How much of what exceptional people achieve can be put down to their own efforts and inner drive, and how much to fate? In this groundbreaking study, the authors argue that the extraordinary achievements of key figures in Irish history were indeed unstoppable--a product of their character and unique way of interacting with the world.
In a series of fascinating character studies, the authors argue that many of those who were crucial to the development of Ireland's political, scientific and artistic traditions would, if they were alive today, be diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome.
Profiles Robert Emmet Padraig Pearse Éamon de Valera Robert Boyle William Rowan Hamilton Daisy Bates W. B. Yeats James Joyce Samuel Beckett
Firstly, my reading of this may be somewhat constrained by the fact I’ve no grounding in psychology and only a tangential understanding of autism and Asperger’s; however, I am aware of the ‘Goldwater Rule’ so-called for when a group of psychiatrists ‘diagnosed’ 1964 US presidential candidate Barry Goldwater as paranoid schizophrenic and thus unfit to be president, without examining him in an official medical capacity, after which psychological professionals have adhered to the principle of not commenting on those they have not personally seen to. I am, as a result, somewhat uncomfortable with the objective of this book which, to whatever degree formally or informally, creates a kind of diagnosis for people who died up to two hundred years ago.
That being said, I think this is quite a fascinating piece of historiography, and would be most useful to history students who were looking to profile the case studies examined therein.