Actual rating: 3.5 stars
I suspect this book is one of those "it's not you, it's me" situations. After loving book 1 of this series, I had REALLY high hopes for this one, so maybe that had something to do with my feelings. I know this book has a few tropes that are like catnip for a lot of romance readers, but I didn't really feel like they worked for me.
Exhibit A: Giovanni, our hero, is pretty fucked up when the novel starts. Drinking, drugs, everything, to the point where Giovanni's father, Antony, is seriously considering forcing him into some kind of sketchy rehab place in Mexico if he doesn't shape up. I knew based on Lucian's book that Giovanni was all kinds of messed up, so it wasn't exactly a surprise for me when I started this book. BUT I was pretty frustrated by the fact that Giovanni's destructive attitude is never explained or even really addressed. He has a family that loves him and wants him to be happy. He IS in the mob, but he loves his job and is good at it. So what's his problem?
It's kind of hinted at that maybe all Giovanni was looking for the whole time was the Love of a Good Woman, which is kind of a cop out when it comes to addiction, IMO. What's even more of a cop out is that once Giovanni gets serious with the heroine, Kim, he basically just sort of stops using. No withdrawals, no rehab, just BAM. Magically cured.
Exhibit B: Kim, our heroine, is also in kind of a tough situation. The daughter of a mob boss, she's being forced into essentially an arranged marriage supposedly due to a mistake she made with her friends one night. While out at a casino, Kim was showing off to her girls and counting cards, not knowing the casino belongs to another Mafia family (how does she not know this??). She gets caught and her punishment is to marry the owner's son. Which, yeah, doesn't make a lot of sense and really isn't supposed to, since we later learn that the son just wants to make a work connection to Kim's dad. (He needs to get LinkedIn like the rest of us.)
What's frustrating about Kim is exactly what frustrates me about most romance novels: she doesn't fucking communicate with Gio for 40% of the novel. Now, once he figures out what's going on with Kim, Gio is still in a pretty tough spot, since she is basically off-limits according to mob law. BUT at least the unnecessary drama finally goes away at the 50% mark, because Gio finally figures out why Kim won't leave her abusive, asshole fiance. (Lots of unnecessary drama in the first half. Lots of it.)
Despite all of my complaints about it, there are a few things that I did love about this book. First, Gio's voice is fucking hilarious:
"Climb down off your high horse. It might be a pretty view, but you’ll break your neck all the same when someone kicks you the fuck off. And I can kick pretty goddamn high, asshole."
Once Gio and Kim actually establish that they want to be together and it's just Gio being Gio and Dealing With Shit, the book gets infinitely funnier and so much better. I kind of wish there was another book about him because if I was just rating the second half of this book, it would be at five stars.
"Do you know how long a person can survive after being gutted? I sure as fuck do. Get away from my wife before you learn, too."
Secondly, I loved the fact that Gio is not a good person. I mean, he's in the mob. He shouldn't be. But since this is a romance series, the hero is inevitably going to be romanticized. Nowhere is this more obvious than in book 1 when Lucian kills the men who beat (and planned to rape) the heroine, Jordyn. Yes, killing is bad, but the reader can be comfortable pretending the hero only kills Bad Men.
With Gio, he kills a more or less innocent man (who is not in the mob) because the man saw Gio and Kim together. If the man had reported what he saw to Kim's fiance, both Gio and Kim would be killed. So Gio hauls off and shoots him pretty much immediately. Which is admittedly all kinds of fucked up, but it fits with the world this story is being told in. So kudos to the author for being willing to make her protagonist more of an anti-hero in this installment.
Looking forward to continuing the series with Dante's book, though I hope to God there will be no more drawn-out miscommunications in that one.