Rafe Aigner and Madeleine Calhoun were young and in love as Rafe prepared to go south to fight in Mexico, but Madeleine insisted on staying behind to care for her father and his newspaper. After learning of Rafe's death, Madeleine was inconsolable, before finally moving on and marrying - a mistake she has come to regret. So Maddie is extremely surprised to find Rafe alive and on her doorstep with news that before he'd died, her husband had gambled away their newspaper, as well as her livelihood. And Rafe is unforgiving about her having moved on, despite her belief in his death. However they come to an agreement that Maddie will care for Rafe's young son, the one he finally claimed after his mother died, while Rafe continues to try to establish his gambling legacy. This puts them in close contact and the two more or less become co-parents - she helps him and his son learn to love each other and she begins to fall in love with Rafe all over again. But someone in town resents Rafe trying to establish his gambling career in town and begins spreading rumors about Rafe and his son that could cause lots of trouble for them, and by association, Maddie.
This had a promising start. I liked the angle with Rafe and his son struggling to come to terms with each other and Rafe learning how to love his son, not just feel responsible for him. Rafe also had to learn how to forgive Maddie - in his heart, he knew that she'd done nothing wrong, but couldn't accept the fact that she'd moved on enough to marry again. And for her part, Maddie, having failed in her marriage, began to wonder if she could trust her feelings given how wrong she'd been about her husband, and Rafe (given that he lied about his death). So this dynamic worked and I enjoyed reading about it. But about the time that the rumors started flying and the town started their threats, I wondered if this could end well...and I feel like I was right. These rumors had made it impossible to live in town unscathed by glares, comments, etc. And all of this was caused by a man who wanted Rafe out of town (so he wouldn't build a gambling house). So to my way of it, either they defeated this man and built their gamling house anyway or they left town completely to get away from the rumors. As it happens, Rafe ends up throwing away his gambling goals and surrendering to the "bad man" and the little family stays in the town that now hates them (though a little outside of it). So...the villain isn't actually defeated, Rafe is more or less branded a coward, and the town still hates them. Not exactly a really happy ending in my book, but at least they're all happy living together. I felt like some of that needed to be dealt with...like the villain admits he'd made up all those rumors and gets kicked out of town, but none of that happens. So the ending wasn't quite satisfying enough for me.