What do you think?
Rate this book
The Classics of Western Spirituality
John Cassian: The Conferences
The first complete English translation of John Cassian's (c. 360-430) Conferences, a work that records dialogues between Cassian and his traveling companion, Germanus, and the great desert masters on the recurring theme of purity of heart, which is the goal of the spiritual life.
886 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 1950
119 people are currently reading
771 people want to read
About the author
John Cassian
112 books26 followersSaint John Cassian was a monk and theologian. Born in the region of Scythia Minor (today's Romania and Bulgaria). As a member of wealthy family he received a good classical education (he was bilingual, knew Latin and Greek). Died in Marseille in 435. Celebrated in both the Western and Eastern Churches for his mystical writings. Cassian is noted for bringing the ideas and practices of Egyptian monasticism to the early medieval West. Influenced St. Benedict, who included many of Cassian's principles into his monastic rule.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews
January 30, 2024
Read this initially for E90 as part of the assignments, reading again this year. The biggest takeaway is that the world is awash on a sea of desires and distractions it cannot fathom and cannot control. The wisest among us can pick those desires up and set them back down at will, unchanged and unchanging by them, for proximate desires are not the same as ultimate desires. This shows how to forge any desire we meet like folded steel, bending it to a higher will than our own.
Fans of stoic stuff will find this more instructive than any of the stoics.
It's also a desert father thing, so you fans of hermits and wild old sages out in the desert might find it useful.
Fans of stoic stuff will find this more instructive than any of the stoics.
It's also a desert father thing, so you fans of hermits and wild old sages out in the desert might find it useful.
January 26, 2019
This was the first book (of ten) which I am reading for a course on the “Classics of Christian Spirituality” at Regent College this term. John Cassian’s Conferences are a series of visits by Cassian and his partner Germanus to monks in the African desert in the form of a dialogue and entered on such “spiritual discussions” as “The Goal of the Monk,” “Prayer,” and “On Perfection.” Cassian and Germanus are somewhat of spiritual tourists examining the life of the Egyptian monk. In this edition, nine of John Cassian’s famous “Conferences” have been selected and translated by Colm Luibheid and introduced by Owen Chadwick. Cassian stood at a unique position between East and West. Fluent in both Latin and Greek, Cassian travelled all around the Mediterranean, eventually bringing Egyptian monastic wisdom back to the West. Cassian’s place in the history of Christian spirituality was ensured when St. Benedict advocated for the reading of the Conferences in his famous Rule. Admittedly, I find myself quite skeptical of the whole eremitic monastic movement - likely due to the strangeness of the thing - and have a hard time believing that such genuine spiritual hunger and wisdom could come from isolated desert dwellers. Cassian's Conferences present a formidable challenge to my thinking.
3.5/5
3.5/5
August 7, 2020
The decline and fall of the Roman empire, wandering Germanic tribes crossing the frontier and invading provinces that had witnessed settled government for centuries and wreaking havoc everywhere, a deluge of religious fanaticism, street fighting between rival political factions often culminating in assassination and the burning of libraries—sounds familiar? To thoughtful observers of the latter fourth and early fifth centuries, the world itself [orbis terrarum] seemed to be threatened with irreversible decadence, what it must be stressed comprises not merely a literary commonplace such as we find in Hesiod’s account of the five ages of man in the Works and Days, lines 110-201 (golden, silver, bronze, heroic, iron), but an exigency actuated by portentous current events, such as the sack of Rome in 410 by Alaric. Augustine composed as a riposte to fears such as these his celebrated De civitate Dei, which would prove to be determinative for educated views on the topic up to the thirteenth century, when it began to be displaced by the apocalyptic delirium of excitable heretics such as the disciples of Joachim of Flora, followed by Jan Hus and a long line of sectarians until our day (modern ideas of progress are in large measure but a secularization of this religious phenomenon). The modern historian of culture knows full well the surprising issue of all these calamities that descended upon the world of late antiquity, taken as if unawares: the emergence of the monastic movement, beginning in Egypt and Syria and then before long spreading over the rest of the lands where Christians were numerous.
As recorded in the testimony of the desert fathers, the earliest stages of the monastic movement, associated with Anthony and his contemporaries in Egypt, remind one of the wild west, but with the difference that the monks were contestants in a reality show aiming to further God’s, not their own glory. Humility was harder to practice in those days, because generally speaking one meant it—as in the story of the monk who returned to his cell one evening after going on a walk, only to find a man engaged in stealing his scant possessions. Rather than provoke an altercation, the monk fell in and commenced to assist the thief in loading the donkey with his remaining gear. Talk about taking the Sermon on the Mount literally! (Cf. Matthew 5:38-42.) Later on, the monastic movement evolved into an institutionalized and culture-forming force.
To save civilization itself was, of course, only a for-the-most-part unintended side-effect of these men and women’s primary concern to repent and to worship God. How did they accomplish it, nevertheless? First of all, by copying manuscripts ever subject to decay; which presupposes they were in demand! Second, by maintaining a knowledge of Latin and even of Greek; see Gregory of Tours’ history of the Franks to get an impression of the desperately low pass to which culture in the outside, secular world had sunk by the Merovingian period. Religious men were indispensable to such governmental administration as existed, even when they themselves were barely literate (hence, the derivation of our term ‘clerk’ from ‘cleric’). But the durable reason why all these efforts prevailed against the odds is brought out well by the English historian Christopher Dawson:
After the fall of the [Carolingian] Empire it was the great monasteries, especially those of Southern Germany, St. Gall, Reichenau and Tegernsee, that were the only remaining islands of intellectual life amidst the returning flood of barbarism which once again threatened to submerge Western Christendom. For, though monasticism seems at first sight ill-adapted to withstand the material destructiveness of an age of lawlessness and war, it was an institution which possessed extraordinary recuperative power. Ninety-nine out of a hundred monasteries could be burnt and the monks killed or driven out, and yet the whole tradition could be reconstituted from the one survivor, and the desolate sites could be repeopled by fresh supplies of monks who would take up again the broken tradition, following the same rule, singing the same liturgy, reading the same books and thinking the same thoughts as their predecessors (Religion and the Rise of Western Culture, p. 66).
Now, John Cassian provides the historical link between Egypt and Europe. Born in what is now Romania, he spent the first half of his life becoming tested in the ways of Egyptian monasticism before emigrating to Gaul, where he exercised lasting influence on the nascent monastic movement there and where he wrote the works for which he is remembered. Cassian is well versed in the pitfalls that threaten solitary monks. The translator Colm Luibheid tells us in the preface,
The history of the desert, as Cassian tirelessly proclaims, was filled with examples of men who would listen to none but themselves and whose lives had moved inexorably into spiritual disaster. This high road to catastrophe was taken especially by those untutored and undirected men in whom a sense of proportion, the capacity for introspection, and a close understanding of the processes of self-delusion had faltered or vanished. As a terrible, paradigmatic example, Cassian relates the story of Hero, a man who lived a solitary and penitential life for over half a century....It is a story set down with horror by Cassian, and the purpose of the telling comes as part of the repeated insistence on the need of all but the very few to be very open to the guidance and the directives and the insights of others. For without such guidance the monk runs the continuous risk of losing whatever feeling he has for the way things are (pp. xiv-xv).
Eventually, cenobitism consolidated itself as the norm in Egypt, although the ideal remained that those who are sufficiently practiced should aspire to graduate to the status of the hermit. How to adapt the experience of the desert fathers to the conditions of the monastic establishments in Gaul and Italy, later the rest of Europe as it converted piecemeal to Christianity over the succeeding seven or eight centuries leading up to the astonishing flowering of medieval civilization during the twelfth and thirteenth? (Dawson op. cit. is very good on detailing the organizational differences between near Eastern and western European monastic institutions; the latter became integrated into the surrounding community and the rural economy in a way the desert monks, who fled the world, never were). This was precisely Cassian’s mission to discover and promote.
What then are Cassian’s actual teachings? This reviewer is in no position to comment on the selection of nine out of twenty-four conferences for inclusion in this edition; in any case, one gets a fair sampling of Cassian’s thought on the spiritual life.
Catena of illustrative quotes:
Everything we do, our every objective, must be undertaken for the sake of this purity of heart. This is why we take on loneliness, fasting, vigils, work, nakedness. For this we must practice the reading of the scripture, together with all the other virtuous activities, and we do so to trap and to hold our hearts free of the harm of every dangerous passion and in order to rise step by step to the high point of love….A worker takes the trouble to get hold of the instruments that he requires….In the same way, fastings, vigils, scriptural meditation, nakedness and total deprivation do not constitute perfection but are the means to perfection (pp. 41-42).
So, then, we must seek in all humility to acquire the grace of discernment which can keep us safe from the two kinds of excess. For there is an old saying: ‘Excesses meet’. Too much fasting and too much eating come to the same end. Keeping too long a vigil brings the same disastrous cost as the sluggishness which plunges a monk into the longest sleep. Too much self-denial brings weakness and induces the same condition as carelessness. Often I have seen men who could not be snared by gluttony fall, nevertheless, through immoderate fasting and tumble in weakness into the very urge which they had overcome. Unmeasured vigils and foolish denial of rest overcame those whom sleep could not overcome. Therefore, ‘fortified to right and to left in the armor of justice’, as the apostle says (2 Corinthians 6:7), life must be lived with due measure and, with discernment for a guide, the road must be traveled between the two kinds of excess so that in the end we may not allow ourselves to be diverted from the pathway of restraint which has been laid down for us nor fall through dangerous carelessness into the urgings of gluttony and self-indulgence (p. 76).
Consider in this connection Friedrich Nietzsche’s Zur Genealogie der Moral, ‘Das asketische Ideal, man errät es wohl, war niemals und nirgendwo eine Schule des guten Geschmacks, noch weniger der guten Manieren – es war im besten Fall eine Schule der hieratischen Manieren – : das macht, es hat selber etwas im Leibe, das allen guten Manieren todfeind ist – mangel an Maß, Widerwillen gegen Maß, es ist selbst ein ››non plus ultra‹‹’ [Walter Kaufmann’s rendering: ‘It is easy to see that the ascetic ideal has never and nowhere been a school of good taste, even less of good manners—at best it was a school of hieratic manners: that is because its very nature includes something that is the deadly enemy of all good manners—lack of moderation, dislike of moderation; it is itself a “non plus ultra”’]. Set aside the side point about manners (although one can allude that what Nietzsche has in mind as ‘good’ manners leave a decidedly bitter aftertaste); the real issue is about moderation, or lack thereof. Let the dear reader judge for himself, whether the passages just cited be indeed indicative of an antipathy towards measure and moderation in the ascetical life, or not!
Hence, the centrality of moderation in one’s ascetical practices is a recurrent theme in Cassian and is counseled as well by Maximus Confessor in his marvelous little gem, the Gnostic Centuries on Love. That Nietzsche should somehow have missed the basic teaching of the two greatest exponents of the ascetical tradition in the East and West shows how little regard for scholarly standards he has. And if Nietzsche, surely a great man of the worldly type, could have so thoroughly fooled himself in this crucial matter, how much the more so his twentieth-century epigone, Walter Kaufmann!
We will most easily come to a precise knowledge of true discernment if we follow the paths of our elders, if we do nothing novel, and if we do not presume to decide anything on the basis of our own private judgment. Instead let us in all things travel the road laid down for us by the tradition of our elders and by the goodness of their lives (p. 70).
The whole purpose of the monk and indeed the perfection of his heart amount to this—total and uninterrupted dedication to prayer. He strives for unstirring calm of mind and for never-ending purity, and he does so to the extent that this is possible for human fragility (p. 101).
As God loves us with a love that is true and pure, a love that never breaks, we too will be joined to Him in a never-ending unshakable love, and it will be such a union that our breathing and our thinking and our talking will be ‘God’. And we will come as last to that objective which I have mentioned, the goal which the Lord prayed to be fulfilled in us: ‘That we may all be one as we are one, as I am in them and you in me so that they are utterly one’ (John 17:22-23). ‘Father, I want those you have given me to be with me where I am’ (John 17:24). This, then, is the goal of the monk. All his striving must be for this so that he may deserve to possess in this life an image of future happiness and may have the beginnings of a foretaste in this body of that life and glory of heaven. This, I say, is the object of all perfection, to have the soul so removed from all dalliance with the body that it rises each day to the things of the spirit until all its living and all its wishing become one unending prayer (pp. 129-130).
A very clear proof of the fact that a soul has not yet cut loose from the corruption of sin is when it feels no sympathizing pity for the wrongdoing of others but holds instead to the strict censoriousness of a judge (p. 149).
Cassian keeps for us a sense of monasticism as it was in its youthful vigor; one will not look here for the exalted refinements of later medieval mystical writers, but the core is there, pure as ever. Front matter reasonably helpful for shaping the novice’s understanding of what he is about to read.
The so-called ‘Benedict option’ today – invoked by Alasdair MacIntyre in the concluding paragraph to his After Virtue in 1981 and lately popularized by Rod Dreher – is not just for monks or crazy survivalist cults, but for anyone of whatever religious conviction who cares to preserve a remnant of civilization in what looks to be the coming dark age—and perhaps even for an odd secularist here and there who, like the previsionary Nietzsche in the nineteenth century, has not altogether forgotten our cultural heritage and will not bury his head in the sand like an ostrich, as so many do.
Can be practiced on small scale: homeschooling, parish life, spiritual direction and reception of the sacraments, leisure-time reading, mystical prayer and contemplation. Whether or not one happens to be an eastern Orthodox Christian, the collection of monastic writings going under the (etymologically very telling) heading of the Philokalia must come as most highly to be recommended. If one be familiar with the deep-seated attachment among the medieval laity to assimilating monastic practices, so far as feasible under the circumstances of its station in life (documented nicely by Marie-Dominique Chenu in Nature, Man and Society in the Twelfth Century, chapter 6), it will be apparent to the unprejudiced that it is not so very difficult after all to adapt prescriptions intended for monks to the needs of the layman (mutatis mutandis). There are several groups active in the contemporary world who essay just this, the sanctification of all aspects of life, should one be apprehensive about setting out intrepidly on one’s own.
For to be sure, just as the last thing that would have occurred to the monks and nuns of old would have been to found a political program and ideology, a forerunner whether of current-day neo-fascism on the right or of identity politics on the left, to be relentlessly and imperiously foisted upon everyone else; so too for us today it will rather be dedicated attention to the seemingly little things in life, along with cultivation of the virtues (which always apply first of all to oneself) and a real peaceableness directed to others, that makes the difference to the renewal of a society riven with hatred and recrimination on all sides.
As recorded in the testimony of the desert fathers, the earliest stages of the monastic movement, associated with Anthony and his contemporaries in Egypt, remind one of the wild west, but with the difference that the monks were contestants in a reality show aiming to further God’s, not their own glory. Humility was harder to practice in those days, because generally speaking one meant it—as in the story of the monk who returned to his cell one evening after going on a walk, only to find a man engaged in stealing his scant possessions. Rather than provoke an altercation, the monk fell in and commenced to assist the thief in loading the donkey with his remaining gear. Talk about taking the Sermon on the Mount literally! (Cf. Matthew 5:38-42.) Later on, the monastic movement evolved into an institutionalized and culture-forming force.
To save civilization itself was, of course, only a for-the-most-part unintended side-effect of these men and women’s primary concern to repent and to worship God. How did they accomplish it, nevertheless? First of all, by copying manuscripts ever subject to decay; which presupposes they were in demand! Second, by maintaining a knowledge of Latin and even of Greek; see Gregory of Tours’ history of the Franks to get an impression of the desperately low pass to which culture in the outside, secular world had sunk by the Merovingian period. Religious men were indispensable to such governmental administration as existed, even when they themselves were barely literate (hence, the derivation of our term ‘clerk’ from ‘cleric’). But the durable reason why all these efforts prevailed against the odds is brought out well by the English historian Christopher Dawson:
After the fall of the [Carolingian] Empire it was the great monasteries, especially those of Southern Germany, St. Gall, Reichenau and Tegernsee, that were the only remaining islands of intellectual life amidst the returning flood of barbarism which once again threatened to submerge Western Christendom. For, though monasticism seems at first sight ill-adapted to withstand the material destructiveness of an age of lawlessness and war, it was an institution which possessed extraordinary recuperative power. Ninety-nine out of a hundred monasteries could be burnt and the monks killed or driven out, and yet the whole tradition could be reconstituted from the one survivor, and the desolate sites could be repeopled by fresh supplies of monks who would take up again the broken tradition, following the same rule, singing the same liturgy, reading the same books and thinking the same thoughts as their predecessors (Religion and the Rise of Western Culture, p. 66).
Now, John Cassian provides the historical link between Egypt and Europe. Born in what is now Romania, he spent the first half of his life becoming tested in the ways of Egyptian monasticism before emigrating to Gaul, where he exercised lasting influence on the nascent monastic movement there and where he wrote the works for which he is remembered. Cassian is well versed in the pitfalls that threaten solitary monks. The translator Colm Luibheid tells us in the preface,
The history of the desert, as Cassian tirelessly proclaims, was filled with examples of men who would listen to none but themselves and whose lives had moved inexorably into spiritual disaster. This high road to catastrophe was taken especially by those untutored and undirected men in whom a sense of proportion, the capacity for introspection, and a close understanding of the processes of self-delusion had faltered or vanished. As a terrible, paradigmatic example, Cassian relates the story of Hero, a man who lived a solitary and penitential life for over half a century....It is a story set down with horror by Cassian, and the purpose of the telling comes as part of the repeated insistence on the need of all but the very few to be very open to the guidance and the directives and the insights of others. For without such guidance the monk runs the continuous risk of losing whatever feeling he has for the way things are (pp. xiv-xv).
Eventually, cenobitism consolidated itself as the norm in Egypt, although the ideal remained that those who are sufficiently practiced should aspire to graduate to the status of the hermit. How to adapt the experience of the desert fathers to the conditions of the monastic establishments in Gaul and Italy, later the rest of Europe as it converted piecemeal to Christianity over the succeeding seven or eight centuries leading up to the astonishing flowering of medieval civilization during the twelfth and thirteenth? (Dawson op. cit. is very good on detailing the organizational differences between near Eastern and western European monastic institutions; the latter became integrated into the surrounding community and the rural economy in a way the desert monks, who fled the world, never were). This was precisely Cassian’s mission to discover and promote.
What then are Cassian’s actual teachings? This reviewer is in no position to comment on the selection of nine out of twenty-four conferences for inclusion in this edition; in any case, one gets a fair sampling of Cassian’s thought on the spiritual life.
Catena of illustrative quotes:
Everything we do, our every objective, must be undertaken for the sake of this purity of heart. This is why we take on loneliness, fasting, vigils, work, nakedness. For this we must practice the reading of the scripture, together with all the other virtuous activities, and we do so to trap and to hold our hearts free of the harm of every dangerous passion and in order to rise step by step to the high point of love….A worker takes the trouble to get hold of the instruments that he requires….In the same way, fastings, vigils, scriptural meditation, nakedness and total deprivation do not constitute perfection but are the means to perfection (pp. 41-42).
So, then, we must seek in all humility to acquire the grace of discernment which can keep us safe from the two kinds of excess. For there is an old saying: ‘Excesses meet’. Too much fasting and too much eating come to the same end. Keeping too long a vigil brings the same disastrous cost as the sluggishness which plunges a monk into the longest sleep. Too much self-denial brings weakness and induces the same condition as carelessness. Often I have seen men who could not be snared by gluttony fall, nevertheless, through immoderate fasting and tumble in weakness into the very urge which they had overcome. Unmeasured vigils and foolish denial of rest overcame those whom sleep could not overcome. Therefore, ‘fortified to right and to left in the armor of justice’, as the apostle says (2 Corinthians 6:7), life must be lived with due measure and, with discernment for a guide, the road must be traveled between the two kinds of excess so that in the end we may not allow ourselves to be diverted from the pathway of restraint which has been laid down for us nor fall through dangerous carelessness into the urgings of gluttony and self-indulgence (p. 76).
Consider in this connection Friedrich Nietzsche’s Zur Genealogie der Moral, ‘Das asketische Ideal, man errät es wohl, war niemals und nirgendwo eine Schule des guten Geschmacks, noch weniger der guten Manieren – es war im besten Fall eine Schule der hieratischen Manieren – : das macht, es hat selber etwas im Leibe, das allen guten Manieren todfeind ist – mangel an Maß, Widerwillen gegen Maß, es ist selbst ein ››non plus ultra‹‹’ [Walter Kaufmann’s rendering: ‘It is easy to see that the ascetic ideal has never and nowhere been a school of good taste, even less of good manners—at best it was a school of hieratic manners: that is because its very nature includes something that is the deadly enemy of all good manners—lack of moderation, dislike of moderation; it is itself a “non plus ultra”’]. Set aside the side point about manners (although one can allude that what Nietzsche has in mind as ‘good’ manners leave a decidedly bitter aftertaste); the real issue is about moderation, or lack thereof. Let the dear reader judge for himself, whether the passages just cited be indeed indicative of an antipathy towards measure and moderation in the ascetical life, or not!
Hence, the centrality of moderation in one’s ascetical practices is a recurrent theme in Cassian and is counseled as well by Maximus Confessor in his marvelous little gem, the Gnostic Centuries on Love. That Nietzsche should somehow have missed the basic teaching of the two greatest exponents of the ascetical tradition in the East and West shows how little regard for scholarly standards he has. And if Nietzsche, surely a great man of the worldly type, could have so thoroughly fooled himself in this crucial matter, how much the more so his twentieth-century epigone, Walter Kaufmann!
We will most easily come to a precise knowledge of true discernment if we follow the paths of our elders, if we do nothing novel, and if we do not presume to decide anything on the basis of our own private judgment. Instead let us in all things travel the road laid down for us by the tradition of our elders and by the goodness of their lives (p. 70).
The whole purpose of the monk and indeed the perfection of his heart amount to this—total and uninterrupted dedication to prayer. He strives for unstirring calm of mind and for never-ending purity, and he does so to the extent that this is possible for human fragility (p. 101).
As God loves us with a love that is true and pure, a love that never breaks, we too will be joined to Him in a never-ending unshakable love, and it will be such a union that our breathing and our thinking and our talking will be ‘God’. And we will come as last to that objective which I have mentioned, the goal which the Lord prayed to be fulfilled in us: ‘That we may all be one as we are one, as I am in them and you in me so that they are utterly one’ (John 17:22-23). ‘Father, I want those you have given me to be with me where I am’ (John 17:24). This, then, is the goal of the monk. All his striving must be for this so that he may deserve to possess in this life an image of future happiness and may have the beginnings of a foretaste in this body of that life and glory of heaven. This, I say, is the object of all perfection, to have the soul so removed from all dalliance with the body that it rises each day to the things of the spirit until all its living and all its wishing become one unending prayer (pp. 129-130).
A very clear proof of the fact that a soul has not yet cut loose from the corruption of sin is when it feels no sympathizing pity for the wrongdoing of others but holds instead to the strict censoriousness of a judge (p. 149).
Cassian keeps for us a sense of monasticism as it was in its youthful vigor; one will not look here for the exalted refinements of later medieval mystical writers, but the core is there, pure as ever. Front matter reasonably helpful for shaping the novice’s understanding of what he is about to read.
The so-called ‘Benedict option’ today – invoked by Alasdair MacIntyre in the concluding paragraph to his After Virtue in 1981 and lately popularized by Rod Dreher – is not just for monks or crazy survivalist cults, but for anyone of whatever religious conviction who cares to preserve a remnant of civilization in what looks to be the coming dark age—and perhaps even for an odd secularist here and there who, like the previsionary Nietzsche in the nineteenth century, has not altogether forgotten our cultural heritage and will not bury his head in the sand like an ostrich, as so many do.
Can be practiced on small scale: homeschooling, parish life, spiritual direction and reception of the sacraments, leisure-time reading, mystical prayer and contemplation. Whether or not one happens to be an eastern Orthodox Christian, the collection of monastic writings going under the (etymologically very telling) heading of the Philokalia must come as most highly to be recommended. If one be familiar with the deep-seated attachment among the medieval laity to assimilating monastic practices, so far as feasible under the circumstances of its station in life (documented nicely by Marie-Dominique Chenu in Nature, Man and Society in the Twelfth Century, chapter 6), it will be apparent to the unprejudiced that it is not so very difficult after all to adapt prescriptions intended for monks to the needs of the layman (mutatis mutandis). There are several groups active in the contemporary world who essay just this, the sanctification of all aspects of life, should one be apprehensive about setting out intrepidly on one’s own.
For to be sure, just as the last thing that would have occurred to the monks and nuns of old would have been to found a political program and ideology, a forerunner whether of current-day neo-fascism on the right or of identity politics on the left, to be relentlessly and imperiously foisted upon everyone else; so too for us today it will rather be dedicated attention to the seemingly little things in life, along with cultivation of the virtues (which always apply first of all to oneself) and a real peaceableness directed to others, that makes the difference to the renewal of a society riven with hatred and recrimination on all sides.
January 23, 2024
A sad reminder that being a hermit who kinda just chills and “conferences” with other hermits is a way of life now lost to history. The closest thing you can do to this today is hop on a minecraft server with the boys and talk through the night.
April 20, 2011
John Cassian lived from 360-435 AD, during the life of Augustine of Hippo. The Conferences is his primary writing, a series of twenty-four dialogues (conferences) with various holy monks. The most interesting of these are conferences three and thirteen where we find discussion on free will and predestination. During Cassian's life the church was experiencing the debate between Augustine and Pelagius. Pelagius argued humans were born more or less in the same situation as our first parents, Adam and Eve, sinless. Born sinless, we have Adam as a bad example which we follow. Thus, Jesus dies for us and we can freely choose to accept his forgiveness. On the other side was Augustine, who argued that in Adam all humanity fell into sin. We are born sinful and guilty, unable to save ourselves. The only way any can be saved is if God gives us life, gifts us with faith.
Cassian's work, much less well-known, comes in between these two. It has often been called "semi-Pelagianism" and it was condemned by a church council sometime in the 500s. Yet it could just as easily be called "semi-Augustinianism". Cassian argues that sometimes humans choose God and sometimes God compels humans. His is a sort of mystical theology, saying we can't really know how it works but perhaps in the end we both freely choose God and he compels us.
For any who are interested in such theological questions, reading conferences 3 and 13 would be enriching.
The rest of the conferences are at times helpful and at times a lightning bolt from a foreign world. There is a reason this has never caught on as a devotional in the same way as The Imitation of Christ, for example. You can read it as a devotional and you will find things that challenge you. But unless you are a monk living in the desert, you will find much either just weird, or even just plain wrong. One monk tells of how he was married and felt called by God to forsake the world and go into the desert. He just assumed his wife would do the same and when she refused, he divorced her to spend his life in solitude, contemplating God. My reaction - what a jerk. Another story is told of a monk who was "dead to the world" for twenty years, so he refused to leave his cell to help his brother save a farm animal that had fallen in a ditch. To me, it seems Jesus would want people to honor their marriage vows and help those in need. Such practical things are much more important than meditating in the desert.
Of course, both those stories are from the final two conferences and there was a lot of thought provoking parts earlier. Maybe I was just getting tired of it.
Thus, I give four stars for the conferences on free will and predestination and three stars for most of the rest of it.
Cassian's work, much less well-known, comes in between these two. It has often been called "semi-Pelagianism" and it was condemned by a church council sometime in the 500s. Yet it could just as easily be called "semi-Augustinianism". Cassian argues that sometimes humans choose God and sometimes God compels humans. His is a sort of mystical theology, saying we can't really know how it works but perhaps in the end we both freely choose God and he compels us.
For any who are interested in such theological questions, reading conferences 3 and 13 would be enriching.
The rest of the conferences are at times helpful and at times a lightning bolt from a foreign world. There is a reason this has never caught on as a devotional in the same way as The Imitation of Christ, for example. You can read it as a devotional and you will find things that challenge you. But unless you are a monk living in the desert, you will find much either just weird, or even just plain wrong. One monk tells of how he was married and felt called by God to forsake the world and go into the desert. He just assumed his wife would do the same and when she refused, he divorced her to spend his life in solitude, contemplating God. My reaction - what a jerk. Another story is told of a monk who was "dead to the world" for twenty years, so he refused to leave his cell to help his brother save a farm animal that had fallen in a ditch. To me, it seems Jesus would want people to honor their marriage vows and help those in need. Such practical things are much more important than meditating in the desert.
Of course, both those stories are from the final two conferences and there was a lot of thought provoking parts earlier. Maybe I was just getting tired of it.
Thus, I give four stars for the conferences on free will and predestination and three stars for most of the rest of it.
September 20, 2017
There were things I did not like about this book, mainly because there are elements of the desert monastic tradition that I have serious problems with, but a charitable reading will find much rich treasure for the spiritual life in this book. This was more humane, pastoral and balanced than I expected, and, as C.S. Lewis has said in his preface to St. Athanasius' On the Incarnation, the errors and blind spots of the past are not our errors and blind spots and so old books like this have much to say to us by way of correction. I especially liked the explanation of spiritual reading of the Scriptures (4 fold), Cassian's insights on the life of unceasing prayer (its purpose, theology and practice), on spiritual discernment being the mother and guide of all virtues, on balance in one's spiritual walk, and on the (in our day lost) practice of exposing and confessing our sins to others who can help us grow in sanctification or "purity of heart," without which no one will attain to God's kingdom. Also, the reception and respect of tradition and received wisdom of the elders/ancients with a heart of humility (though not without critical interaction) and the practices of fasting, meditation on Scripture, and other hard spiritual disciplines could help the lazy and confused church find strength and direction today.
reference
November 23, 2010Have had this on my shelves for years ... and meant to read it. Our parish youth minister, Frank, referred to it last November and it piqued my interest. Thanks Frank!
September 5, 2017
I did not read the whole thing, as it is incredibly long. However, I was impressed that a 5th century ascetic classic is so accessible and readable.
July 14, 2025
Another encyclopedia of Human living from this incredible Saint of Early Christianity, a book that is possibly too big to go hand in hand with the earlier work titled "The Institutes" but for me, an essential read for anyone trying to grow spiritually out of the wreckage of fleshly impulses. This is the Boneface Ramsey translation and its the only one I recommend as the other translators left out the chapter on Chastity. (I have no idea why)
Conferences is an elaboration, a live example or examples of how Monks and great Christian men have set about conquering the impulses and desires of the body, in the hope they can attain a higher and closer level of existence to God.
Conferences differs from the Institutes in the sense that once into the Vices, the latter tends to list and describe the basic tenets of the Vices whereas the former is a series of discussions that highlight ways Vices attack and how folks have battled, fallen to, or overcome these Vices.
A huge read, but not a difficult one. It's high points are moments of real insight, where sometimes you sit and contemplate how these Vices are running through oneself. It also struck me how similar feelings and impulses in even monks in the desert are relevant to any person today as we all endure the same desires and impulses in different measures and ways to one another.
Gluttony, Lust, Avarice are three leading motivations for modern society, and Vainglory, Pride and Acedia seem to be rife through perhaps the content creation world we live in now where everyone is a star it seems.
Cassians message is always clear. Return to Jesus and his teachings. There is no magical spiritial fix where one wakes up vice free the next morning forever. Cassian and his elders make it clear that these trials never end whilst we dwell in the flesh. They will attack you daily, and it's only the grace of God that will provide you with the resolve you need to turn away from Vices, coupled with a huge struggle of soul over flesh.
The attitude here is violence. Violence to one's own desires, violence on one's own flesh through abstinence. It starts with Fasting, ends with Chastity, at which point discretion is achieved and humility acquired. Discretion and Humilty are the end goals. With these achieved the aduration and servitude to God will make Vices so filthy and disgusting to a successful soul, they will be instantly cast out by the person.
My only criticism, the book can be repetitive in regards some of the quoting of scripture. Many of the commands and reassurances of the Gospels are chanted here sometimes just when one is riffing excitedly as another vice or trait of his own being is illuminated, and can lead to a long passages of repetitive Biblical commands.
This and the Institutes are imperative reading. Individuals puffed up and haughty are often not aware of their own Vices and society has taught them to accept these as normalcy. There is nothing "normal" about modern society.
Conferences is an elaboration, a live example or examples of how Monks and great Christian men have set about conquering the impulses and desires of the body, in the hope they can attain a higher and closer level of existence to God.
Conferences differs from the Institutes in the sense that once into the Vices, the latter tends to list and describe the basic tenets of the Vices whereas the former is a series of discussions that highlight ways Vices attack and how folks have battled, fallen to, or overcome these Vices.
A huge read, but not a difficult one. It's high points are moments of real insight, where sometimes you sit and contemplate how these Vices are running through oneself. It also struck me how similar feelings and impulses in even monks in the desert are relevant to any person today as we all endure the same desires and impulses in different measures and ways to one another.
Gluttony, Lust, Avarice are three leading motivations for modern society, and Vainglory, Pride and Acedia seem to be rife through perhaps the content creation world we live in now where everyone is a star it seems.
Cassians message is always clear. Return to Jesus and his teachings. There is no magical spiritial fix where one wakes up vice free the next morning forever. Cassian and his elders make it clear that these trials never end whilst we dwell in the flesh. They will attack you daily, and it's only the grace of God that will provide you with the resolve you need to turn away from Vices, coupled with a huge struggle of soul over flesh.
The attitude here is violence. Violence to one's own desires, violence on one's own flesh through abstinence. It starts with Fasting, ends with Chastity, at which point discretion is achieved and humility acquired. Discretion and Humilty are the end goals. With these achieved the aduration and servitude to God will make Vices so filthy and disgusting to a successful soul, they will be instantly cast out by the person.
My only criticism, the book can be repetitive in regards some of the quoting of scripture. Many of the commands and reassurances of the Gospels are chanted here sometimes just when one is riffing excitedly as another vice or trait of his own being is illuminated, and can lead to a long passages of repetitive Biblical commands.
This and the Institutes are imperative reading. Individuals puffed up and haughty are often not aware of their own Vices and society has taught them to accept these as normalcy. There is nothing "normal" about modern society.
May 15, 2020
"The perfect love with which God 'first loved us' (1 Jn 4:10) will come into our hearts, for our faith tells us that this prayer of our Savior will not be in vain. And these will be the signs of God being all that we love and all that we want. He will be all that we are zealous for, all that we strive for. He will be all that we think about, all our living, all that we talk about, our very breath. And that union of Father and Son, of Son and Father, will fill our senses and our minds. As God loves us with a love that is true and pure, a love that never breaks, we too will be joined to Him in a never-ending unshakable love, and it will be such a union that our breathing and our thinking and our talking will be 'God.'" (Conf 10, 7)
This was remarkably good, I was disappointed in myself for purchasing it and then leaving it on my shelf for so long. Written in the 4th century as a end-of-life recollections of conferences and discussions Cassian had attended with Egyptian desert monks in his youth, each collection (more or less) covers the teachings of a different abba or holy man. Each conference covers a different thematic topic ranging from the goal or objective of a monk to the gifts of God, prayer, perfection, discernment, etc. Purchased a translation of The Institutes and looking forward to reading that next.
This was remarkably good, I was disappointed in myself for purchasing it and then leaving it on my shelf for so long. Written in the 4th century as a end-of-life recollections of conferences and discussions Cassian had attended with Egyptian desert monks in his youth, each collection (more or less) covers the teachings of a different abba or holy man. Each conference covers a different thematic topic ranging from the goal or objective of a monk to the gifts of God, prayer, perfection, discernment, etc. Purchased a translation of The Institutes and looking forward to reading that next.
March 4, 2018
This books is simply a manual for those who would be monks, written by one who sought out advice from monastics in the Holy Land, Levant and Egypt. That's was its purpose, but its broader goal is instruction in prayer. It's basically a technical manual.
If one wants to understand how to pray (a task which might seem so simple that we'd wonder at the need for a technical manual), one must understand the pre-requisites of effective, earnest prayer. And herein is where this work, composed seventeen centuries ago, explodes with its practicality and deep understanding of man's psyche. Cassian's voice is wonderfully anachronistic. Many of his assumptions and observations took me aback: how could someone have this much insight into our cogitations and our universal inability to understand mindfulness before 20th century psychology, before westerners had come into contact with the many rich resources of Buddhist practitioners for those seeking (any form of) "spirituality?"!
T
If one wants to understand how to pray (a task which might seem so simple that we'd wonder at the need for a technical manual), one must understand the pre-requisites of effective, earnest prayer. And herein is where this work, composed seventeen centuries ago, explodes with its practicality and deep understanding of man's psyche. Cassian's voice is wonderfully anachronistic. Many of his assumptions and observations took me aback: how could someone have this much insight into our cogitations and our universal inability to understand mindfulness before 20th century psychology, before westerners had come into contact with the many rich resources of Buddhist practitioners for those seeking (any form of) "spirituality?"!
T
February 3, 2021
John Cassian’s conferences are an embarrassing riches of wisdom, theology, and spirituality. I imagine each of the twenty-four conferences could be meditated on for months at a time. One of the threads that jumped out at me was the conjunctive nature of much of Cassian’s theology. There was always a desire to find a middle way that embraces what on the surface appear to be conflicting priorities. The discussion of telos and scopos near the beginning, and lying as absolutely forbidden or not near the end with other discussions of a life marked both by abstinince and relaxation of that abstinance, and the relationship of grace and works in between. These all are topics worthy of serious engagement. I did find the conference that delved deeply into nocturnal emissions a little weird, but even there it led to a rich discussion about Holy Communion!
July 22, 2024
A classic work that is probably the biggest single influence on Western Christianity
This is a collection of Cassian‘s conversations with important Abbas, the desert fathers, in the fourth century A.D. Moreso than the sayings of the desert fathers, these conferences give an excellent insight into the thinking, beliefs and practices of many of those who fled to the desert to seek God in Christ. Cassian chose to publish conversations with the more balanced Abbas, staying away from the ultra ascetic ones. Even though you may not agree with some of the ideas, if you are serious about following Jesus these conferences will challenge you. I also love it because it helps me to get outside of my own time and culture and transport me back 1600 years to the other side of the world, to learn how other devout believers followed Jesus.
This is a collection of Cassian‘s conversations with important Abbas, the desert fathers, in the fourth century A.D. Moreso than the sayings of the desert fathers, these conferences give an excellent insight into the thinking, beliefs and practices of many of those who fled to the desert to seek God in Christ. Cassian chose to publish conversations with the more balanced Abbas, staying away from the ultra ascetic ones. Even though you may not agree with some of the ideas, if you are serious about following Jesus these conferences will challenge you. I also love it because it helps me to get outside of my own time and culture and transport me back 1600 years to the other side of the world, to learn how other devout believers followed Jesus.
April 8, 2023
Read this book for class. I give it 5 stars simply because I discovered some treasures of wisdom
in it. Like the goal to have purity of heart, to seek the kingdom, and to have eternal life; the simplicity of the faith so as not to have division; most things (including miracles of healing and possessions) don’t go with us, but the spiritual things and live do; great stories; and a wonderful explanation of faith, hope, and love. Fear vs love. Servant good vs sonship. Humility not glory. Meditation on the scripture to have with you when the time arises. Asking God to come to your rescue and to help you. Now I know why my professor likes reading the work of John Cassian.
in it. Like the goal to have purity of heart, to seek the kingdom, and to have eternal life; the simplicity of the faith so as not to have division; most things (including miracles of healing and possessions) don’t go with us, but the spiritual things and live do; great stories; and a wonderful explanation of faith, hope, and love. Fear vs love. Servant good vs sonship. Humility not glory. Meditation on the scripture to have with you when the time arises. Asking God to come to your rescue and to help you. Now I know why my professor likes reading the work of John Cassian.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 28, 2019
I think I finished it, but at least read most, I believe.
April 22, 2021
One of the best spiritual books I have ever read. Such practical spirituality for all people, layman and otherwise.
May 26, 2022
Early mystic with a lot to say about getting to the human-God relationship. Clearly influenced by P-Dionysus
December 29, 2024
Good nuggets of truth. Hard to read at times.
March 2, 2021
A book to be read by anyone seeking to deepen their spiritual life. It is a book to be pondered upon and shared. I would suggest reading the Appendix first. It is the best insight into reading for spiritual formation. I am definitely going to use this in my work.
July 15, 2022
My second book to read from the monastic literature. I am amazed by depth of knowledge this monks.Their knowledge in behavioural change, spiritual ware fare and interpersonal relationship comes from daily practice and ancient wisdom. I learned a lot from reading that book.
It is written by St John Cassian, a Romanian monk who went to Egypt in the fifth century to learn from the Egyptian monks about the monastic principles. After he left Egypt he compiled his notes into articles, he called them ‘conferences’. Some of these are translated from the Latin origin into that book.
I found the first and the second Conference hard to understand. The others were easier.
I hope you enjoy and learn from that book as much as I did.
It is written by St John Cassian, a Romanian monk who went to Egypt in the fifth century to learn from the Egyptian monks about the monastic principles. After he left Egypt he compiled his notes into articles, he called them ‘conferences’. Some of these are translated from the Latin origin into that book.
I found the first and the second Conference hard to understand. The others were easier.
I hope you enjoy and learn from that book as much as I did.
August 23, 2015
Lots of good material to consider for personal edification if you know enough history and philosophy to translate Cassian's worldview to our own. Often he struck me as dangerously close to espousing Gnostic views of the body and physical world, adhering a bit too stubbornly to some Neo-Platonisms less easily accommodated to orthodoxy than others. Passages on prayer and meditation on Scripture were superb and helpful.
Do your research before reading.
Do your research before reading.
November 23, 2016
I read this many years ago and all I remember is really disliking the way his neck is distorted in the cover image. (I dislike most of the covers in this series, but this one the most.)
I just tried rereading it and it seemed boring. Shrug. I guess I'd recommend this more to those interested in the historical development of religious ideas than in theology per se. Cassian's writing is clear enough but not especially interesting or moving.
I just tried rereading it and it seemed boring. Shrug. I guess I'd recommend this more to those interested in the historical development of religious ideas than in theology per se. Cassian's writing is clear enough but not especially interesting or moving.
March 25, 2012
I consider the reading of this book to be a watershed event in my life. I don't recommend reading it as a matter of curiosity or to gain some intellectual knowledge, however. Such approaches will obscure its benefits.
September 13, 2014
A fascinating read for anyone interested in the spiritual life or monasticism. I blogged on this here: http://pastormack.wordpress.com/2014/...
February 15, 2008
I liked this one. The typical anti-material bent of any Ancient Near Eastern spirituality notwithstanding, Cassian's work has a lot to offer even after 1500 years.
June 22, 2010
I find most of these early monastic texts inspiring as they call me back to my roots, ask me to find a truly radical spirituality.
October 29, 2014
Cassian's conferences are a series of interviews with various spiritual masters among the desert monastics, covering a wide array of topics.
December 29, 2014
I liked Cassian's value of moderation, discretion, and insight against self-delusion.
December 16, 2017
Lectura rapida, interesante exposición del Padre Nuestro que podría servir para catequizar/discipular.
Util también cuando recomienda que debemos preparar la mente antes de la oración.
Util también cuando recomienda que debemos preparar la mente antes de la oración.
May 25, 2016
Want to understand the teachings of the desert fathers? Here is 700+ pages of first hand account of their thoughts, questions and teachings.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews