I, like many, met Rachel Cusk via her Outline trilogy, and went back to this later out of curiosity about from whence she came.
While I have little contact with the outside world and its Chattering Classes, I can only assume that despite her immense talent, Rachel Cusk's stock is likely low with those who deplore her unfashionable bourgeois white feminism, which I can agree is an objectively boring thing. However, as a boring and unfashionable bourgeois white feminist, I certainly can relate to and appreciate many of her chosen themes. More to the point, Rachel Cusk writes like a motherfucker, or she anyway writes like a very cruel, terrifying, avenging and immortal goddess, and I am her helpless fan.
A lot of what was fun about this book for me was knowing that Rachel Cusk is over a decade older than I am. Her kids have already gone off to college! Hooray for her! Part of my own challenge here was fixating on that while also trying to separate out the development of her novels' characters over their life spans from the progression ("apotheosis" is surely too strong a word) of the writer herself, which did get me pretty confused.
The Rachel Cusk of Arlington Park is a much younger woman, and a much less formed writer, than the harsh and impermeable steely mistress of the Outline books. This novel contains frills and amusements and extraneous descriptions of weather, the sort of junior varsity pathetic fallacy moves that have you nod understandingly and root for the girl out there, trying her darned best. The characters in Arlington Park are similarly pathetic, and a fallacy, the kinds of rich, whiney domesticated ladies no one feels sorry for anymore.
This book is worth reading just for the contrast, because in her later work Cusk has completely excised out all of these frills and fat. In doing this, she draws an exacting but thrilling map of the way forward for a certain type of lady of a certain age: can all the whining and triviality be carved away, left as extraneous by the roadside, as we age and become harder, leaner, less funny and more dangerous and exacting, to stab right to the heart of it? Will all the snickering and jokes fall silent one day, like unneeded weight and accessories, leaving us carved and cold, nonnegotiable... finally... ultimately... having become (what I believe is known in today-ish's parlance as)... a Bad Bitch?
That was definitely my greatest takeaway from this book: that a Bad Bitch can come into existence --at least here as an artist, and hopefully too (for my own purposes) as a bitter post-menopausal bourgie mom-lady -- quite a bit later in life. Ultimately, even late in the game, with frivolity shed, tiresome complaints shaved and honed to lethal blades, a raw seriousness and its icy aesthetic can be achieved.
I hope that that's true!
If you are looking at this review trying to figure out whether to read Arlington Park, I'd want to spend a moment questioning your aims. As a mother in a tony suburb, I don't feel this book has aged especially well or spoken that meaningfully to the contemporary experience of what she's describing. However, if you happen to be completely obsessed with Rachel Cusk, which you should be, because she's fascinating and incredible, than obviously this could be fun and maybe even worthwhile to read. As a novel, it's okay.... Not that bad, not that good! Its main value is its unintended though powerful message that it is possible to move relatively swiftly from negligible to transcendent, and we all should hope that whatever it took Cusk to achieve that transcendence (spider bite? radiation exposure?) happens one day to us: that we harden, minimize, and look down to find we've become a Bad Bitch Ice Goddess who can describe the essentials of our experience using only the most perfect and necessary words.