In 1965, James Tate road-tripped from Kansas to Iowa City and offered Donald Justice a dozen or so poems to judge, opening up a fount of hyperbole and high keyed hilarity in our literature. Within six years, Tate had published six books, several quite substantial, and tempered his scale of loose talking to the automatic procedures of European modernism, including Eliotic impersonality. A period of adjustment toward the prose poem marks his Eighties, culminating in The Worshipful Company of Fletchers(1994), which right now is striking me as his best book.
The Shroud of Gnome is not that, but the shrewd literary professional is apparent in lines such as these, from "School of Paddling": "We had traveled a great distance | and no one would speak to us| so we just sat there on the shore | and threw stones at stones | which led to the accidental erection | of a cairn, whose significance | we considered iffy at best." The professionalism is here -- from the unpunctuated lines to the droll joke on contemporary hermeneutics, to the "iffy" take that a Tate poem is just such a cairn. But so is the situation (on a shore), the impersonality, and the disjunction of the earlier period of Tate's pastoral surrealism, here transmuted in an effortless guile that reads much differently when it was the bluff of the ephebe. That prairie bluff entails "the embarrassing heartache of my latest apercu," and yet, for this persona, "It is a mystery to me, along with | so much better rubbish, | the trash people are eager to kill for." This poem of domestic bliss, "Of Two or Three Minds," has in its close Ashbery's "By the Flooded Canal" on its ear, and so apologizes for the shrewdness of that judgment, but by then Tate was ensconced at Amherst, where the Boston literary scene presumably calls up a homicidal dumpster-diver or two.
Tate's great poem about the orders of poetry is collected here, "Dream On," which opens, "Some people go their whole lives | without ever writing a single poem." The next time poetry comes up in the poem, it's when the speaker says: "[These poem-less folk] contribute to political campaigns | that have absolutely no poetry in them," and as a friend pointed out to me, if the reader simply substituted, in their reading of "Dream On," "love" for "poetry," "Dream On" could clearly enough be a religious poem of a certain Christ-centered kind. This remark led me to understand that Tate was writing about the orders of poetry. In an order, one takes vows, and Tate's poem is about the vows poets take. The domestic bliss pictured at the close of "Of Two or Three Minds," is of lovers who offer within the house the humors or inflationary space that makes possible staying within one's poetry vows. Keep in mind that Tate loves poetry, and that the orders of that love have made it so that Tate experiences everything in the world (the great world, as he would have seen it) through poetry's lens. It is a social order he can be quite wry about -- and is, in this volume: "Per Diem," e.g., is Tate's parody of James Wright's "To A Blossoming Pear Tree." It doesn't call Wright out by name, but only in rhythm, and through imitation. And the book is thoroughly Thoreauvian, nowhere more than "Think of Your Absent Friend," a poem on the same theme as Thoreau's "Walking."