What do you think?
Rate this book
CAROLINE
Whatever happened to Caroline Bingley after her brother and unrequited love interest married a Bennet sister? Join me in this story of redemptive love and the healing of broken dreams.
Caroline Bingley, beyond frustrated with her brother, Charles and Mr. Darcy both proposing to the Bennet sisters, dreads their upcoming nuptials. For three years her sole focus has been on attaining a marriage proposal from one Fitzwilliam Darcy of Pemberley, only to be foiled by a country miss with ‘fine eyes’. Adrift and not sure of her place in life, she meets the mysterious and devastatingly handsome Lord Nathan, who equally vexes and intrigues her.
Lord Nathan Kerr, third in line to a Dukedom, had a well-earned reputation as a Rake. He cast all that and his noble title aside to become Mr. Darcy’s vicar in Kympton, finding contentment in leading his small flock and doing the Lord’s work. His plan for a quiet, country life is thrown into upheaval when he meets the fiery Miss Bingley. Can he reconcile his rising desire for the spoiled miss with how a vicar’s wife ‘should’ behave?
Caroline Bingley, beyond frustrated with her brother, Charles and Mr. Darcy both proposing to the Bennet sisters, dreads their upcoming nuptials. For three years her sole focus has been on attaining a marriage proposal from one Fitzwilliam Darcy of Pemberley, only to be foiled by a country miss with ‘fine eyes’. Adrift and not sure of her place in life, she meets the mysterious and devastatingly handsome Lord Nathan, who equally vexes and intrigues her.
Lord Nathan Kerr, third in line to a Dukedom, had a well-earned reputation as a Rake. He cast all that and his noble title aside to become Mr. Darcy’s vicar in Kympton, finding contentment in leading his small flock and doing the Lord’s work. His plan for a quiet, country life is thrown into upheaval when he meets the fiery Miss Bingley. Can he reconcile his rising desire for the spoiled miss with how a vicar’s wife ‘should’ behave?
204 pages, Paperback
Published February 8, 2017
9 people are currently reading
409 people want to read
About the author
Sue Barr
18 books89 followers“If I loved you less, I might be able to talk about it more.” ~ Jane Austen
I love all things Regency and sometimes a wee Highlander story. I also have a weakness for Alpha males and feisty heroines, who keep them on their toes.
I love all things Regency and sometimes a wee Highlander story. I also have a weakness for Alpha males and feisty heroines, who keep them on their toes.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
March 26, 2017
4 stars!
Review and Giveaway at Of Pens and Pages.
I didn’t now what to expect when I first heard of this story. I’m not Caroline’s biggest fan, but there’s always been a tiny part of me that wanted to know what happened to her after Mr. Bingley and Mr. Darcy married their respective Bennet brides.
And color me surprised. I enjoyed this story very much! It was interesting to see how Ms. Barr would write what life was like for Caroline after her brother’s engagement to Jane. She started out as every bit the character we got to know in Pride and Prejudice—shallow, judgmental, and has a penchant for looking down on other people. She finds a match in Lord Nathan Kerr, a reformed rake, and the current vicar at Kympton.
Like Darcy and Elizabeth, Caroline and Nathan’s love story was not without its bumps along the way. The two first meet in London at the theatre where it was easy to see the attraction between the two. Caroline expected him to call on her, but when he didn’t, she tried to forget him, not once thinking they’d cross paths again.
They both had their inner battles and reservations. Nathan has heard of Caroline and her goal in securing a good match, and Caroline has heard of Nathan’s past reputation as a rake. They both fight their attraction, and in the process, ended up arguing at almost every encounter. Nathan, like Elizabeth towards Darcy, was quick to judge Caroline, and Caroline never fails to fights back. I’ll be honest and say it bothered me when Nathan judged Caroline and accused her of such terrible things. And will you look at that? I’m actually sympathizing with a character I’ve always disliked! It shows the lady in question has made some progress in trying to be a better person.
There was a lot of introspective moments for Caroline as she realizes how she’s been acting before and she sees how people really see her. She draws strength from the memory of her grandmama and the scriptures from the bible her grandmama spoke to her when she was still alive. Nathan was like her, too. After fighting in the war, he became despondent and found distraction in vices and debauchery. With the help of her brother, the Duke, he found enlightenment in the word of the Lord.
As she aims to change for the better, Caroline gains new friends, those of whom are unexpected yet makes total sense. It reminded me of Kitty, who eventually improved for the better when she found better company and a more calming influence.
Nathan is a man of the cloth, but there are moments when you can still see hints of mischief and flirtatious actions. I couldn’t help but giggle when he made a move on Caroline. I giggled every time he did! Such a charming man!
Although the story focuses on Caroline and Nathan’s story, we still get a glimpse of our beloved characters. We see how the Bingley siblings are with each other, how sweet and in tune with each other Darcy and Elizabeth are. Those two never fail to put a smile on my face!
Caroline reminded me of the Cinderella sequel where Cinderella’s step-sister, Anastasia, falls in love with a baker. She finds love in the most unexpected place, and has found happiness and contentment along with it. There’s nothing I love more than character growth! This book has made me a happy happy girl.
Caroline is a clean, Christian historical romance fiction told in the third POV, but alternates from Caroline’s perspective to Nathan’s. I think it’s a successful variation when I found myself cheering for Caroline and hoping she finds her own happily ever after. If you’re looking for a quick and insightful read, you might enjoy Caroline.
*ARC received in exchange for an honest review.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram
Review and Giveaway at Of Pens and Pages.
I didn’t now what to expect when I first heard of this story. I’m not Caroline’s biggest fan, but there’s always been a tiny part of me that wanted to know what happened to her after Mr. Bingley and Mr. Darcy married their respective Bennet brides.
And color me surprised. I enjoyed this story very much! It was interesting to see how Ms. Barr would write what life was like for Caroline after her brother’s engagement to Jane. She started out as every bit the character we got to know in Pride and Prejudice—shallow, judgmental, and has a penchant for looking down on other people. She finds a match in Lord Nathan Kerr, a reformed rake, and the current vicar at Kympton.
Like Darcy and Elizabeth, Caroline and Nathan’s love story was not without its bumps along the way. The two first meet in London at the theatre where it was easy to see the attraction between the two. Caroline expected him to call on her, but when he didn’t, she tried to forget him, not once thinking they’d cross paths again.
They both had their inner battles and reservations. Nathan has heard of Caroline and her goal in securing a good match, and Caroline has heard of Nathan’s past reputation as a rake. They both fight their attraction, and in the process, ended up arguing at almost every encounter. Nathan, like Elizabeth towards Darcy, was quick to judge Caroline, and Caroline never fails to fights back. I’ll be honest and say it bothered me when Nathan judged Caroline and accused her of such terrible things. And will you look at that? I’m actually sympathizing with a character I’ve always disliked! It shows the lady in question has made some progress in trying to be a better person.
There was a lot of introspective moments for Caroline as she realizes how she’s been acting before and she sees how people really see her. She draws strength from the memory of her grandmama and the scriptures from the bible her grandmama spoke to her when she was still alive. Nathan was like her, too. After fighting in the war, he became despondent and found distraction in vices and debauchery. With the help of her brother, the Duke, he found enlightenment in the word of the Lord.
As she aims to change for the better, Caroline gains new friends, those of whom are unexpected yet makes total sense. It reminded me of Kitty, who eventually improved for the better when she found better company and a more calming influence.
Nathan is a man of the cloth, but there are moments when you can still see hints of mischief and flirtatious actions. I couldn’t help but giggle when he made a move on Caroline. I giggled every time he did! Such a charming man!
Although the story focuses on Caroline and Nathan’s story, we still get a glimpse of our beloved characters. We see how the Bingley siblings are with each other, how sweet and in tune with each other Darcy and Elizabeth are. Those two never fail to put a smile on my face!
Caroline reminded me of the Cinderella sequel where Cinderella’s step-sister, Anastasia, falls in love with a baker. She finds love in the most unexpected place, and has found happiness and contentment along with it. There’s nothing I love more than character growth! This book has made me a happy happy girl.
Caroline is a clean, Christian historical romance fiction told in the third POV, but alternates from Caroline’s perspective to Nathan’s. I think it’s a successful variation when I found myself cheering for Caroline and hoping she finds her own happily ever after. If you’re looking for a quick and insightful read, you might enjoy Caroline.
*ARC received in exchange for an honest review.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram
March 23, 2017
4.5 stars rounded up to 5 stars:
It is near midnight as I finished reading this story. Surprisingly I did love it...and though others may find it hard to believe, this author does find a way to redeem Caroline...a lady, who along with Wickham, we love to hate.
Know this: the author does bring in her Christian beliefs and the power of prayer. I have read other authors' stories in which they do such and if it is not presented in a preaching and overbearing style it can add to the story...in my opinion.
So Caroline has lost her campaign for Darcy and the man lets her know that he will no longer tolerant any insults to his fiancée. Caroline's brother and sister have made it known also that there will be no place in their homes for her in the future.
Caroline is to attend the double wedding for Charles and Darcy and it is to be held in Derbyshire. So she is invited to Pemberley along with the other guests. A ball is to be held a few days in advance to allow friends to get to know each other better. It is at this ball that the chemistry between Caroline and Lord Nathan sizzles. But she does only knows of his reputation as a rake in London and then he dropped from the scene about 3 years ago. She expects he will come calling the next day as she is sure he was attracted to her. No dice - what?
Nathan is a third son and had chosen to buy a commission in the military. His experiences on the Continent sickened him. And when after those life experiences his brother shows him a way to change his outlook on life he becomes a totally different man. Then Darcy offers him the living at Kympton.
Yes, he is drawn to this fiery redhead and he learns much about her in questioning others of their circle of friends. But he wants to follow the path GOD led him to and he now questions if she can fit into the life of service in a country parish...because she has told him that she wants a life in London with all the razzle-dazzle of the ton and what he has learned of her confirms this. He prays about it and asks for guidance.
The author does a convincing job of writing how Caroline finally, when things look their darkest for her future, looks at her own life and makes some comparisons to those around her and then makes some changes. She does not become Goody-two-shoes, but she convinces shy sweet Georgiana that she is sincere...Whoa! Now that you have to read about.
It is near midnight as I finished reading this story. Surprisingly I did love it...and though others may find it hard to believe, this author does find a way to redeem Caroline...a lady, who along with Wickham, we love to hate.
Know this: the author does bring in her Christian beliefs and the power of prayer. I have read other authors' stories in which they do such and if it is not presented in a preaching and overbearing style it can add to the story...in my opinion.
So Caroline has lost her campaign for Darcy and the man lets her know that he will no longer tolerant any insults to his fiancée. Caroline's brother and sister have made it known also that there will be no place in their homes for her in the future.
Caroline is to attend the double wedding for Charles and Darcy and it is to be held in Derbyshire. So she is invited to Pemberley along with the other guests. A ball is to be held a few days in advance to allow friends to get to know each other better. It is at this ball that the chemistry between Caroline and Lord Nathan sizzles. But she does only knows of his reputation as a rake in London and then he dropped from the scene about 3 years ago. She expects he will come calling the next day as she is sure he was attracted to her. No dice - what?
Nathan is a third son and had chosen to buy a commission in the military. His experiences on the Continent sickened him. And when after those life experiences his brother shows him a way to change his outlook on life he becomes a totally different man. Then Darcy offers him the living at Kympton.
Yes, he is drawn to this fiery redhead and he learns much about her in questioning others of their circle of friends. But he wants to follow the path GOD led him to and he now questions if she can fit into the life of service in a country parish...because she has told him that she wants a life in London with all the razzle-dazzle of the ton and what he has learned of her confirms this. He prays about it and asks for guidance.
The author does a convincing job of writing how Caroline finally, when things look their darkest for her future, looks at her own life and makes some comparisons to those around her and then makes some changes. She does not become Goody-two-shoes, but she convinces shy sweet Georgiana that she is sincere...Whoa! Now that you have to read about.
February 6, 2017
Read on AHA. Subtle inspiration themes with romantic heat. If you like her writing, try Sue Barr's non-JAFF sweet modern romances, particularly "According to Plan," with its detective/mystery plot.
February 16, 2017
Very nicely thought out story of Caroline Bingley's complete change in attitude. It's a beguiling combination of romance and Christian redemption.
As the story opens, Caroline is still smugly certain that Mr. Darcy will offer for her. The rug is unceremoniously yanked from under her when a letter from her brother Charles arrives for Louisa. It announces that not only will he be marrying Jane Bennet, but the wedding will be shared with Jane's sister Elizabeth, who is actually marrying Mr. Darcy! Recognizing the necessity of mending fences with the Bennet sisters in order to maintain a pathway to the higher social sphere to which she aspires, Caroline must compose a congratulatory letter to Jane.
In the midst of Caroline's despair over the unexpected turn of events, she starts to remember how her grandmother would comfort her when she was a little girl. Scripture verses she has not ever thought about in any depth come to mind and have unsettling significance as she reflects on her past behavior and looks for guidance for her uncertain future.
It is in a less confident state of mind that Caroline encounters Lord Nathanial Kerr at a London theatre. Significantly, she finds herself attracted to him rather than to his older brother Maxwell, the Duke of Adborough.
Nathan has a reputation of having been a notorious rake after resigning his military commission, although he has been out of society's eye for the past four years. What Caroline doesn't know is that Nathan experienced a dramatic religious conversion, repented of his dissolute past, attended seminary, and then Darcy appointed him to the living at Kympton, where he is now the vicar. "Mr. Kerr," as he prefers to be known now, will be officiating at the double wedding of Darcy and Bingley to the Bennet sisters.
Caroline and Nathan fight their mutual attraction. Nathan has heard from Darcy about her determination to move up in society by marrying well, even if she has to use devious means to do so. Meanwhile, Caroline has no intention of allowing herself to be a plaything for a rake.
Answered prayer leads these two to each other although, in my own experience, the Lord rarely responds quite so promptly! I enjoyed discovering Caroline's softer side and found the way this story evolves to be believable; it's often perceived failure that leads to self-reflection and correction of our life goals. The writing flows nicely, alternating the POV primarily between the two main characters.
Generally, this is a pleasing novella that's well worth reading.
As the story opens, Caroline is still smugly certain that Mr. Darcy will offer for her. The rug is unceremoniously yanked from under her when a letter from her brother Charles arrives for Louisa. It announces that not only will he be marrying Jane Bennet, but the wedding will be shared with Jane's sister Elizabeth, who is actually marrying Mr. Darcy! Recognizing the necessity of mending fences with the Bennet sisters in order to maintain a pathway to the higher social sphere to which she aspires, Caroline must compose a congratulatory letter to Jane.
In the midst of Caroline's despair over the unexpected turn of events, she starts to remember how her grandmother would comfort her when she was a little girl. Scripture verses she has not ever thought about in any depth come to mind and have unsettling significance as she reflects on her past behavior and looks for guidance for her uncertain future.
It is in a less confident state of mind that Caroline encounters Lord Nathanial Kerr at a London theatre. Significantly, she finds herself attracted to him rather than to his older brother Maxwell, the Duke of Adborough.
Nathan has a reputation of having been a notorious rake after resigning his military commission, although he has been out of society's eye for the past four years. What Caroline doesn't know is that Nathan experienced a dramatic religious conversion, repented of his dissolute past, attended seminary, and then Darcy appointed him to the living at Kympton, where he is now the vicar. "Mr. Kerr," as he prefers to be known now, will be officiating at the double wedding of Darcy and Bingley to the Bennet sisters.
Caroline and Nathan fight their mutual attraction. Nathan has heard from Darcy about her determination to move up in society by marrying well, even if she has to use devious means to do so. Meanwhile, Caroline has no intention of allowing herself to be a plaything for a rake.
Answered prayer leads these two to each other although, in my own experience, the Lord rarely responds quite so promptly! I enjoyed discovering Caroline's softer side and found the way this story evolves to be believable; it's often perceived failure that leads to self-reflection and correction of our life goals. The writing flows nicely, alternating the POV primarily between the two main characters.
Generally, this is a pleasing novella that's well worth reading.
April 18, 2017
Review Initially posted on :
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...
Did you ever think about what was Miss Bingley’s reaction to Darcy’s engagement? Can you imagine what it must have been like to realise everything she fought for during the last years of her life had been for nothing? What about her future? Did she ever get married? Or ended up an old spinster? Did she let go of her feelings of superiority towards the Bennet sisters?
Sue Barr clearly thought about all these questions and wrote a delicious novel describing Caroline Bingley’s life after the double engagement of Darcy and Bingley 🙂
I was never a fan of Caroline Bingley, but lately I find stories about her quite interesting and Sue Barr definitely made me want to read more about Caroline. In fact, there is so much potential about Miss Bingley’s character that I wonder why we don’t have more stories about her, Sue Barr clearly saw all this potential and used it in an exceptional manner.
Caroline is a romance whose main character is Caroline Bingley but it isn’t just a book about a secondary character of Pride & Prejudice, it is a book about second chances, lessons learnt and personal growth. This story tells us how Caroline took the news that shattered her life and how she moved on, but also how others continued to view her and react to her actions. These two aspects made the book very real because life makes us who we are, it shapes our behaviours and personalities, and some events may alter us into someone else, but it doesn’t erase who we were and the perception others have of us. That perception will only change if we change ourselves and if our new behaviours are different from what they used to be, and that is what happens to Miss Bingley in this book,she is brought to life as an imperfect human being who is forced to grow with life’s blows.
But as I mentioned earlier, this is a romance, so it’s not all about inner growth. Caroline’s love interest in this book will be Lord Nathan..err..I mean Mr. Kerr..or shall I say both? Let’s just say you would never picture Caroline with someone with this profession, but neither would you imagine someone with this profession exactly like him. I did like to know why he chose it though, it made me understand why someone with that background and personality ended up as a vicar. He is a charming man, and should I say too good for Caroline? Or is that my prejudice speaking? He is indeed an interesting character and I loved his interactions with Caroline but I would have prefered for them to have a different ending… don’t worry, there is a HEA, I would just prefer it if it wasn’t so perfect.
If you want a secondary character story which is fast to read and a page turner, this book is for you! I’m sure you’ll enjoy it between two ODC books 🙂
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...
Did you ever think about what was Miss Bingley’s reaction to Darcy’s engagement? Can you imagine what it must have been like to realise everything she fought for during the last years of her life had been for nothing? What about her future? Did she ever get married? Or ended up an old spinster? Did she let go of her feelings of superiority towards the Bennet sisters?
Sue Barr clearly thought about all these questions and wrote a delicious novel describing Caroline Bingley’s life after the double engagement of Darcy and Bingley 🙂
I was never a fan of Caroline Bingley, but lately I find stories about her quite interesting and Sue Barr definitely made me want to read more about Caroline. In fact, there is so much potential about Miss Bingley’s character that I wonder why we don’t have more stories about her, Sue Barr clearly saw all this potential and used it in an exceptional manner.
Caroline is a romance whose main character is Caroline Bingley but it isn’t just a book about a secondary character of Pride & Prejudice, it is a book about second chances, lessons learnt and personal growth. This story tells us how Caroline took the news that shattered her life and how she moved on, but also how others continued to view her and react to her actions. These two aspects made the book very real because life makes us who we are, it shapes our behaviours and personalities, and some events may alter us into someone else, but it doesn’t erase who we were and the perception others have of us. That perception will only change if we change ourselves and if our new behaviours are different from what they used to be, and that is what happens to Miss Bingley in this book,she is brought to life as an imperfect human being who is forced to grow with life’s blows.
But as I mentioned earlier, this is a romance, so it’s not all about inner growth. Caroline’s love interest in this book will be Lord Nathan..err..I mean Mr. Kerr..or shall I say both? Let’s just say you would never picture Caroline with someone with this profession, but neither would you imagine someone with this profession exactly like him. I did like to know why he chose it though, it made me understand why someone with that background and personality ended up as a vicar. He is a charming man, and should I say too good for Caroline? Or is that my prejudice speaking? He is indeed an interesting character and I loved his interactions with Caroline but I would have prefered for them to have a different ending… don’t worry, there is a HEA, I would just prefer it if it wasn’t so perfect.
If you want a secondary character story which is fast to read and a page turner, this book is for you! I’m sure you’ll enjoy it between two ODC books 🙂
Read
November 3, 2017Review originally posted on Diary of an Eccentric
Caroline is the first book in a series of Pride and Prejudice sequels by Sue Barr, opening when Mr. Darcy and Mr. Bingley go back to Hertfordshire to propose to Elizabeth and Jane Bennet. Caroline Bingley is angry and distraught when she learns of Mr. Darcy’s engagement to the “country miss” Elizabeth Bennet, as she’d spent the last few years trying to grab his attention in her quest to marry into high society. Meanwhile, Lord Nathan Kerr, Mr. Darcy’s new vicar, is instantly captivated by Caroline but understands that, in her current frame of mind, she is not a suitable match for him.
Unaware of Lord Nathan’s humble lifestyle in Kympton, Caroline is infuriated by his judgmental comments. She knows that Mr. Darcy is lost to her forever and that she must forge a new path for herself, but Lord Nathan can’t help lashing out at her for her marital aspirations. Yet neither can deny the growing passion between them, nor can they deny that they both need to do some serious soul searching before they can find inner peace.
I really enjoyed Barr’s take on Caroline, from her temper tantrums to her memories of her grandmamma — and the advice she soon realizes she must take to heart. I also loved Lord Nathan, the reformed rake who still struggles with his memories of the war and the behavior he put behind him when he took orders. I thought he was pretty harsh to Caroline, but getting to see things through his point of view made me understand him better. It was entertaining to see their evolution over the course of this short novel. I was so wrapped up in their troubles that I didn’t mind the quick character development or that Mr. Darcy/Elizabeth and Mr. Bingley/Jane take a backseat as their wedding preparations are underway.
Barr does a good job handling the Christian elements of the novel, from the Scripture passages Caroline remembers from her grandmamma to Lord Nathan’s prayers and counseling. It made sense given Lord Nathan’s occupation, and it wasn’t too heavy-handed. The only minor quibble I had with the book is that the ending seemed too convenient given the character development throughout the novel.
Overall, Caroline is a strong start to the series, and readers will be happy that there isn’t a cliffhanger ending. I was thrilled to see a description for Book Two at the end of Book One, and I cannot wait to read the next volume!
I received a free copy of this book for review.
Caroline is the first book in a series of Pride and Prejudice sequels by Sue Barr, opening when Mr. Darcy and Mr. Bingley go back to Hertfordshire to propose to Elizabeth and Jane Bennet. Caroline Bingley is angry and distraught when she learns of Mr. Darcy’s engagement to the “country miss” Elizabeth Bennet, as she’d spent the last few years trying to grab his attention in her quest to marry into high society. Meanwhile, Lord Nathan Kerr, Mr. Darcy’s new vicar, is instantly captivated by Caroline but understands that, in her current frame of mind, she is not a suitable match for him.
Unaware of Lord Nathan’s humble lifestyle in Kympton, Caroline is infuriated by his judgmental comments. She knows that Mr. Darcy is lost to her forever and that she must forge a new path for herself, but Lord Nathan can’t help lashing out at her for her marital aspirations. Yet neither can deny the growing passion between them, nor can they deny that they both need to do some serious soul searching before they can find inner peace.
I really enjoyed Barr’s take on Caroline, from her temper tantrums to her memories of her grandmamma — and the advice she soon realizes she must take to heart. I also loved Lord Nathan, the reformed rake who still struggles with his memories of the war and the behavior he put behind him when he took orders. I thought he was pretty harsh to Caroline, but getting to see things through his point of view made me understand him better. It was entertaining to see their evolution over the course of this short novel. I was so wrapped up in their troubles that I didn’t mind the quick character development or that Mr. Darcy/Elizabeth and Mr. Bingley/Jane take a backseat as their wedding preparations are underway.
Barr does a good job handling the Christian elements of the novel, from the Scripture passages Caroline remembers from her grandmamma to Lord Nathan’s prayers and counseling. It made sense given Lord Nathan’s occupation, and it wasn’t too heavy-handed. The only minor quibble I had with the book is that the ending seemed too convenient given the character development throughout the novel.
Overall, Caroline is a strong start to the series, and readers will be happy that there isn’t a cliffhanger ending. I was thrilled to see a description for Book Two at the end of Book One, and I cannot wait to read the next volume!
I received a free copy of this book for review.
January 30, 2020
In this P&P variation so how does Caroline Bingley fair when Darcy announces that he is to marry Elizabeth Bennet? Then she meets Lord Nathan - he everything she has always wanted - society and a title but he is the vicar of Kympton.
Really enjoyed this story, another re-read before reading the next in the series, of this well-written Caroline's story. She certainly has become a likeable character.
Really enjoyed this story, another re-read before reading the next in the series, of this well-written Caroline's story. She certainly has become a likeable character.
October 11, 2017
I love when authors take secondary characters from 'Pride and Prejudice' and develop them further. I go in with an open mind and wait for the author to give further depth to them. Ms. Barr takes Caroline Bingley from her high pretentious pedestal to her earth shattering fall, when she learns both her brother, Charles, and Mr. Darcy are marrying the two eldest Bennet sisters. We get to see how Caroline flounders, as she tries to find a way out of her misery. She becomes more reflective of her past and the grandmother who could sooth her soul, but she is still bound and determined to become a wife of a peer.
Then she meets Lord Nathan, not knowing he is Darcy's vicar. The man frustrates her to no end. He questions her past, her present and her future. For he is man who has seen the worst that humankind can do to each other and has come out on the other side...but only through his faith. (As others have said, there is a Christian element to this story, but I felt it appropriate to the narrative.)
"Where was Charles? He was her anchor. Without his calming presence she felt as though she were bobbing about the surface of the water and Lord Nathan a hurricane force wind about to descend."
I enjoyed this redemptive story on Caroline. The chemistry between her and Lord Nathan was palpable and the road to each other was not easy. There were some touching scenes as well between Caroline, Jane and Elizabeth. I also enjoyed having most of it take place at Pemberley where we got snippets of all our favourite characters. However, Lord Nathan, and his brother, Max, the Duke of Adborough, where two delightful new characters that I enjoyed getting to know. I must say though that the 'Steward of the Linen Cupboard' added just the right touch of humour when it was needed.
Note: The cover art deserves it's praise as well.
February 7, 2017
This is a super fast paced story that reveals how Caroline Bingley was completely surprised by her brother's engagement to Miss Jane Bennet and Mr. Darcy's engagement to Miss Elizabeth Bennet. She quickly learns she has no hope of changing their minds so she had better straighten up and fly right. However everyone is a bit suspicious of Miss Bingley's motivations.
I should also note that the author goes off canon and moves the Darcy/Bennet/Bingley wedding to Pemberley. I should also note that as with the title this is a book about Caroline, ODC and others are really minor supporting characters if you are looking for details or really even much dialogue with them it isn't in this book.
Prior to heading north Caro and the Hursts attend the theater where they meet a Duke and his brother, Lord Nathan Kerr. At this point we the reader know a secret Caro doesn't - who Lord Nathan really is... and that Lord Nathan has had an ear full of her behavior towards the Bennets, her brother and Darcy.
When they 'reunite' at Pemberley sparks fly. Caro does seem to be making a genuine attempt at self improvement and self refection but Nathan is determined to see the worst of her. He twice accuses her of looking to compromise someone. And he stands by silently while a member of the nobility insults her to her face. I think the author is trying to imitate the tension between Darcy & Lizzy but it didn't ring true to me. While Darcy insults Lizzy's family he never insulted her directly.
The story moves very quickly it pretty much jumps from important scene to important scene with little unnecessary filler. There is also a bit of Christianity and Bible quotes.
I should also note that the author goes off canon and moves the Darcy/Bennet/Bingley wedding to Pemberley. I should also note that as with the title this is a book about Caroline, ODC and others are really minor supporting characters if you are looking for details or really even much dialogue with them it isn't in this book.
Prior to heading north Caro and the Hursts attend the theater where they meet a Duke and his brother, Lord Nathan Kerr. At this point we the reader know a secret Caro doesn't - who Lord Nathan really is... and that Lord Nathan has had an ear full of her behavior towards the Bennets, her brother and Darcy.
When they 'reunite' at Pemberley sparks fly. Caro does seem to be making a genuine attempt at self improvement and self refection but Nathan is determined to see the worst of her. He twice accuses her of looking to compromise someone. And he stands by silently while a member of the nobility insults her to her face. I think the author is trying to imitate the tension between Darcy & Lizzy but it didn't ring true to me. While Darcy insults Lizzy's family he never insulted her directly.
The story moves very quickly it pretty much jumps from important scene to important scene with little unnecessary filler. There is also a bit of Christianity and Bible quotes.
March 8, 2017
People change and forget to tell each other -- Lillian Hellman
Redemption -- did we ever think it would happen to the shrewish Caroline Bingley?
Our story begins with the Bingley sisters discovering their brother has returned to Netherfield -- they suppose he needs to check the house before giving up the lease. Little do they suspect he will return betrothed to Jane Bennet!
As her story continues, Caroline must face her loss – not only of her brother but the loss of her hopes for Darcy (uh, rather her hopes for Pemberley).
SPOILER: Caroline meets a clergyman who looks for someone able to give to others and suspects Caroline is selfish and manipulative. He twice thinks he has caught her trying to compromise a wealthy man. Their story contains multiple misunderstandings – willful and otherwise.
It must be something perverse in my character but I kept expecting that Caroline would stumble back into her regular habits. Or maybe that the man she admired would see through her and fall for Kitty or Mary or Georgiana or someone else instead.
A HEA for my favorite shrew just doesn’t seem right to me.
This story is a well-written and mostly free of grammatical and typographical errors.
Lots of people want to ride with you in the limo, but what you want is someone who will take the bus with you when the limo breaks down. ~Oprah Winfrey
Redemption -- did we ever think it would happen to the shrewish Caroline Bingley?
Our story begins with the Bingley sisters discovering their brother has returned to Netherfield -- they suppose he needs to check the house before giving up the lease. Little do they suspect he will return betrothed to Jane Bennet!
As her story continues, Caroline must face her loss – not only of her brother but the loss of her hopes for Darcy (uh, rather her hopes for Pemberley).
SPOILER: Caroline meets a clergyman who looks for someone able to give to others and suspects Caroline is selfish and manipulative. He twice thinks he has caught her trying to compromise a wealthy man. Their story contains multiple misunderstandings – willful and otherwise.
It must be something perverse in my character but I kept expecting that Caroline would stumble back into her regular habits. Or maybe that the man she admired would see through her and fall for Kitty or Mary or Georgiana or someone else instead.
A HEA for my favorite shrew just doesn’t seem right to me.
This story is a well-written and mostly free of grammatical and typographical errors.
Lots of people want to ride with you in the limo, but what you want is someone who will take the bus with you when the limo breaks down. ~Oprah Winfrey
March 17, 2017
4.5 stars rounded up
I rounded this up because I needed this enjoyable story after a most stressful month of illness and moving. I loved seeing Caroline redeemed almost as much as I love evil Caroline. I found Caroline's transformation believable. I can't wait for Georgiana's story by this author.
I rounded this up because I needed this enjoyable story after a most stressful month of illness and moving. I loved seeing Caroline redeemed almost as much as I love evil Caroline. I found Caroline's transformation believable. I can't wait for Georgiana's story by this author.
February 19, 2017
Caroline Bingley must come to terms with the fact that Darcy is marrying Elizabeth and that her brother is marrying Jane. How will this impact her social climbing wishes? By chance she is introduced to a duke and his brother. Lord Nathan and Caroline bump heads constantly once she discovers that he also lives in Derbyshire as Darcy's vicar!
This book takes a religious bend as the vicar is a reformed rake and Caroline does a lot of soul searching and praying about her life. Together they find love.
It was a cute story but I am not a fan of the religious aspect. I also find it hard to believe that Caroline could change so much in such a short period of time.
As a side note the woman on the book cover is beautiful!
This book takes a religious bend as the vicar is a reformed rake and Caroline does a lot of soul searching and praying about her life. Together they find love.
It was a cute story but I am not a fan of the religious aspect. I also find it hard to believe that Caroline could change so much in such a short period of time.
As a side note the woman on the book cover is beautiful!
July 8, 2018
This was a good redemption book for Caroline and I actually liked who she ended up with. It's also a fast read with it being a short book.
February 17, 2017
I loved this book, a very different look at Caroline Bingley - you actually end up rooting for her by the end of the book!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 21, 2017
Mr Darcy and Mr Bingley are engaged to two Miss Bennets and Caroline Bingley could not be more angry, disappointed and lost. Even after seeing the attraction that Darcy had towards “dear Eliza” or how happy his brother seemed with “dear Jane”, she kept thinking about herself and how she will conquer Darcy and become the next mistress of Pemberley. However, now everything is lost to her and she is lost.
I have a nickname for this book: “the penny dropper”. Caroline acts like a child and her brother explains very clearly what will happen if she dares to damage his relationship again.
In this book we read how her understanding of the world comes around. She still wishes to become a lady and get a rich husband and be an important part of society but maybe her feelings about that are not her only drive.
Caroline has never been in love before and therefore she does not understand how her body and her mind acts when she meets Lord Nathan.
Lord Nathan is not exactly what he appears to be. he used to be a rake but now he is quite the opposite but at the beginning Caroline does not know. Their attraction is mutual but also their stubbornness and their different ways of finding happiness. They will evolve into new characters, the evolution is greater in Caroline but Lord Nathan with his faith will also have to realise what God has put in front of him and how his life outside the ton can be seen as a non-appealing one by Caroline.
So, can you see a nice Caroline? Can you believe that she will change completely? Do you think she is capable of love? What would you do if a new acquaintance is always following you thinking that you are about to do the worst? What if everything is misunderstanding? What is your “worst enemy” (Elizabeth Bennet) is your only person to ask for advise? What if love is more powerful than society but then you are actually rewarded?
I have a nickname for this book: “the penny dropper”. Caroline acts like a child and her brother explains very clearly what will happen if she dares to damage his relationship again.
In this book we read how her understanding of the world comes around. She still wishes to become a lady and get a rich husband and be an important part of society but maybe her feelings about that are not her only drive.
Caroline has never been in love before and therefore she does not understand how her body and her mind acts when she meets Lord Nathan.
Lord Nathan is not exactly what he appears to be. he used to be a rake but now he is quite the opposite but at the beginning Caroline does not know. Their attraction is mutual but also their stubbornness and their different ways of finding happiness. They will evolve into new characters, the evolution is greater in Caroline but Lord Nathan with his faith will also have to realise what God has put in front of him and how his life outside the ton can be seen as a non-appealing one by Caroline.
So, can you see a nice Caroline? Can you believe that she will change completely? Do you think she is capable of love? What would you do if a new acquaintance is always following you thinking that you are about to do the worst? What if everything is misunderstanding? What is your “worst enemy” (Elizabeth Bennet) is your only person to ask for advise? What if love is more powerful than society but then you are actually rewarded?
February 13, 2017
A Strong Step Forward
As a writer who believes that the secondary characters in Pride and Prejudice, Ms Barr;'s Caroline was a pleasure to read...No...Savor. She starts with the traditional treatment of Caroline Bingley and advances her in a realistic and plausible manner. Her acceptance of the liaison with the Bennet family may strike some as sudden and too Pat. But, Caroline's personal Road To Damascus had to have already been in the making. Barr's device of giving Caroline her own personal conscience in the form of a loving but late grandmother helped ground the character. Her rediscovery of a her inner self after the rupture in her worldview makes this "Caroline" well worth the reading.
As a writer who believes that the secondary characters in Pride and Prejudice, Ms Barr;'s Caroline was a pleasure to read...No...Savor. She starts with the traditional treatment of Caroline Bingley and advances her in a realistic and plausible manner. Her acceptance of the liaison with the Bennet family may strike some as sudden and too Pat. But, Caroline's personal Road To Damascus had to have already been in the making. Barr's device of giving Caroline her own personal conscience in the form of a loving but late grandmother helped ground the character. Her rediscovery of a her inner self after the rupture in her worldview makes this "Caroline" well worth the reading.
April 23, 2023
There are days when you start a book and you have to adjust all the rest of the weekend around it. This is one of those books! I am not one who likes continuations as a general rule. Sue is masterful in this tale. A delightful changing of Miss Bingley's character to her deliciously enticing gentleman. It was also done in a way that still the bulk of the book took place during the engagement period for Darcy and Elizabeth, and Jane and her brother, so that all of it was her quiet realizations and her accepting that she was less and more than she had thought. A beautiful story for a character most love to hate.
May 24, 2017
3.5-4 stars.
Overall, I thought it was a very nice story. Well written, although there was the occasional wrong word, typo etc - but I've seen those even in books from the "traditional" publishers.
a few other minor issues:
- There was a certain amount of religion, so if you're not religious and/or Christian, it may bother you a bit, however it's not so much as to be too offensive.
- as other reviewers have noted, Caroline did seem to reform rather quickly.
- many of the characters were given ages that seemed a bit too young. Nathan has done an awful lot for someone only in his mid-20s!
I received a free copy from the author in a giveaway on her blog tour.
Overall, I thought it was a very nice story. Well written, although there was the occasional wrong word, typo etc - but I've seen those even in books from the "traditional" publishers.
a few other minor issues:
- There was a certain amount of religion, so if you're not religious and/or Christian, it may bother you a bit, however it's not so much as to be too offensive.
- as other reviewers have noted, Caroline did seem to reform rather quickly.
- many of the characters were given ages that seemed a bit too young. Nathan has done an awful lot for someone only in his mid-20s!
I received a free copy from the author in a giveaway on her blog tour.
July 6, 2017
Wonderfully written. I felt the temper rising as Caroline finds she can’t have her way. She learns the hard way, manipulation brings pain. Enjoyed the scenery but the story line kept me up much past my bedtime. Just had to finish Caroline!
January 8, 2018
This book has received a Discovering Diamonds Review:
Helen Hollick
founder #DDRevs
"...a light and sweet story with a lovely happily ever after. It was a fast read and kept me entertained throughout "
Helen Hollick
founder #DDRevs
"...a light and sweet story with a lovely happily ever after. It was a fast read and kept me entertained throughout "
February 14, 2017
I am surprised that this book has such high marks. I expected to enjoy it and did at the beginning but after the constant berating of Caroline's character by one who hardly knew her, plus her attraction to that person, it was too much. It reminds me of the popularity of Shades of Grey which I can not comprehend. I kept thinking, how would this play out to readers if this was Elizabeth in the Caroline role.
I did enjoy the references to Caroline's family and childhood. That was endearing and special. If only Caroline was allowed by the author to be a complete person, I would have been on board.
I did enjoy the references to Caroline's family and childhood. That was endearing and special. If only Caroline was allowed by the author to be a complete person, I would have been on board.
February 14, 2017
I always appreciate it when an Austen variation/sequel author makes the choice to redeem a supposed "villain". I don't feel like any of Austen's less savory characters were completely beyond redemption and that includes Caroline Bingley. Sue Barr does a great job in a relatively short book of showing the steps Miss Bingley goes through to better herself and make amends. And as a reward, she gets her own happily ever after.
jaff-tbr
January 14, 2022Status: unread
*** Giveaway winner via Just Jane 1813 (http://justjane1813.com/) - provided with no expectation of, or promise of a review (favourable or otherwise). ***
Rating:
Review:
My Library Notes:
[ kindle doc ]
*** Giveaway winner via Just Jane 1813 (http://justjane1813.com/) - provided with no expectation of, or promise of a review (favourable or otherwise). ***
Rating:
Review:
My Library Notes:
[ kindle doc ]
June 5, 2021
An engaging regency romance well crafted by Sue Barr. It was lovely to see Caroline Bingley in a new light and her journey to love with Lord Nathan. They have an instant attraction and their banter and chemistry is well written to keep it engaging to the end.
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews