David. St. Clair's book read like a critical review of Brazilian religion and spirituality. He asks questions about the educational background of practitioners, about superstitions, poverty, African influences...he starts this book as a critic, not as a "believer". What follows is a man's amazing journey through various Brazilian traditions - Spiritusm, Candomble, Umbanda and Quimbanda and not to forget "spirit healing" which in Brazil is sometimes not associated with any other practice! David. St. Clair writes in a clear and honest way. He is not afraid to ask himself in the course if this book many times "is this really happening?" Whan you have finished the book, you will see that David. St. Clair's attitude towards Brazilians and Brazilian spirituality has completely changed.
I would have to say that I really enjoyed this book. Although it is dated (being written in 1971) it does give a very basic view into the faiths in Brazil. He gets things going with some history which is essential to understanding how Candomble. Then goes into a very nice history of Allen Kardec and his Spiritist movement (which is super large in Brazil). Then he goes into Umbanda and Quimbanda. Now even though he doesn't create a onestop book on these faiths he really gives a great basic understanding. Furthermore all through the book he has his own personal experiences and adventures in Brazil as well as interviews and oneshots of famous persons in the movements. Well worth the time spent reading it.
A fascinating - if not objective - examination of the many folk religions that have sprung up in Brazil from the exoticism of Umbanda and Candomble to the mystic mediumship of Allan Kardek.
The use of the word 'Negro' jars a modern reader, but this was written in the late sixties, so one has to put it into context. David St Clair utterly embraces his exploration of this vast country and its unofficial faiths, and illustrates how they don't merely thrive in favelas and country villages but are part of the everyday life of sophisticated Cariocas (natives of Rio).
There's no doubt that David is won over by Brazil and its magic and miracles, there's hardly a concession to any point of view that does not support the authenticity of the tales he relates and the experiences he undergoes. However, this is the writing of a journalist, not a scholar, and as such is thoroughly readable and packed with fascinating characters and detail, including some Umbanda magic spells and rituals (you'll need access to plenty of frogs, and maybe a fresh corpse or two).
If you don't find yourself watching a film of 'Brazilian Miracle Man' on YouTube by the time you've read this, I'll be very surprised!
1st Read: July 22, 1997 - August 18, 1997 (**** Rating)
This is the author's first book and he hit a home run with it! Much of this book had kept me interested in complete fascination. One of my beliefs is to research before I cast criticism or judgement. Only then, will you know if it is a good thing or a bad thing - based on personal preference. I don't believe it is bad, nor good. Quite simply, it is what is right for the Brazilians and those who have made parts of the lower United States of America their home. It is all about one's personal tastes and disposition. I honestly have a better understanding of Voodoo Spiritism and Brazilian Spiritualism. There is a very good chance I will read this title again a few more times.
2nd Read: September 29, 2017 - October 9, 2017 (**** Rating)
Once again, an enjoyable read it was! My curiosity has been aroused by wanting to experience it in person. Another part of me isn't sold on the idea of it and I see it as skeptical.
The only negative thing I can say about my copy of this book are about the frequent spelling mistakes in nearly every chapter, such as the word nest, intended to be the word next.
A great little book that gives a nice concise examination of the many interesting (and confusing) religions/cults/paths that define Brazils spiritual landscape. Most interesting were the stories and accounts concerning Umbanda and Quimbanda. A bit dated and somewhat sensationalized, but effective and engaging reading nonetheless. Highly recommended!