I would love this story. Harry and Molly had a hard road but they overcame misunderstandings and found love again. You could tell Amelia had to be a Sullivan just by reading how she came to find Harry and her personality. I hope we get her story in the future. Thank you for another amazing read Bella!
Profile Image for Kelly G (Now Accepting Book Boyfriend Applications).
1,123 reviews87 followers
July 18, 2018
Oh how I LOVE the Sullivans!!!! 😍. Harry did not disappoint! When he has a15 year old girl show up on his doorstep claiming to be his daughter, he didn't even bat an eyelash! Harry and Molly after a fantastic 2nd chance romance! And having a 15 year old to throw into the mix just made it such a great story. I always love the 2nd chances. This was a very well deserved one! Harry and Molly are totally worth one clicking right now!!! Amelia is just a ray of sunshine. I loved them all! I always look forward to another Sullivan story. 😁💜
Profile Image for Mary Schuck.
84 reviews
July 18, 2018
I have read all of the Sullivan books and this maybe my favorite one yet. I love second chance love stories and Bella didn’t disappoint with this book. It’s not the normal angst ridden second chance love story. This book is sweet, romantic, heartwarming and sexy in all the best ways. If you are a lover of the Sullivans or even if you haven’t started this series yet you should read this book!
199 reviews21 followers
August 30, 2020
Lucky to have received an ARC!

A knock on the door, a delightful 15 yr old girl, a love never forgotten, a sweet ole dog, a family finally healing, and second chances. All these threads come together beautifully in the latest book of Bella Andre’s Sullivans series.

Harry Sullivan is the only one single of the NY Sullivan siblings and he’s beginning to think it might be time to remedy that seeing as all his brothers and sister are happily coupled up and their father finally getting his act together. Little did he know that something will come up sooner than later to change his life.

Molly and Amelia Connal were living a simple life in Alexandria Bay when Amelia’s curiosity got the best of her and found some answers to a long standing question.

I have been eagerly waiting for Harry’s book and it was everything I imagined it would be and more. I love second chance romances and this is one of the best I’ve ever read. The story was well crafted, and you can feel all the emotions from the characters. And who can resist Aldwin??!! Just a wonderful, romantic, and heartwarming story you can read over and over again. I also love how history was incorporated here. It made me look up Alexandria Bay, Boldt Castle, and the story of George and Louise Boldt!

Long time fans of this series will not be disappointed and congrats Bella for another outstanding book! I can’t wait for the next one!



This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Melanie.
4,240 reviews34 followers
January 25, 2021
Bella Andre writes some of the most magical love stories I've ever read. They are timeless and heartwarming. Her characters are genuinely likeable and richly layered, Their stories are relatable to our own every day experiences.

Harry Sullivan and Molly Connal have a second chance for love when thet are reunited by a 15 year old girl who shows up on Harry's doorstep with DNA test in hand that says Harry is her father. Harry is ready to go all in because he never stopped loving Molly. However, Molly is hesitant and needs to protect her her heart as well as her daughter in case things don't work out. It takes both parties really opening up about their past feelings, hurts and insecurities for them both to realize their love is real and will sustain them.
Profile Image for Pam .
1,442 reviews13 followers
July 15, 2018
A surprise visitor has the ability to change Harry’s life forever. Ever since his mother’s death, he’s been the practical responsible one. He gave up his romance to try to help his father with his depression & keep his siblings out of trouble. Now, he has a second chance at love. Is the timing right this time?

I really enjoyed this story! I love second chance stories & this one was exceptional. The characters of Harry & Molly are perfect for each other. The interactions of Harry with his Dad & siblings show the strong family ties. I can’t wait to meet the next family of Sullivan’s!
Profile Image for Tpagirl Loves Romance.
1,672 reviews185 followers
December 31, 2018
Every Time We Fall In Love by Bella Andre was the fourth book in the New York Sullivans series and the eighteenth in the total Sullivan’s series.

Harry was the second oldest Sullivan sibling. Although successful professionally, he put his personal life on hold during college to take care of his family. In doing so, he let the love of his life go and never fully recovered from that loss, even though it had been fifteen years. No one could ever measure up to his first and only love, Molly Connal.

Molly was a single mom raising her daughter, Amelia. She would never talk about Amelia’s father, knowing it was best to keep the details to herself. Amelia was now fifteen and unbeknownst to Molly, she set out to find her dad.

Although the plot seemed like an old predictable one, there was a twist revealed immediately and not all was as it seemed. The entire book spanned only a week but central to the storyline, frequent reflection for past events was also included. At times there was an underlying sad vibe to it but it was also mixed with hope. In the end, it was a sweet second chance read.

Foster brought the NY Sullivan’s series to a conclusion with peace, hope and love, while also introducing the Maine Sullivan’s six siblings with Cassie’s story next to kick it off.
Profile Image for Christy Almeida.
88 reviews4 followers
July 18, 2018
Harry and Molly gave me all the warm and fuzzies and left me with a big old goofy smile on my face! Every Time We Fall In Love by Bella Andre takes us back into the wonderful, loving world of the amazing Sullivan Family. It was so nice to go back. This was such a sweet book that it provided me with the perfect get-away from the craziness of real life- so much so that I read it in on sitting!

This book is about Harry Sullivan the sexy historian professor who helped raised his siblings and took great care of his family. He really is a modern day Knight. Now that they’ve all found their great happy-ever-afters, it’s FINALLY his turn.

In this second-chance romance, Harry gets the shock of his life when a 15-year-old teenager shows up at his door with a DNA test. And while this is a popular story line, Bella, being the great write that she is, manages to give us some twists and turns to keep us on our toes. And of course as with every Sullivan book, you can expect family time and lots of warmth and great characters.

This is a super enjoyable and quick read. Every Time We Fall In Love will leave you smiling and feeling happy. Happy Reading!

Now, I have to go back and re-read the Sullivans because I sure do love this family.

I received an Advanced Reader Copy of this novel. I am voluntarily and freely providing an honest review.
Profile Image for litljen.
1,239 reviews41 followers
July 20, 2018
Aaahhhhh.....another Sullivan book! I can't ever get enough of the world that Bella Andre has created for this dynamic family! In Every Time We Fall In Love, Andre gives us the last New York Sullivan's story and it's beautiful and sexy. Harry Sullivan is just as swoon-worthy as you'd expect. When he opens the door to reveal a huge secret, it leads him back to his first love, Molly---the woman he never quite got over. As he and Molly find their way back to each other, readers will relish Andre's romantic storytelling. There are secrets that are revealed and hurdles to overcome but our couple perseveres and readers are rewarded with a beautiful story befitting the Sullivan name. This was the perfect wrap-up to the New York storyline and I can't wait to get to know the Maine Sullivans as Andre introduces the next chapter in her fabulous series.
Profile Image for JigsawGirl.
4,196 reviews
July 15, 2018
It never ceases to amaze me how Bella Andre's books can make you feel so good.

Her characters, although some of them may be rich, really successful, or famous, are all down to earth. They don't have perfect lives as they each have their own issue to overcome. But, the characters and their lives are not full of anger, angst, and sadness. That being said, they do experience an almost full range of emotions.

You get this great sense of family, support, loyalty, and love. Harry and Molly's story is a great second chance romance. Harry's dad, William, also gets his second chance. Molly and Harry's relationship seems to have happened quickly, but once you read it you will get a better of how out happened.

Once again I picked up this book and read until the last page. I want to say more, but too much more will move us into the **spoiler alert** arena, and I don't want to do that. If you are looking for romance and s HEA, I would recommend you read 'Every Time We Fall in Love'. Definitely 4.5 stars. I only wish it had been longer.

I voluntarily read and reviewed the Advanced Reader Copy.
Profile Image for BBMoreB ~.
784 reviews
July 25, 2018
I am a HUGE fan of second-chance love stories. However, Harry's story surprised the bejesus out of me. He is so devoted and romantic...
"Nothing has ever been this good." He needed her to know the truth. His truth.
there was no chance for Molly (nor me) to not fall quickly in love. Even when Molly was having doubts, during her many insecure moments, I knew this was a true love story.

...and Ameila added nice commentary.

Bella has given all of the New York Sullivan wonderful Happily Ever Afters...but Harry's was the cherry on top. -- Looking forward to what adventures she has planned for the Maine Sullivans.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 220 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.