AGREE / DISAGREE
I am rather mixed as to where I agree and where I disagree. This book is a tome of practical ways to involve creativity in the teaching process. Thus, it focuses less on actively convincing the reader as to why one should use creativity in the classroom as it does on passively explaining the benefit through practical examples, anecdotes, and testimonies. My thinking has definitely been challenged regarding the use of creativity in the classroom. I do agree that it should be used and is a helpful teaching tool. I will reserve some of my “disagreement” for the next section.
QUESTION
My thoughts here may not be entirely fair because I’m reading a bit between the lines of this book. The author may not have intended it, but the general impression I came away with is that every class should be full of creative activities. There were a few passing statements that the author made about it being used purposefully, but it gets lost in the sea of examples. I felt like we should be using creativity for creativity sake, and that is obviously not right. As long as we are using creativity purposefully to reinforce our teaching, then this book is a good reference. So, in some sense I question the overall thrust of the book, and the careless reader may come away with the idea of developing lesson plans centered around creativity and not the Scripture. I’m also not sure of the practicality of using some of the creative ideas such as drama, miming, and role-play, for they tend to consume so much time. If it were the right classroom, I can see it being helpful.
WORTHY OF MORE THOUGHT
This book as a whole serves as worthy of more thought for me. I tend to focus heavily on the cognitive aspect of learning, because that’s my preferred method. Since I don’t view myself as an exceptionally creative person, I likewise don’t tend to view others that way, and I know that’s wrong. Although I may not benefit from creative activity in the same ways as other creative folks, I do need to figure out ways to involve creativity in my lessons.
GENERAL COMMENTS
If she were to rewrite the book, I would suggest an opening section arguing the theory of using creativity in lessons plans while making it clear that it is a tool to be used, not the main thrust. Then I would follow it with the examples she gives. I found the book to be extremely wordy and she could have communicated the same things in about half the space. I would also recommend condensing most of the examples into an appendix for easier reference later.