Four for Christmas: A Holiday Reverse Harem Romance

Four #9

by Stephanie Brother

This Christmas, the forecast calls for two pairs of hot brothers and zero chill.

I’ve been single all year, but apparently the North Pole delivers in bulk, because now I have more men than I can unwrap.

It all starts when I volunteer to play Mrs. Claus for a charity event, and not one, but four Santas show up, each one looking like he belongs on a romance novel cover. When the “extras” put on helper costumes instead of bulky red suits, I discover there’s nothing miniature about these elves.

Nick and Rudy Frost have smiles that could thaw the Grinch’s heart. Think broad chests, soft sweaters, and kisses warm as cocoa. They’re the kind of men who make the season feel magical.

Jasper and Felix Winter are hotter, edgier, and a little dangerous. Being near them is like standing too close to a fire—you know you should step back, but you can’t bring yourself to move.

It would all be a dream come true … if they didn't expect me to choose. I’ve never been good at picking just one cookie off the tray.

But tension is rising as fast as my heart rate, and the men are starting to get their tinsel in a tangle. When a playful snowball fight escalates into a full-on brawl, the four of them wrestling in the snow, I know I have to do something, even though I'd sooner cancel Christmas than let any of them go.

But the holiday season is about sharing, caring, and maybe a little daring … and if Santa can visit every house in one night, I don’t see why there isn't room for everyone on the nice and naughty list.

Genres: Romance, Christmas, Contemporary, Erotica, Why Choose

278 pages, Kindle Edition

Published November 4, 2025

About the author

International bestselling author Stephanie Brother writes high heat love stories with a hint of the forbidden. Since 2015, she’s been bringing to life handsome, flawed heroes who know how to treat their women. If you enjoy stories involving multiple lovers, including twins, triplets, stepbrothers, and their friends, you’re in the right place. When it comes to books and men, Stephanie truly believes it’s the more, the merrier.

She spends most of her day typing, drinking coffee, and interacting with readers.

Her books have been translated into German, French, and Spanish, and she has hit the Amazon bestseller list in seven countries.

Find her at:
WEBSITE - www.stephaniebrotherbooks.com
FACEBOOK - www.facebook.com/stephaniebrother
FACEBOOK READER GROUP - https://www.facebook.com/groups/86194...
MAILING LIST - https://landing.mailerlite.com/webfor...
INSTAGRAM - www.instagram/stephaniebrotherbooks
TIKTOK - www.tiktok.com/@stephaniebrotherbooks

Reviews

[Stephanie Brother]

🎄 It’s always the right time to head home for the holidays, especially when Four Points Island is calling your name!

I’m thrilled to announce that Four for Christmas, my brand-new holiday reverse harem romance in the FOUR series, is now available!

Writing this story felt like coming home to a dear friend. This time, however, the island is stirring up a blizzard of delicious trouble. 🎅🎅 Two pairs of brothers—one naughty, one nice—are all vying for our heroine’s heart. 🎅🎅 And when four sexy Santas want you to themselves … what’s a girl to do?

Bundle up, pour yourself something warm, and get ready to fall in love (four times over).

[Nikki Miskey · Rating 4 out of 5]

Holly meets the Frost brothers and the Winter brothers while volunteering for a Santa's workshop. Both sets of brothers want her, and when she starts casually dating them, sparks fly and feelings quickly get involved. But the two sets of brothers are competitive, and end up fighting. Can they set aside their differences or will Holly have to choose?

This was a super cute and fun read! I enjoyed the two sets of brothers and how, despite their seemingly naughty and nice exteriors, all four ended up being sweet and caring. I loved all the pets as well! The conflict between the brothers was rough, and escalated quickly. Poor Holly was caught in the middle, falling for all the brothers and unable to make a decision. I enjoyed reading how they all came together in the end and built a family.

I recommend this if you enjoy why choose, steamy romances with swoonworthy MMCs and a FMC with a heart of gold.

[ChristiLovesBooks_smut · Rating 4 out of 5]

Four For Christmas, book 9 of the Four series by Stephanie Brother @stephaniebrotherbooks. I have loved this series about Club Red!

This was a good book about Holly, Nick, Rudy, Jasper & Felix! Tropes: Contemporary, Reverse Harem/No MM, 2 Sets of Brothers, 2 Strippers, 2 Veterinarians, Single POV (Holly), Holly Builds Her Harem, Found Family & HEA!

[Bev · Rating 5 out of 5]

Wow, what a winner. I loved this one from start to finish. What more can you want in a story but a beautiful woman, two sets of handsome brothers, dogs, cats, and Santa.

[Penny · Rating 5 out of 5]

That was so much fun! I read it in one sitting ... in a coffee shop ... out in public. Lol!

I've been single for AGES, where are MY four men?!? I think I might just have to move to Four Points. 4 hot men, motorcycles, and pets! If they weren't already hot as f*ck I'd fall for them anyway.

Sigh, I wish real men were as dreamy as our book boyfriends. :D

If I had to choose, I wouldn't. Would you?

[Rachel Stephens · Rating 5 out of 5]

What a fun and delicious holiday treat!
Holly became one lucky lady with four men wanting her attention. Or should I say Santa Claus/Elfs
This book had drama, humor throughout, tension, and spicy goodness.
I enjoyed the banter between the two sets of brothers. My favorite was seeing the guys "compete" or try to win Holly's heart.
I loved it!

[Charlotte · Rating 5 out of 5]

Four hot Santas/Elves - Frost brothers - Rudy & Nick and Winter brothers - Jasper & Felix become entwined with Mrs. Santa - Holly when they all volunteer for a charity. Only sparks fly for Holly with all of them and as the steamy scenarios escalated the choice of who to choose became more difficult for Holly. A sweet and steamy Christmas read. I loved it.

[Logan bushby · Rating 2 out of 5]

Maybe I’m jaded bc I’ve yet to find a good spicy holiday book but this one in particular felt like it was written at a 5th grade reading level. It was just 270 pages of….nothing? The chapters were very bare bones, the character descriptions were sparse, and plot development was nonexistent. And it seemed like detail was given for the most obscure unimportant things?
I truly do not think the FMC said more than 5 sentences to any of the men. Yet one set of brothers literally tell her they’re in love with her after like a week + having one “date” with her.
I can always overlook a lack of plot of if the smut delivers…but these “spicy” scenes felt like they were written by a high schooler whose experience with seggs is through reading about it in other novels. They just lacked any juicy details, and sounded more clinical than spicy? I’m so sorry but I literally couldn’t stop laughing that this is actually how the first climax/post-sex scene is described.
“It’s all so good, and it continues to be wonderful as the men work together to clean me up. Nick brings in a glass of water for me and a small bowl of nuts, and after we all share the snack, we climb under the covers together and they cuddle me all night.”
Shared a SMALL BOWL OF NUTS?! Every girl’s post-coital dream come true!!

[Tiffany · Rating 5 out of 5]

I was so excited about this story!! It was everything and more that I love to read when it comes to poly relationships!! I would definitely recommend this book to other people that love this type of trope romance!

[Heather · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was a good why choose holiday book. I liked Holly and her men. I liked the way the different personalities interacted. I liked how well everyone eventually meshes. There's steam but there's also a plot. Overall it was a good book I read in a couple hours.

[StaceyJ · Rating 4 out of 5]

Another *bang-her* from Stephanie Brother.

A Christmas for Holly she will never forget with her meeting the Winter and Frost brothers. Things don't stay chilly for long....
Cute Christmas story (just in time for the Christmas season) with splashes of heat along the way.

Another good read.

[Shawnte · Rating 5 out of 5]

Sugar and spice and everything I want! What a holiday treat of perfection right before the Christmas season! Firstly, I can never get enough of anything Four Points Island related! It's one of my favorite series even before Club Red joined in on the fun! Holly's just a librarian who's had her share of disappointing men, who's luck changes when she volunteers to be Mrs. Clause to four hot Santa's. They even sound delicious as elves. The world building was like a cozy cup of hot cocoa with great holiday vibes. Nick and Rudy Frost are the sweet veterinarians and Felix and Jasper Winter are the spicy dancers at Club Red and they've all set their sights on Holly to choose a pair. The tension really heats up as both pairs try their hardest to win Holly over and dump the others. And boy does it get heated!😍This was a little different from Stephanie's other reverse harems because of the enemies and found family aspects. I loved every moment of it! It was so different to see them fight for her but put their egos aside for the love of their girl. This book was special, sugar plum sweet and filled with so much passion and heat! Scorch my kindle type of heat!🔥It was so delicious just like these Santa's! Holly couldn't choose and I don't blame her one bit, these men were pure perfection wrapped up as every woman's dream man. So many stars! ❤️ARC💚

[Danielle E. · Rating 5 out of 5]

real feel to it

Let me start by saying Stephanie is my favorite RH author. This one is the most authentic and real of any of her books I’ve read. Holly volunteered to play Mrs Clause for four weekends and meets the Frost brothers Nick and Rudy first. Then to the surprise of everyone the Winter brothers Jasper and Felix arrive. The men all volunteered to play Santa and the others will be elves. The Frosts and Winters had never met before and don’t particularly like each other but they all like Holly. She starts to go on dates with both sets of brothers. What I liked about the story is unlike other RH books these guys didn’t get along with each other, weren’t all that happy that Holly dated the other brothers and basically ignored each other. The spice level was only 3/5 and didn’t happen until half way through but the story more than made up for it. The last 3 chapters is where the four finally agree to share her together. The story was so well written with only a few errors at the end. There was no unnecessary drama at the end ,or midway breakup. The story made you feel like they had a real connection.

[Claudia, Cmarie927 · Rating 5 out of 5]

What's not to love about 4 hot guys in Santa and Elf suits vying for Holly's attention? How lucky can one girl get? Add in motorcycles, exotic dancers, veterinarians, and an animal shelter - and you've got yourself a really interesting and engaging Christmas read.

While it's a pretty straight forward plot line, these 2 sets of brothers are very entertaining, in how they approach Holly, and what they do do win her affections and time. Their connections are easy to enjoy, steamy chemistry and sweet interactions abound in these pages, and I tore through this one quicker than I thought I would. Love it!

I recommend this story and this author, and once done here, please look into other books in her catalog of creative work. I received an ARC (thank you) and happily leave my thoughts.

[Lorie · Rating 5 out of 5]

Working Together
Stephanie Brother has again given us a story that will make your ❤️ happy and make you look at things from a different perspective! I started this book and couldn’t put it down. Feelings of happiness, confusion and Love are throughout this story and it kept me enthralled to the very end. Holly is Ms Claus and she meets Rudy and Nick as Santa but she soon finds out that Felix and Jasper are also vying for the Santa position, among others!!! Can they work together to make the fundraiser for the pet adoption center a success or will jealousy ruin everything which even includes Hollie’s ❤️. Settle in to a comfortable spot and prepare to be enticed into the world of Holly, Rudy, Nick, Jasper and Nick.

[Kerry Boulanger · Rating 5 out of 5]

Woo! All I want for Christmas is 4 hot Santas! Holly meets two sets of brothers when she volunteers to Mrs. Claus for an animal rescue fundraiser. Nick and Rudy are veterinarian brothers looking for the one woman to complete them. Felix and Jasper work at Club Red, the male revue club, and would love to share Holly between them. Holly agrees to date both pairs, but as the tensions rise between both sets of brothers, Holly finds that she just can’t choose, she loves them all. Determined to be a part of her life the 4 men decide to try and get along for Holly, surprising themselves when they realize they have more in common than they thought. This book is sweet, funny and very steamy! Loved it!

[Cynkris · Rating 5 out of 5]

Holly, Nick and Rudy, Felix and Jasper have all volunteered to help out the local shelters fundraising by doing Santa pictures. The 4 men take turns being Santa while the other 3 are elves and Holly is Mrs. Santa. There is an instant connection with Holly for all of them men...2 set's of brothers who likes to share! One thing I loved about this why choose? It wasn't smooth sailing for the 4 guys. They had to battle their way to being all with Holly. I loved this book. The sets of brothers are so different from the other. Holly is sweet but strong. Steamy in the hottest way. Definitely worth your hard earned book money. 5 stars

[Fiona · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a cute story about Holly, who, along with Brothers, Jasper & Felix Winter are mechanics by day and erotic dances by night and Nick & Rudi Frost are veterinarians both sets of brothers, have volunteered to be Santas and she is Mrs Claus, to raise funds for the local animal shelter. at first, both sits of brothers are vying for her attention, and Holly is wondering if she should just break it off with all of them, because neither of them are getting along. Eventually, they all towed the line and started working together and then headed towards there happily ever after.

I was given an advanced copy of this book to read and I am reviewing with my honest and fair opinion.

[Carolyn Reeves · Rating 2 out of 5]

Given the title of this book, I was just expecting more ... coming. You don't get a scene until 50% of the way in! And, it's not as descriptive as I would have liked to see. And, again, here we are making a happily ever after that just felt forced.

It was interesting because I don't think I've read a true reverse harem before -- where none of the males are into each other too and are okay just waiting for their turn essentially. Also, I'm not into the whole brothers angle, I honestly think that is weird.

I'll give it a 3.5🌶️ but there are better things to read out there if you are looking for spice.

[Melissa · Rating 5 out of 5]

When Holly volunteers at Santa's workshop, she never expected to meet not only one, but two sets of brothers. She also didn't expect that they would all be interested in dating her. Sparks fly while volunteering, so she decides there is no harm in casually dating both sets of brothers. She also lets them know that she is dating all of them. However, neither set of brother's want to give her up, and both are very competitive and want her to be theirs, eventually causing them to fight each other for her. Who will win Holly's heart? This was a great holiday read with tons of chemistry!

[Martha · Rating 5 out of 5]

Four for Christmas by Stephanie Brother is book 9 in the Four series. This book was Amazing and I loved our FMC and four MMCs dynamics throughout this story. If you're looking for a holiday read with all the holiday vibes, yummy men and more than this is the perfect read for you. I devoured this story so quick and can't wait to read more.

Laurie West and Christian Black did STUNNNING bringing this story to audio. I listened to it multiple times because I just couldn't get over how Amazing they did and sounded. This audio is a MUST have in your collection and I'm so happy I snagged my copy.

[ReadsBetweenKatNaps · Rating 4 out of 5]

Low angst, Droolworthy MMcs

Cute little paste cleansor if you enjoy instalove, and a little bit of rivalry during the holidays. How does a girl go from being a bit lonely other than her cat to all of a sudden being inundated with not 1 but 4 men. All want her not just for a good time, but a long time. No surprise she won’t choose. I wouldn’t either! The only thing I missed was multiple POVs for the entire book, not just the end and I would have loved an epic epilogue years don’t the road. That is just personal preference.

[Yvonne · Rating 2 out of 5]

Leider hat dieses Buch nicht halten können, was ich mir erwartet hatte.
Die Charaktere in dieser Story waren wie so oft in den Büchern der Autorin viel zu oberflächlich gehalten und konnten mich nicht erreichen. Holly wurde als weiblicher Hauptcharakter zwar noch am ehesten beleuchtet, trotzdem fand ich sie nicht unbedingt einnehmend. Die männlichen Hauptcharaktere Nick, Rudy, Jasper und Felix wurden total vernachlässigt und waren viel zu flach. Es fehlte ihnen an jeglicher Tiefe und sie konnten so überhaupt keine Emotionen in mir wecken. Auch wenn ich hier eine leicht cozy Weihnachtsgeschichte erwartet hatte, war mir die Grundidee zur Story einfach zu platt. Einzig die Konstellation der 4 Männer und die Art und Weise, wie ein gemeinsames Miteinander entstanden ist, fand ich erfrischend anders.
Leider konnten in diesem Buch weder die Charaktere noch die Story auf irgendeine Art und Weise mein Interesse wecken. Dieses Buch war nicht schlecht, aber in allen Punkten einfach zu wenig für mich. Kann man lesen, muss man aber nicht – 2 1/2 Sterne.

[Jennifer Lovins · Rating 5 out of 5]

Christmas miracle

Holly, Nick, Rudy, Jasper, and Felix volunteered Christmas photos in the park. Holly will dress as Mrs. Claus and take photos. The guys will be Santa or Elves. Holly finds herself in between two sets of brothers. Can she choose one set over the other? Will the guys pull out all the stops to get her to them over the others?Come watch the fireworks as they figure out who will be chosen.

[Anja · Rating 5 out of 5]

I voluntarily reviewed an ALC of this book. Though it does seem that’s it’s just a - what can I do for Christmas-story - it is indeed so much more. As usual in Stephanie Brothers books. You have men and a woman, facing societies dismissal, though it’s not the main part of the book, but rather the force to choose. But that’s just Holly‘s thinking. It actually is - the more, the merrier. Great story, I very much enjoyed. Though I have to say, the narrator is just superb!

[Catherine Leigh · Rating 5 out of 5]

I absolutely loved this book, this is the ultimate Christmas read.
The relationship journey is perfect and the steamy scenes were hot AF.
I adored the festive names and the way they are possessive of Holly. The vast differences between the sets of brothers made for a delicious good vs bad aspect.
Highly recommend

[Lesley Walker · Rating 5 out of 5]

Loved it

It just goes to show that sharing can bring people together. What a position for Holly to be in. Four men and she is unable to choose which pair she wants. I wish I had had that dilemma when I was in my twenties, what a position to be in. (Pun intended) Thank goodness for the snow and the festive time of year.

[Alma · Rating 4 out of 5]

I love the Four series. I love Stephanie Brother. This series has seemed like real life (fictional). Clear and common problems that a female would face as she deals with the past and the future. Stories are very realistic. I've read all the previous books several times. (Mature themes). I've read the audiobooks bundles.

[Elizabeth · Rating 5 out of 5]

Love the holidays :)

Sweet and spicy read for the holidays X4 😉 Holly expected a pretty quiet albeit lonely holiday. What she didn't expect was to catch the attention of two sets of brothers.. Brothers who want Holly to choose them and will show just how sweet the Holidays can be if she did, but how can she choose?

[Katherine Sarvis · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was pure perfection, guess you could say it was the sprinkles to my hot chocolate, err I mean Christmas romance ❤. The characters and spice level are perfection! I love how Stephanie brother always draws you into her stories with the first sentence.