In his book, Bevere quotes 1 Samuel 15:23, “Rebellion is witchcraft”, as the foundation for his argument that submission to authorities in the Christain life is of utmost importance. He sees this book as necessary for today’s democratic, individualistic world that has little category for submitting to those in authority over you, whether that be God himself or God’s delegated authority. He discusses how going against authority can lead to troubles in the Christian life as we come out from under the cover of God’s protection and into sickness and hard times. He then goes on to discuss what submitting to authorities looks like by covering a wide variety of Bible stories that range from submission to kings, Prophets, and church leaders. He ends the book by claiming that as we obey more, our faith will increase and then calls the reader to repentance in areas of their life where they have been in rebellion to authorities.
I do agree with Bevere in that, today, we generally do not have a good understanding of submission to authorities. If we disagree with someone, we think it is our right to do our own thing. However, outside of the insight from this general principle that this book provides, I would urge Christians to not read this book. Bevere quotes scripture often and the majority of time seems to be stripping the verses from their context in order to support his already made conclusions. This alone makes many of his conclusions difficult to trust. Further, he seems to not distinguish between how Old Testament Israel was to live versus the authority structure we see in the New Testament. He uses numerous examples of people submitting and not submitting to Prophets, Israelite kings, and non-Israeite kings and makes direct correlations to submitting to your head pastor. Without directly saying it, he seems to suggest that modern day “head pastors” are to be submitted to in the same way Moses was. A couple of the dangerous assumptions here are that God spoke directly to these Prophets, today, he has given us his word. Further, churches are not supposed to have one head man akin to a Prophet. God set up the structure of eldership as the group who is to make decisions for a church. Further, these elders are to submit to Christ and his word while being servants to the ones they are called to lead. Further, the way he discusses the blessings and curses seem to be gleaned from applying OT curses and blessings to today’s new covenant world. After giving an example of Africans receiving miraculous healings because they receive a minister with honor, he says, “Give great honor, and honor will be your portion.” This is one example but much of the motivation he seems to give for submitting to authorities is that God will bless you for it with success and prosperity now. He misses the new testament reality that our blessings are now realized in Christ. By submitting to authorities, we can experience the privilege of knowing God better, despite what the outcome may be. When we do not obey authorities, God may discipline us out of love for his children but we never can escape from under the cover of God’s protection. Lastly, he often puts in quotations of things that he has heard directly from God. While I am okay with him hearing from God on his own, I do think it is dangerous to defend your theology on a topic using personal revelations you have received. I do appreciate how, at the end of the book, he shows how there is forgiveness in Christ; however, I wish the promises of this forgiveness would have been highlighted more throughout the book.