This is a collection of 2 Christmas novellas. Both stories were sweet, clean, and filled with nostalgia... Personally though ,I found the first story the real winner.... I'd give the puppy story 5 stars for solid writing, and charm... The story was so well written, and nothing felt missing or rushed, and it didn't need any cliche romances or anything to help it really feel alive. If you want a good Christmas book that is short, with Christian values, and no romance, but rather just real life daily interactions, and oozing with charm, I think you'll really enjoy the first story..... The second story was cute, but I would give it 3stars, because several places felt like the writer had to cut the scene short without notice, and in the end it felt like they had to rush to an ending....I wanted a good short book, and it is still short, but I think if the author had just given themselves a few more pages it could have been a much better book/story... As it was, it felt rushed and choppy in places. Also, personally i was hoping for more Faith elements like the first one, and I really did want romance (even though the romance was extremely mild, and I do appreciate that, I still did appreciate the surprise of it coming about half way in, when the first book didn't have any).