I’ve read very few self-published books, but Caught is by far the best. It’s about two groups of people; one group is trapped in a mysterious realm, and the other is in the real world trying to defeat/get revenge on an evil enemy from their past. In the first half of the book, you really don’t know what’s going on, and you learn about the mysterious realm as the characters do. The second half, after the two groups meet, is about them all trying to defeat/get revenge on their shared enemy- the person who trapped/abused them. The book definitely had its flaws, but they didn’t distract me from its strengths.
I was genuinely drawn-in by the story. In the first half of the book, as stated, I really didn’t know what was going on and I wanted to find out how all the characters, who were introduced to me gradually, would interact once they met up. These are the characters of the first group:
Caden: insane elderly savant
Sal: ex-soldier and hero-man
Kaitlyn: teenager who generally needs protecting
Chris: ex-firefighter and skeptic
Chris was by far my favorite. I thought his skepticism made him the most realistic character- what was less realistic, though, was how guilty he felt over what happened to his buddy in his “nightmare.” I feel like people would understand their limited liability in such a situation, and his reaction to it seemed a tad lazy and/or protective of him, and I think the situation should have been much darker to warrant his response. Regardless, I really wish there had been more chapters featuring him. Kaitlyn was okay, too, she was sweet and quiet, and that’s what was most notable about her. Her “nightmare” had the most impact to the story, so she definitely wasn’t insignificant, and I still quite liked her, but she was mostly there to fill in the gap Sal’s “nightmare” had left in his heart. Sal, who was the main character, got on my nerves, unfortunately. He was too much of a “good guy,” and came off as lacking nuance. His “nightmare” was the darkest, and it could have contributed to an amazing character arc, but the author didn’t give it room to breathe or weight to impact the story, and it was resolved rather quickly. Caden’s nightmare was hardly explained, but you could understand it enough, and it contributed to the strangeness of his character. I thought his crazy dialogue sounded too intentional many times, and it just didn’t come across as the ramblings of a madman. What most bothers me, though, is that the story never properly explains how he became what he became in the end or why. That’s probably my biggest problem with the story and I really felt like I was left hanging there.
Despite my complaints about the characters, I did love seeing them interact as they slid in and out of the mysterious realm. They played off each other really well, and their warming up to each other was done smoothly and realistically.
The second group of characters consisted of Steve, Brandon, Kira, and Dom. These people were all very similar in personality; all hard, smart-talking toughguys with different backstories, and they interacted in much the same way as any of them would interact with themselves. I was disappointed by the fact that half of the characters weren’t distinct, and that part of the story could definitely have been stronger.
Aside: the author seemed overly fixated on the fact that Brandon was Texan and Chris was black. Like, okay, we get it- you don’t have to say it more than twice.
Anyway, the narrative flaws were very few, and mostly came down to my personal preference rather than actual mistakes. Something I kept noticing was that the author seemed to want to “protect” his characters too much. The bad things they did were either not punished, not bad enough, or forgiven too easily, and the characters didn’t have to dwell too much on their flaws, and so they didn’t have to confront themselves and change as much as I’d hoped. For example, Sal does some crazy stuff with a dying (later dead) guard near the end (pg 229), and, while he says it was “necessarily brutal,” it really wasn’t. Throughout the entire book I wasn’t really shocked by anything the characters did or experienced- good or bad- but this appalled me, and that would have been okay if Sal had answered for it, but the story went on like this wasn’t one of the most barbaric events of the whole book that changed my opinion of Sal entirely. He could have achieved the same result with the guard’s gun far less evilly, and I don’t see why Sal (or the author) went with the choice he did.
One other flaw was the technicalities of the writing- spelling and grammar errors and awkward wording. These only slightly distracted me from the story, but really they shouldn’t have been there at all. The story really needed to have been edited more thoroughly, as this would have prevented the thousand times the author used the word “suite” instead of “suit,” and other such errors. About the awkward wording: what did take me out of the story was when the author cursed as the 3rd person narrator; this was odd and not something I’d ever seen before. Perhaps this is a matter of personal opinion, but calling people “bastards” though the mouth of the narrator broke my immersion. I think cursing and name-calling is a job that’s best left up to the characters.
That being said, the world-building was great. It was nicely unraveled and I can think of no holes in it off the top of my head. The two plotlines converged towards each other excellently, and I could tell when the two groups were about to meet- and not just because of the dwindling number of pages I had left. I genuinely enjoyed the read, and am glad I spent my time with this book.